Trophy Talk

Mary Poppins Returns Could Be a Late-Season Awards Spoiler

Mary Poppins has returned to shake up the awards landscape, and it may just pull off an upset or two.

by | December 4, 2018 | Comments

Walt Disney Studios
(Photo by Walt Disney Studios)

This month, Mary Poppins Returns has the Herculean task of recapturing the magic and music of the beloved original. Not possible, right? Well, according to many of the critics and industry folks who saw it at last week’s premiere, it might just come close. Early social reactions saw the majority of critics praising the film and Emily Blunt in particular, for her turn in the iconic blue coat. Germain Lussier of i09 was typical of the praise thrown her way and the movie’s way when he tweeted: “Mary Poppins Returns is an exquisitely made film with delightful music, excellent performances (especially by Emily Blunt) & contagious optimism.” But, could the movie – like its predecessor – be an Oscar contender?

There is no Tomatometer score as of yet – reviews will release soon on December 12th, and as you know, anything can happen – but reading the tea leaves, Mary Poppins Returns looks to be a perfectly timed holiday hit, and one that has shot to the top of many Oscar prognosticators’ lists. And not just for Blunt. Variety‘s awards editor Kristopher Tapley set the tone a few weeks back following a very early screening, going as far as to say, “Mary Poppins Returns will be a massive hit, which will drive the point home all the more: Audiences want a movie like this right now. Critics, even the most cynical of them (whether they admit it or not), want a movie like this right now. Surely, Oscar voters want a movie like this right now.”

As we enter December, with Golden Globe nominations just days away and Oscar ballots almost on their way to voters, let’s take a look at the competitive awards categories for Mary Poppins Returns and why this unlikely late-season entry could just shake things up.


It’s the Film We Need Right Now

Walt Disney Studios
(Photo by Walt Disney Studios)

We hate the “thing we need right now” hot-take framing as much as you do, but in this case, there’s some truth to it. Like a high-flying kite – scratch that: a balloon – Mary Poppins Returns has brought a huge dollop of joy to a pretty dour awards-season field. Of all the major contenders – think Roma, If Beale Street Could Talk, Vice, The Favourite, or Green Book – Poppins is the most unapologetically joyful film, which might be exactly what audiences and voters are drawn to in the dying days of 2018. Despairing at the state of the world? Then perhaps you want to see Emily Blunt and Lin-Manuel Miranda singing and dancing around London more than another dark examination of the nature of humankind. Just saying. Director Rob Marshall seems to have tapped into something that’s hard to quantify yet wholly disarming, especially for adults. As Dame Angela Lansbury says towards the end of the film, most grownups “forget what it’s like… to be a child.” Don’t think that’s enough to convince voters? It’s the same kind of infectious optimism that La La Land inspired in Academy voters back in 2016.


Below the Line, Poppins is Tops

Walt Disney Studios

Looking for nomination sure bets? Look straight to below-the-line categories like costumes, make-up, visual effects, and production design. But you already knew that from the trailers. Having seen the film, we would add Best Editing and the sound categories to that list. One sequence that takes place on the surface of a porcelain bowl highlights the best elements of all of the aforementioned trades: careful sound mixing and effects seamlessly integrate the characters into a delicate ceramic and animated world, while Sandy Powell’s costumes for the sequence are a mix of materials and appear as a blend of soft fabrics and watercolor paints that would crumple upon touching. Powell could go up against her contemporary rival Colleen Atwood for Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald, Black Panther costume designer Ruth E. Carter, and, in an interesting wrinkle, herself; Powell has a second bite at the Oscar apple with her equally impressive work on Yorgos Lanthimos’ The Favourite.

To achieve the vivid 2-D animation sequences that are a particular highlight of the porcelain bowl scene, Marshall went to painstaking lengths. These days, Disney animators work primarily in the digital format — the studio’s last hand-drawn animation was back in 2004, long before most of the current crop of animators joined the company. It required calling former animators out of retirement to achieve the signature mix of live action and 2-D animation, while implementing innovations for both formats. Marshall had to merge two animation mediums that were never intended to coexist; the results could earn the movie consideration in the effects categories.


“Shallow” May No Longer Be a Lock for Best Original Song

Walt Disney Studios
(Photo by Walt Disney Studios)

Lady Gaga and Bradley Cooper’s “Shallow” from A Star is Born has seemingly been a lock for the Best Original Song Oscar for months. A bona fide chart-topper that has been streamed over 10 million times since its September 27th release, it has long looked unstoppable. But last week “The Place Where Lost Things Go,” sung by Blunt, and “Trip a Little Light Fantastic,” sung by Miranda, were released, marking them as the two songs Disney seems to be backing for the category – and they may just cause an upset.

As in recent years, the “hit” may not prove to be the eventual winner come ceremony time. Back when Sam Smith won for Spectre’s “Writing’s on the Wall,” he beat The Weeknd’s “Earned It” from Fifty Shades of Grey – which people had actually, you know, heard of. Everyone remembers La La Land being favored with “City of Stars,” but do you remember that in the same year it beat out Trolls’ infectious four-time platinum smash “Can’t Stop The Feeling” by Justin Timberlake? Keeping with the trend, last year the quiet and sentimental “Remember Me” from Coco won over The Greatest Showman’s “This is Me,” a song that is still charting as part of the film’s soundtrack more than a year after the movie exited cinemas. So don’t be surprised if Blunt’s “The Place Where Lost Things Go” topples the Gaga-liath “Shallow.”


Acting Nods and (Maybe) A Best Picture Chance 

Walt Disney Studios
(Photo by Walt Disney Studios)

For acting, it’s all down to Miranda and Blunt. They get the lion’s share of screen time and perform the narrative heavy lifting. At the Globes, Miranda has more than a decent shot of a nomination, with the categories being split between Comedy and Drama, but it’s unlikely he will prove a challenge to Christian Bale and Viggo Mortensen. Blunt fares slightly better in the Best Actress – Musical or Comedy race. It will likely be a three-way race between Blunt, Constance Wu for Crazy Rich Asians, and Olivia Colman for The Favourite, and while most think Colman is a shoo-in, Blunt has a history with the Hollywood Foreign Press Association that shouldn’t be dismissed (she is a five-time nominee and one-time winner). Even Mary Poppins herself would have a hard time magicking an Oscar nomination for Miranda, but Blunt has the pedigree and delivers a performance that may squeeze her into contention before the Academy announces its nominees.

For Best Picture, things will likely come down to how many nominees we get. At least five percent of first-place votes must go to a particular film in order for it to contend for Best Picture as one of the final nominees. With the race still wide open, it’s not unreasonable to think the Academy could have a strong preference for more than five films; Mary Poppins Returns will stand a strong chance if the Best Picture field stretches to eight or ten nominees.

Tag Cloud

NYCC Amazon Prime Valentine's Day Drama cults miniseries 2017 Box Office IFC Films Western animated Mary Tyler Moore doctor who Sundance natural history Christmas Tarantino Opinion green book DGA History Masterpiece based on movie TLC E! Comedy adventure strong female leads DC Universe technology adaptation Paramount DC streaming service Awards Tour biography 2016 nature crossover Food Network elevated horror Reality Competition vampires social media spider-man Pride Month Amazon unscripted blaxploitation Disney Channel Premiere Dates Red Carpet New York Comic Con Year in Review CBS MSNBC Comedy Central Infographic DC Comics Ovation Kids & Family war Election docudrama binge Star Wars 45 harry potter Anna Paquin ABC Family Comic Book YA The Arrangement AMC cinemax sports Fox News Biopics Grammys zombies 2015 Comics on TV police drama Universal USA Network golden globes 007 Dark Horse Comics ITV Marvel MCU Paramount Network Nat Geo Spring TV OWN 24 frames Columbia Pictures Syfy Set visit Fantasy Cartoon Network witnail dramedy Lucasfilm streaming Bravo Women's History Month Sundance Now dc LGBTQ Epix cops richard e. Grant Super Bowl Tomatazos Writers Guild of America crime thriller zombie award winner GLAAD spy thriller FX Nominations Holidays BBC E3 casting theme song Spectrum Originals X-Men VH1 ABC Starz Winners YouTube Red Horror Action TCA 2017 CW Seed Pet Sematary Mudbound Chernobyl BET Certified Fresh festivals dceu Ghostbusters Mindy Kaling Marathons YouTube Premium San Diego Comic-Con Watching Series Stephen King Rocky Lionsgate Extras Summer Hulu 21st Century Fox hist Podcast Pop National Geographic anthology Mary Poppins Returns Country TruTV Trailer Elton John period drama ESPN justice league Best and Worst Shondaland Countdown toy story Oscars what to watch VICE Rocketman Freeform science fiction psychological thriller First Look IFC Tumblr teaser Apple SDCC cooking Rom-Com Adult Swim Brie Larson comiccon psycho talk show CMT political drama Lifetime finale GIFs spinoff Calendar HBO space romance composers diversity Video Games robots Britbox Walt Disney Pictures Rock Shudder CBS All Access El Rey facebook Netflix Winter TV Photos Heroines Showtime Mystery Interview Song of Ice and Fire Logo Schedule LGBT President Sci-Fi Nickelodeon American Society of Cinematographers mutant 2019 20th Century Fox anime DirecTV Cannes Polls and Games game show travel PaleyFest discovery Star Trek Ellie Kemper Animation sequel TIFF USA mockumentary APB politics Warner Bros. FOX SXSW RT21 true crime Esquire television Crackle thriller Trivia transformers TNT crime drama Thanksgiving MTV Acorn TV jamie lee curtis Teen dragons SundanceTV Sneak Peek TCA TBS historical drama ratings The CW Captain marvel Black Mirror zero dark thirty boxoffice crime See It Skip It NBC serial killer aliens Sony Pictures Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Musical medical drama Creative Arts Emmys Cosplay 2018 disaster Film Festival comic Mary poppins Musicals Character Guide Spike FXX Fall TV Martial Arts TV WGN TV Land Pixar Pirates Reality Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Trophy Talk RT History Awards Vudu supernatural The Witch Toys Superheroes TCM Quiz BBC America A&E cats singing competition Emmys Music CNN Disney PBS sitcom GoT Superheroe