Golden Tomato Awards: "Casino Royale," "The Queen" Best-Reviewed of 2006

by | January 10, 2007 | Comments

The 8th Annual Golden Tomato Awards were announced today, and "Casino Royale" and "The Queen" are the best reviewed wide and limited releases, respectively. The worst-reviewed movie was "Basic Instinct 2," Sharon Stone‘s attempt to re-capture past glory.

With a new actor in the role of James bond, as well as a grittier, back-to-basics approach for the 007 franchise, "Casino Royale" has been overwhelmingly embraced by the critics, one of whom opined that the movie "is everything you could ask for in a Bond movie, and more." It scores an impressive 95 percent on the Tomatometer. "Die Another Day," Pierce Brosnan final movie as a double O, scores 59 percent in comparison.

New York Times Crossword Puzzle Editor Will Shortz with his Golden Tomato trophy for "Wordplay." Photo credit: Kevin Tachman

Dame Helen Mirren and Michael Sheen are perfect in their roles in "The Queen." The movie is near perfect on the Tomatometer as well, scoring 98 percent. Mirren and Sheen anchor a movie that illuminates what goes on behind the scenes in Buckingham Palace at a time when the royals faced a crisis of confidence from the populace. New York Magazine’s David Edelstein calls the film "a small masterpiece."

No puzzle here. RT’s Senh Duong hands writing/directing team Patrick Creadon (left) and Christine O’Malley their well-deserved Golden Tomato trophy for best-reviewed documentary, "Wordplay." Photo credit: Mieke Kramer

Here’s how some of the award recipients responded to their Golden Tomato recognition:

"Critical acclaim is the lifeblood of a quality independent film like ‘The Queen‘ and it is a dream come true to be recognized as the best reviewed film in limited release by Rotten Tomatoes," said Daniel Battsek, president of Miramax Films, which distributed the film. "The award will take pride of place in the Miramax trophy cabinet and will hopefully be joined by many more in the future. Long live ‘The Queen!’ May she be forever fresh."

Guillermo del Toro, writer and director of Foreign Film winner "Pan’s Labyrinth," was equally pleased with his win: "The positive response to ‘Pan’s Labyrinth’ has been overwhelming. I can’t tell you how many times I have clicked onto Rotten Tomatoes and been bowled over by our positive rating. Rotten Tomatoes provides a much needed, though nerve-wracking service, to all filmmakers. I am proud and honored to accept this award on behalf of ‘Pan’s Labyrinth.’"

Neil Marshall, writer and director of "The Descent," winner of the Golden Tomato for Horror had this to say about his win, "This is by far the coolest award I’ve been lucky enough to receive!"

Director Michel Gondry cherishes his Golden Tomato trophy, but wishes it was a pen instead. Photo credit: Kevin Tachman

Michel Gondry, writer and director of the Golden Tomato winner for Romance, "The Science of Sleep," demonstrated that he can sling barbs as well as any critic when he said, "I am thrilled by this Rotten recognition of the critics. Although, one of them said I should not be allowed to hold a pen, so I wanted to know if I could be offered a Rotten Tomato pen as a trophy that I would gladly present to this critic to place in a not so romantic location."

Other major winners include "Borat" for Comedy; "The Departed" for Thriller; and "Cars" for Animation.

The Golden Tomato Awards honor the best-reviewed (as well as worst-reviewed) movies of the previous year by tallying critics’ reviews using a weighted formula to account for the variation in the number of reviews.

2006 Winners Complete List:

"Casino Royale"

"The Queen"

"Casino Royale"



"The Queen"

"The Descent"


"The Science of Sleep"

"Children of Men"


"Pan’s Labyrinth"

"The Departed"

MOLDY TOMATO (Worst Reviewed Movie of the Year):
"Basic Instinct 2"

Click here to see the runner-ups.

Tag Cloud

TV TruTV Comedy 20th Century Fox Star Wars Action Rock Western Interview robots politics Spike Disney Mystery 45 Grammys CMT Sneak Peek Fox News Tomatazos supernatural Acorn TV ratings Columbia Pictures binge Awards Writers Guild of America crossover YouTube Premium Chilling Adventures of Sabrina golden globes period drama Tumblr CW Seed VICE dc Fantasy zombies 2018 Walt Disney Pictures USA Network GoT Pixar Spring TV cops 21st Century Fox X-Men AMC Paramount Box Office Comedy Central thriller Super Bowl Christmas BET DC Comics DC Universe Drama RT History Comics on TV IFC Marathons Comic Book crime drama Quiz Warner Bros. Countdown 007 Superheroes MTV Apple Set visit GLAAD Mindy Kaling GIFs TIFF DirecTV police drama Food Network Photos Rocky Best and Worst YA Toys The Arrangement Music 2016 ABC Family cooking Epix Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt A&E TV Land Trivia Year in Review Mary Tyler Moore social media El Rey CBS All Access Amazon Marvel Disney Channel streaming HBO FOX what to watch Certified Fresh jamie lee curtis Lifetime Opinion Reality Competition based on movie dceu Polls and Games romance Nominations American Society of Cinematographers Showtime Awards Tour Star Trek Nickelodeon PaleyFest zombie Cartoon Network festivals spy thriller SDCC Podcast harry potter ITV ESPN dramedy cults Mary Poppins Returns Netflix Kids & Family FX WGN Red Carpet Shudder Masterpiece science fiction E! IFC Films NBC E3 Ghostbusters Pop green book sports serial killer Shondaland Oscars Universal comiccon Britbox New York Comic Con Trophy Talk Sundance Now Character Guide LGBTQ cats vampires CNN History MSNBC Nat Geo docudrama historical drama award winner Starz Hulu Esquire 2019 SXSW medical drama 2017 San Diego Comic-Con FXX sitcom political drama cinemax spider-man Lucasfilm Musicals See It Skip It aliens Teen boxoffice Reality Logo NYCC Mary poppins Video Games CBS Infographic Dark Horse Comics DC streaming service Freeform SundanceTV TCM Bravo Trailer BBC Watching Series PBS technology Song of Ice and Fire Premiere Dates Horror Cosplay 2015 APB VH1 Superheroe crime President television TCA 2017 mutant doctor who Sundance Election Biopics Extras Winter TV YouTube Red Musical justice league OWN Summer Holidays adventure composers Rom-Com Lionsgate crime thriller Animation travel blaxploitation Adult Swim Thanksgiving comic finale psycho Ovation Fall TV TBS Martial Arts 24 frames hist TNT Syfy National Geographic Winners diversity Crackle talk show Sci-Fi biography Emmys Paramount Network anime transformers USA Valentine's Day Schedule Ellie Kemper war singing competition Calendar discovery Country Creative Arts Emmys Sony Pictures The CW unscripted TLC Pirates First Look ABC TCA BBC America