Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Cinderella is Certified Fresh

Plus, Run All Night is hit and miss, and Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt is Certified Fresh.

by | March 12, 2015 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a fairy tale princess (Cinderella, starring Lily James and Cate Blanchett) and a regretful hit man (Run All Night, starring Liam Neeson and Ed Harris). What do the critics have to say?



Revisionist fairy tales are all the rage these days, so it’s a bit surprising that director Kenneth Branagh has taken the opposite tack with his mostly-straightforward version of Cinderella. Not that that’s a bad thing; critics say this is charming, visually striking family entertainment with more than a touch of the old Disney magic. You probably know the story by heart, but here goes: after her aristocratic father’s tragic death, Cinderella (Lily James) is left in the care of her wicked stepmother (Cate Blanchett) and her cruel stepsisters. But with the help of a fairy godmother (Helena Bonham Carter), our heroine wins the heart of a prince. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Cinderella doesn’t bring many new twists to the classic tale, but it’s so exquisitely crafted and energetically acted that it hardly matters. (Watch our video interview with Branagh, James, and Blanchett, and click through our gallery of the most important shoes in the movies.)

Run All Night


Another week, another movie in which Liam Neeson is out for blood. Critics say Run All Night is a so-so entry in this budding subgenre, one that’s better than Taken 3 but a notch or two below A Walk Among the Tombstones. Neeson plays Jimmy, a broken-down mob assassin with a long personal and professional history with crime boss Shawn (Ed Harris). But when Jimmy kills Shawn’s kid in order to save his son’s life, he finds his old buddy gunning for him. The pundits say the main reason to watch Run All Night is Neeson and the strong cast, but otherwise, the plot is too convoluted and the execution is too workmanlike. (Check out Harris’ best-reviewed films here.)

What’s On TV:

Critics say that Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt (Certified Fresh at 95 percent) is as odd as it is hilarious, thanks in part to a spot-on performance from Ellie Kemper.

The pundits say season three of Bates Motel (90 percent) further blurs the lines around TV’s creepiest taboo mother/son relationship, uncomfortably darkening its already fascinating tone.

Critics say that while The Returned (64 percent) is overshadowed by its superior source material, the US version retains enough of the creep factor and character drama to appease fans of the genre.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Of Horses and Men, an Icelandic dramedy featuring a series of interlocking stories about disparate people and their equine companions, is at 100 percent.
  • Seymour: An Introduction, a documentary profile of concert pianist and teacher Seymour Bernstein directed by Ethan Hawke, is at 100 percent.
  • It Follows, an indie horror film about a malevolent force that preys on teens in a Michigan suburb, is Certified Fresh at 95 percent.
  • The Wrecking Crew, a doc about the legendary L.A. session musicians who backed up everyone from Frank Sinatra to the Beach Boys, is at 93 percent.
  • 3 Hearts, starring Charlotte Gainsbourg and Catherine Deneuve in a romantic drama about two sisters who fall for the same man, is at 82 percent.
  • Champs, a documentary in which legendary pugilists Mike Tyson and Evander Holyfield discuss their lives in and outside the ring, is at 60 percent.
  • Walter, a dramedy about a movie theater employee who believes he’s the son of God, is at 57 percent.
  • Treading Water, starring Douglas Smith and Zoë Kravitz in a dramedy about a lonely teenager with a rare medical condition that makes him smell like a fish, is at 50 percent.
  • Cymbeline, starring Ethan Hawke and Ed Harris in a modern-day retelling of Shakespeare’s tragedy featuring warring bikers and cops, is at 33 percent.
  • The Cobbler, starring Adam Sandler and Steve Buscemi in a comic fantasy about a shoe repairman who discovers a machine magical properties, is at 11 percent (check out co-star Method Man’s Five Favorite Films here).
  • Home Sweet Hell, starring Katherine Heigl and Patrick Wilson in a drama based on the true story of the brazen kidnapping of a brewery heir, is at eight percent.

Tag Cloud

Disney Plus Certified Fresh Western PaleyFest Mary Tyler Moore zombie TCA Kids & Family Extras worst movies Ovation WGN finale Reality tv talk adaptation Star Wars reviews Pet Sematary Quiz Binge Guide social media dark Shondaland IFC Epix blaxploitation VH1 DGA romantic comedy superhero Avengers MTV Awards TV renewals dramedy Drama war TCA Awards San Diego Comic-Con Schedule spanish language Emmys supernatural History Star Trek archives robots aliens Baby Yoda Toys Warner Bros. Britbox quibi NYCC MCU cooking Oscars anthology justice league Captain marvel TCA Winter 2020 Anna Paquin TCM 71st Emmy Awards films GoT Women's History Month Crunchyroll breaking bad The Walking Dead foreign Valentine's Day rt archives news Dark Horse Comics emmy awards universal monsters Sundance Freeform satire canceled festival Action YA Food Network game show VOD YouTube Premium Holidays blockbuster screen actors guild harry potter nfl Television Academy spinoff Discovery Channel Alien Bravo 007 Fox Searchlight name the review Set visit Amazon Prime Video police drama 20th Century Fox mockumentary latino streaming Endgame El Rey Spike Shudder New York Comic Con TV Land doctor who Tubi TV Character Guide thriller obituary 72 Emmy Awards Turner australia Brie Larson travel Holiday BET football SXSW E! comics Tomatazos Elton John DirecTV politics President 4/20 biography movies Esquire Winners Paramount Network WarnerMedia book GIFs elevated horror documentaries 24 frames Amazon Prime Cartoon Network cartoon Christmas boxing BBC One Trivia NBC Pop GLAAD Creative Arts Emmys science fiction natural history singing competition Ghostbusters hollywood Emmy Nominations movie technology FX on Hulu comedies Netflix Christmas movies 21st Century Fox Country festivals cinemax Classic Film ESPN discovery X-Men free movies golden globes batman Mudbound Comedy Central Photos boxoffice cancelled VICE psychological thriller classics 2018 Lifetime zero dark thirty Marvel The Arrangement Summer Marathons USA Network Martial Arts medical drama black Ellie Kemper A24 OWN Rocketman sports mutant indie FOX richard e. Grant Funimation Black History Month diversity Musical Writers Guild of America binge A&E revenge a nightmare on elm street CNN Chernobyl The CW PBS rotten PlayStation 45 99% OneApp historical drama SDCC 2015 laika Crackle spy thriller canceled TV shows Thanksgiving mission: impossible Film Nominations Heroines Spring TV crime drama award winner slashers Mary Poppins Returns Cannes Hulu dc ABC Family Pride Month teaser cancelled TV series CMT dogs composers crossover Sony Pictures video best strong female leads deadpool ABC animated American Society of Cinematographers Best and Worst Calendar zombies japanese asian-american hispanic Comic Book Nat Geo 2017 criterion Opinion The Purge Trophy Talk IFC Films comiccon Lucasfilm werewolf Adult Swim ghosts Super Bowl sitcom indiana jones sequels toronto Mystery spider-man kids Podcast TCA 2017 fresh witnail Countdown 2020 Film Festival parents Year in Review cults french die hard Family Superheroes critics Music MSNBC Disney streaming service Fall TV See It Skip It Lifetime Christmas movies Vudu facebook docudrama halloween tv italian Paramount Marvel Studios TBS true crime television screenings green book Superheroe Amazon directors Mindy Kaling Sundance TV dragons franchise Animation TLC USA HBO Max Logo theme song Walt Disney Pictures Comedy spanish SundanceTV Tarantino HBO Go YouTube HBO National Geographic Sci-Fi Disney+ Disney Plus Disney Premiere Dates documentary Awards Tour period drama TruTV Grammys Box Office DC Universe Apple TV Plus vampires psycho Video Games Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Hear Us Out Syfy Rock rotten movies we love stop motion renewed TV shows unscripted political drama cancelled television 2016 Red Carpet DC Comics FXX worst Nickelodeon The Witch Rocky RT21 Interview 2019 what to watch Apple TV+ Pirates versus miniseries Peacock Starz crime cancelled TV shows Comics on TV Academy Awards CBS FX nature comic james bond Horror RT History Fox News E3 Spectrum Originals Cosplay disaster APB south america Hallmark anime hist First Reviews all-time Disney Channel toy story Lionsgate Polls and Games Rom-Com Showtime video on demand The Academy cats ID Black Mirror spain ratings stoner stand-up comedy christmas movies cars Winter TV Marvel Television Watching Series adventure DC streaming service Sneak Peek Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Netflix scorecard Fantasy BET Awards Sundance Now comic books Universal dceu sequel Biopics fast and furious Masterpiece concert serial killer CW Seed Hallmark Christmas movies Television Critics Association Pixar ITV Amazon Studios LGBT Acorn TV Election LGBTQ Song of Ice and Fire Musicals series Tumblr transformers child's play reboot independent based on movie scary movies TNT halloween Columbia Pictures remakes First Look casting sag awards BBC America Infographic Pop TV twilight Apple BAFTA TIFF children's TV CBS All Access venice Trailer jamie lee curtis talk show chucky joker Mary poppins Arrowverse YouTube Red game of thrones space crime thriller Teen AMC Travel Channel Reality Competition Turner Classic Movies nbcuniversal Stephen King BBC cops romance