RT's Top Yuletide Comedies -- Christmas Countdown, Day One

by | December 18, 2006 | Comments

Welcome to RT’s Five Days of Christmas Countdown, where we serve up a different list each day of the best holiday flicks around. Today, feast your eyes on the Top Christmas Comedies — a little Billy Bob, a little Will Ferrell, and at least one triple dog dare — and prepare to get in the holiday spirit.

The holidays are here, and it’s time to break out your sleds, roast your chestnuts, and watch a movie or five about yuletide magic (or a decided lack thereof). Chances are you’ve seen enough Christmas movies to know that just because you stick a Santa hat on something, it isn’t necessarily worth watching (yes, "Jingle All the Way," we’re looking at you). And when in doubt regarding your best viewing for any occasion, as always, we’re here to help; the merry elves at Rotten Tomatoes have listed the Tomatometers, checked them twice, and will be presenting, over the next five days, the best holiday films in the following categories: Classics, Comedies, Animated/Children’s, Dramas, and Thrillers. Pour yourself a cup of eggnog and get ready for some fine seasonal viewing!


"It’s the most wonderful time of the year…"

Top 5 Yuletide Comedies

First, the holiday comedy — surely one of the most problematic genres in all of cinema. Luckily, we’re here to help you navigate the tinsel-strewn minefields of holiday humor; all five of these films are as fresh as the day they were picked. Ho, ho, ho!

5) Bad Santa (2003) 74%

Regarded skeptically upon its release in 2003, "Bad Santa" has gone on to find new life as a rental cult classic for folks who like a little bourbon in their cinematic eggnog. The setup is simple — Billy Bob Thornton is a larcenous department-store Santa — but it’s the little touches that make the movie worth revisiting, from Bernie Mac as a mall detective to John Ritter (in one of his last roles) as a store manager. There are reasons this film caused a mild uproar, but if you’ve got the sense of humor for it, "Bad Santa" might find its way into your perennial holiday lineup.

Starring: Billy Bob Thornton, Bernie Mac
Directed by: Terry Zwigoff

4) The Santa Clause (1994) 78%



Consider it the anti-"Bad Santa": the first entry in Tim Allen‘s yuletide trilogy doesn’t have a mean bone in its goofy red and green body — and though subsequent sequels about the everyman-turned-Saint Nick have been ill-advised at best, "The Santa Clause" is better than you might remember. Though Allen has always seemed a little too small for the big screen, and the jokes are often broad enough to paint a barn door, this is a fine choice for viewers with kids. Or viewers who just want to feel like kids for a couple of hours.

Starring: Tim Allen, Judge Reinhold
Directed by: John Pasquin

3) The Ref (1994) 79%

This wasn’t Denis Leary‘s first feature film, but it was his first starring vehicle, and its low crap quotient — along with its release hot on the heels of Leary’s hit "No Cure for Cancer" album — helped make it a higher-profile affair than certain subsequent Leary films. It isn’t perfect, and certainly, if you’re a fan of the late Bill Hicks, "The Ref" is probably the last Denis Leary film you ever want to see — but that being said, the comedian’s ceaseless ranting is at its most palatable here, and Kevin Spacey and Judy Davis add a nice touch as Leary’s feuding captives. No patience for holiday cheer? "The Ref" might be the movie for you.

Starring: Denis Leary, Judy Davis
Directed by: Ted Demme

2) Elf (2003) 85%



Every star in the firmament had to align in order to make a picture about a man-child who believes himself one of Santa’s elves anything more than fodder for horrible late-night movie marathons — and, with "Elf," align themselves they did. Will Ferrell has the perfect blend of naïveté and oafishness for the title role, and director Jon Favreau keeps things sweet without being cloying. It’s also awfully hard to argue with any film that puts Bob Newhart in pointy shoes and a silly cap.

Starring: Will Ferrell, Zooey Deschanel
Directed by: Jon Favreau

1) A Christmas Story (1984) 88%

There are probably some negative things that can be said about this movie — it gave star Peter Billingsley the chance to go on and make "The Dirt Bike Kid," for one — but none of them detract from "A Christmas Story"’s sheer holiday greatness. If you came of age in the 1980s, it’s safe to say you’ve seen it dozens of times; "Story" is the "It’s a Wonderful Life" of the MTV generation, which is why it’s at once evocative of both Norman Rockwell‘s America and breakdancing. It shouldn’t make sense, but it does.

Starring: Peter Billingsley, Darren McGavin
Directed by: Bob Clark

Stay tuned, as tomorrow we count down the Freshest seasonal dramas!

Tag Cloud

suspense know your critic Women's History Month Infographic GIFs IMDb TV toy story Superheroes parents Acorn TV Hear Us Out dogs posters television spider-man Stephen King king arthur revenge golden globe awards cars Hallmark Christmas movies kids Polls and Games fresh 90s Disney+ Disney Plus kaiju DC Comics remakes jamie lee curtis 24 frames strong female leads Chilling Adventures of Sabrina South by Southwest Film Festival reviews sequels Alien psycho Super Bowl aapi godzilla young adult Bravo vampires Turner obi wan Family cinemax Holidays foreign rom-coms Elton John Reality Competition 99% mission: impossible OWN FX zombie animated Marathons Lifetime Amazon 20th Century Fox Premiere Dates Chernobyl science fiction rt labs 94th Oscars X-Men 73rd Emmy Awards politics VH1 biography The CW book adaptation concert screenings 2017 Kids & Family police drama NBA japan Thanksgiving dexter cops twilight Photos live event WGN natural history latino Spring TV monster movies razzies Broadway The Walt Disney Company Turner Classic Movies Shudder Hollywood Foreign Press Association CNN Action mockumentary Star Trek gangster Holiday Best and Worst Black Mirror Columbia Pictures transformers Syfy canceled TV shows Lifetime Christmas movies Apple new york halloween tv PBS YouTube toronto ESPN Mystery adventure travel james bond Countdown Apple TV Plus YouTube Red FOX batman talk show Epix BAFTA 93rd Oscars Neflix Film Avengers ID binge Paramount Plus Exclusive Video Mary Poppins Returns golden globes trophy composers Vudu Sony Pictures comedies kong historical drama basketball Winners facebook discovery Star Wars Toys hollywood YouTube Premium Showtime Arrowverse IFC Films medical drama Hallmark Comic Book elevated horror The Walking Dead Binge Guide all-time spider-verse Ellie Kemper black comedy ABC critics FXX RT History football Netflix Valentine's Day stop motion Spike Funimation E! Best Picture streaming boxoffice children's TV Country Sundance TV Comics on TV Opinion 21st Century Fox Prime Video TCA Winter 2020 period drama Starz dramedy Dark Horse Comics MGM spanish language comic book movie 2019 Food Network sopranos ABC Family supernatural venice Rock lord of the rings game show ViacomCBS Trivia Academy Awards TLC History TIFF SDCC TV One slasher Walt Disney Pictures deadpool VOD DC Universe superhero Lucasfilm rotten Teen emmy awards broadcast VICE book superman comic books prank Paramount Pictures new zealand robots cancelled TV shows Pop Ovation NYCC debate cats breaking bad Anna Paquin Ghostbusters APB miniseries Character Guide Musicals scene in color Television Critics Association zombies Song of Ice and Fire TNT classics Logo Mudbound obituary SundanceTV Sci-Fi USA Network italian American Society of Cinematographers disaster quibi rt archives BET psychological thriller A24 Calendar Certified Fresh space New York Comic Con doctor who dark GLAAD docuseries A&E Cannes Christmas DirecTV Hulu TV Land Adult Swim reboot HBO Max comiccon Drama Podcast Comedy Central serial killer Disney Channel Fox News rotten movies we love hispanic First Look National Geographic Shondaland festival BBC One mutant Apple TV+ Universal E3 dc 2018 docudrama Nominations Legendary Trailer saw laika movie action-comedy Year in Review AMC cooking news 2021 asian-american Instagram Live 007 Disney Plus See It Skip It Lionsgate Summer Mary poppins Paramount MSNBC Animation Video Games 45 pirates of the caribbean Musical based on movie Netflix Christmas movies Spectrum Originals Extras Biopics Fox Searchlight OneApp Schedule movies anime IFC boxing video Comedy The Purge Captain marvel NBC women RT21 streaming movies cancelled TV series Esquire Emmys Watching Series cartoon Tomatazos Interview TCM Rom-Com versus Wes Anderson stand-up comedy Tumblr crime drama festivals singing competition TruTV target Box Office free movies spanish technology Travel Channel rt labs critics edition Amazon Studios telelvision scorecard Pixar stoner mcc Martial Arts wonder woman TV movies genre MTV archives WarnerMedia new star wars movies royal family chucky Marvel Television MCU finale renewed TV shows Grammys First Reviews unscripted satire The Academy theme song nbcuniversal documentary marvel cinematic universe Peacock spinoff adaptation Tokyo Olympics vs. canceled Disney legend 2016 summer TV popular Best Director joker hispanic heritage month Superheroe Warner Bros. documentaries summer TV preview french Image Comics romance TCA TBS Paramount Network 2020 Sundance olympics christmas movies crime thriller 71st Emmy Awards screen actors guild blaxploitation adenture sports CMT tv talk justice league thriller BBC America marvel comics Fantasy Marvel Studios Oscar CW Seed FX on Hulu ITV Amazon Prime Video TV worst movies jurassic park Reality 2015 comic book movies Masterpiece comics ABC Signature crime Rocketman franchise crossover Tarantino Best Actress Quiz films Awards TCA Awards CBS All Access TV renewals social media Freeform sitcom video on demand true crime Mindy Kaling Pride Month Cartoon Network San Diego Comic-Con GoT Tubi black Crunchyroll Horror name the review universal monsters Crackle dreamworks international 4/20 ghosts SXSW 2022 scary australia The Arrangement Endgame Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt best Trophy Talk high school HFPA Cosplay halloween slashers DC streaming service Sundance Now Amazon Prime 1990s sequel Disney streaming service scary movies worst romantic comedy Oscars nature mob Nat Geo USA PlayStation The Witch spy thriller LGBTQ ratings werewolf Fargo Black History Month Election Sneak Peek Television Academy summer preview Set visit green book streamig Marvel nfl diversity witnail hidden camera SXSW dragons art house indie Best Actor blockbuster criterion sag awards harry potter king kong Nickelodeon Britbox President Writers Guild of America LGBT biopic blockbusters Western Pirates anthology series Winter TV TCA 2017 political drama Comic-Con@Home 2021 Music child's play Pet Sematary heist movie teaser feel good award winner japanese hist Tags: Comedy independent die hard 79th Golden Globes Awards HBO Discovery Channel trailers casting 72 Emmy Awards Universal Pictures a nightmare on elm street live action south america aliens BET Awards indiana jones fast and furious war HBO Go 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Pacific Islander comic CBS game of thrones AMC Plus spain Awards Tour cancelled television cults zero dark thirty Focus Features Film Festival directors YA Mary Tyler Moore El Rey Red Carpet DGA Rocky richard e. Grant Baby Yoda dceu Heroines Emmy Nominations critic resources leaderboard PaleyFest Classic Film Creative Arts Emmys BBC cancelled Fall TV what to watch Brie Larson Pop TV