"Clerks II" Getting Some Premature Critical Love

by | June 19, 2006 | Comments

After screening at Cannes to an eight-minute standing ovation, "Clerks II" is beginning to garner precious positive reviews from print and online critics, who have given Kevin Smith‘s latest film an 88% Unofficial Tomatometer rating.

The MGM release isn’t due in theaters until July 21, but early reviews from the pic’s Cannes debut and other sneak screenings are already trickling in. Among 8 early reviews, 7 are positive critiques that applaud Smith’s return to his raunchy roots, while the lone negative review (written by Kevin Smith enthusiast Phil Villareal) declares "Clerks II" an eagerly anticipated disappointment.

The raves:

"After Jersey Girl, some felt that Smith had spunked his mojo, and heading back to Clerksworld could so easily have been a mad dash back to the comfort zone. It’s good to report, then, that Clerks II is what Smith does so well; it’s a tender, scabrous and very, very funny comedy that picks up 12 years after the original."

Damon Wise, Empire Online

"What Kevin has slyly done in his own ass-to-mouth, donkey show kinda way – has crafted his own modern mid-thirties geek retelling of AMERICAN GRAFFITTI."

Harry Knowles, Ain’t It Cool Movie Reviews

The OKs:

"Filled with tart dialogue and the kind of pop culture diatribes that propelled the original Clerks, this is a return to both the form and the substance that brought Smith to public attention in the first place."

Pop Syndicate

"If ‘Clerks II’ doesn’t have quite the scabrous kick of its predecessor, the chance to revisit a classic premise must have renewed the writer in Smith, whose banter here often achieves a sharpness and quality that haven’t been in evidence since 1999’s ‘Dogma.’"

Justin Chang, Variety

The pan:

"The film’s problems are myriad. The new clerk, an ultraconservative Christian 19-year-old ‘Transformers’ and ‘Lord of the Rings’ geek played by Trevor Fehrman, is a sloppy caricature that strives and fails for the bizarro elegance of a Screech or an Urkel."

"The original was gleefully nasty for the sake of ingenious pop culture jabs, while the sequel, sadly, is raunchy for the sake of gag-inducing obscenity alone. The same is true about Smith’s trademark consumer satire."

"Sadly, ‘Clerks II’ was so bad that it actually had me pining for ‘Jersey Girl.’"

Phil Villareal, Scripps News

The sequel to Smith’s indie breakout "Clerks" (85% on the Tomatometer) has the potential to bring up the cult fave director’s own Tomatometer ranking, which started out strong with 1994’s "Clerks," dipped with 1995’s "Mallrats" (58%), peaked with 1997’s "Chasing Amy" (93% Tomatometer), and subsequently declined following 1999’s "Dogma" (67%), 2001’s "Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back" (53%), and 2004’s "Jersey Girl" (41%).

Tag Cloud

halloween Nat Geo cops Comedy Sundance Now finale Comedy Central disaster 2019 know your critic Red Carpet Martial Arts kids Best and Worst MTV National Geographic universal monsters Winter TV laika crime drama Watching Series anthology spanish language Interview comiccon Disney Star Wars Turner game of thrones Set visit cancelled television hollywood rotten Drama Emmys slashers golden globes TCA Winter 2020 facebook zombie HBO Go BET sports RT History Columbia Pictures Warner Bros. American Society of Cinematographers TV renewals 20th Century Fox hidden camera halloween tv ITV Legendary Star Trek Mindy Kaling medical drama Sneak Peek Certified Fresh Ovation Marathons canceled TV shows Disney Plus breaking bad sequel miniseries Holiday chucky Disney Channel DC Comics animated comic Lucasfilm dragons worst satire E! book Hear Us Out Chilling Adventures of Sabrina video docuseries TIFF mission: impossible reviews OneApp superman free movies Shudder richard e. Grant Spring TV YouTube Premium fresh asian-american TruTV vampires cats Sundance TV renewed TV shows Adult Swim true crime Sony Pictures festivals Trailer Lifetime Christmas movies best 93rd Oscars Cannes films hispanic toronto biography Mary poppins ViacomCBS news Tarantino TCM war parents cartoon adventure heist movie Disney+ Disney Plus cinemax Mystery Funimation space Tumblr Extras Spike anime canceled doctor who dc Black Mirror zero dark thirty Cosplay 2018 FX on Hulu Musical screenings Pacific Islander Marvel Studios versus talk show superhero spinoff Film Festival documentary kaiju Fox News Amazon Studios Action dramedy tv talk See It Skip It MSNBC venice LGBT Dark Horse Comics cults San Diego Comic-Con DGA streaming stand-up comedy lord of the rings justice league mutant adaptation Valentine's Day Teen sag awards monster movies Hulu Bravo razzies Academy Awards MCU The Academy Television Critics Association Shondaland Calendar Ghostbusters romantic comedy Classic Film Universal critics spain Amazon Prime Video ID television witnail cars stop motion Awards green book nature Country crime thriller ABC docudrama BAFTA Schedule VICE cancelled 45 live action romance Grammys Apple TV+ revenge 21st Century Fox harry potter Food Network Super Bowl Crackle Captain marvel Marvel Television nbcuniversal book adaptation comics Discovery Channel Photos deadpool 99% crime black E3 BBC One YouTube Red ghosts scary movies werewolf serial killer ABC Signature The CW based on movie king kong Reality Competition twilight Video Games Lionsgate Spectrum Originals Epix kong Superheroes concert dogs Trivia a nightmare on elm street police drama golden globe awards psychological thriller Animation Horror Britbox YA Biopics DirecTV Fox Searchlight Baby Yoda Podcast Apple TV Plus Amazon Prime batman FOX obituary new zealand Acorn TV Music directors jamie lee curtis Awards Tour First Reviews marvel cinematic universe strong female leads SundanceTV TLC El Rey italian mockumentary ESPN The Walt Disney Company independent A&E football First Look Pride Month Fall TV X-Men toy story what to watch award winner WGN 2021 LGBTQ Sci-Fi Amazon Holidays Crunchyroll Chernobyl Superheroe Showtime transformers TNT New York Comic Con screen actors guild SXSW 72 Emmy Awards indie crossover stoner TV One GLAAD criterion TV Land 2020 Christmas Arrowverse video on demand christmas movies Pixar Turner Classic Movies Broadway YouTube Brie Larson USA children's TV 71st Emmy Awards CW Seed indiana jones Premiere Dates WarnerMedia History PaleyFest historical drama 2016 psycho ABC Family The Purge latino trailers festival classics target GoT CBS Rom-Com Tomatazos Countdown comedies Writers Guild of America Endgame Esquire movie DC Universe joker saw Reality high school Sundance Opinion quibi Women's History Month Trophy Talk foreign singing competition new star wars movies Stephen King Travel Channel japanese documentaries Rock james bond A24 Comics on TV international APB Hallmark comic books dceu spider-man Walt Disney Pictures fast and furious Paramount Network thriller Hallmark Christmas movies sitcom BET Awards Character Guide Alien 4/20 australia cancelled TV series Vudu political drama popular BBC America worst movies prank TCA Awards VOD scene in color blockbusters CNN Election 2015 technology Toys Cartoon Network Summer Peacock rom-coms composers dark AMC cooking Elton John Paramount Western Fantasy french Logo all-time Mary Tyler Moore Infographic Box Office theme song Masterpiece Television Academy franchise Starz Disney streaming service 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards PBS spy thriller blockbuster telelvision movies IFC zombies Pop Nominations boxing Pirates Film politics aliens Comic Book archives pirates of the caribbean Binge Guide Pet Sematary 2017 The Walking Dead social media discovery teaser 24 frames Heroines Emmy Nominations OWN GIFs scorecard diversity Ellie Kemper BBC Creative Arts Emmys Image Comics Thanksgiving Freeform Rocketman IFC Films new york emmy awards jurassic park Winners spanish cancelled TV shows women DC streaming service rotten movies we love boxoffice supernatural south america Exclusive Video Quiz ratings rt archives die hard Kids & Family The Arrangement TCA Oscars Avengers RT21 Anna Paquin name the review 007 Rocky game show binge Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt The Witch natural history CMT NBC Nickelodeon SDCC Mudbound FXX Lifetime Tubi nfl NYCC President Netflix sequels godzilla aapi Song of Ice and Fire robots elevated horror series period drama blaxploitation unscripted Musicals hist TV child's play reboot Family Pop TV Marvel travel USA Network FX TBS casting Syfy CBS All Access TCA 2017 Year in Review science fiction remakes Netflix Christmas movies VH1 PlayStation HBO Max Black History Month Paramount Plus Polls and Games Apple Mary Poppins Returns HBO