Best-Reviewed Horror Movies 2016

From supernatural happenings to bloodthirsty killers, these spooky flicks earned praise – and a fair number of shivers – from the critics.

The order of the list reflects the scores as of December 31, 2016, but the number displayed on the Adjusted Tomatometer may change as more reviews keep getting added after the end of the year.

#1

The Witch (2016)
90%

#1
Adjusted Score: 102.538%
Critics Consensus: As thought-provoking as it is visually compelling, The Witch delivers a deeply unsettling exercise in slow-building horror that suggests great things for debuting writer-director Robert Eggers.
Synopsis: In this exquisitely made and terrifying new horror film, the age-old concepts of witchcraft, black magic and possession are innovatively... [More]
Directed By: Robert Eggers

#2

Green Room (2016)
91%

#2
Adjusted Score: 99.919%
Critics Consensus: Green Room delivers unapologetic genre thrills with uncommon intelligence and powerfully acted élan.
Synopsis: GREEN ROOM is a brilliantly crafted and wickedly fun horror-thriller starring Patrick Stewart as a diabolical club owner who squares... [More]
Directed By: Jeremy Saulnier

#3

The Love Witch (2016)
95%

#3
Adjusted Score: 98.64%
Critics Consensus: The Love Witch offers an absorbing visual homage to a bygone era, arranged subtly in service of a thought-provoking meditation on the battle of the sexes.
Synopsis: Elaine, a beautiful young witch, is determined to find a man to love her. In her Gothic Victorian apartment she... [More]
Directed By: Anna Biller

#4

Don't Breathe (2016)
88%

#4
Adjusted Score: 96.493%
Critics Consensus: Don't Breathe smartly twists its sturdy premise to offer a satisfyingly tense, chilling addition to the home invasion genre that's all the more effective for its simplicity.
Synopsis: A trio of reckless thieves breaks into the house of a wealthy blind man, thinking they'll get away with the... [More]
Directed By: Fede Alvarez

#5

The Conjuring 2 (2016)
80%

#5
Adjusted Score: 89.43%
Critics Consensus: The Conjuring 2 can't help but lose a bit of its predecessor's chilly sting through familiarity, but what remains is still a superior ghost story told with spine-tingling skill.
Synopsis: Reprising their roles, Oscar nominee Vera Farmiga ("Up In the Air," TV's "Bates Motel") and Patrick Wilson (the "Insidious" films),... [More]
Directed By: James Wan

Tag Cloud

The Walking Dead hispanic Turner reboot dragons cancelled television true crime Captain marvel Tomatazos Best and Worst anthology transformers BET DC Universe Nat Geo dceu Election TruTV Awards Country NBC The Witch RT21 crime thriller DC Comics Epix Film Festival Super Bowl casting TCA 2017 space Columbia Pictures CMT Rocketman tv talk Spike Pop zombie DC streaming service Star Trek Photos IFC political drama Infographic Rock A&E disaster BBC thriller Amazon Prime Video aliens Comics on TV BBC America blockbuster Biopics crossover Apple mockumentary Avengers Hulu TIFF comiccon animated OWN Animation Superheroes 21st Century Fox Lifetime Freeform indie Stephen King teaser Bravo talk show Cosplay technology Masterpiece Extras HBO elevated horror Set visit series doctor who Spring TV joker war Heroines Tubi CBS All Access The Arrangement christmas movies unscripted romance Musical ABC Endgame Academy Awards police drama docudrama Syfy Paramount Network MCU The CW Logo SXSW HBO Max witnail Dark Horse Comics rotten movies we love Sneak Peek screenings 2019 Schedule Women's History Month Song of Ice and Fire Apple TV+ Music Creative Arts Emmys Ghostbusters sitcom Shudder Cartoon Network Kids & Family richard e. Grant canceled TV shows Superheroe Esquire YouTube Red E3 TNT award winner Opinion Valentine's Day Amazon Thanksgiving YA 2017 YouTube Trailer justice league Countdown Action batman spain dramedy ghosts 2015 Nominations Starz Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Food Network Vudu PBS CW Seed VH1 MTV hist Showtime Netflix Christmas movies Marathons ABC Family Box Office vampires Video Games Rom-Com politics Fox News Black Mirror zombies Nickelodeon Pride Month jamie lee curtis 24 frames Toys Tarantino A24 Family historical drama 007 golden globes ESPN San Diego Comic-Con National Geographic Warner Bros. Acorn TV Summer Emmy Nominations Emmys Peacock Grammys Premiere Dates ITV south america History renewed TV shows Tumblr slashers science fiction quibi Reality Competition sports social media mutant miniseries GLAAD Winners festivals Winter TV Mary Tyler Moore serial killer PaleyFest zero dark thirty Anna Paquin Television Academy Christmas FOX 2018 biography video Brie Larson First Reviews Chernobyl spider-man game show AMC children's TV Year in Review Pirates Ellie Kemper cartoon Hallmark Christmas movies cooking Trophy Talk Rocky natural history cancelled TV shows Pixar medical drama cops Trivia WGN comic Sundance cancelled TV series Ovation Comedy Western 2020 crime OneApp TV Land Comedy Central cats adventure diversity Reality Elton John Crunchyroll El Rey X-Men Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Red Carpet period drama latino Calendar Disney+ Disney Plus Baby Yoda TCA Classic Film robots 20th Century Fox revenge Mystery nature Pet Sematary Writers Guild of America USA Network Oscars Mary poppins Mindy Kaling TV renewals The Purge Character Guide Mudbound Marvel Studios LGBTQ strong female leads Crackle 71st Emmy Awards directors TV Film facebook GIFs Star Wars canceled what to watch SundanceTV YouTube Premium book Britbox Lifetime Christmas movies Turner Classic Movies SDCC USA breaking bad TCA Winter 2020 composers American Society of Cinematographers Disney streaming service spanish language Disney green book Fall TV blaxploitation singing competition Mary Poppins Returns Universal Podcast cancelled LGBT travel comics cinemax free movies foreign finale name the review psychological thriller Polls and Games crime drama DirecTV CBS Sundance Now Sci-Fi Holidays Cannes Drama TBS Horror spinoff New York Comic Con Interview stand-up comedy Walt Disney Pictures Disney Plus sequel Marvel Television toy story Lionsgate streaming Disney Channel IFC Films spy thriller Musicals Quiz discovery sag awards Binge Guide Netflix Watching Series MSNBC based on movie VICE Marvel television Holiday boxoffice psycho Arrowverse ratings Comic Book halloween APB kids Shondaland FXX screen actors guild Lucasfilm anime versus CNN Awards Tour Sundance TV Amazon Prime See It Skip It Adult Swim supernatural RT History 2016 WarnerMedia binge Sony Pictures GoT game of thrones harry potter cars Teen theme song cults E! Hallmark Martial Arts 45 werewolf Certified Fresh Fantasy NYCC President TLC adaptation Spectrum Originals First Look independent DGA Paramount FX movies Discovery Channel dc romantic comedy Apple TV Plus TCM