Hear Us Out

Hear Us Out: Nyong’o and Woodard’s Snubs Might Have Shocked, But Shouldn’t Have Surprised If You Know Your Oscars History

The Academy has made a habit of rewarding certain kinds of roles for Black women, and it’s time it expanded its horizons.

by | February 3, 2020 | Comments

THE COLOR PURPLE, Whoopi Goldberg (Warner Brothers)

(Photo by © Warner Bros. )

Hear Us Out is a semi-regular column in which guest contributors and editors venture forth a take that’s sure to get fans talking. 

On February 29, 1940, in the Coconut Grove at the Ambassador Hotel, Jezebel actress Fay Bainter presented Hattie McDaniel with the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress. McDaniel was awarded Hollywood’s highest honor for playing Mammy, a slave to protagonist Scarlett O’Hara, in the big-screen adaptation of Margaret Mitchell’s Gone with the Wind. In her introduction, Bainter remarked that this award was more than a gold statuette: “It opens the doors of this room to embrace the whole of America, an America… that pays tribute to those who give it their best regardless of creed, race, or color.” Accepting the award, McDaniel said it was her sincere hope to “remain a credit to her race and the motion picture industry.”

McDaniel was the first female African American Oscar nominee and winner, and has been cited as a trailblazer by the likes of Halle Berry and Mo’Nique in acceptance speeches for their more recent Academy Awards. But watching John Cho and Issa Rae read the nominations for the 2020 Oscars in January, as it sank in that only one African American actor would be nominated in the four major acting categories – and that person would be the only actor of color more broadly to be nominated – one began to think of McDaniel and wonder, “What would Hattie think of where we are today?” Would she be glad to see Cynthia Erivo become the 12th Black actress ever to be nominated for a lead performance for her portrayal of Harriet Tubman in Harriet? Or would she be saddened to see Erivo is only the 12th, and to learn that it had taken five decades after her own win for another Black actress, Whoopi Goldberg, to repeat the feat for a supporting role?

And what would she think when she found that our newest Black female nominee is being honored for playing a slave – a rebellious, inspiring historical figure, true, but a slave nonetheless – just as Hattie had been honored for playing a slave 80 years ago?

(Photo by @Neon)

It should come as little surprise that even in a year populated by incredible and critically lauded performances by Black women – Lupita Nyong’o playing a mother/monster in Us; Alfre Woodard as a death-row warden in Clemency; Octavia Spencer as a high-school teacher in Luce; and so many more – it was Erivo’s rousing portrayal of Tubman that gained awards-season traction and ultimately an Oscar nomination. From 1939 to 2020, there have been 35 performances by Black women nominated for an Academy Award; of that 35, some 21 actresses were nominated for portraying a maid, a woman living in abject poverty, or a slave.

There has been a bias, or a tendency, intentional or not, to recognize portrayals of suffering – of slavery and its devastating after-effects – over the more rich array of roles other non-Black actresses are frequently rewarded for. This Oscars season feels like the right time to take a beat and question why this is and what the impact might be.

Each year’s Oscar story is different for a host of reasons beyond the actual performances that are nominated – different storylines emerge, the voting makeup differs, the competition mix is always unique, campaigns and release dates have their impacts. And this year is no different, with 10 strong and acclaimed performances up for Best Actress and Best Supporting Actress. But it’s hard to look past glaring incidences where a Black actress has been snubbed, or failed to gain any serious awards-season buzz, for a role almost identical to one a white actress has been nominated and even won for. The argument that it is a certain type of role that is ignored for women across the board just doesn’t pan out.

Consider Alfre Woodard in Clemency this year. The previously Oscar-nominated Woodard (1983, Cross Creek) was considered an instant Oscar hopeful among many from the moment they witnessed her performance as a death row warden grappling with a crisis of conscience at the 2019 Sundance Film Festival. Critics lauded her work, notably Rolling Stone’s Peter Travers, whose review of Clemency read like an editorial endorsement for her Oscar campaign: “Woodard, who has won four Emmys out of 18 nominations, is one of the best actors on the planet. Shockingly, she has only been nominated for an Oscar once… It would be a case of blatant neglect to ignore her artistry in the dramatic powerhouse that is Clemency… Like the movie she inhabits with every fiber of her being, Woodard is some kind of miracle.”

Tiffany Haddish, Girls Trip

(Photo by © Universal)

And yet, as the year went on, the performance largely failed to capture voters’ imaginations at the various guilds and other awards. This professional, middle-class character, struggling with the kinds of challenges white nominees’ characters frequently do – a crumbling marriage, growing alcohol dependency – didn’t connect. Back in 1995, Susan Sarandon was Oscar-nominated, and won, for a similar role – her character was a nun who formed a bond with a death-row inmate. Were the films in which they featured so different? Tim Robbins was an accomplished actor before he directed Dead Man Walking, but this was merely his second feature, just as Clemency was writer-director Chinonye Chukwu’s sophomore film. Sarandon was riding a wave of recent nominations and industry acclaim, but it would be hard to make the case she had as much of an “it’s her time” pitch as Woodard, who’s been acting for more than 40 years and has won four Emmys in addition to her Supporting Actress Oscar nomination.

Was Lupita Nyong’o’s dual turn as “Red”/Adelaide in Us that much different from Natalie Portman’s Jekyll/Hyde performance in Black Swan, hailed as a landmark and rewarded with the actress’s first Oscar? Both required physical feats to achieve – Portman’s ballerina diet and training; Nyong’o’s intense vocal work – and both set the zeitgeist alight, but only one managed to bust through the genre barrier to capture voters’ attention. (Notably, Nyong’o’s previous Oscar win was for playing a slave who is raped and tormented in 12 Years A Slave.)

Speaking of genre breakouts: Was Tiffany Haddish’s turn in Girls Trip so different from Melissa McCarthy’s in Bridesmaids? Was grapefruitin’ any less iconic than McCarthy’s airplane antics? It is all subjective, of course, but the point remains: performances in the same space, in the same types of films, seem to rarely cut through if they’re given by Black actresses. If we could mark one exception it would Whoopi Goldberg’s Oscar-winning turn in Ghost, but it’s worth noting what The Color Purple actress said when she accepted the trophy in 1991: She was not the filmmakers’ first choice, she had to fight for the role, and it was star Patrick Swayze stating he wanted her that finally secured her the part. And she was already an Oscar-nominated actress – for playing a victim of abuse – at the time.


(Photo by @Universal)

What is an award-worthy performance for a Black actress? Viola Davis received her first Oscar nomination for Doubt, playing a mother whose son is abused by the Church (and her abusive husband); she got her second for playing a maid in The Help; she would win for playing a housewife in Fences. Oscar-winner Halle Berry’s character was living in abject poverty in Monster’s Ball; Regina King, who won Best Supporting Actress for playing family matriarch Sharon in If Beale Street Could Talk, was thankfully just poor. Mo’Nique played a verbally abusive mother who chose her boyfriend – who was sexually abusing her daughter – over her own child in Precious. The performance resonated so much with voters the comedienne famously didn’t even need to campaign for the award.

Meanwhile, Angela Bassett campaigned to the fullest and did everything an Oscar hopeful is expected to do and still came up short when she played Tina Turner in What’s Love Got to Do With It; Pam Grier in Jackie Brown was also deemed unworthy of Oscar consideration, despite her celebrated comeback role with one of the hottest directors in Hollywood, Quentin Tarantino. Grier’s is an understated role in an ensemble cast, but that didn’t keep her similarly understated co-star Robert Forster from an Oscar nomination or, years later, Amy Adams from a nomination when she played a wise con-artist in American Hustle.

The most accomplished Black actresses of our time – Woodard, Spencer, Cicely Tyson, Goldberg, Nyong’o, and even Oprah – all had to make a stop as a maid or slave on their way to the Oscar stage. And what of the winners? Of the nine Black women who have actually won Academy Awards, only three – Whoopi Goldberg, Jennifer Hudson, and Regina King – can boast that they broke the mold, playing in order: a con artist, a scorned singer, and mother whose son was accused of rape.

Regina King

(Photo by John Rasimus / Barcroft Media via Getty Images)

The numbers don’t lie: A Black actress’s best chance at being nominated for and winning an Oscar lies in playing a maid or a slave – and, at the very least, making a mark as a maid or slave before moving to a different Oscar-winning role. Is that progress? Meanwhile, the road to Oscar victory for some non-Black winners over the last few decades has included playing a waitress falling in love, an inspirational football mom, a drunken socialite, a witty widow, an FBI agent, a boxer, and an elderly rich lady just taking a ride. It’s not that any one of these was not deserving, simply that they illustrate that the path and potential for white actresses aspiring to the Oscars stage seems extraordinarily wide, while the path for Black actresses seems as narrow as an Olympic gymnastics balance beam – stepping just an inch or so off means you falter.

This phenomenon is not unique to Black actresses: If you are an Asian actress, your chances of a nomination are even slimmer, and still to this day, more white actresses have won for playing Asians than Asian women have for playing their own identity. And Latinx actresses have not fared much better, with only two wins out of 10 nominations.

What is the impact when certain narratives, and certain roles, are so heavily favored by the Academy and other awards voting groups, particularly when those roles home in on poverty and subjugation? The effect is insidious. If you are a young Black actress in Hollywood today and given a script with “Oscar potential” – say, one playing a historical figure like Shirley Chisholm (the first Black woman to run for president) or Mae Carol Jemison (the first Black female astronaut in space) – you could take the role, be lauded by critics, become a hit with audiences, and yet you would do so with the full knowledge that it will likely come up short of consideration for your profession’s highest honor. The safer bet now, as it ever was, is to play a slave.

Octavia Spencer, Luce

(Photo by © Neon)

And what is the impact of that calculus and its repetition? We will continue to see a certain type of role and character repeatedly rewarded, and the cycle will go on.

These tales of slaves and maids and more are incredibly valuable and relevant stories to tell and lives to portray, and the performances – Erivo’s included – can be mind-blowingly good. But they are not the only stories worth being told or the only characters worthy of recognition. The world of ideas shrinks incredibly when we don’t see the full array of the Black experience represented and rewarded, whether that be the life of a 1950s maid or a modern-day prison warden or a school teacher or an astronaut or a twentysomething looking to party hard in New Orleans. Or the life of Aretha Franklin, whom Jennifer Hudson will play on the big screen this year, and Erivo herself will play on TV.

Hattie McDaniel could never dream of playing a megastar musician. She won her Oscar for playing a maid, and made a living playing similar roles. She’s drawn criticism for taking so many “Mammy” jobs, but countered that it was her only real option for regular work at the time. She famously said it was far better to make “Seven hundred dollars a week playing a maid than earn seven a day being a maid.” In that sense, some progress has been made. The variety of roles available to actresses of color may still be limited, but it’s vaster than it ever has been. It would be great to see that better reflected on future nominations mornings.

Are you as obsessed with awards as we are? Check out our Awards Leaderboard for 2019/2020.

Tag Cloud

obituary Showtime X-Men medical drama See It Skip It Box Office romance 1990s VICE Paramount Plus Trophy Talk BET book adaptation robots Apple TV+ adenture revenge Action biography Amazon Studios what to watch El Rey Year in Review TCA Britbox Musical Mudbound political drama twilight films sitcom Tokyo Olympics festival TCM comedies theme song fresh trailers sopranos Hallmark venice Horror wonder woman FOX VH1 crossover toy story adventure composers Freeform emmy awards documentary halloween SXSW new zealand child's play adaptation Endgame kong Film Festival Interview Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Hear Us Out 21st Century Fox Extras latino Legendary festivals Grammys Musicals CBS Shondaland live event Hulu Thanksgiving USA know your critic reviews Country New York Comic Con legend dexter indie Polls and Games crime drama HBO Max Premiere Dates TNT RT21 hispanic heritage month Paramount Network sequels TV Land Creative Arts Emmys Lifetime Christmas movies green book Broadway Reality Competition versus cartoon Adult Swim NBC rotten movies we love Wes Anderson Western comic HBO Go Star Wars comic books 2018 criterion TCA Awards Video Games Instagram Live australia PlayStation Marvel nfl superman renewed TV shows slasher cooking Academy Awards best worst cops Neflix thriller ViacomCBS Binge Guide YouTube Red Pop Crunchyroll HBO Sneak Peek canceled anthology discovery SundanceTV Amazon Walt Disney Pictures quibi CBS All Access fast and furious 2015 Universal king kong parents all-time black comedy TV renewals Winners YouTube zombies Nominations critics nbcuniversal Fantasy razzies series marvel cinematic universe Emmys Awards Set visit romantic comedy stop motion pirates of the caribbean elevated horror indiana jones Red Carpet Tarantino cancelled YouTube Premium target scorecard dogs 2020 documentaries animated Infographic laika E! LGBT AMC Brie Larson 99% debate Esquire toronto Pixar Disney streaming service Tumblr Sundance Now spider-verse concert Apple TLC children's TV FX History christmas movies 73rd Emmy Awards Dark Horse Comics Stephen King Anna Paquin stoner independent Heroines Hallmark Christmas movies Pop TV Cannes black tv talk BBC scene in color art house RT History kaiju The CW doctor who superhero Disney Rocketman Super Bowl movies boxing Superheroe 2021 GoT historical drama godzilla psychological thriller Summer Pacific Islander 20th Century Fox a nightmare on elm street Comic-Con@Home 2021 award winner IFC sequel disaster breaking bad nature Crackle Arrowverse dreamworks spy thriller Paramount sports social media Exclusive Video suspense Film Columbia Pictures universal monsters witnail game show 93rd Oscars international 007 Disney Plus canceled TV shows Comedy Central Watching Series cats ratings First Reviews deadpool comiccon anime mutant Spectrum Originals Oscars japanese dramedy worst movies science fiction saw spanish Discovery Channel die hard genre TBS 2016 video on demand Mindy Kaling Calendar Cartoon Network Amazon Prime zombie unscripted sag awards casting cinemax ABC Signature LGBTQ royal family zero dark thirty Reality lord of the rings basketball San Diego Comic-Con Television Critics Association 4/20 Nat Geo comic book movies Family Mary poppins Black Mirror chucky MTV Pirates Quiz stand-up comedy Mary Tyler Moore MCU prank FX on Hulu new york supernatural Bravo harry potter Captain marvel comic book movie 72 Emmy Awards french ABC talk show Baby Yoda reboot psycho DC Comics Election satire Music scary spain DC Universe feel good MSNBC cancelled television dceu Pride Month strong female leads natural history Comics on TV miniseries SDCC Biopics asian-american young adult archives spinoff remakes action-comedy VOD Writers Guild of America 24 frames Spring TV Turner Classic Movies television A24 classics National Geographic Peacock PBS vs. Toys Trailer jurassic park Holiday Alien Best and Worst rom-coms Vudu vampires Ovation The Walking Dead Tubi women franchise Ellie Kemper dark Syfy Sony Pictures CW Seed Christmas james bond king arthur Fox Searchlight USA Network Marvel Television based on movie aapi 90s CNN Comedy true crime Shudder Marvel Studios golden globe awards Rocky dragons Logo A&E slashers Awards Tour WarnerMedia E3 directors streaming mob Netflix movie NYCC italian monster movies TruTV comics gangster Schedule docudrama TIFF marvel comics Avengers Cosplay Image Comics Spike screen actors guild Lucasfilm Black History Month Starz Netflix Christmas movies Podcast Emmy Nominations The Witch critic resources Kids & Family Fox News Lifetime Pet Sematary Tomatazos Comic Book halloween tv 45 technology The Arrangement cancelled TV series Mystery spanish language OneApp First Look news American Society of Cinematographers YA aliens TCA 2017 Classic Film batman Song of Ice and Fire diversity Teen BET Awards BBC America Acorn TV mcc name the review Sundance posters cancelled TV shows Disney+ Disney Plus rotten crime telelvision Television Academy Rock space crime thriller mission: impossible mockumentary Masterpiece politics Travel Channel japan Amazon Prime Video Valentine's Day Women's History Month Universal Pictures Rom-Com heist movie Apple TV Plus teaser olympics ESPN spider-man Opinion TV One south america Fall TV Holidays The Walt Disney Company Countdown Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt live action Turner Lionsgate Sci-Fi new star wars movies jamie lee curtis dc NBA Marathons DirecTV The Academy Certified Fresh OWN TV hispanic Trivia Disney Channel Warner Bros. 71st Emmy Awards joker 2017 streaming movies foreign war Photos video cults Star Trek Sundance TV richard e. Grant scary movies high school WGN PaleyFest Chernobyl Funimation justice league Ghostbusters IMDb TV popular rt labs cars police drama transformers travel FXX hollywood hist football APB binge book finale GLAAD CMT Character Guide Mary Poppins Returns rt labs critics edition facebook Superheroes docuseries Food Network AMC Plus kids DGA golden globes rt archives hidden camera werewolf ID singing competition IFC Films President 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards TCA Winter 2020 free movies TV movies blockbuster ITV DC streaming service Animation Martial Arts Winter TV Nickelodeon Epix biopic ghosts blaxploitation 2019 period drama blockbusters The Purge Elton John serial killer screenings BAFTA BBC One ABC Family boxoffice GIFs Drama game of thrones