SUNDANCE: "Battle in Heaven" Review

by | January 23, 2006 | Comments

Visually arresting but dramatically inert, “Battle in Heaven” is the very definition of a difficult film. The question is whether such difficulty is ultimately rewarding.

Marcos (Marcos Hernandez) works as a driver for a general. He and his wife have kidnapped a baby for ransom money, but the baby dies (offscreen, for the record). Marcos picks up Ana, his boss’ daughter, at the airport. Ana works in a brothel for fun, and Marcos and his wife argue about how to best avoid trouble in the wake of the baby’s death. Much amazing cinematography and empty transgression ensues.

There isn’t a moment in the film that isn’t visually remarkable. And I mean, really remarkable; from the unfurling of a huge Mexican flag to the buzz of activity at a religious pilgrimage, Carlos Reygadas’ direction is sure-handed and evocative.

However, “evocative” is not the first adjective that springs to mind to describe the characters. It’s hard to work up much enthusiasm for these people, with their somber moods, blank expressions, and inexplicable actions. Marcos is such an enigma, and his crime so abstract, that any attempts to depict inner tumult and/or cold calculation are unsuccessful.

“Battle in Heaven” currently stands at 25 percent on the Tomatometer.

Check out Sundance features by Rotten Tomatoes:
Sundance Full Coverage
Sundance Blog
Sundance Discussion

Tag Cloud

football TCA DC Universe Adult Swim quibi medical drama 21st Century Fox Anna Paquin Discovery Channel Christmas concert crossover Television Academy documentary WGN doctor who Turner superhero BET ABC WarnerMedia Disney streaming service fast and furious The Academy nature USA thriller sitcom TCA Winter 2020 slashers Comics on TV foreign GIFs Netflix Winter TV Pride Month USA Network Western Freeform SundanceTV Martial Arts archives romantic comedy Opinion versus cinemax DirecTV spanish language Countdown italian Baby Yoda composers asian-american Comedy Rock Food Network Toys Set visit TIFF Dark Horse Comics halloween tv Tarantino cats name the review Acorn TV Polls and Games Summer Sundance TV Disney Lionsgate Academy Awards OWN Music Sneak Peek Funimation french TBS YouTube TV Song of Ice and Fire harry potter VICE richard e. Grant Watching Series Winners ghosts Starz Certified Fresh Stephen King Crackle Hallmark Christmas movies TCM blaxploitation cars Amazon Classic Film sag awards video on demand a nightmare on elm street Reality Competition talk show National Geographic TNT ITV singing competition natural history game of thrones Fall TV MTV Super Bowl TV renewals Election Nominations animated Amazon Prime Video 2015 stop motion Television Critics Association President witnail TLC BAFTA First Reviews screenings canceled TV shows indiana jones BBC America cooking Turner Classic Movies Logo Country VH1 A24 disaster Cartoon Network mutant dc The Arrangement FX on Hulu Amazon Studios Sci-Fi toronto nfl screen actors guild festivals Esquire book HBO Go Red Carpet History documentaries stoner spanish period drama BET Awards adventure technology FX teaser Character Guide discovery mission: impossible toy story Brie Larson OneApp IFC Apple TV Plus Masterpiece emmy awards science fiction revenge DC Comics 007 Comedy Central tv talk X-Men PaleyFest theme song twilight rotten movies we love American Society of Cinematographers Trivia The Witch worst renewed TV shows Teen Spike worst movies 45 dceu festival SXSW Film dragons movie Pet Sematary Apple Pop Black History Month Disney Channel TV Land LGBTQ Family Holiday cults news canceled rotten spinoff Lifetime blockbuster green book hollywood best biography Animation spain based on movie Film Festival Nickelodeon Nat Geo reviews DGA PlayStation Walt Disney Pictures NBC Paramount Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt docudrama dark HBO Horror Captain marvel Bravo Hallmark dogs laika 2017 sequel Rocky Musical Photos YouTube Premium space 4/20 golden globes Musicals universal monsters Travel Channel San Diego Comic-Con Cannes Mudbound Pirates transformers FXX Tumblr Schedule Spectrum Originals LGBT war Avengers nbcuniversal Ovation Year in Review Epix christmas movies Star Trek CBS All Access politics casting Heroines diversity satire Awards Tour cops series vampires Cosplay cancelled Trailer cancelled television Fantasy Reality Star Wars cartoon Shudder breaking bad Paramount Network historical drama reboot comedies Quiz Rocketman Superheroe Fox News Showtime die hard television Holidays NYCC Vudu Mary Poppins Returns VOD 2016 batman chucky critics kids New York Comic Con joker video Women's History Month Calendar indie Chernobyl Thanksgiving game show halloween Shondaland ABC Family 72 Emmy Awards unscripted Grammys 2018 20th Century Fox obituary werewolf children's TV GoT YouTube Red Apple TV+ The Purge binge crime drama supernatural psychological thriller hispanic social media serial killer parents zombie Disney Plus criterion RT History A&E finale Hear Us Out award winner Infographic RT21 scorecard stand-up comedy Action dramedy Tomatazos Warner Bros. Marvel Studios 24 frames Oscars YA all-time Awards hist comiccon APB Extras The CW Lucasfilm ratings Writers Guild of America romance crime thriller cancelled TV series Mindy Kaling travel GLAAD Columbia Pictures Box Office Netflix Christmas movies 2019 cancelled TV shows Syfy Superheroes TCA 2017 Mystery anthology Premiere Dates Pop TV Marvel Television Best and Worst Comic Book Interview crime independent E! Ellie Kemper Emmy Nominations child's play sports Binge Guide franchise Creative Arts Emmys ESPN Trophy Talk Hulu police drama HBO Max movies Podcast true crime Fox Searchlight Amazon Prime MSNBC Sundance Spring TV Marvel AMC Pixar BBC Sundance Now CNN south america justice league 71st Emmy Awards latino Chilling Adventures of Sabrina TruTV Rom-Com spy thriller facebook scary movies E3 Peacock PBS streaming FOX robots CMT MCU Elton John Mary Tyler Moore classics free movies directors Video Games CBS Crunchyroll Marathons Sony Pictures Tubi political drama comic boxoffice Black Mirror mockumentary The Walking Dead miniseries psycho Mary poppins Ghostbusters aliens comics CW Seed El Rey Britbox spider-man films Valentine's Day 2020 adaptation what to watch zombies anime TCA Awards Drama sequels First Look IFC Films remakes See It Skip It SDCC venice Emmys Lifetime Christmas movies Biopics Kids & Family BBC One Endgame zero dark thirty elevated horror strong female leads DC streaming service jamie lee curtis Disney+ Disney Plus Universal Arrowverse