Five Favorite Films

Five Favorite Films with Whit Stillman

The writer-director of Metropolitan and this week's Damsels in Distress on five of his favorite movies.

by | April 5, 2012 | Comments

Back in the 1990s, Whit Stillman wrote and directed what might be regarded as three modern American classics. While independent cinema grew saturated with dysfunctional Sundance dramas and pop culture solipsism, Stillman’s so-called “yuppie trilogy” — Metropolitan (1990),
Barcelona (1994) and The Last Days of Disco
(1998) — instead offered comedic portraits of hyper-literate, obsessive preppy types negotiating a world of social etiquette that felt extracted from another time. Before Wes Anderson, Noah Baumbach or Lena Dunham — and indeed, Christian Bale’s take on Patrick Bateman — Stillman was indie film’s premier chronicler of the young, privileged and neurotic.

Which is all to say, it’s great to have him back. Fourteen years (and several aborted projects) after Disco, Stillman at last returns with
Damsels in Distress, which opens in theaters in New York and Los Angeles this week. The director’s take on the campus comedy — in so much as the film can be confined to a genre — it stars Analeigh Tipton as a freshman recruited by a clique of female students plotting a minor social revolution (and a major dance craze) at a school overrun with boorish frathouses. Not unlike an alternate universe Clueless populated with the urban haute bourgeoisie (and better cardigans), it’s an unmistakably Stillman piece: dry of wit, whimsical in the most beguiling sense, and refreshingly counter-cultural placed next to the endless, formula-joke bromances of the era.

While on the press rounds for the film this week, Stillman took some time out to write about his five favorite films. “These are just five of a possible 55 faves — or more,” he says. “But one has to start somewhere.”

The Gay Divorcee (Mark Sandrich, 1934; 100% Tomatometer)



Mark Sandrich was the superlative director of Fred Astaire musicals, strikingly more successful at this demanding (though charming) form than the better known George Stevens. It’s very funny, chock-a-block with great character actors, and with wonderful music (Cole Porter) and choreography (Astaire with Hermes Pan). There’s something about works at the beginning of a form or style of cinema, even if rough and lacking couth, that I find more lovable and compelling than that form perfected (which in this case would be the gorgeous Top Hat made by Sandrich the next year).

The Shop Around the Corner (Ernst Lubitsch, 1933; 100% Tomatometer)



Ernst Lubitsch’s profoundly moving and charming recreation of a microcosm of commerce-hunting humanity in an idealized, bygone Budapest. Jimmy Stewart and Margaret Sullavan are brilliant in their roles as the letterwriting non-lovers — but it’s Frank Morgan’s plight as the lovelorn, betrayed shop owner which gives the film its heart and weight.

Wagon Master (John Ford, 1950; 100% Tomatometer)


Directors going independent to make precisely the film they want was not begun — as we sometimes think — by the latterday Johns (Cassavetes and Sayles). After World War Two John Ford formed an indie with the legendary producer (war hero also) Merian C. Cooper: Wagon Master was the lovely result, a film that seems like folk art. The stirring score and brilliant diagonals of Ford’s composition greatly inspired us in the Barcelona edit room — though I’m not sure if any trace of that influence could be found in our film.

The Miracle of Morgan’s Creek (Preston Sturges, 1944; 90% Tomatometer)



Writer-director Preston Sturges’ most exuberant comedy — a film that’s easy to watch and hard to imagine, God-like in its love for and forgiveness of its protagonists. The Sturges cuisine transforms seemingly lunchmeat ingredients into a rich cinematic repast.

I Soliti Ignoti aka Big Deal on Madonna Street (Mario Monicelli, 1958; 88% Tomatometer)



The American title — Big Deal on Madonna Street — must be the worst of the international variants for Mario Monicelli’s brilliant incompetent-caper comedy, said to be the absurd version of Rififi. The direct translation — Persons Unknown — used elsewhere, seems funnier once you’ve seen the film; the Spanish distributor had the wit to call it Rufufu and there it’s a treasured classic. The shooting style — the great use of the so-called “curtain effect” — has also been something we always try to put to use.


Damsels in Distress opens in New York and Los Angeles this week.

Tag Cloud

crime thriller Image Comics Academy Awards History Disney+ Disney Plus die hard Crackle Marvel Television Cartoon Network nature cinemax Drama 2015 Thanksgiving new zealand CW Seed hist Ovation Marvel 2016 2017 AMC worst LGBT latino spanish language Comedy critics ITV RT History documentary OneApp TV movies Fantasy Cannes dceu Discovery Channel adaptation Mindy Kaling Writers Guild of America strong female leads Starz Broadway mission: impossible teaser cops PBS TLC Extras green book Epix Reality Competition X-Men FX south america sequel Exclusive Video rt labs critics edition First Reviews dramedy Shudder Film witnail 45 social media Television Critics Association 21st Century Fox Nickelodeon wonder woman FXX mutant HFPA 4/20 blaxploitation 93rd Oscars Western Video Games franchise comedies twilight Endgame Wes Anderson sag awards asian-american telelvision 79th Golden Globes Awards ABC facebook action-comedy Star Wars dogs french ID superhero Peacock Mudbound versus Red Carpet true crime theme song Rocketman TBS cats Awards Tour MCU TV El Rey spider-man dragons VICE streaming movies live event new york breaking bad rotten fresh The Witch YA Vudu Super Bowl IMDb TV Freeform Tags: Comedy movie christmas movies Stephen King TV renewals 24 frames psychological thriller reboot Spike joker Baby Yoda Lionsgate cancelled television SDCC Spectrum Originals Turner Classic Movies concert Legendary NBC canceled TV shows kong GLAAD Pet Sematary Fall TV book adaptation Tomatazos hollywood parents DC Comics science fiction cancelled TV series Avengers werewolf Pop Heroines new star wars movies criterion international 20th Century Fox sequels dark New York Comic Con serial killer Comedy Central mcc video spinoff natural history 007 The Walking Dead Oscars Valentine's Day HBO scary movies Winter TV Rocky Fox Searchlight Holidays sports best dexter space young adult blockbusters obi wan hispanic heritage month Nat Geo dreamworks Tubi casting 2018 73rd Emmy Awards gangster comic book movie See It Skip It TNT comic books art house BBC America psycho stoner Classic Film medical drama women tv talk cults Hear Us Out Women's History Month trailers American Society of Cinematographers SXSW 2022 comiccon TruTV festivals Walt Disney Pictures 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards CMT Quiz Amazon Prime Video cartoon feel good Acorn TV Lifetime Pacific Islander adenture singing competition Mystery biography Paramount Apple cancelled LGBTQ spain 72 Emmy Awards Lifetime Christmas movies game show Ellie Kemper miniseries Sundance comics hidden camera zombies Columbia Pictures black comedy Showtime Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Disney Plus Comic Book Nominations Emmy Nominations Disney Channel black renewed TV shows name the review rotten movies we love festival South by Southwest Film Festival MSNBC popular Tarantino venice Trophy Talk japanese Universal Amazon Lucasfilm Emmys crossover canceled BET Awards movies justice league SundanceTV comic book movies Sony Pictures DC Universe vampires period drama Black History Month GoT Sundance TV Certified Fresh Ghostbusters zero dark thirty Teen fast and furious docuseries Netflix Christmas movies A&E war boxing Toys Best Picture Photos binge The Academy Instagram Live rom-coms Fargo Warner Bros. children's TV book Action italian target documentaries football king arthur DC streaming service basketball Character Guide universal monsters sitcom scorecard Esquire historical drama golden globe awards Fox News Reality ViacomCBS 2019 Tumblr TCA RT21 Pirates toy story rt labs Funimation vs. scene in color suspense Bravo nbcuniversal Superheroe godzilla Dark Horse Comics CBS All Access independent Animation rt archives heist movie Polls and Games GIFs monster movies talk show Marvel Studios obituary Syfy Disney Apple TV+ discovery prank 2020 australia NYCC Marathons TV One YouTube chucky Hollywood Foreign Press Association Logo child's play Grammys VH1 unscripted lord of the rings Awards marvel cinematic universe Oscar award winner APB royal family TCM screenings ESPN Binge Guide Rom-Com toronto Best Director game of thrones streamig IFC Films Crunchyroll archives Cosplay laika Best Actor kaiju Interview jamie lee curtis Opinion Neflix WGN Schedule doctor who Comic-Con@Home 2021 Holiday romance pirates of the caribbean Horror TCA Winter 2020 mockumentary NBA 99% streaming halloween TCA 2017 Disney streaming service indiana jones romantic comedy free movies reviews Sneak Peek marvel comics robots batman stand-up comedy classics anime critic resources Elton John USA Network adventure Summer slashers San Diego Comic-Con biopic Netflix television aliens Television Academy japan Sundance Now Amazon Prime CBS golden globes films nfl Best and Worst Kids & Family Pop TV 2021 aapi james bond harry potter 94th Oscars cooking HBO Go zombie Britbox indie Sci-Fi Paramount Network Captain marvel HBO Max Year in Review Mary Poppins Returns BBC legend E3 Musical emmy awards President what to watch Infographic Star Trek a nightmare on elm street high school series cars olympics stop motion deadpool Anna Paquin boxoffice YouTube Premium Masterpiece Martial Arts Food Network Spring TV TIFF thriller slasher Travel Channel FOX screen actors guild spider-verse Hallmark hispanic 90s ghosts jurassic park AMC Plus Trivia Mary poppins crime drama spanish Hallmark Christmas movies superman Turner Watching Series ratings Box Office Comics on TV crime supernatural composers video on demand A24 The Walt Disney Company Brie Larson Creative Arts Emmys PlayStation Musicals Mary Tyler Moore razzies Country The CW leaderboard Calendar cancelled TV shows remakes BBC One travel posters quibi TCA Awards kids Film Festival king kong Superheroes BAFTA DGA Hulu First Look directors Best Actress foreign Black Mirror Election Pride Month scary sopranos ABC Family SXSW all-time Countdown Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt spy thriller Set visit Tokyo Olympics genre BET WarnerMedia OWN worst movies technology diversity IFC Rock YouTube Red DirecTV Podcast Adult Swim PaleyFest police drama transformers MGM politics docudrama Shondaland blockbuster National Geographic Trailer FX on Hulu Pixar Premiere Dates revenge live action anthology know your critic 1990s elevated horror Winners dc ABC Signature debate halloween tv disaster Christmas Amazon Studios news Chernobyl USA E! richard e. Grant MTV TV Land Universal Pictures Biopics The Arrangement mob trophy saw VOD satire CNN Alien Prime Video comic Arrowverse Paramount Plus animated The Purge based on movie political drama Song of Ice and Fire Family 71st Emmy Awards Apple TV Plus finale Music