The "People's Choice" is Pure Idiocy

by | January 11, 2006 | Comments

Whenever I share a new Top Ten List or Critic’s Group Nomination list, I’m always extra careful to be fair and respectful of other peoples’ opinions. But after seeing what the "People’s Choice Awards" handed out for 2005’s movies, I just can’t contain myself. It’s simply too hilarious.

According to CNN, "the nominations were determined by editors at Entertainment Weekly, the People’s Choice production team and a panel of pop culture fans. Winners were determined by Internet voting."

So here are the peoples’ choices:

Favorite Female Movie Star: Sandra Bullock
Also nominated: Angelina Jolie & Nicole Kidman

(Ms. Bullock appeared in two films in 2005: the ensemble drama "Crash" and the stunningly awful "Miss Congeniality 2: Armed and Fabulous.")

Favorite Male Movie Star: Johnny Depp
Also nominated: Nicolas Cage & Samuel L. Jackson

(OK, no real complaint here, even if applauding the awesomeness of Johnny Depp has grown a little old-hat by now. JD did have a great ’05 tho, starring in "Charlie and the Chocolate Factory," "Corpse Bride," and "The Libertine.")

Favorite Leading Lady: Reese Witherspoon
Also nominated: Cameron Diaz & Renee Zellweger

(So does this mean Reese isn’t a "movie star"?)

Favorite Leading Man: Brad Pitt
Also nominated: Jamie Foxx & Adam Sandler

(Just for "Mr. & Mrs. Smith" alone? OK, peoples. Better than the alternatives, anyway.)

Favorite Female Action Star: Jennifer Garner
Also nominated: Angelina Jolie & Catherine Zeta-Jones

(Well this just makes no freakin’ sense at all. The only action movie Ms. Garner appeared in last year was "Elektra," which nobody went to see because it sucked. And yet enough people saw it to make it their "choice.")

Favorite Male Action Star: Matthew McConaughey
Also nominated: Brad Pitt & The Rock

(For "Sahara"? Did nobody SEE the lead actor in "Batman Begins"?)

Favorite On-Screen Matchup: Vince Vaughn & Owen Wilson in "Wedding Crashers"
Also nominated: Angelina Jolie & Brad Pitt in "Mr. & Mrs. Smith" and Chris Rock & Adam Sandler in "The Longest Yard"

(I’m really glad they said "On-Screen," otherwise I’d assume Vince and Owen are lovers.)

Favorite Movie Comedy: "Wedding Crashers"
Also nominated: "Hitch" & "The Longest Yard"

(Raise your hand if you honestly think "Wedding Crashers" is funnier than "The 40-Year-Old Virgin," which somehow didn’t even earn a nomination.)

Favorite Family Movie: "Charlie and the Chocolate Factory"
Also nominated: "Chicken Little" & "Madagascar

(Another decent pick, although "Wallace & Gromit" would have been nominated if the average American didn’t think British films come with subtitles.)

Favorite Movie Drama: "Star Wars: Episode III: Revenge of the Sith"
Also nominated: "Batman Begins" & "Coach Carter"

Favorite Movie: "Star Wars: Episode III: Revenge of the Sith"
Also nominated: "Batman Begins" & "Hitch"

(OK, I’ll let ’em get away with the overall movie pick since "Sith" was huge at the box office and I really dug it a whole lot, but … BEST DRAMA??? The "American public" chose Star Wars freakin’ 3 as best drama??? Oh, people. You must stop. Why make the U.S. even more of a global laughing stock? "Brokeback Mountain" is a drama. "Good Night, and Good Luck." is a drama! "Munich," "A History of Violence," "Crash," "Walk the Line," and alllll of THESE MOVIES are dramas. Sorry, but I figure a working knowledge of genre classifications is a minimum requirement if you’re going to vote on any sort of movie poll … even one this painfully silly. Next year they’ll give "BloodRayne" best musical.)

My apologies to the folks on the People’s Choice payroll for my derisive mockery, but c’mon, you guys made it way too easy. And I challenge anyone to explain to me how "Star Wars 3" qualifies as a drama.

Tag Cloud

DC streaming service Tarantino Classic Film spain Red Carpet quibi serial killer women Hallmark Christmas movies Tubi Nickelodeon documentaries YouTube Premium PlayStation popular comics ESPN Rocky laika police drama canceled CMT singing competition latino boxoffice Mary Tyler Moore Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt gangster Awards critic resources A24 2020 best screenings Trivia south america films TCA Biopics lord of the rings hispanic Ellie Kemper marvel cinematic universe halloween tv stop motion Stephen King 71st Emmy Awards hidden camera Baby Yoda Summer Action Marvel Television TV worst movies Shondaland IFC Cosplay Infographic historical drama Schedule Film National Geographic Mudbound The Arrangement YouTube fast and furious Winners strong female leads ID 20th Century Fox universal monsters WarnerMedia 21st Century Fox criterion aliens YouTube Red Pride Month psychological thriller sitcom Black Mirror know your critic Crunchyroll Fox Searchlight Peacock TCA 2017 high school scene in color witnail Trailer The Walking Dead australia OneApp indie E! royal family BBC America First Look blockbusters The CW zombies discovery Podcast king arthur scorecard Teen NYCC Alien E3 ratings Sundance TV robots Amazon Prime venice cancelled docuseries Election HBO 24 frames tv talk Elton John superhero The Academy a nightmare on elm street revenge unscripted archives theme song Esquire Television Critics Association elevated horror Chilling Adventures of Sabrina satire Pixar Starz harry potter Lifetime streaming Disney Channel mutant comic book movie jamie lee curtis Columbia Pictures Spring TV telelvision The Purge Logo Photos DGA AMC 2015 Pop TV Hear Us Out Disney Dark Horse Comics Disney streaming service football HBO Max ghosts LGBT docudrama YA 72 Emmy Awards Ovation hist Rock Comics on TV VOD TCA Awards Legendary dark TV Land stoner Film Festival Turner Classic Movies slasher Image Comics cancelled TV series IFC Films animated spider-man live action 99% Lifetime Christmas movies Toys SXSW Tokyo Olympics composers Holidays green book Mystery comiccon Sci-Fi anthology Character Guide BET Awards finale feel good comic zero dark thirty Emmys directors WGN critics Marvel Studios golden globe awards pirates of the caribbean BBC Animation spanish name the review DC Comics godzilla Crackle First Reviews festival zombie book TV One travel 93rd Oscars President movies Music Shudder politics rotten movies we love adventure TV movies Countdown Amazon Prime Video Certified Fresh GIFs Discovery Channel Horror Video Games Quiz twilight Rocketman Spectrum Originals binge rotten sequel japanese news CW Seed Tumblr Sneak Peek stand-up comedy children's TV Paramount Network reviews dragons parents transformers series natural history The Walt Disney Company Apple TV+ nature trailers Winter TV saw HBO Go TBS Disney Plus romance Adult Swim Rom-Com richard e. Grant Lionsgate ABC Family Best and Worst comic book movies Oscars TCM Mindy Kaling new york foreign all-time 007 political drama legend Universal Hulu The Witch james bond documentary Captain marvel spanish language breaking bad boxing 73rd Emmy Awards razzies Funimation psycho Premiere Dates asian-american Set visit game of thrones sequels Reality period drama 4/20 Super Bowl doctor who Arrowverse blaxploitation Pirates VICE PaleyFest Endgame Fall TV comedies cancelled television Comic-Con@Home 2021 cats emmy awards facebook DC Universe Thanksgiving deadpool streaming movies Lucasfilm FX on Hulu San Diego Comic-Con Masterpiece El Rey Spike talk show scary movies toy story NBA BBC One obituary ViacomCBS dogs FXX die hard dexter blockbuster cancelled TV shows international Nat Geo PBS Emmy Nominations worst halloween BAFTA black crime drama Superheroes mockumentary Reality Competition Comedy Central Fox News Vudu new zealand young adult rom-coms versus based on movie crossover Comedy Song of Ice and Fire casting History MTV indiana jones nbcuniversal Paramount Plus Grammys Television Academy italian RT21 cartoon toronto Netflix 2017 new star wars movies french Brie Larson video BET Superheroe true crime Walt Disney Pictures TLC 90s cooking A&E game show biography space franchise DirecTV miniseries remakes biopic child's play slashers Tomatazos Turner anime Acorn TV Pacific Islander SDCC X-Men jurassic park GoT mission: impossible rt archives Warner Bros. Interview Calendar NBC batman hispanic heritage month CBS MSNBC 45 Heroines Paramount mcc festivals Broadway superman CNN basketball Bravo Mary Poppins Returns TV renewals dceu wonder woman American Society of Cinematographers teaser Box Office USA what to watch Academy Awards Drama Holiday thriller Valentine's Day Western Avengers book adaptation suspense VH1 chucky Musicals social media dc Syfy Sundance rt labs adaptation independent medical drama 1990s Extras Anna Paquin Ghostbusters Apple Amazon adenture Wes Anderson rt labs critics edition Awards Tour disaster Fantasy dramedy debate Hallmark spy thriller supernatural Cartoon Network prank kids free movies monster movies Pet Sematary Disney+ Disney Plus 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards award winner ABC Signature Country olympics GLAAD canceled TV shows TNT reboot action-comedy heist movie king kong OWN Creative Arts Emmys Opinion Food Network war renewed TV shows Black History Month sports RT History Amazon Studios cults Writers Guild of America SundanceTV Travel Channel Martial Arts ITV japan See It Skip It nfl joker posters technology Epix TruTV golden globes diversity comic books Christmas Britbox Nominations Comic Book christmas movies target concert crime thriller 2016 Watching Series MCU Polls and Games cops science fiction Year in Review marvel comics werewolf hollywood Sony Pictures kong Kids & Family Mary poppins TIFF Cannes vampires 2019 Apple TV Plus Star Trek video on demand Women's History Month cinemax USA Network LGBTQ screen actors guild TCA Winter 2020 FX romantic comedy New York Comic Con Binge Guide kaiju classics ABC Exclusive Video FOX Netflix Christmas movies cars Marvel movie Marathons Chernobyl Musical television Sundance Now spinoff Pop Star Wars 2021 APB Freeform aapi CBS All Access 2018 Trophy Talk Family sag awards fresh justice league crime Showtime