Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Minions Is Funny But Flimsy

Plus, Self/less and The Gallows misfire, and Spoils Before Dying is a funny noir parody.

by | July 9, 2015 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got an army of little flunkies (Minions, featuring voice performances by Sandra Bullock and Jon Hamm), a man with a new identity (Self/less, starring Ryan Reynolds and Ben Kingsley), and cursed teen thespians (The Gallows, starring Cassidy Gifford and Reese Mishler). What do the critics have to say?



The two Despicable Me films were ostensibly about evil mastermind Gru, but it was those ovular yellow troublemakers the Minions who were the franchise’s breakout stars. Now they’ve got their own movie — aptly titled Minions — and critics say it’s colorful and funny, though its wacky slapstick gags only partially compensate for the lack of a strong narrative. The movie tells the millennia-spanning story of the Minions and their supervillain servitude; special attention is paid to Minions Stuart, Kevin, and Bob, who team up with the nefarious Scarlett and Herb Overkill (voiced by Sandra Bullock and Jon Hamm) for a daring jewel heist. The pundits say Minions is cute and visually inventive, though the titular heroes may be put to better use as supporting players. (Check out our video interviews with the cast, and flip through our gallery of the best and worst TV and movie henchmen.)



Director Tarsem Singh is undoubtedly a strong visual stylist, and his latest, Self/less, has an undeniably intriguing premise. So it’s unfortunate, critics say, when the film shifts abruptly from cerebral sci-fi to generic shoot-’em-up. Loosely based on John Frankenheimer’s eerie 1966 classic Seconds, the film follows ailing real estate billionaire Damian Hale (Ben Kingsley) as he undergoes a risky medical procedure to inhabit a new, younger body. Soon, however, this rejuvenated Damian (now played by Ryan Reynolds) learns there may have been more to the procedure than he was led to believe. The pundits say the performances are fine, but Self/less never achieves the intellectual ambitions to which it aspires. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Kingsley’s best-reviewed movies, and find out our Singh’s Five Favorite Films.)

The Gallows


The best found footage horror films (The Blair Witch Project, Paranormal Activity) succeed in creating an air of immediacy. Unfortunately, critics say the big problem with The Gallows is that its handheld camera gimmick does little to intensify its bump-in-the-night jolts. Twenty years after the onstage death of the lead actor in a high school play, students from the school decide to revive the production to pay tribute to the dead; spookiness ensues. The pundits say The Gallows has a couple decent scares, but not enough to sell this relatively generic frightfest.

What’s On TV:

Maybe Tomorrow” (77 percent) serves as a dark, stylish diversion from earlier episodes of True Detective, even if it offers a somewhat less-than-satisfying conclusion to a previous cliffhanger.

The Spoils Before Dying (82 percent) serves up a jazz noir spoof that could be considered better than its predecessor — for those that appreciate its specific brand of comedy.

Extant (70 percent) amps up the action in Season Two, adding much-needed stamina to shore up Halle Berry’s compelling performance.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Stations of the Cross, a drama about a German teenager struggling with her faith and the demands of her strict family, is at 95 percent.
  • Tangerine, a dramedy about a wild day in the lives of two transgendered sex workers, is at 92 percent.
  • Do I Sound Gay?, a documentary that explores the nature of the stereotypical “gay voice,” is at 92 percent.
  • The Suicide Theory, a thriller about a despondent man who pays a hitman to kill him, is at 86 percent.
  • 10,000 Km, a drama about a couple trying to hold their relationship together despite the vast distance that separates them, is at 79 percent.
  • What We Did On Our Holiday, starring Rosamund Pike and David Tennant in a comedy about a family that vacations in Scotland amidst marital strife, is at 74 percent.
  • Boulevard, starring Robin Williams and Kathy Baker in a drama about a married man coming to terms with his homosexuality, is at 48 percent.
  • Strangerland, starring Nicole Kidman and Joseph Fiennes in a period drama about a couple searching desperately for their missing children in the aftermath of a huge dust storm, is at 35 percent.

Tag Cloud

Video Games sag awards latino documentary indie USA Network theme song discovery medical drama Ellie Kemper children's TV Women's History Month WGN joker natural history casting Star Wars robots cancelled television breaking bad game of thrones boxing scary movies Mudbound ratings Pop VOD Hallmark Christmas movies Holidays Lionsgate TCA Awards Freeform Rocketman WarnerMedia singing competition New York Comic Con black jamie lee curtis hist chucky reviews harry potter See It Skip It james bond The Witch Epix YouTube Red Peacock DC Comics composers E! Certified Fresh OneApp toy story Acorn TV nature green book Film cancelled TV shows Set visit TBS DC streaming service Sneak Peek LGBTQ golden globes Amazon Studios SDCC archives name the review sitcom versus what to watch Lifetime Christmas movies Logo Vudu Pop TV Pirates Apple TV Plus YouTube Captain marvel ghosts crossover critics Family doctor who Song of Ice and Fire rotten Nominations football movies hollywood Grammys Kids & Family Syfy anthology San Diego Comic-Con Tumblr spain Comics on TV asian-american Travel Channel serial killer Endgame Comic Book AMC Extras Martial Arts Opinion Warner Bros. finale Film Festival 72 Emmy Awards series Marvel Chernobyl comiccon El Rey Sundance Now Stephen King worst DC Universe comic anime television MCU space laika spy thriller CMT video Winners Infographic Shondaland Disney FOX Year in Review worst movies cats blockbuster Fox News 21st Century Fox Musicals directors Rom-Com romance FX Superheroe screen actors guild Tomatazos Hear Us Out parents foreign Premiere Dates APB psycho Nat Geo Marvel Studios politics diversity ABC TV renewals indiana jones science fiction Cartoon Network HBO Go Esquire sequel technology MTV Heroines CNN war IFC Films Fall TV BET universal monsters Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Amazon YA deadpool American Society of Cinematographers batman Funimation Food Network RT21 Musical TCM Apple FX on Hulu comic books LGBT Comedy Creative Arts Emmys binge psychological thriller A&E mission: impossible dogs History The Walking Dead Schedule Television Critics Association BBC America 2017 Bravo Character Guide Crackle dceu DirecTV ID National Geographic spanish Election halloween SXSW Sundance TV Elton John festivals Masterpiece Country rt archives cooking Crunchyroll USA TLC Spectrum Originals Amazon Prime disaster TCA Winter 2020 rotten movies we love Binge Guide Best and Worst Dark Horse Comics screenings sequels italian TIFF video on demand remakes Rock classics nbcuniversal CBS All Access Mary poppins Arrowverse renewed TV shows Hallmark independent blaxploitation Watching Series BAFTA FXX talk show Awards A24 toronto 007 book Drama police drama werewolf australia zombies dramedy PBS docudrama stoner Alien Fox Searchlight TCA Lifetime Valentine's Day documentaries Spring TV Star Trek ESPN Pride Month concert fast and furious Turner TruTV BET Awards richard e. Grant cancelled unscripted fresh GLAAD First Look japanese Podcast Mary Poppins Returns quibi GoT The Academy Photos Super Bowl halloween tv mutant best aliens Lucasfilm transformers Spike Pixar biography 2018 TCA 2017 Cosplay franchise period drama 2019 mockumentary NBC social media Tubi The CW scorecard Showtime Discovery Channel Disney Channel spinoff 2016 stop motion dragons Anna Paquin Mary Tyler Moore streaming HBO kids dc Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt based on movie comedies thriller YouTube Premium animated Quiz true crime Action Starz twilight a nightmare on elm street cinemax child's play Tarantino elevated horror Mystery The Arrangement Summer Thanksgiving 4/20 Christmas CW Seed Amazon Prime Video Paramount Network Netflix Ghostbusters NYCC The Purge Disney Plus Trophy Talk adaptation Black History Month Universal Music witnail Awards Tour political drama strong female leads Walt Disney Pictures cops Polls and Games canceled Baby Yoda crime CBS Red Carpet french Trailer GIFs DGA festival dark TNT zombie travel cancelled TV series Rocky Reality Calendar HBO Max Horror Classic Film tv talk adventure comics Teen Mindy Kaling PlayStation Interview south america Oscars obituary Marathons 20th Century Fox sports justice league Paramount facebook VH1 Adult Swim Box Office cults Hulu movie Disney+ Disney Plus Nickelodeon romantic comedy Sony Pictures superhero Emmys all-time MSNBC satire Marvel Television BBC crime thriller Academy Awards cartoon Brie Larson Toys miniseries news spider-man venice slashers vampires cars reboot 2020 BBC One Apple TV+ E3 Sundance teaser 45 Holiday OWN X-Men stand-up comedy RT History IFC Reality Competition Disney streaming service zero dark thirty 2015 nfl Ovation Black Mirror 24 frames First Reviews Pet Sematary Trivia President 99% Comedy Central 71st Emmy Awards Emmy Nominations Turner Classic Movies VICE Animation Netflix Christmas movies boxoffice Writers Guild of America PaleyFest christmas movies canceled TV shows game show Britbox Fantasy Biopics supernatural Western die hard ABC Family TV criterion Avengers Sci-Fi films Shudder Cannes Superheroes spanish language hispanic award winner Countdown Television Academy TV Land emmy awards SundanceTV historical drama revenge crime drama Winter TV free movies Columbia Pictures ITV