The Gimmicks That Changed Cinema: Part 1

James Cameron promises Avatar will be the next step in a fully-immersive, 3-D movie experience -- but will it have the impact of these?

by | December 9, 2009 | Comments

James Cameron’s Avatar is almost here, and if it’s anything like the director’s been promising — a new way to experience immersive 3-D movies, whatever that means — then the industry could be about to enter a new phase of technology.

So to mark the release of the latest revolution in film technology, we took a look back — way back — at the ones that have come before it. In the first of our two-part series about the technological advances that changed the movie industry forever, we look at the gimmicks that are now part of the standard moviegoing experience. Tomorrow, we look at the ones that weren’t so fortunate.


Hand tinting of black-and-white shorts started at the birth of cinema, but it wasn’t until 1906 that the first color process, the additive red-green format called Kinemacolor, was developed in the UK. The Brits can also lay claim to the world’s first color feature film, with 1914’s five-reel Kinemacolor melodrama The World, The Flesh and The Devil. Kinemacolor flicks had to be projected on special equipment at double speed, which was hell on prints, but, even so, hundreds of cinemas in Britain, Japan and the US installed the technology to play the film. Hollywood’s first color feature, 1922’s Technicolor The Toll of the Sea, was also the first to not require special projectors. While most were amazed, some were sceptical. Screenwriter Rupert Hughes told Popular Science Monthly in 1923: “For general use the single-tone pictures will enormously prevail.” Writing later in The Guardian in 1929, a commentator named “R.H.” confessed: “I view the prospect of colour with more alarm that I ever did the advent of sound… There will be so little left to imagine.”


Motion-picture pioneers Thomas Edison and Eadweard Muybridge apparently met to discuss the prospect of synchronized sound for the movies in 1888 — seven years before the first publicly projected films! Film with sound — that is, projected images accompanied by music, songs or dialogue on a phonograph recording — began in 1896 in Berlin. And it was in the same German city in 1922 that the first sound-on-film dramatic talkie, The Arsonist, was screened for the public. Most famously, the first feature film with partial talking was The Jazz Singer, which opened in the US in October 1927 and featured two dialogue sequences totalling 354 words. While perfect for the occasion, Al Jolson’s “You ain’t heard nothin’ yet” was actually an ad-lib of a line he frequently used on stage. But Lights of New York, released in 1928, was the first all-talking flick, with Time magazine noting, “as an experiment, like the first hot-dog sandwich, it is a palpable hit.” But even as sound took off, critics carped. In 1930, David Belasco, who’d been a leading Broadway playwright, director and producer for decades, said cinemagoers had tired of the sound novelty, which was like “an exhausted toy, ready to be cast aside.” Meanwhile, influential British film historian Paul Rotha reckoned sound movies were “absolutely contrary to the aims of cinema”. Alfred Hitchcock was also initially sceptical — until he made 1929’s Blackmail, the first successful European all-talking picture.


Like sound and color, 3-D’s conception coincided with the earliest days of film, with British cinematography pioneer William Friese Greene experimenting with stereoscopic moving images in the early 1890s. The first 3-D film presentation for a paying audience was at New York’s Astor Theater in 1915, with a triple-bill program of one-reel travelogues, while the first 3-D feature, Power of Love, debuted in Los Angeles in 1922. The first color 3-D feature was the 1947 Soviet film Robinson Crusoe, but it was the first American color 3-D film, 1952’s low-budget Bwana Devil, that kicked off the three-dimensional movie fad. Independent writer-producer-director Arch Obeler filmed Bwana Devil in “NaturalVision” that required audiences to don special polarized glasses. Promoted with the tagline “The Miracle of The Age!!! A LION in your lap! A LOVER in your arms!”, the movie was a hit, smashing attendance records and grossing $95,000 on two Los Angeles screens before United Artists acquired it for roll-out across the country. Critics reached for the obvious: “Even in 3-D, Bwana Devil is a singularly flat adventure yarn,” opined Time. But other studios took note of the grosses and jumped on the bandwagon, with Columbia releasing the first studio-produced 3-D feature, Man in the Dark, in 1953, beating Warner Bros. better-remembered House of Wax into cinemas by two days. The 3-D craze burned bright that year, with 27 movies made and released. In 1954, there were 16, but by 1955 just one 3-D flick hit screens. The next major revival of the format was in the early 1980s, with the likes of Comin’ At Ya, Parasite, Space Hunter: Adventures In The Forbidden Zone and Jaws 3-D. Now, thanks to the digital cinematography and projection and computer imaging processes used in Avatar, it seems 3-D’s here to stay. But then again, that’s what they always say.


While the first all-widescreen feature was 1929’s Fox Movietone Follies, the format didn’t catch on until the early 1950s when, like 3-D, it was viewed as a defense against the spread of TV. It was then that studios looked to the CinemaScope and Cinerama formats. The former was created by French inventor Henri Chretien as an evolution of his 1927 Hypergonar system. Fox bought the patent and in September 1953 unleashed Biblical blockbuster The Robe in the new 2.55:1 ratio, throwing in a revolutionary four-track stereo sound mix for further “wow” factor. Taking on not only TV but also 3-D, it was billed as “the modern miracle you see without glasses”. The gamble paid off handsomely, with the $5m feature grossing $36m which, adjusted for inflation, is $470m. Two months later, How To Marry A Millionaire, which was the first film to be shot in CinemaScope, was released and grossed a tidy $7.3m. Cinerama, meanwhile, was devised by American inventor Frederick Waller and utilized three 35mm projectors each projecting one-third of a movie image, creating a massive, curved 146-degree “panorama” which gave audiences the illusion of depth. The process had its public premiere in New York in September 1952 with the feature This Is Cinerama. Due to the cost of production and exhibition, few true Cinerama movies were produced, with the most famous being How The West Was Won. However it morphed into various single-camera big-image 70mm formats, which was the format used for the likes of 2001: A Space Odyssey and Ice Station Zebra. The massive screen idea would evolve into IMAX, which was first demonstrated at Expo ’70 in Japan, in advance of the first permanent IMAX venue, established in Toronto in 1971.

Serials and Cliffhangers

The Harry Potter “bridging” instalments are but the latest big-budget, feature-length versions of an idea that’s nearly 100 years old: the serial, with or without cliffhanging ending. What better way to keep audiences coming back than by not quite finishing the story they’ve paid to see? Back in the silent days, the movie serial — shown one chapter per week — was one of the most popular entertainment forms on the planet. The first of these was 1912’s What Happened To Mary. Made by Edison’s people and consisting of 12 one-reel episodes, it followed the action adventures of the title gal, played by Mary Fuller. In an early instance of the media cross promotion we now take for granted, each episode was released to coincide with an instalment of the story in McLure’s Ladies World magazine. While Mary was the first serial, it wasn’t the first cliffhanger. That honor went to 1913’s The Adventures of Kathlyn ¬- also printed as a Chicago Tribune newspaper serial — which did end each instalment on a suspenseful and perilous note. Ironically, the most famous “cliffhanger” series, 1914’s The Perils of Pauline, didn’t actually feature such endings.

Air conditioning

While summer is now the blockbuster season, for the first two decades of the movie business the hottest months were a dead loss. That changed in 1925 when Willis Carrier, inventor of air-conditioning, persuaded Paramount Pictures to install his technology in the Rivoli Theater, which was under construction in New York’s Times Square. The new cinema, promoted as offering “cool comfort”, opened its doors on Memorial Day, but a hiccup with the air-conditioning system meant that the crowd of 2000 sat fanning themselves and grumbling. Finally the a/c started working, the chill descended, the hand-fans were lowered and movie-going was forever changed. The most important audience member, Adolph Zukor, head of Paramount, was impressed, declaring, “Yes, the people are going to like it”. Carrier rolled out his air-conditioning to cinemas across the country and by 1928 Time magazine listed “To keep cool” as the number-one reason people went to the movies.

Click here to read Part 2.

Showgirls, Teen Wolves, and Astro Zombies: A Film Critic’s Year-Long Quest to Find the Worst Movie Ever Made (It Books/HarperCollins), Michael Adams’ pop-culture memoir about his search for the world’s worst movie, is in book stores next month. Read a chapter of it for free here.

Tag Cloud

X-Men directors prank boxoffice 2020 james bond Britbox tv talk Winter TV Syfy comic books Comic-Con@Home 2021 new star wars movies high school Comics on TV Black History Month Anna Paquin Disney streaming service classics laika japanese asian-american psychological thriller television Marvel Television sequel zero dark thirty BBC America Crunchyroll Heroines Awards Tour Drama Tarantino zombie rotten movies we love DirecTV vs. 2021 Amazon Tags: Comedy FXX Character Guide halloween tv Esquire basketball GLAAD AMC wonder woman Grammys hispanic heritage month CBS All Access canceled fast and furious Funimation Arrowverse Action FOX TBS PaleyFest green book razzies reboot The Witch talk show animated Fox News Set visit video on demand HBO Vudu Star Trek Amazon Studios monster movies Creative Arts Emmys DC Universe TNT christmas movies live action History 007 award winner batman Disney Plus news Fantasy Infographic Schedule NBA Turner Lucasfilm docudrama FX on Hulu Shudder cancelled critics Alien Quiz nature Box Office Prime Video Song of Ice and Fire genre adenture transformers hist Disney YouTube Red concert CW Seed Film Festival Holiday 2019 young adult Discovery Channel what to watch Food Network DC Comics VICE First Reviews pirates of the caribbean deadpool Crackle Mystery E3 Comedy Central black Image Comics dramedy witnail fresh mockumentary emmy awards Showtime Western National Geographic telelvision Women's History Month TV slashers aliens natural history festivals TIFF SundanceTV crime screen actors guild Pop spider-verse Polls and Games The Academy independent Netflix Christmas movies Apple BET Awards renewed TV shows child's play police drama YouTube Premium Nat Geo streaming movies comics Summer rt archives blockbusters obituary Elton John true crime discovery TLC festival OneApp The Walt Disney Company Hollywood Foreign Press Association Shondaland LGBTQ trailers dceu zombies royal family indiana jones olympics The Purge Horror AMC Plus hispanic lord of the rings boxing docuseries American Society of Cinematographers Sony Pictures medical drama Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt HFPA facebook stoner ABC Signature comic book movie adaptation BBC One Turner Classic Movies saw gangster criterion Toys TCM cancelled TV series romance Lifetime Christmas movies Fox Searchlight leaderboard Musicals HBO Max sag awards Sundance YA Thanksgiving book adaptation Apple TV+ revenge hidden camera TruTV twilight Spectrum Originals golden globe awards venice BET TV Land aapi remakes anime Tumblr Captain marvel GIFs hollywood Election heist movie Lionsgate cancelled TV shows game show nfl movies TV renewals foreign Paramount Network APB Sundance TV Valentine's Day USA die hard TCA Awards psycho cars comic book movies Disney+ Disney Plus 20th Century Fox franchise Hulu Paramount Plus Holidays football sopranos Spike Universal Pictures HBO Go halloween toronto TCA Biopics romantic comedy San Diego Comic-Con social media RT21 Fall TV Amazon Prime Video king kong Tomatazos trophy Hear Us Out period drama video strong female leads President MCU Universal ratings Hallmark versus 79th Golden Globes Awards Travel Channel Peacock Opinion richard e. Grant scary movies jurassic park Columbia Pictures Writers Guild of America First Look breaking bad Logo ViacomCBS 24 frames Hallmark Christmas movies MSNBC 2018 joker SDCC The Walking Dead Film dreamworks Superheroes Classic Film disaster A24 Musical dark superman Best and Worst Dark Horse Comics harry potter Comedy Animation Marvel Studios Pet Sematary historical drama feel good RT History VOD LGBT know your critic Spring TV CNN war Video Games scene in color Calendar dexter satire 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Superheroe spanish CBS Martial Arts archives DC streaming service action-comedy Mary Tyler Moore posters slasher Cartoon Network supernatural Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Paramount Christmas spider-man Mary poppins Trailer kids Neflix marvel comics spanish language Pixar serial killer IFC YouTube Rocketman unscripted 73rd Emmy Awards cinemax stand-up comedy rt labs critics edition spain legend Walt Disney Pictures streaming mcc PlayStation quibi ABC Family ABC vampires ID composers PBS Stephen King reviews 21st Century Fox Starz comic Endgame doctor who New York Comic Con mutant Bravo kaiju Trivia singing competition Adult Swim MTV GoT binge 2015 thriller marvel cinematic universe comiccon king arthur japan WGN best south america cults italian superhero Ellie Kemper toy story new york universal monsters worst robots Pop TV Country FX Rock Certified Fresh rotten anthology parents Sci-Fi E! Fargo theme song Pacific Islander NBC politics Awards debate Tokyo Olympics based on movie 1990s godzilla Rom-Com elevated horror blaxploitation VH1 worst movies ghosts Teen Freeform Super Bowl Academy Awards Masterpiece Amazon Prime space Countdown Pride Month Family cooking 90s werewolf kong science fiction latino Emmy Nominations Sneak Peek Reality Competition Winners stop motion WarnerMedia A&E Baby Yoda dogs See It Skip It Year in Review spy thriller live event Broadway cops movie Chernobyl women sports scorecard Acorn TV Marvel Legendary sequels Disney Channel international crime thriller IFC Films adventure Music cartoon screenings Trophy Talk 45 crossover Reality TCA 2017 OWN comedies canceled TV shows indie Cannes Red Carpet Cosplay mission: impossible NYCC documentaries Binge Guide series 4/20 Television Critics Association miniseries a nightmare on elm street diversity Television Academy political drama El Rey Lifetime mob Kids & Family rt labs Interview nbcuniversal art house SXSW free movies casting biography black comedy book blockbuster cancelled television Warner Bros. cats Wes Anderson Star Wars Mindy Kaling Nickelodeon Mudbound popular Instagram Live travel name the review Marathons Sundance Now Ghostbusters Netflix children's TV finale Mary Poppins Returns justice league australia sitcom Brie Larson documentary suspense Ovation CMT Comic Book game of thrones Black Mirror TV movies scary BBC The Arrangement 72 Emmy Awards Premiere Dates BAFTA USA Network TCA Winter 2020 Podcast 2017 Pirates spinoff TV One DGA The CW all-time dc chucky technology Emmys biopic Tubi Epix Oscars teaser Apple TV Plus 71st Emmy Awards Watching Series critic resources Avengers jamie lee curtis french 99% IMDb TV films Nominations Exclusive Video 2016 Photos crime drama golden globes 93rd Oscars new zealand target dragons Rocky rom-coms ITV Extras ESPN