It's A Bird! It's A Plane! It's a "Superman Returns" Tomatometer!

by | June 20, 2006 | Comments

Yes indeed, "Superman Returns" has enough reviews by approved critics (six, and all Fresh) to have an Official Tomatometer — and what a Tomatometer, at 100%. Even the Unofficial Tomatometer, counting all sneak reviews and unapproved critics, remains strong at 95% with 21 opinions counted.

Shall we start with the trades? The Hollywood Reporter‘s Kirk Honeycutt says that Bryan Singer‘s "Superman" injects enough emotional depth to resonate, while using advances in CGI technology to his advantage, and to great effect:

"Director Bryan Singer positions this new film as a sequel to Donner’s film, and his Superman — played with winning fortitude by newcomer Brandon Routh — is less a Man of Steel than a Man of Heart."

"The oh-wow technical wizardry behind ‘Superman Returns’ accomplishes two things: It makes you appreciate the huge advances in visual effects since 1978 but also appreciate the considerable accomplishments of Donner’s team back in the day."


Will "Superman" soar through the skies in victory?

Variety‘s Todd McCarthy applauds the dramatic weight of the film, which could have easily been misplayed into cheesiness and camp:

"Despite its acute awareness of what’s come before, "Superman Returns" is never self-consciously hip, ironic, post-modern or camp. To the contrary, it’s quite sincere, with an artistic elegance and a genuine emotional investment in the material."

McCarthy goes on to compare the story and its characters to those of a tragic opera:

"There are dramatic passages where, in another context, one could easily imagine any of the three leading characters breaking out into arias of regret, confession, desire or intent."

The remaining four print and online Tomatometer-approved critics concur in their positive critiques, agreeing that Singer’s "Superman" has a heartstring-pulling resonance in its themes of loneliness and longing.

Newsweek‘s David Ansen gives a particularly glowing review:

"[Superman Returns] infuses its action with poetry, soars as a love story filled with epic yearnings, thwarted desires and breathtaking imagery: Lois, spied on with her lover’s X-ray vision, ascending in a skyscraper’s elevator; Superman, zapped with kryptonite, descending silently and helplessly through space."

"(If Jean Cocteau had directed $200 million action movies, they might have looked a little like this.)"

Emanuel Levy‘s critique offers the rare mixed-Fresh bag, as he rates "Superman Returns" a flawed but entertaining B-grade, due to what he considers sub-par performances and Singer’s lack of a cohesive vision:

"As he showed in the first two segments of ‘X-Men,’ Singer is an intelligent and skillful director in the technical department, but he is not as strong in narrative, characterization, and most important of all, endowing a big, necessarily episodic movie like ‘Superman Returns’ with a unified and coherent vision."

"The movie never overcomes a major narrative problem, that is, there are no significant differences between Superman’s dual identity in looks or conduct."

"Though displaying his customary blend of humor and cynicism, Spacey gives a flat, one-dimensional performance."

For more Official Tomatometer reviews, click here.

Don’t forget, while there are only six Tomatometer-approved reviews for "Superman Returns" (contributing to the Official Tomatometer), the Unofficial Tomatometer, currently at 95%, combines all reviews (with a total of 21 articles with ratings, including sneak movie reviews and Dave Poland’s controversial lone negative rating!).

Tag Cloud

disaster A24 Marvel Studios Comics on TV Shondaland screen actors guild Comedy Lifetime Christmas movies MCU spider-man green book dc Mystery Disney+ Disney Plus Fall TV NYCC Emmy Nominations parents Marvel APB Britbox Amazon Prime Video Endgame AMC Crunchyroll scary movies golden globes LGBT Thanksgiving halloween Pixar crime drama social media Columbia Pictures casting discovery versus Black History Month robots X-Men Video Games Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Mary Poppins Returns Arrowverse unscripted movies Creative Arts Emmys GIFs E! San Diego Comic-Con Classic Film latino BBC Awards space DC Comics TV sports children's TV USA Network Awards Tour Cartoon Network Dark Horse Comics game of thrones franchise canceled TV renewals best quibi Peacock 71st Emmy Awards The Arrangement vampires Western OWN Sci-Fi PBS TCA Winter 2020 2017 universal monsters Oscars chucky criterion Disney streaming service die hard comedies Lifetime DC streaming service Tumblr reviews based on movie cartoon psychological thriller Turner kids Anna Paquin game show FOX Comedy Central Interview Country Hallmark Christmas movies book Hulu 007 Funimation Freeform TCM cancelled TV series YouTube TCA 2017 toy story Superheroes RT21 politics Mindy Kaling President Family Rom-Com period drama crossover Martial Arts Heroines blockbuster werewolf Summer Holiday Showtime Election screenings dark Holidays Certified Fresh Ellie Kemper Polls and Games 20th Century Fox series batman Reality jamie lee curtis Podcast Logo dogs Film ABC Marvel Television TNT See It Skip It Sundance Now hispanic Acorn TV FX Musicals technology Toys adaptation Nickelodeon Ghostbusters Ovation 2020 cooking doctor who miniseries biography award winner spinoff Countdown YA Fantasy romance aliens concert Song of Ice and Fire Writers Guild of America nature Superheroe 2015 Amazon Studios TIFF Lionsgate Esquire science fiction Pet Sematary Christmas hist zero dark thirty TBS Shudder spain documentary cancelled TV shows police drama HBO Max ABC Family Teen Apple TV Plus cars NBC cinemax Starz stand-up comedy Avengers elevated horror 2019 witnail PaleyFest rotten movies we love Mudbound docudrama Rocky anime free movies TCA Photos OneApp spanish language Premiere Dates crime thriller CBS All Access National Geographic finale stoner Binge Guide composers Brie Larson Food Network independent thriller Walt Disney Pictures Pop TV Hear Us Out BET CW Seed singing competition Captain marvel TV Land 21st Century Fox E3 Trophy Talk psycho cats Winter TV medical drama Trailer spy thriller Tomatazos Rock Opinion Pop Hallmark zombie YouTube Red dramedy transformers Watching Series Trivia cancelled Reality Competition canceled TV shows indie Paramount facebook Apple TV+ what to watch Lucasfilm Cannes blaxploitation binge Star Wars IFC Films movie comic Masterpiece WGN 2016 The Walking Dead FXX streaming adventure Kids & Family zombies Musical Mary Tyler Moore Emmys El Rey Grammys dceu Sundance TV Vudu political drama GoT ratings travel Stephen King 45 cults Biopics GLAAD First Reviews renewed TV shows romantic comedy Sundance cancelled television Cosplay Disney BBC America Extras LGBTQ FX on Hulu Travel Channel DC Universe Amazon Prime television diversity foreign Black Mirror strong female leads Animation TLC The CW supernatural theme song Super Bowl MTV Rocketman Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Elton John Apple Paramount Network animated justice league VICE Set visit reboot 24 frames child's play teaser YouTube Premium sitcom crime Horror natural history Spring TV The Witch mockumentary RT History Bravo breaking bad CMT Schedule A&E Red Carpet sequel Quiz Academy Awards Disney Plus Discovery Channel joker CNN Nat Geo CBS Adult Swim Television Academy Turner Classic Movies comiccon Sony Pictures Box Office Drama Film Festival Netflix Nominations dragons Character Guide Infographic name the review Best and Worst Chernobyl historical drama harry potter 2018 revenge First Look video a nightmare on elm street Star Trek sag awards Pirates asian-american TruTV true crime Tarantino SundanceTV The Purge Action mission: impossible VH1 Valentine's Day Amazon Tubi Baby Yoda Universal DirecTV HBO comics Sneak Peek Calendar slashers war IFC Comic Book 4/20 History Epix Syfy New York Comic Con Year in Review tv talk Spectrum Originals festivals Crackle MSNBC Women's History Month anthology south america American Society of Cinematographers directors Disney Channel Spike Marathons talk show ESPN mutant cops serial killer Netflix Christmas movies Warner Bros. Music boxoffice DGA Winners ITV SXSW Fox News Pride Month christmas movies ghosts USA richard e. Grant SDCC Mary poppins WarnerMedia