Everything We Know

Everything We Know About Martin Scorsese's The Irishman

We dig into the celebrated director's long-in-development passion project -- its premise, its stunning cast, its release, and why it took so long to make.

by | July 31, 2019 | Comments

Will The Irishman Bring Oscar Glory to Netflix?

Can a de-aged De Niro bring home an Oscar for ‘The Irishman’? We explore what brought Scorsese’s passion project to Netflix.

Posted by The Rotten Tomatoes Channel on Thursday, August 1, 2019

Martin Scorsese’s latest feature film, The Irishman, has been talked about for years, enduring financial, developmental, and technological bumps along the way, but with the release of the teaser trailer this morning, we finally get our first look at what it’ll look like, when it’ll come out (sort of), and who’s involved, but let’s be honest, this trailer had you at “hello.”

So, let’s break down what we know — and don’t know — about Martin Scorsese’s Netflix-produced film The Irishman. [Updated on 7/31/19.]

The Premise

Jimmy Hoffa

Jimmy Hoffa in 1961

Based on I Heard You Paint Houses, the biography of Frank “The Irishman” Sheeran by Charles Brandt, The Irishman tells the story of mafia hitman Sheeran and his relationship to, and possible murder of, Teamsters Union leader Jimmy Hoffa. The disappearance (but let’s just call it murder) of Jimmy Hoffa is one of the most notorious organized crime stories of the 20th century, and more than 40 years later, the case still remains unsolved.

Hoffa’s connections to organized crime began in the 1930s when he was a union activist in New York, and it was here that the young Hoffa first gained an audience with mafia dons Russell Bufalino and Angelo Bruno. After years of moving up in the Teamsters Union, all while making shady backdoor deals with the East Coast mafia, Hoffa became president of the Teamsters from 1957 until 1971 and turned it into one of the most powerful in the world.

But, on July 30, 1975, just four years after stepping down as Teamsters president, Hoffa vanished without a trace. The unsolved disappearance has led to countless theories of what happened, including ones that posit Hoffa was either buried underneath Giants Stadium in the Meadowlands, compacted in a car and sold as scrap metal and shipped to Japan, or buried under a suburban Detroit driveway. The one commonality is that they all agree the mafia had him taken out.

The teaser trailer released today seems to have higher ambitions than just exploring Hoffa’s rise, fall, and presumed death, however. With frequent allusions to John F. Kennedy and the role of “big business and the government,” it seems like The Irishman will tackle the connections between a tangled web of organized crime, crooked unions, and American politics in the 20th century.

The Cast and Crew

Universal courtesy Everett Collection

(Photo by Universal courtesy Everett Collection)

We first got a glimpse of the type of talent in this movie in the initial teaser (even though it was only their names), but now we finally get to see some of the greatest actors in film history and one of the most beloved and revered directors of all time doing their thing.

We all know the work Scorsese, De Niro, Keitel, and Pesci have done together, including Mean StreetsTaxi Driver, Raging Bull, Goodfellas, and Casino, but adding Pacino to that crew is the pistachios on the cannoli.

In the upcoming film, Pacino plays Union leader Hoffa and De Niro plays his friend and alleged killer Sheeran, while Keitel and Pesci play bosses of rival East Coast crime families.

But the talent doesn’t stop there, as The Irishman’s roster is both top heavy and deep. In addition to these heavy hitters, the film will also feature Oscar winner Anna Paquin, two-time Emmy winner Bobby Cannavale, two-time Emmy nominee Jesse Plemons, and Emmy-winner Ray Romano.

In case you weren’t keeping count, that cast features actors who have been nominated for a combined 19 Oscars, 35 Golden Globes, and 27 Emmys, and have collectively taken home five Oscars, five Golden Globes, and seven Emmys. And that’s just in front of the camera.

Between Scorsese, screenwriter Steven Zaillian, editor Thelma Shoonmaker, and cinematographer Rodrigo Prieto, the talent behind the camera has combined for 25 Academy Award noms and four wins.

So, with all that talent and excitement, how has it taken so long for this film to get made?

The Journey

Andrew Cooper/Paramount courtesy Everett Collection

(Photo by Andrew Cooper/Paramount courtesy Everett Collection)

This film has been a passion project for director Martin Scorsese for years, with news coming about the potential film as far back as 2008. (That same article refers to Scorsese’s adaptation of Shutter Island as an upcoming release, just to give a sense of how long ago 2008 was.)

Since then, the film has floundered in development hell, and Scorsese moved on to directing other long-gestating passion projects like Hugo, The Wolf of Wall Street, and 2016’s Silence. But Scorsese kept coming back to the story of the most famous mob hit in history, and finally, in 2017, Paramount and Fábrica de Cine came together to co-finance the film and aim for a 2019 release.

So how did it end up on Netflix, you ask?

The Budget

Mean Streets

Yes, like all things, it comes down to cold, hard cash.

Initially targeted for a $100 million budget, the movie’s cost soon ballooned to nearly $200,000,000 after the production opted to use a CGI de-aging technique to make De Niro, Pacino, and co. appear younger while playing the younger versions of their characters.

Because of this price tag (and perhaps still feeling the burn left by Silence, which cost upwards of $50 million and took in less than $25 million at the box office), Fábrica de Cine and Paramount decided to back out of the project less than a year after agreeing to fund it.

Fábrica de Cine producer Gaston Pavlovich explained this difficult decision, saying “We quickly realized that Marty and De Niro really thought that the aging process was going to be a very important aspect of this film. The traditional model was not going to work with this new vision of the project… [we could not] risk that amount [of money] when all our data was telling us that it was not going to come back.”

Thankfully, Netflix stepped in, and the importance is not lost on Scorsese, who recently said, “People such as Netflix are taking risks. The Irishman is a risky film. No one else wanted to fund the pic for five to seven years. And of course we’re all getting older. Netflix took the risk.”


(Photo by Netflix)

Even so, the CGI de-aging comes with both budgetary and cinematic concerns. Previously used on Brad Pitt in Benjamin Button, Jeff Bridges in Tron: Legacy, and Robert Downey Jr. in Captain America: Civil War, the de-aging technology has advanced in recent years to appear more natural, but still remains costly. So costly, in fact, that until Samuel L. Jackson (and, perhaps less noticeably, Clark Gregg) was made to look 25 years younger in the recent Captain Marvel, it had only been used sparingly.

Editor Thelma Schoonmaker called it a “risk,” saying, “We’re youthifying the actors in the first half of the movie. And then the second half of the movie they play their own age. So that’s a big risk. We’re having that done by Industrial Light and Magic Island, ILM. That’s a big risk.”

While it might be cool to see young Pacino, young De Niro, young Pesci, and young Keitel in the same scene, it could also venture too close to the uncanny valley and take the viewers out of the film.

Schoonmaker has also expressed some trepidation over how the public is going to view seeing a 30-year-old Pacino, De Niro, et al. in a 2019 movie: “I haven’t gotten a whole scene where they’re young, and what I’m going to have to see, and what Marty’s going to have to see, is ‘How is it affecting the rest of the movie, when you see them young?’” In that same interview, the eminent editor said that, of the few people they’ve screened the movie for, “nobody minds. Nobody minds watching them play young, because they’re gripped.”

While we don’t see too much of the de-aged film legends in the teaser trailer, what we do see looks pretty good. On first impressions, the one shot of a young De Niro talking on the phone might be a little distracting, but this is just the first glimpse, so that’s a given. With what is sure to be stellar directing from Scorsese and brilliant acting from some silver screen legends, audiences likely won’t even notice that there’s a 40-something Robert De Niro in a 2019 movie.

The Release

Paramount Pictures

(Photo by Paramount Pictures)

As one of Netflix’s main prestige productions for 2019, it was always expected that The Irishman would be released at the heart of awards season, and now we have confirmation.

It was recently announced that The Irishman will celebrate its world premiere as the Opening Night film for the 2019 New York Film Festival on September 27. Most likely, the film will be available for the general public a few weeks later in theaters and on your couch.

Previously, Scorsese has expressed his disdain for movie-watching on small screens, saying that when he was growing up, films “had to be shown in certain ways — people went to a movie, it wasn’t something you could choose or pick up, or walk out of the room. You actually made a commitment. It was a different experience.” He continued, “the ideal would be to see cinema in its proper context… It’s a problem of pure concentration.”

Robert de Niro agrees, saying at a recent film festival, “Movies have to be shown on a big screen.” It appears Netflix also shares this sentiment, as the teaser trailer announces that the film will be shown in “select theaters.”

Unfortunately, we still don’t really know when exactly The Irishman will be released. But we now know that it will have a splashy premiere at a prestigious film festival at the end of September, and will be shown in theaters and on the streaming service sometime this Fall.

The Irishman  is currently set to release in select theaters an on Netflix during the Fall of 2019.

Tag Cloud

First Look Discovery Channel HBO Max Cartoon Network blaxploitation richard e. Grant HBO Go TV Land Action Tumblr Netflix Christmas movies Winter TV The Walking Dead cancelled television boxoffice New York Comic Con Masterpiece Valentine's Day Spectrum Originals The CW Baby Yoda cartoon FX on Hulu mockumentary facebook diversity theme song 007 E! Summer CNN SXSW Rocky YouTube Red VH1 rotten movies we love dramedy cooking Western what to watch 4/20 crime drama Mary Tyler Moore Ghostbusters GLAAD slashers BET aliens Musicals Comic Book 2018 social media archives toy story 24 frames Chilling Adventures of Sabrina spanish language christmas movies blockbuster anthology asian-american Shudder Shondaland NBC Rocketman comic Comics on TV USA Network romantic comedy Star Trek Photos police drama romance Disney+ Disney Plus 71st Emmy Awards animated E3 Best and Worst technology toronto Marvel doctor who First Reviews reviews Academy Awards game of thrones Awards Tour halloween 2020 Columbia Pictures screen actors guild Film Festival Lifetime Sci-Fi green book Walt Disney Pictures 21st Century Fox Fantasy Holidays Apple TV+ Pride Month X-Men best Acorn TV franchise Lucasfilm golden globes Tarantino Oscars Infographic Hear Us Out American Society of Cinematographers Animation critics Travel Channel Horror WarnerMedia Chernobyl spinoff crime BBC America YouTube Premium child's play Certified Fresh APB joker zombies Sundance Sony Pictures Bravo true crime Holiday Video Games stoner El Rey disaster comiccon TCA Awards comedies zero dark thirty 2016 dceu Grammys NYCC canceled TV shows Ellie Kemper CW Seed zombie documentaries adventure vampires Lionsgate biography Pirates universal monsters Anna Paquin hist elevated horror cars documentary Hulu BBC DirecTV Winners based on movie PBS CBS All Access breaking bad science fiction ITV Pet Sematary FOX transformers historical drama Stephen King TCM YouTube Captain marvel canceled Pixar Emmy Nominations movies robots Nominations RT History Ovation Netflix National Geographic versus sports cancelled TV series TCA 2017 Emmys criterion Nickelodeon casting DC streaming service Binge Guide political drama Black Mirror IFC Disney streaming service Disney Plus Star Wars Writers Guild of America psychological thriller teaser crime thriller Trophy Talk Cannes Classic Film latino 45 Film Trailer cops cults reboot Reality Competition docudrama scorecard Turner streaming children's TV laika Election dragons TLC History composers emmy awards tv talk Polls and Games Christmas all-time A&E jamie lee curtis Showtime Turner Classic Movies chucky Countdown Brie Larson Musical free movies miniseries dogs Apple justice league Rock Amazon Studios Trivia screenings Arrowverse Tubi mission: impossible Extras Comedy game show Starz TV Quiz Fox Searchlight LGBT PaleyFest television satire witnail 2019 hollywood The Academy parents medical drama Set visit ESPN Mudbound sequel YA Nat Geo Crunchyroll cancelled crossover VICE unscripted cinemax Kids & Family cats TIFF Pop TV Comedy Central Vudu GIFs Awards book Heroines natural history dc video Television Academy Elton John BET Awards singing competition worst MCU Adult Swim dark psycho AMC Drama Mary Poppins Returns ghosts The Witch Spike venice Marvel Television TruTV finale Teen The Arrangement comics OWN halloween tv Interview Reality Hallmark Rom-Com Hallmark Christmas movies TV renewals stop motion harry potter Martial Arts spider-man discovery worst movies Amazon Prime Video Television Critics Association SDCC TCA Winter 2020 DC Universe A24 Opinion indie werewolf FXX scary movies movie Music Superheroes Lifetime Christmas movies 2015 Toys Tomatazos binge MSNBC concert obituary Spring TV Women's History Month spy thriller spanish MTV TCA GoT Epix Funimation revenge Amazon die hard Year in Review french period drama sitcom Creative Arts Emmys USA Britbox See It Skip It FX nfl award winner LGBTQ festivals Fox News Song of Ice and Fire superhero Thanksgiving WGN Crackle BBC One war supernatural video on demand Disney Disney Channel Food Network Amazon Prime Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Black History Month politics Sundance Now football nbcuniversal Red Carpet 72 Emmy Awards 2017 CBS Fall TV Freeform directors spain IFC Films mutant BAFTA Premiere Dates nature Syfy Paramount Network PlayStation Esquire Mindy Kaling Mystery Superheroe Marvel Studios ratings independent Mary poppins Super Bowl Peacock films Logo quibi remakes ABC Family Box Office news a nightmare on elm street Warner Bros. talk show Family batman 20th Century Fox hispanic festival Country The Purge VOD Watching Series travel Universal italian Cosplay foreign kids sag awards Apple TV Plus OneApp series twilight Avengers Character Guide Pop Calendar adaptation CMT Sneak Peek Marathons name the review ABC DC Comics Sundance TV DGA RT21 space cancelled TV shows stand-up comedy SundanceTV classics thriller TNT south america serial killer President Podcast TBS Schedule anime San Diego Comic-Con Paramount Dark Horse Comics Biopics HBO renewed TV shows sequels fast and furious strong female leads indiana jones Endgame rotten