Five Favorite Films

Five Favorite Films with Michael Phillips

The new co-host of At the Movies also talks about audiences and a special HBO cameo.

by | September 22, 2009 | Comments

John Malkovich

Chicagoans Gene Siskel and Roger Ebert changed the face of movie criticism with At the Movies; now, another critic from the Windy City, Chicago Tribune film critic Michael Phillips, is ready to take up the mantle on the venerable show. Phillips was a theater writer at the LA Times, the San Diego Union-Tribune, the St. Paul Pioneer Press and the Dallas Times Herald before taking over as the movie beat at the Tribune. In 2006 and 2007 he was a frequent guest on At the Movies, filling in for Roger Ebert alongside Richard Roeper. Now he’s a full-time occupant of the critics’ chair, alongside New York Times pundit A.O. Scott (find out what Scott’s Five Favorite Films are here.)

Phillips spoke with RT about his favorite films (he’s a sucker for Orson Welles and musicals) as well as the joys of watching a movie with an audience and what it’s like to make a cameo on a popular HBO series.

The Passion of Joan of Arc (1928,
97% Tomatometer)



The Passion of Joan of Arc

It is the most vexing challenge because I just find that, depending… I’m not so psychotic that my mind changes constantly on that subject, but it really depends on where you are in your life. You sort of have a rolling list of a few dozen that you cherish for different reasons. All you try to do is avoid interviews like this so you don’t get pinned down. [laughs] No, I always have trouble pinning anything to a fixed list. Why is it hard? Is it easy for you? You start thinking about the directors you leave off the list and your heart starts breaking.

In chronological order, The Passion of Joan of Arc. The last time I saw that film, it struck as me as if it was an artifact from the period itself that it’s depicting. It was like a medium unto itself, and [Maria] Falconetti’s performance, it really cannot be compared to anything else. It’s beyond naturalism, it’s beyond melodrama, it’s beyond everything. It’s just coming straight out of her soul. But mainly, the last time I saw it I just had this weird time slip kind of experience where I felt like I was really seeing a mad visionary from the time who somehow invented the movie camera. [laughs] Putting on this intense pageant on this subject of intense religious devotion. I find that film a knockout. You can’t watch it lightly, but that’s all right.

His Girl Friday (1940,
97% Tomatometer)



His Girl Friday

I’m desperately trying to find a way not to include His Girl Friday because it’s kind of been touted a lot. But it’s my favorite romantic comedy couple on screen. I think Cary Grant and Rosalind Russell in that picture are roughly as great as Beatrice and Benedict in Shakespeare’s Much Ado About Nothing. That’s how great they are. It’s my favorite Cary Grant performance because it combines the leading man side of his persona with this crazy farceur. I just love hearing people talk as fast as most people think. And I love the fact that they condense this three-hour play into whatever the running time is — ninety, ninety-two minutes — and they basically didn’t cut anything; they just got it all in. I adore this film.

That first scene… You watch that first scene when she comes back to the office, and it’s 10 of the greatest minutes of romantic byplay ever, and it’s beautifully performed. I revere Hawks more highly than I do John Ford, and that’s saying something. For me, if you don’t have a Hawks film on that list, you’re lying.

Citizen Kane/The Magnificent Ambersons (1941,
100% Tomatometer)



Citizen Kane

I really was trying to avoid Citizen Kane, but I would say Kane and the first fourth, the first half of The Magnificent Ambersons, for, you know, reasons that are obvious. I mean, it’s all miserably compromised after the first half — actually after the first third, I think — but I think the first twenty, twenty-five minutes of Ambersons is in many ways richer than anything in Kane, and that really is saying something. It struck a tone in American moviemaking; it was just absolutely new to me as a kid when I first saw that. I had never seen that kind of lightly ironic, very bittersweet, but achingly nostalgic… It’s just great, it’s just great. It’s also got probably one of my single favorite shots in cinema, that silhouette combined with the two couples after the ball. It’s the most incredible moment, and you just can’t believe you’re seeing it, and it lasts only as long as it could humanly last, and then it’s over. It’s great.

Do you have any hope that they’ll actually find the missing full-length version of Ambersons?

No. You know, I keep hearing it’s turning up in Brazil, or I heard a story that some idiot destroyed a copy in the 1980s. You know, there’s a lot of urban myths going around, but nothing would make me happier. Well, not nothing, but with Wells, nothing would make me happier. But look at Wells! I mean, Touch of Evil, Chimes at Midnight

The Band Wagon (1953,
100% Tomatometer)



The Band Wagon

I gotta throw a musical in there, and I’d go with The Band Wagon. Singin’ in the Rain is more exuberant, but [Vincent] Minnelli is one of my favorite stylists in cinema. You know, I love {Fred] Astaire, and I’m crazy about that film. I’ve loved it since I was in high school. Often, these favorites come and go, and they change position on your list, and you make room for other things that maybe you didn’t appreciate as strongly when you were younger, but I’ve always been crazy about that movie.

Taxi Driver (1976,
98% Tomatometer)



Taxi Driver

So here’s where, for me, it comes down to either the second Godfather, Taxi Driver, which is [Martin] Scorsese’s best film, I think, or one of two or three Altmans, I guess. And of those three, I’d probably go with Taxi Driver. It’s pretty great, and it’s one of the most dangerous films ever to come out of this country, I think. And it’s got great performances, and it’s got such electric ambiguity in what it’s saying about this guy. For me, that film marks, probably, the end point of that great period of the 1970s. So many fine directors; Altman, Coppola, the freedom of expression. I almost didn’t have the resources to deal with Taxi Driver when I first saw it . I don’t go back to it all the time, because it’s such a handful, but I think that’s Scorsese’s best film.


Next, Phillips talks about how different it is to watch a film with an audience and what it was like guest-starring on Entourage.


RT: Now, about the show: what’s different this time?

MP: The show has always changed, depending on who’s on it, and I think what we’re finding as we get our footing in on this is I really do sense an appetite on behalf of Disney, on behalf of everybody we’ve heard from since the announcement for a show that really goes back to why people love talking about the movies in the first place. We’re being encouraged to, within the format, to really find ways to talk about all the new releases, but also connect it to film history and the classics we love, the classics that most people really don’t know about. We’re not wildly reworking the formula — to the degree it makes sense, we’re really going back and embracing the formula — but also just embracing the idea of the right kind of discussion, the right kind of argument. I think it has been nothing but reassuring to kind of hear from the folks at Disney ABC and our producers in Chicago that, “We’re not trying to make you into anybody you’re not.” And with the idea of, we have these online exclusives every week, which kind of gives people even a better sense of what’s really on our minds with the given subject on film. It’s been really lovely and heartening to hear from a wide range of people, “Yes, it’s good. Thank you. We were waiting for this kind of discussion and argument and passion to come back to the show.” All we have to do is try to find ways to make it more polished, but not more slick.


RT: After you guested with Richard Roeper, was TV a medium you wanted to continue in, or were you sort of like, “Oh, I’m back to my print reviews now?” Was there an idea of going back to television eventually?

MP: Oh, it was a lot of fun. Richard was an excellent sparring partner, and I think Tony (A.O. Scott) and I, separately, both learned a lot from working with him. And again, separately, Tony and I have learned a lot from the friendship and the collegial relationship we’ve enjoyed with Roger [Ebert]. I was really thrilled. You don’t hire guys like me and Tony for a show like this with the idea of trying to package them in such a way as to win over an audience that may not have any interest in that show in the first place. I don’t know, I just feel like the pressure’s on because we want to make it good, and we want to try to make it the best show we can, but in another way, we’re not being pressured to turn this thing into something it shouldn’t be.


RT: What’s the best thing you’ve seen so far this year?

MP: I really loved Sugar. You know, so far, the two American pictures that come to mind most immediately are a big hit, Up, and a little flop, Adventureland. I love them both. Yeah, so far, those are the two. I found Up just extraordinarily moving and it’s not perfect; I think that action climax is a little attenuated and that feels more like, not a shock to the audience necessarily, but… Well, actually it does feel like a little bit of a shock to the audience. But I also think Michael Giacchino is the best contemporary film composer we have, and that’s his best score. Because music means a lot to me, that’s reason enough for me to recommend that film.


RT: Do you always try to think of yourself as a member of the audience primarily and a critic second, or the other way around? How do you balance that?

MP: Good question. No, you are both, but really I’m just trying to work out my own responses clearly so that they make sense to me and they’re going to make sense to whoever’s listening to my opinion. What I like doing, too, over the course of a year — because, you see what, 300 films — I find it crucial to see a fair number of those films with an audience, and it doesn’t really matter what kind. I don’t really believe in the phrase “audience picture,” because I think any kind of film changes somewhat depending on the situation you’re seeing it in. Sometimes I go a week or two and I think, “Yeah, you know what? I need to see a movie with a crowd.” And it doesn’t have to be a comedy. For me it’s still a social endeavor.


RT: I have just one more question, and it’s been on my mind for a long time. When you did the fake review on Entourage, was that ad-libbed?

MP: You know, that was actually kind of a pleasant experience because Richard and I did it once as scripted by the Entourage folks, and they also allowed us to revise it and rewrite it our own way, and they ended up going with that version. And Doug Ellin, he was very gracious in some interview. He said, “Those guys really punched up that scene, and their version was much better.” And that was just a very gracious thing to say. And of course it was a real honor to be called a d— on the show.

And if you talk to Tony again, tell him he’s really not right about The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance. That shouldn’t be on anybody’s list.



Check out our interview with A.O. Scott. For more from Michael Phillips, read our Meet-a-Critic interview from 2007. And be sure to check out all the reviews from At the Movies on RT.

Tag Cloud

movies Horror Thanksgiving LGBTQ harry potter asian-american boxoffice Musical dragons Sneak Peek IFC ITV comics action-comedy Anna Paquin Disney+ Disney Plus 71st Emmy Awards batman adaptation The CW spider-man festival legend YouTube Red Ellie Kemper Marvel Studios spinoff discovery Mary Poppins Returns Apple TV+ children's TV screen actors guild Quiz Election Calendar Paramount Network talk show Lifetime Christmas movies History video X-Men Sundance Now LGBT Avengers Star Trek king arthur aapi all-time doctor who crime drama social media The Arrangement Netflix Christmas movies Comic Book Black History Month book breaking bad Tarantino NBA MSNBC video on demand casting Superheroes women politics WarnerMedia Comic-Con@Home 2021 Disney Plus new zealand Travel Channel christmas movies TIFF OWN football USA james bond stoner Crunchyroll science fiction TV One 20th Century Fox Sci-Fi Dark Horse Comics book adaptation singing competition basketball Amazon Prime crime thriller dramedy best Brie Larson PaleyFest Nominations biopic TCA Superheroe hidden camera high school Chernobyl Awards Tour parents worst movies CBS dogs renewed TV shows RT21 Acorn TV Starz FXX Disney USA Network Red Carpet Summer TV movies cults halloween tv Britbox olympics NBC dreamworks Pirates Oscars Amazon Studios adventure Best and Worst zero dark thirty Endgame remakes Sundance TV award winner 2019 Infographic Polls and Games robots Rock Neflix true crime Interview slasher Shondaland Toys NYCC Sundance Awards royal family Christmas Epix blockbuster DirecTV vampires OneApp Elton John SXSW animated kong 73rd Emmy Awards AMC Plus rt labs comedies BBC One VICE Rocky New York Comic Con HBO Go unscripted BET Tumblr Turner Classic Movies DC Comics blaxploitation south america Ovation Winners independent target San Diego Comic-Con APB The Walking Dead kaiju game show reboot Funimation saw spider-verse cats BET Awards space witnail prank scene in color joker twilight Amazon AMC documentaries E! cancelled TV shows italian Rom-Com king kong Holiday Adult Swim Teen comic french Spring TV Country Photos japan CW Seed mutant Cosplay razzies Extras cops Hallmark ESPN comiccon Trailer CNN trailers 007 composers marvel cinematic universe diversity Pet Sematary wonder woman aliens transformers TNT Biopics docuseries Tokyo Olympics FX police drama facebook 2015 toronto Crackle Video Games 4/20 Instagram Live Podcast political drama 72 Emmy Awards nature YA nbcuniversal Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt spanish gangster dexter Esquire Stephen King suspense E3 directors black Food Network natural history 90s 2018 TCA Winter 2020 BAFTA superhero YouTube Cartoon Network japanese psycho Pride Month teaser Song of Ice and Fire Western Universal Wes Anderson rt labs critics edition Holidays canceled BBC America cinemax Alien boxing TBS TCA Awards Vudu Television Critics Association Martial Arts Music dceu Sony Pictures venice toy story American Society of Cinematographers Academy Awards based on movie lord of the rings technology anthology Reality cooking serial killer Apple TV Plus sports spy thriller stand-up comedy Turner hollywood child's play richard e. Grant quibi universal monsters miniseries international festivals marvel comics Captain marvel CMT Hallmark Christmas movies Countdown sequels binge First Reviews Universal Pictures criterion Peacock ID Comedy Central 1990s die hard movie live action biography pirates of the caribbean debate cancelled halloween Character Guide Opinion ABC DC Universe worst crossover cartoon Reality Competition DC streaming service Pixar sopranos archives WGN cars tv talk indie Schedule hist Disney Channel 2017 Writers Guild of America Comics on TV rt archives psychological thriller Freeform The Purge The Walt Disney Company Women's History Month DGA versus A&E Shudder Mudbound Nickelodeon romance Binge Guide travel new york YouTube Premium comic book movie black comedy HBO Max Nat Geo VOD indiana jones Fall TV medical drama vs. TV Heroines fresh MTV new star wars movies Trivia dc Arrowverse Mary poppins Tubi Walt Disney Pictures Box Office monster movies Exclusive Video Television Academy genre First Look 45 ghosts Ghostbusters Premiere Dates Film Festival Family disaster Paramount IMDb TV chucky Mystery Syfy mcc sag awards 21st Century Fox romantic comedy screenings Emmys blockbusters laika Comedy Marvel Television Spike anime historical drama TV Land Hulu comic books Masterpiece golden globe awards spanish language war 2020 ABC Family Pop See It Skip It name the review IFC Films ABC Signature art house PlayStation canceled TV shows kids FOX Logo 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Film Marathons CBS All Access concert Trophy Talk critics 24 frames Watching Series Cannes Fantasy zombie Broadway Apple Netflix spain Rocketman Columbia Pictures 99% Hear Us Out elevated horror classics scary movies FX on Hulu TLC Fox Searchlight werewolf posters cancelled TV series Drama National Geographic foreign Winter TV fast and furious comic book movies green book Mindy Kaling heist movie Black Mirror Marvel game of thrones slashers Lifetime Warner Bros. rotten rotten movies we love Valentine's Day Action telelvision golden globes Discovery Channel Showtime El Rey Kids & Family rom-coms GoT 2016 TCM Super Bowl critic resources Creative Arts Emmys finale popular 93rd Oscars TruTV jurassic park Lucasfilm Mary Tyler Moore feel good satire stop motion cancelled television President crime television obituary Image Comics Spectrum Originals streaming movies superman justice league young adult Paramount Plus a nightmare on elm street what to watch Legendary TV renewals The Witch latino Pacific Islander Grammys series SDCC thriller adenture TCA 2017 free movies GIFs Star Wars PBS films australia theme song revenge reviews ViacomCBS Certified Fresh sequel Set visit hispanic heritage month Pop TV GLAAD franchise Lionsgate supernatural RT History Baby Yoda MCU period drama Year in Review VH1 A24 Bravo jamie lee curtis SundanceTV HBO know your critic scary ratings Fox News BBC nfl news Chilling Adventures of Sabrina mission: impossible zombies mockumentary emmy awards docudrama Classic Film Amazon Prime Video 2021 Tomatazos Animation documentary Musicals Emmy Nominations live event dark scorecard streaming The Academy deadpool godzilla sitcom mob Disney streaming service strong female leads hispanic