News

Comic Books to TV: 10 Echoes of X-Men in FX’s Legion

How much of the X-Men comic books can you find in the new series? Here are some possible traits to look out for.

by | February 15, 2017 | Comments

Legion Dan Stevens (Chris Large/FX); X-Men Legacy (Marvel.com)

In many of the interviews leading up to the premiere of FX’s new X-Men inspired series Legion, executive producer Noah Hawley made it clear he wanted to create original characters and stories in the X-Men setting.

“None of the other characters that I’ve surrounded him with are from the comics. It’s sort of an invented world,” Hawley told Variety.

With the premiere last Wednesday, it is clear he succeeded — established X-Men comic book character David Haller (Dan Stevens) stands alone among new faces and is placed in a setting that, while familiar, appears new for an X-Men screen adaptation.

Nevertheless, there are many echoes of the source material, and the books may offer some clues to where David’s journey will lead.

Spoilers ahead! The following discussion contains plot details from the X-Men comic books that may foreshadow events in FX television series Legion


1. The Me Decade

Dan Stevens, Rachel Keller, Aubrey Plaza in Legion ep 1 (Chris Large/FX)

Though the series appears to be set in a timeless now, the art direction, costumes, and musical choices harken back to the 1970s, one of the great heydays for the X-Men as a comic book series. Though it debuted in 1963, the title began to reprint older stories starting with issue #67 in 1970 and briefly ceased publication after issue #93 in 1975.

At the same time, writer Len Wein and artist Dave Cockrum reinvigorated the concept with a new line-up of characters like Storm and Wolverine in the pages of Giant Size X-Men #1. The regular series resumed with issue #94 in August 1975. Writer Chris Claremont (who would go on to co-create Legion in 1985) took over the title and, with collaborators like Cockrum and John Byrne, established much of the X-Men world as we know it.

Nowadays, the effort would be called a “soft reboot,” and it proved to be quite a success; particularly with college-aged readers in the mid-70s. By the end of the decade, X-Men was one Marvel’s most popular titles.


2. X-Men Gold

Katie Aselton, Dan Stevens in Legion (Chris Large/FX)

In the pilot episode, the patients at Clockwork Psychiatric Hospital sport jackets with a distinctive yellow stripe along the arms. Though quite stylized, it is easy to see the inspiration from various X-Men uniforms across its 50+ year history; particularly the fashion-conscious look of Grant Morrison’s New X-Men in the early part of the 21st Century. At the time, Morrison wanted to turn the individualized costumes of the characters into a unified school uniform. He also hoped the designs by his frequent collaborator Frank Quitely would become a line of official Marvel clothing. Third-party companies filled the gap, and their efforts are still seen occasionally at comic conventions across the country. Curiously, this yellow is typically referred to as gold in the comics; particularly in the early 1990s, when the X-Men split into “Team Blue” and “Team Gold” in honor of their traditional color scheme.


3. Roguish

Rachel Keller in Legion; Rogue #3 - 2005 (Chris Large/FX; Marvel.com)

Though Sydney Barrett (Rachel Keller) appears to be an original character with a Pink Floyd-inspired name, her reticence to be touched — and her body-swapping ability — echoes the power and curse of villain turned X-Man Ana Marie, better known to the world as Rogue. Debuting in the pages of Avengers Annual #10, she used her ability to absorb other people’s powers and memories on Ms. Marvel; permanently obtaining flight, superstrength and invulnerability. As useful as these powers proved to the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants, it also left Rogue unable to ever touch another person. In doing so, she would leave her victims in a deep coma even as she gained their abilities.

She eventually traded sides and became an important X-Men character in the early 1990s and in the first successful X-Men animated series. She was also one of the first mutants to appear in live-action in the first X-Men feature. Played by Anna Paquin, her power is both quite evocative of the mutant concept and inexpensive to realize. Well, as long as you leave her Ms. Marvel powers in the pages of the comics. Of course, it remains to be seen if Syd will eventually find herself with Rogue’s distinctive stripe of white hair.


4. The Devil with Yellow Eyes

Though it is unclear just what David’s vision of the Devil with Yellow Eyes truly represents, his visual manifestation certainly echoes occasional X-Men villain Mojo, a ratings-hungry reality show producer from another dimension. First appearing in 1985’s Longshot #3 (by Ann Nocenti and Art Adams) as a critique of television network executives, Mojo required a cybernetic platform for mobility. Without it, his organic body bears a striking resemblance to David’s recurring vision — right down to the yellow eyes.

While the visual of the Devil with Yellow Eyes harkens to Mojo, David’s early comic book appearances featured another X-Men villain rooting around in his head: the incorporeal psychic entity known as the Shadow King. Created by Claremont and Byrne, the Shadow King inspired Charles Xavier to form the X-Men following an encounter in Egypt. Many years later, he possessed David in an attempt to claim the body of a de-aged Storm (X-Men stories can get quite complicated.) In removing the Shadow King’s control, David became unstable and ultimately ended up in a coma.


5. Division One

X-FACTOR (2005) #204 (Marvel.com)

Referenced in a throwaway line by David Selby’s unnamed government agent, Division One could be an allusion to the Mutant Response Division. First appearing in 2010’s X-Factor #204, the MRD was formed by the United Nations after an anti-mutant group attempted to stage a mutant-led terrorist attack. Division One will also look very familiar to General William Styker’s Weapon X program, an initiative to weaponize mutants, in almost all of the X-Men feature films; an element which first appeared in 1991’s Marvel Comics Presents #72 by writer and artist Barry Windsor-Smith. There are also other government agencies across the world — like Canada’s Department H — interested in understand and utilizing mutant powers. Of course, it is still unclear just what Division One’s real aim will be.


6. The Eye

Mister Sinister (Marvel)

With his milky right eye, preference for wolves, and an uncanny ability to survive David’s explosions of power, The Eye — as he’s referred to in the cast list — echoes any number of renegade mutant researchers in the pages of the various X-Men titles, but his obviously evil countenance most closely resembles geneticist Mister Sinister. Debuting in Uncanny X-Men #221, the vaguely vampiric Sinister was originally intended to be a child’s projection of a bad guy; projected by a mutant unable to mature into adulthood. When that concept was abandoned, Sinister was revealed to be a Victorian scientist given immortality by Apocalypse. In the 20th century, he became obsessed with the bloodline of Cyclops and may have nudged events to lead to the birth of his son, Cable.

Of course, that field of study was not the exclusive province of Sinister. Allies like Moria MacTaggert and enemies like Stryker were all interested in the genetic secret which unlocked incredible abilities. And even if the Eye is no one particular X-Men scientist, his ambitions resonate well into the comic book’s past.


7. Lenny Finds a Home

Aubrey Plaza in Legion (Chris Large/FX)

While David’s fellow patient and friend Lenny — played by Aubrey Plaza — is an original character, her place in David’s mind is a well-established part of Legion’s powerset and story.

When David’s powers first manifested during a terrorist attack in Paris, his mind absorbed the personas of some of the victims and even some of the terrorists. Presented as distinct souls David captured via his psychic powers, these other minds eventually grew to control aspects of his abilities and eventually sought to control David’s body on a more permanent basis.

But one persona in particular — a young girl name Marci — came to be a friend and kept David company after one of his other more aggressive personalities killed the real Marci. Thought it is unclear if Lenny is trapped in his mind or just a projection of David’s turmoil, her place in his head is one of the more direct echoes back to the comics.


8. Which Disorder Is in Order?

 Dan Stevens, Rachel Keller in Legion (Michelle Faye/FX)

With the constant appearance of new personas vying for control, David’s comic book ailment more closely resembles dissociative identity disorder (multiple personalities). But in the premiere of Legion, his visions represent something closer to schizophrenia. The understanding and nature of David’s underlying issue has changed over the years. In his initial appearances, he was referred to as “The Autistic” — and some of his mannerism in the series echo that early diagnosis — but this was short-lived, as the demands of plot sent the character toward DID. It remains to be seen if the screen version of David will eventually find his disorder more closely resembles something else in the DSM than what he’s been told, but hopefully the series will clearly define it and stick with it.


9. New X-Men

Jean Smart in Legion (Frank Ockenfels/FX)

In their brief moments in the pilot, Ptonomy Wallace (Jeremie Harris), Kerry Loudermilk (Amber Midthunder), and Melanie Bird (Jean Smart) certainly seem familiar to readers of X-Men comics. As a super-powered strike team led by an older and seemingly wiser leader, the parallel to the X-Men seems obvious, even as the characters appear to be brand new. If nothing else, Kerry seems to have the X-Men power-stride down.

Meanwhile, Melanie Bird appears to be a stand-in for Professor Xavier — at least in the mentor role. In various articles leading up to the premiere, she has been described as an unconventional therapist, which once again conjures up the echoes of the various mutant researchers like Moira MacTaggert and Mister Sinister.

Also worth noting is her repeated use of the word “son” when talking to David. While a more common epithet in the 20th Century, the use of it nowadays usually suggests a more familial connection in the grammar of scripted television. Of course, that could just be more of the 1970s bleeding through and cementing her role as mentor or else an indication of something deeper.


10. In a World That Hates and Fears Them

NEW X-MEN VOL. I: E IS FOR EXTINCTION (Marvel.com)

Other than that use of the word “son,” the pilot offered no clues to David’s parentage. Though David Selby’s character refers to David as the most powerful mutant they’ve encountered, what of the world’s most powerful telepath? While the notion of a mutant does not seem new Selby or his team, it is unclear just how common mutants actually are in the world. In the pages of X-Men, the covert nature of their work varies from writer to writer, with Xavier initially wanting his brightly suited X-Men to defend a world that hates and fears them. Grant Morrison’s New X-Men began with the pronouncement that mutants would soon outnumber humans and Xavier finally outing himself to the world. After subsequent events and creative changes, that number would be reduced dramatically by editorial fiat and the in-story abilities of Scarlett Witch (again, X-Men stories can be complicated), with the surviving mutants retreating to the shadows.

Or, perhaps, the absence of Xavier is a bigger echo than the show is letting on.

After several years away, David returned to X-Men in the mid-1990s intent on traveling to the past and eliminating Xavier’s archrival Magneto before the latter could harm the mutant rights cause. After a series of missteps, David’s trip though time resulted in Xavier dying, leading to an event across all the X-Men titles know as “The Age of Apocalypse.” The alternate timeline saw the mutant despot taking over the Earth because Xavier was not there to form the X-Men. As Hawley himself has pointed out, “With the X-Men comics, there are a lot of alt universes, so that has allowed me some leeway.”

Is it possible David has already played with time to such an extent that his own birth is the greatest anomaly of all?

Legion airs Wednesdays at 10 p.m. ET/PT on FX. Also read our interview with series star Dan Stevens.


Tag Cloud

TV CBS Television Academy APB Crackle animated Film Dark Horse Comics slashers Action Showtime BBC America Comedy Sundance Baby Yoda Oscars RT History documentary Paramount Network technology Avengers Music WGN The Academy emmy awards mutant First Look Bravo Winners mission: impossible Chernobyl cooking stoner Spring TV Opinion quibi blaxploitation Fall TV Rom-Com screenings renewed TV shows television transformers DGA PBS binge travel Biopics Box Office Apple TV+ aliens Discovery Channel christmas movies remakes venice Universal Rock FOX satire American Society of Cinematographers BET Marvel Studios superhero Toys The Witch halloween die hard 2015 romantic comedy batman E3 See It Skip It USA Nat Geo TCM DirecTV Acorn TV Lifetime Christmas movies Trailer TV Land BAFTA Reality diversity independent asian-american spinoff National Geographic cops Sundance Now strong female leads spy thriller psycho BET Awards Musicals festivals crossover TLC cars A&E Thanksgiving FX a nightmare on elm street hispanic concert GoT cats nature Mindy Kaling The CW 2020 period drama canceled TV shows discovery 2019 docudrama Esquire Starz spider-man Travel Channel TruTV series rotten Disney Plus Disney Channel Watching Series name the review VOD HBO Go critics Comedy Central mockumentary YouTube Premium Video Games australia Star Wars football Ghostbusters children's TV universal monsters worst Christmas Fantasy canceled news Pirates New York Comic Con TNT jamie lee curtis Marvel halloween tv obituary scary movies boxoffice dogs italian theme song TV renewals Countdown sequel WarnerMedia what to watch golden globes casting disaster Musical classics Shudder Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Holidays Awards Tour OWN Set visit Premiere Dates Endgame documentaries BBC One spanish language Trivia Marathons FX on Hulu Columbia Pictures Elton John YA vampires criterion dragons Paramount The Walking Dead Tumblr Tarantino Shondaland El Rey SDCC archives Apple YouTube Red Infographic Peacock Family zero dark thirty directors facebook medical drama festival werewolf OneApp based on movie blockbuster crime social media indiana jones Captain marvel Trophy Talk Holiday Comic Book Disney streaming service Pet Sematary San Diego Comic-Con Election CBS All Access Film Festival cancelled television Food Network USA Network Star Trek elevated horror Disney+ Disney Plus Rocketman worst movies YouTube films Ovation TBS Quiz Kids & Family Winter TV reviews DC Universe Drama 24 frames historical drama TCA Fox Searchlight Pop A24 Heroines tv talk child's play Superheroe Marvel Television Pride Month Song of Ice and Fire composers Spike Turner Classic Movies witnail Academy Awards free movies politics ratings rotten movies we love Crunchyroll twilight Certified Fresh Emmy Nominations CMT nbcuniversal stop motion Tubi First Reviews indie RT21 dc south america Sony Pictures singing competition IFC Films hollywood parents Arrowverse true crime Interview laika Mary Poppins Returns Amazon Prime Video Summer Mary Tyler Moore 2017 comiccon E! 2016 Pop TV Valentine's Day romance adaptation toronto natural history political drama DC streaming service Hallmark Christmas movies Spectrum Originals sports police drama crime thriller Chilling Adventures of Sabrina joker Podcast SundanceTV miniseries Red Carpet zombie Martial Arts finale 007 Black History Month ITV Vudu comics Awards Classic Film space sag awards toy story book cartoon Polls and Games Ellie Kemper Sundance TV Superheroes cinemax Character Guide spanish adventure Amazon Writers Guild of America Cosplay science fiction green book cults Year in Review Emmys movies Adult Swim TCA Awards Cartoon Network award winner SXSW Masterpiece NYCC Lifetime X-Men NBC TIFF video on demand Mary poppins sequels MTV Lucasfilm Women's History Month The Purge breaking bad game of thrones GLAAD Hallmark 45 Nominations Warner Bros. nfl Horror Turner VICE comic serial killer ABC Family Sci-Fi Super Bowl revenge unscripted Creative Arts Emmys best cancelled Extras Hulu dark comedies Pixar dceu crime drama latino Best and Worst Stephen King DC Comics TCA 2017 2018 LGBTQ Syfy Disney zombies franchise hist Mystery supernatural french ABC The Arrangement Netflix Christmas movies 72 Emmy Awards HBO Max Anna Paquin Black Mirror PaleyFest TCA Winter 2020 Tomatazos dramedy Mudbound Calendar war Freeform doctor who spain robots Photos screen actors guild 20th Century Fox chucky Animation Schedule Comics on TV Television Critics Association 71st Emmy Awards teaser Hear Us Out Cannes cancelled TV series video Western PlayStation cancelled TV shows foreign Grammys streaming game show thriller sitcom versus HBO psychological thriller Fox News CW Seed President MCU Brie Larson Reality Competition biography Teen kids Apple TV Plus ESPN Binge Guide anime Netflix FXX Funimation GIFs BBC justice league movie Country fast and furious talk show Nickelodeon Amazon Studios CNN Epix Sneak Peek 4/20 VH1 Britbox 21st Century Fox richard e. Grant Logo Lionsgate harry potter Rocky LGBT scorecard Amazon Prime reboot stand-up comedy Walt Disney Pictures ghosts IFC all-time AMC anthology MSNBC History japanese