Rotten Tomatoes Predicts the 2020 Emmy Winners

Who will emerge a winner on Sunday? We're betting on Schitt's Creek, Watchmen, and Succession to dominate.

by | September 17, 2020 | Comments

Watchmen keyart Regina King (HBO)

(Photo by HBO)

When the Television Academy announces winners for the 72nd Annual Emmy Awards on Sunday, HBO’s Watchmen and Succession and the final season of Schitt’s Creek are sure to dominate — in the world according to us.

We’ve weighed the variables — including Tomatometer scores (critical reception), Audience Scores, industry buzz, competition in each category, and our own wild (but educated) hunches — to come up with our list of who we think will take home awards this weekend.

Check out our Emmy award predictions below and come back on Sunday when we reveal the winners of the 2020 Emmy Awards.

Disagree? Let us know who you think will win in the comments.

Read also: Rotten Tomatoes’ 2020 Fall TV Reader Survey — The Mandalorian and The Stand Lead Our Top Categories

Outstanding Comedy Series

Schitt's Creek the final season keyart

(Photo by Pop TV)

What’s nominated?

What will win? Schitt’s Creek

And why? The sixth and final season of Pop series Schitt’s Creek climbed from four nominations last year to a whopping 15 this year, and its cast is likely to dominate in their respective categories. With 20 nominations this year and 17 past Emmy wins, Amazon Prime Video’s The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel is the title to beat, but its Certified Fresh third season scored an 82% compared to Schitt’s Creek season 6’s Certified Fresh 100% score. Meanwhile, a win by What We Do in the Shadows, another title whose most recent season is Certified Fresh at 100%, would be a big category upset.

Lead Actress in a Comedy Series

Catherine O'Hara in Schitt's Creek, s6

(Photo by Pop TV)

Who is nominated?

Who will win? O’Hara

And why? O’Hara will ride the Schitt’s Creek wave and take the category for her role as the Rose family’s wig-loving matriarch, Moira. Brosnahan, with three Emmy nominations in her career, won this category once for her as Midge Maisel. The stars of Dead to Me are likely to have split their vote, while Ross was the surprise nomination for the category, despite having been nominated three previous times for her role as Rainbow Johnson.

Lead Actor in a Comedy Series

Eugene Levy in season 6 of Schitt's Creek

(Photo by Pop TV)

Who is nominated?

Who will win? Levy

And why? We’re betting on Levy and that Schitt’s Creek love, though we felt that Youssef was a strong contender for the award. They face Danson, who’s been nominated in this category for the past two years, and Douglas, while Cheadle and Anderson’s nominations came as a surprise.

Supporting Actress in a Comedy Series

Alex Borstein in The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel season 3

(Photo by Amazon Prime Video)

Who will be nominated?

Who will win? Borstein

And why? Borstein won this category the past two years in a row for her role as Susie Myerson in The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel and, we think, is again the front runner this year. Seven-time nominee, two-time winner McKinnon and nomination newcomer Strong, may split votes for their Saturday Night Live work. Meanwhile, Emmy-nomination newbies Murphy and Carden have strong support for the final seasons of their respective shows — but this is a tough category.

Supporting Actor in a Comedy Series

Tony Shalhoub in The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, season 3

(Photo by Amazon Prime Video)

Who is nominated?

Who will win? Shalhoub

And why? Emmy heavyweight Shalhoub (11 career nominations, four wins) will defend his title in this category against Schitt’s Creek executive producer, co-creator, and star Levy. (We’re thinking the Television Academy will reward Levy’s producer role with the comedy series win.) Braugher and Harper’s nominations were a nice surprise, but they’re facing an uphill battle against the two favorites; that said, Ali could provide an even bigger surprise and knock everyone out come awards time.

Outstanding Drama Series

Succession s2

(Photo by HBO)

What is nominated?

What will win? Succession

And whyThe strength of Succession’s first season seemed to take some off-guard, but series creator Jesse Armstrong (Oscar nominated for 2009’s In The Loop) went on to win a writing Emmy for it. The HBO show’s story was on steroids in season 2, setting the series itself up for an award this year. Still, the category offers a few questions to ponder: Could all that Baby Yoda love carry surprise nominee The Mandalorian into the winners’ circle? Or will Better Call Saul take revenge for its stars’ snubs in the acting nominations and spank everyone in the category? We’re sticking with Succession in our predictions.

Lead Actress in a Drama Series

Laura Linney in Ozark SEASON 3 EPISODE 6 PHOTO CREDIT Steve Dietl/Netflix

(Photo by Steve Dietl/Netflix)

Who is nominated?

Who will win? Linney

And why? Colman seemed the actress to beat for her highly-anticipated turn as Queen Elizabeth II in season 3 of The Crown, but Linney and Aniston are Emmy favorites, now with seven nominations each in their careers, with Linney winning four times and Aniston winning once. Comer is the incumbent here, but Killing Eve Tomatometer score took a dive in season 3 at 80%, compared to season 1’s 96% and 2’s 92% (all were Certified Fresh), and then there’s the nomination of Oh in the category that further dilutes the Killing Eve duo’s individual chances. Zendaya’s nomination surprised many (not us), but with so many awards-veteran challengers, a win seems out of reach. We’re giving it to Linney for the buzz on her chances — but wouldn’t be surprised at all if Colman snagged it from her.

Lead Actor in a Drama Series

Brian Cox, Succession

(Photo by Peter Kramer/HBO)

Who is nominated?

Who will win? Cox

And why? Forgive us, we’re still reeling from the nomination snub of Bob Odenkirk in this category for his work on season 5 of Better Call Saul. That leaves Cox in the strongest position; though Strong may have split the vote among Succession fans, leaving Bateman in the lead. Porter won this category last year for his role as Pray Tell in the FX series, and there’s every reason to think he could take it again. Brown and Carell were the surprise nominations for us, and we don’t see them overtaking the front runners. We’re betting Cox will prevail for his epic performance as the Roy family patriarch.

Supporting Actress in a Drama Series

Helena Bonham Carter in season 3 of The Crown

(Photo by Sophie Mutevelian/Netflix)

Who is nominated?

Who will win? Carter

And why? Carter clearly had a ball playing aging Princess Margaret in season 3 of The Crown, but the big question is how she will fare against last year’s winner in the category, Garner, for her role as Ruth Langmore in Ozark. The category’s competition is wickedly strong across the board, but we think it’s down to those two, and we’ll give it to Carter for her surprising and delightful portrayal.

Supporting Actor in a Drama Series

Billy Crudup in The Morning Show

(Photo by Apple TV+)

Who is nominated?

Who will win? Crudup

And why? Our guess is that Crudup and Culkin battled it out for supremacy; though both must contend with the possibility that their costars siphoned off votes, and maybe Whitford, Wright, or Esposito will have realized an advantage because of it. Team Succession probably collectively won, but we’re betting on Crudup in a category that could really go to any of the nominees.

Outstanding Limited Series

Watchmen, season 1 Regina King. Andrew Howard. Photo: Mark Hill.

(Photo by HBO)

What is nominated?

What will win? Watchmen

And why? Mrs. America and Unbelievable may have higher Tomatometer scores, but we think the category is going Watchmen, Damon Lindelof’s timely and tense examination of history, race, and justice within the superhero milieu.

TV Movie

The winner in this category will be announced on Saturday, September 19 as part of the Creative Arts Emmy Awards presentation, airing at 5 p.m. PT / 8 p.m. ET on FXX.

Bad Education

(Photo by Ben Rothstein / Netflix )

What is nominated?

What will win? Bad Education

And why? The power of Bad Education, with its Certified Fresh 93% score and outstanding performances led by Hugh Jackman and Allison Janney, is undeniable. Jesse Pinkman and his El Camino may not go down without a fight, but we think they’re going to get schooled.

Lead Actress in a Limited Series or Movie

Watchmen Season 1, Episode 9 (season finale) Regina King. photo: Mark Hill/HBO

(Photo by Mark Hill/HBO)

Who is nominated?

Who will win? King

And why? Though Blanchett is a front runner, we think 2018 category winner King will emerge victorious once more for her powerful performance in HBO’s alternate-history, vigilante-superhero drama.

Lead Actor in a Limited Series or Movie

Mark Ruffalo in I Know This Much Is True

(Photo by Atsushi Nishijima/HBO)

Who is nominated?

Who will win? Ruffalo

And why? Ruffalo turned in a stellar dual performance in I Know This Much Is True, and his biggest competition is fellow film star Jackman. We can’t help thinking, however, that Ruffalo did twice the work.

Supporting Actress in a Limited Series or Movie

Jean Smart in Watchmen

(Photo by Mark Hill/HBO)

Who is nominated?

Who will win? Smart

And why? This is a tough category chock full of superb performances. For one, we expect the three Mrs. America stars to divide the Academy, leaving Smart — with her buzzy performance in a timely genre series — as the favorite for the win.

Supporting Actor in a Limited Series or Movie

Yahya Abdul-Mateen II in Watchmen

(Photo by Mark Hill/HBO)

Who is nominated?

Who will win? Abdul-Mateen II

And why? The odds favor four-time Emmy winner Parsons, but — feel that breeze? That’s the wings of Watchmen and the winds of change.

The 72nd Emmy Awards winners will be announced on Sunday, September 20, at 5 p.m. PT / 8 p.m. ET on ABC. 

Tag Cloud

toy story Super Bowl Fox Searchlight spider-man sitcom Television Academy all-time franchise Amazon transformers PaleyFest Trophy Talk Apple Reality TCA 2017 series Superheroe halloween space renewed TV shows Dark Horse Comics breaking bad mockumentary christmas movies films free movies Family Writers Guild of America docudrama Best and Worst YouTube Red Musicals what to watch aliens Superheroes war Spectrum Originals cooking 72 Emmy Awards slashers scary movies romance streaming First Reviews TCA Winter 2020 Pirates Character Guide Summer Elton John rotten Hallmark Christmas movies Sundance crime drama comic stoner Paramount Set visit Premiere Dates Cosplay E3 New York Comic Con WarnerMedia movies Winners Comedy Central TV renewals a nightmare on elm street MCU obituary Endgame blaxploitation Cannes BET Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt vampires name the review disaster based on movie ESPN Walt Disney Pictures movie cats nfl USA El Rey Turner football crossover 2020 LGBTQ BAFTA Bravo sequels Syfy criterion hispanic Heroines reviews psychological thriller south america Travel Channel twilight Nickelodeon Stephen King CBS Year in Review Kids & Family Classic Film indie venice quibi Sony Pictures Spike Acorn TV Marathons cancelled TV series Oscars Amazon Prime Video TNT talk show medical drama Interview Election comiccon Chilling Adventures of Sabrina emmy awards Tubi MTV crime thriller news Winter TV Nominations latino Esquire television festivals jamie lee curtis IFC Action universal monsters Drama First Look Television Critics Association SXSW Teen video Martial Arts chucky 2017 directors diversity Thanksgiving Comedy tv talk historical drama X-Men Shondaland SundanceTV Columbia Pictures Holidays YouTube comics Fantasy elevated horror archives satire TBS period drama animated Rom-Com Emmy Nominations Lucasfilm kids classics Podcast Peacock Warner Bros. Schedule Certified Fresh CBS All Access japanese The Arrangement halloween tv Apple TV+ CNN rotten movies we love zombies Chernobyl BET Awards screen actors guild Cartoon Network Pet Sematary golden globes discovery MSNBC binge stand-up comedy asian-american revenge casting cars Polls and Games spain OneApp social media biography superhero worst Film Opinion See It Skip It Star Trek FX on Hulu Brie Larson video on demand fast and furious RT History Masterpiece scorecard book Box Office travel 2016 Anna Paquin Disney+ Disney Plus batman Rocky 45 Star Wars Sundance TV RT21 children's TV singing competition Comics on TV Discovery Channel harry potter parents Toys TCA Awards Tomatazos President game show CMT Lifetime Crunchyroll Mudbound Pixar laika BBC One finale Pop dogs green book reboot Spring TV Infographic technology political drama Disney Plus AMC WGN YA Ghostbusters joker Calendar Sci-Fi Trailer Mystery Universal Adult Swim Freeform true crime dramedy robots Trivia spanish Music nature Creative Arts Emmys 21st Century Fox USA Network adaptation teaser National Geographic Animation Horror GLAAD Countdown BBC America mutant blockbuster toronto Pop TV Lifetime Christmas movies Sundance Now FX supernatural Rock Crackle Women's History Month Rocketman dragons Avengers Amazon Prime thriller 2018 screenings LGBT independent Britbox YouTube Premium miniseries Nat Geo dceu versus 71st Emmy Awards Fox News cults anime Baby Yoda cancelled television Christmas sequel PlayStation zero dark thirty ITV TV Land award winner Mary Tyler Moore Mindy Kaling Food Network OWN VH1 Awards Tour Photos critics ABC A&E 2019 Comic Book 4/20 American Society of Cinematographers Watching Series strong female leads Tumblr crime Starz Showtime psycho FOX composers nbcuniversal The Academy Lionsgate 2015 Fall TV Country Mary poppins child's play hist Disney streaming service anthology Emmys comedies remakes Quiz Grammys TV werewolf Amazon Studios DGA FXX Marvel Television facebook canceled TV shows Valentine's Day foreign NBC justice league mission: impossible dc DirecTV Netflix Christmas movies serial killer PBS politics Disney Channel Ovation ABC Family natural history dark game of thrones festival Musical GIFs science fiction sag awards witnail cartoon Netflix DC Universe Red Carpet richard e. Grant Extras TLC documentaries TIFF GoT Logo spanish language Mary Poppins Returns Paramount Network Apple TV Plus IFC Films Binge Guide spinoff Captain marvel A24 San Diego Comic-Con ratings zombie VOD cops NYCC unscripted TCA The Purge The Walking Dead canceled Hulu Black Mirror cancelled APB Biopics DC Comics Ellie Kemper Holiday CW Seed Shudder Marvel Studios Reality Competition The CW 007 police drama concert theme song adventure Hear Us Out SDCC indiana jones Video Games 20th Century Fox Marvel TCM doctor who HBO spy thriller Funimation italian Awards HBO Max cinemax cancelled TV shows 24 frames boxoffice Academy Awards romantic comedy ghosts TruTV Arrowverse E! Sneak Peek History documentary sports hollywood Film Festival best VICE die hard Black History Month Western stop motion The Witch Epix Turner Classic Movies Disney DC streaming service worst movies french BBC Tarantino Vudu HBO Go Pride Month Hallmark Song of Ice and Fire