Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Shrek's Final Chapter Is So-So

Plus, MacGruber's early Tomatometer is impressive!

by | May 21, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a fairy tale finale (Shrek Forever After, starring the voices of Mike Myers and Cameron Diaz) and a clueless commando (MacGruber, starring Will Forte and Kristen Wiig). What do the critics have to say?


Shrek Forever After

Everyone’s favorite ogre returns this week in the fourth (and reportedly final) installment of the Shrek franchise, but is there enough fairy tale magic left after Shrek the Third? Unfortunately, the critics don’t all seem to think so. Presented in 3D (a franchise first), Shrek Forever After finds its titular hero longing for the good old days, when he was still a regular ogre. When the conniving Rumpelstiltskin tricks Shrek into giving up a day from his past in exchange for a day as a regular ogre, Shrek unwittingly signs away the day of his birth, effectively rewriting the history of Far Far Away… as if he never existed. Though critics say Forever After has its share of moments, and it’s a step up from the third installment, most also felt that the film felt entirely too familiar and formulaic.



While Saturday Night Live has produced some of America’s best comedic talents over the past few decades, its track record on film is hardly as impressive. Most films based on SNL sketches have done poorly, with a few rare exceptions like The Blues Brothers and the Wayne’s World films. This week, Will Forte’s bumbling action hero, MacGruber, finds himself thrust into an international espionage comedy on the big screen, and it’s up to him to save the world from the dastardly Dieter Von Cunth (Val Kilmer) and his nuclear warhead. So far, only a handful of critics have chimed in, but most of them have been pleasantly surprised by what they felt was a relatively effective and enjoyable sendup of 80s action movies. Continue to check back as more reviews roll in. (Also, check this week’s Total Recall to see a ranked list of films based on SNL sketches.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

fresh Reality cults hispanic movies Marvel San Diego Comic-Con TBS TCM GLAAD Family Spike Elton John CNN Sneak Peek 45 Bravo A&E Rom-Com hidden camera Stephen King boxoffice legend Red Carpet die hard robots harry potter comic book movie telelvision adenture Heroines DGA Disney Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Character Guide Avengers renewed TV shows Thanksgiving Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt comic books TV Land Horror french Creative Arts Emmys independent screenings Amazon Prime Pirates streaming book adaptation First Reviews thriller Tarantino TIFF Academy Awards Cosplay American Society of Cinematographers TV australia reboot Fall TV 93rd Oscars The Walking Dead Rock Schedule cops Amazon Prime Video CMT emmy awards PBS historical drama TCA Winter 2020 ghosts Country zombies Legendary SDCC directors asian-american franchise VICE comiccon Marvel Studios Comic-Con@Home 2021 festivals parents Winners HBO Max Cartoon Network italian 71st Emmy Awards Tokyo Olympics lord of the rings critic resources Disney Channel Crackle Exclusive Video Rocky police drama criterion critics Certified Fresh Paramount Network action-comedy know your critic Warner Bros. Lifetime Christmas movies Box Office BAFTA Ghostbusters serial killer ViacomCBS olympics Hallmark social media Vudu witnail adventure spanish language toronto japanese LGBT Musical Shudder disaster RT History game show cancelled joker romance nature Turner Classic Movies justice league child's play mcc MCU documentaries universal monsters Hallmark Christmas movies transformers Food Network jurassic park Spring TV Trailer reviews dceu archives best 20th Century Fox TLC The Purge rt labs critics edition comics 2019 comic Sundance docuseries marvel cinematic universe binge Adult Swim Holiday mission: impossible DC Comics Pop TV CBS diversity 24 frames Disney+ Disney Plus women Walt Disney Pictures Syfy See It Skip It Winter TV Shondaland President hist Polls and Games latino kids Ellie Kemper Starz USA Network stoner Comedy razzies godzilla Showtime monster movies First Look feel good Comedy Central deadpool south america dramedy halloween twilight Mudbound unscripted Animation Hulu Superheroe concert science fiction 2018 basketball Nickelodeon international Election Summer richard e. Grant cancelled television NYCC aliens nfl Song of Ice and Fire Music BET scorecard New York Comic Con Sci-Fi Rocketman cats posters Television Academy canceled TV shows natural history YA crossover spinoff YouTube Red Black Mirror Brie Larson Mindy Kaling boxing Apple TV+ blaxploitation Interview 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards PlayStation YouTube Peacock Quiz Trivia football Turner werewolf Star Trek Acorn TV TNT Biopics Lionsgate indiana jones remakes 4/20 popular game of thrones blockbuster TV movies series Amazon supernatural Teen 2015 anime festival Opinion trailers Television Critics Association Spectrum Originals debate APB Sundance TV Oscars 21st Century Fox Ovation versus prank fast and furious Netflix Christmas movies all-time young adult aapi cinemax 2016 nbcuniversal zombie doctor who new york tv talk Dark Horse Comics Holidays YouTube Premium slashers TruTV rt labs Fantasy travel cancelled TV shows IFC Films The Academy Pride Month facebook news Valentine's Day ABC HBO MSNBC elevated horror crime drama National Geographic new zealand 007 cartoon Drama video vampires The CW spain History james bond wonder woman screen actors guild spanish Extras satire toy story period drama laika 2021 CBS All Access canceled dragons Tumblr stop motion indie Mystery Image Comics crime thriller medical drama SXSW award winner Endgame Hear Us Out golden globes Esquire Masterpiece Tubi Mary poppins Columbia Pictures a nightmare on elm street Podcast dark mockumentary movie Lifetime slasher Writers Guild of America Freeform batman japan Nat Geo VOD Arrowverse television LGBTQ 73rd Emmy Awards DC streaming service 90s TCA 2017 Set visit stand-up comedy VH1 Black History Month Funimation Crunchyroll Toys CW Seed strong female leads king arthur Film ABC Signature Nominations foreign jamie lee curtis dogs AMC Premiere Dates WarnerMedia sag awards Pacific Islander Amazon Studios Mary Poppins Returns USA PaleyFest El Rey Fox Searchlight Marathons NBA Epix Calendar black new star wars movies quibi biopic heist movie Disney streaming service WGN BET Awards cooking Year in Review spider-man revenge kong Cannes OneApp Film Festival christmas movies singing competition E! streaming movies talk show worst dexter 72 Emmy Awards anthology FOX romantic comedy 99% adaptation blockbusters sequels king kong 1990s IFC space Classic Film BBC One rom-coms Musicals Wes Anderson kaiju theme song Watching Series Paramount Plus Disney Plus Sony Pictures Comic Book politics rotten Apple obituary Pet Sematary children's TV TCA animated FX on Hulu Women's History Month Superheroes A24 Action rt archives name the review breaking bad suspense sitcom ESPN 2017 finale halloween tv Martial Arts Fox News biography The Arrangement Marvel Television cars Broadway Anna Paquin based on movie comic book movies sequel book ABC Family teaser golden globe awards saw OWN Alien documentary scary movies superman discovery Best and Worst BBC zero dark thirty green book DirecTV marvel comics docudrama Countdown Discovery Channel target Pop Chernobyl casting Kids & Family X-Men Photos spy thriller psycho Comics on TV Britbox sports Baby Yoda live action free movies Emmy Nominations political drama GIFs FX video on demand war Apple TV Plus Logo Netflix mutant crime dc SundanceTV hollywood Awards comedies FXX TCA Awards rotten movies we love Paramount DC Universe hispanic heritage month Western cancelled TV series Pixar Reality Competition gangster The Witch miniseries Star Wars chucky Universal GoT psychological thriller royal family Infographic The Walt Disney Company 2020 true crime technology BBC America ID superhero high school what to watch MTV Tomatazos TV renewals Travel Channel NBC composers scene in color classics HBO Go TV One Captain marvel ratings worst movies Super Bowl Awards Tour pirates of the caribbean Sundance Now Grammys E3 Emmys films Christmas Lucasfilm RT21 venice Mary Tyler Moore Binge Guide ITV Trophy Talk Video Games