Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Shrek's Final Chapter Is So-So

Plus, MacGruber's early Tomatometer is impressive!

by | May 21, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a fairy tale finale (Shrek Forever After, starring the voices of Mike Myers and Cameron Diaz) and a clueless commando (MacGruber, starring Will Forte and Kristen Wiig). What do the critics have to say?


Shrek Forever After

Everyone’s favorite ogre returns this week in the fourth (and reportedly final) installment of the Shrek franchise, but is there enough fairy tale magic left after Shrek the Third? Unfortunately, the critics don’t all seem to think so. Presented in 3D (a franchise first), Shrek Forever After finds its titular hero longing for the good old days, when he was still a regular ogre. When the conniving Rumpelstiltskin tricks Shrek into giving up a day from his past in exchange for a day as a regular ogre, Shrek unwittingly signs away the day of his birth, effectively rewriting the history of Far Far Away… as if he never existed. Though critics say Forever After has its share of moments, and it’s a step up from the third installment, most also felt that the film felt entirely too familiar and formulaic.



While Saturday Night Live has produced some of America’s best comedic talents over the past few decades, its track record on film is hardly as impressive. Most films based on SNL sketches have done poorly, with a few rare exceptions like The Blues Brothers and the Wayne’s World films. This week, Will Forte’s bumbling action hero, MacGruber, finds himself thrust into an international espionage comedy on the big screen, and it’s up to him to save the world from the dastardly Dieter Von Cunth (Val Kilmer) and his nuclear warhead. So far, only a handful of critics have chimed in, but most of them have been pleasantly surprised by what they felt was a relatively effective and enjoyable sendup of 80s action movies. Continue to check back as more reviews roll in. (Also, check this week’s Total Recall to see a ranked list of films based on SNL sketches.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

zombies Interview Teen RT21 transformers psychological thriller Tarantino comic Vudu Action Mary poppins APB cults hist San Diego Comic-Con Polls and Games National Geographic Nickelodeon See It Skip It talk show binge Masterpiece Watching Series Food Network witnail TruTV space anthology Winter TV SDCC Character Guide ratings VH1 Reality Competition Stephen King Super Bowl SXSW discovery 2015 BBC America 2017 Ghostbusters Music teaser Superheroe strong female leads streaming NBC Calendar Mary Tyler Moore Awards USA Network Certified Fresh Sony Pictures Paramount Comedy Set visit zero dark thirty mutant richard e. Grant HBO Lucasfilm Marvel Podcast Election disaster science fiction adventure Drama natural history Photos LGBTQ 45 medical drama FX TNT historical drama serial killer Amazon Lifetime television Quiz crime drama doctor who Bravo 2019 Grammys nature Schedule History Musical IFC Films Countdown dramedy Warner Bros. Brie Larson E! award winner 24 frames Comic Book DC Comics TCM Opinion DGA Cannes Trivia Acorn TV Netflix diversity robots thriller Cartoon Network political drama Extras ITV Tumblr Tomatazos Walt Disney Pictures politics TCA OWN Elton John dceu Toys Spike Trophy Talk Sundance Mudbound President Oscars Creative Arts Emmys American Society of Cinematographers SundanceTV TLC technology social media CMT Sneak Peek Winners boxoffice El Rey Ovation Shudder BBC Disney Channel composers Logo The CW finale cooking Spring TV Box Office Ellie Kemper cops Song of Ice and Fire Awards Tour spider-man ABC Family MTV The Arrangement biography CBS Chilling Adventures of Sabrina crime golden globes Britbox war singing competition Thanksgiving Pirates Summer Dark Horse Comics Fox News green book Superheroes sitcom Trailer zombie DC streaming service Crackle RT History Holidays Universal Christmas Animation 2016 Syfy facebook FXX IFC A&E VICE elevated horror Pixar CBS All Access spy thriller vampires Pop Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Rom-Com MCU Disney TCA 2017 YouTube Premium Lionsgate TIFF sequel YouTube Red Reality Western USA Best and Worst anime aliens crossover comiccon Women's History Month Country Video Games Emmys police drama Mystery Apple what to watch Pet Sematary crime thriller Mindy Kaling psycho cats Fall TV CNN BET Writers Guild of America 007 New York Comic Con based on movie WGN sports DirecTV TBS Film Festival Freeform dc Captain marvel FOX ESPN PBS YA justice league Spectrum Originals X-Men Year in Review TV Land Red Carpet Horror theme song 20th Century Fox Star Trek Amazon Prime Musicals Star Wars harry potter Epix Cosplay unscripted Sundance Now Black Mirror Rocky PaleyFest Comedy Central docudrama AMC DC Universe Biopics 21st Century Fox Valentine's Day GIFs First Look casting Paramount Network Anna Paquin Comics on TV Martial Arts jamie lee curtis festivals travel adaptation TV period drama E3 The Witch 2018 Infographic Esquire romance Marathons ABC NYCC Sci-Fi Heroines Starz GoT dragons Columbia Pictures Kids & Family Nominations mockumentary Nat Geo Shondaland cinemax Hulu Fantasy MSNBC blaxploitation Premiere Dates Adult Swim supernatural true crime Rock CW Seed Showtime miniseries Rocketman Mary Poppins Returns GLAAD