"Clerks II" Getting Some Premature Critical Love

by | June 19, 2006 | Comments

After screening at Cannes to an eight-minute standing ovation, "Clerks II" is beginning to garner precious positive reviews from print and online critics, who have given Kevin Smith‘s latest film an 88% Unofficial Tomatometer rating.

The MGM release isn’t due in theaters until July 21, but early reviews from the pic’s Cannes debut and other sneak screenings are already trickling in. Among 8 early reviews, 7 are positive critiques that applaud Smith’s return to his raunchy roots, while the lone negative review (written by Kevin Smith enthusiast Phil Villareal) declares "Clerks II" an eagerly anticipated disappointment.

The raves:

"After Jersey Girl, some felt that Smith had spunked his mojo, and heading back to Clerksworld could so easily have been a mad dash back to the comfort zone. It’s good to report, then, that Clerks II is what Smith does so well; it’s a tender, scabrous and very, very funny comedy that picks up 12 years after the original."

Damon Wise, Empire Online

"What Kevin has slyly done in his own ass-to-mouth, donkey show kinda way – has crafted his own modern mid-thirties geek retelling of AMERICAN GRAFFITTI."

Harry Knowles, Ain’t It Cool Movie Reviews

The OKs:

"Filled with tart dialogue and the kind of pop culture diatribes that propelled the original Clerks, this is a return to both the form and the substance that brought Smith to public attention in the first place."

Pop Syndicate

"If ‘Clerks II’ doesn’t have quite the scabrous kick of its predecessor, the chance to revisit a classic premise must have renewed the writer in Smith, whose banter here often achieves a sharpness and quality that haven’t been in evidence since 1999’s ‘Dogma.’"

Justin Chang, Variety

The pan:

"The film’s problems are myriad. The new clerk, an ultraconservative Christian 19-year-old ‘Transformers’ and ‘Lord of the Rings’ geek played by Trevor Fehrman, is a sloppy caricature that strives and fails for the bizarro elegance of a Screech or an Urkel."

"The original was gleefully nasty for the sake of ingenious pop culture jabs, while the sequel, sadly, is raunchy for the sake of gag-inducing obscenity alone. The same is true about Smith’s trademark consumer satire."

"Sadly, ‘Clerks II’ was so bad that it actually had me pining for ‘Jersey Girl.’"

Phil Villareal, Scripps News

The sequel to Smith’s indie breakout "Clerks" (85% on the Tomatometer) has the potential to bring up the cult fave director’s own Tomatometer ranking, which started out strong with 1994’s "Clerks," dipped with 1995’s "Mallrats" (58%), peaked with 1997’s "Chasing Amy" (93% Tomatometer), and subsequently declined following 1999’s "Dogma" (67%), 2001’s "Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back" (53%), and 2004’s "Jersey Girl" (41%).

Tag Cloud

Captain marvel Star Trek Acorn TV 2017 Amazon Studios films spanish language Premiere Dates chucky Endgame stoner Mary Poppins Returns ITV all-time talk show technology cinemax dragons aliens streaming 2018 HBO Go El Rey toy story GIFs National Geographic Cosplay Character Guide Trailer Grammys Amazon Prime VICE vampires transformers critics Esquire TCA Winter 2020 Ovation Hallmark Christmas movies elevated horror finale comic Watching Series Best and Worst Chernobyl SundanceTV Black Mirror 2020 Drama Mary poppins criterion natural history hist Disney+ Disney Plus 2016 Amazon Prime Video a nightmare on elm street Emmys rotten movies we love cooking free movies children's TV BET TruTV WGN The Arrangement FXX cancelled TV shows Nominations cancelled Teen Syfy First Reviews jamie lee curtis Baby Yoda Year in Review blockbuster Lionsgate SDCC The Witch theme song sequel richard e. Grant Trophy Talk Pirates breaking bad Reality Competition Shondaland Black History Month adventure crime medical drama Fantasy BBC hispanic DGA VH1 The Purge satire biography Music PBS Rocketman Turner Rocky Apple TV Plus Calendar witnail reboot Hallmark Anna Paquin Spring TV spain 2019 television discovery unscripted Action Winter TV OneApp composers cars A&E Hear Us Out christmas movies zombie Oscars true crime Cannes USA Vudu 007 Box Office BBC America docudrama The CW kids historical drama video Cartoon Network Paramount Network AMC Trivia war binge travel game of thrones Western E! Animation 21st Century Fox Mindy Kaling PaleyFest Netflix Christmas movies Warner Bros. Rock Masterpiece LGBT 2015 YouTube Premium quibi YouTube E3 IFC Films WarnerMedia Marvel Studios FX cats Reality Tumblr crossover Women's History Month cartoon Adult Swim twilight NYCC VOD Lifetime Emmy Nominations spinoff sag awards reviews Sundance TV Apple CBS movies child's play cults justice league TCA 2017 boxoffice foreign Winners south america disaster batman Interview Red Carpet Bravo social media asian-american cancelled television IFC Sony Pictures Pop TV latino indie Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Martial Arts Biopics Extras Infographic 4/20 animated Creative Arts Emmys PlayStation CNN Superheroes Travel Channel ESPN Quiz thriller GLAAD teaser dramedy space FX on Hulu Film Festival Pet Sematary anime tv talk dc Paramount DC Universe documentary Rom-Com Food Network SXSW Tubi Spectrum Originals strong female leads TCA anthology Christmas History screen actors guild Country sports Musical TIFF Stephen King Spike doctor who zombies OWN mockumentary 45 CW Seed Countdown DirecTV Sundance Certified Fresh dogs parents crime thriller scary movies mutant Arrowverse Mystery Writers Guild of America RT History Mary Tyler Moore Comedy adaptation comics Kids & Family robots facebook Super Bowl Freeform cancelled TV series MCU Britbox FOX Opinion casting golden globes franchise Thanksgiving dark Disney Pride Month screenings First Look APB name the review Comics on TV singing competition best Netflix police drama Starz directors dceu TNT American Society of Cinematographers San Diego Comic-Con book President ABC Family Video Games spy thriller Lifetime Christmas movies Superheroe game show Universal universal monsters zero dark thirty Chilling Adventures of Sabrina mission: impossible Horror what to watch serial killer based on movie movie canceled TV shows Hulu crime drama A24 See It Skip It Showtime sitcom renewed TV shows Nickelodeon Shudder cops Sundance Now HBO ABC HBO Max Epix CMT Avengers Ellie Kemper Marathons Elton John BBC One 20th Century Fox Song of Ice and Fire news Academy Awards award winner Columbia Pictures The Walking Dead Disney streaming service Apple TV+ Disney Plus Musicals Star Wars romance video on demand 71st Emmy Awards Tomatazos DC Comics Television Academy miniseries die hard politics Ghostbusters festivals MTV Polls and Games NBC Schedule Discovery Channel Comic Book Mudbound Brie Larson LGBTQ romantic comedy joker Toys Comedy Central canceled BAFTA Sci-Fi Awards Tour Sneak Peek spider-man Nat Geo Peacock YA nature Film Summer Classic Film TV renewals YouTube Red Podcast New York Comic Con revenge Marvel stand-up comedy Holiday DC streaming service comedies political drama X-Men indiana jones concert Holidays werewolf MSNBC 24 frames Crunchyroll Awards Fox News Marvel Television Valentine's Day ghosts Logo documentaries BET Awards series TV Land Election green book Walt Disney Pictures USA Network Pop ratings comiccon harry potter period drama Binge Guide Pixar Crackle blaxploitation Amazon Family supernatural science fiction TBS independent Lucasfilm TV RT21 TLC diversity Fall TV CBS All Access halloween Photos psychological thriller GoT Disney Channel slashers Turner Classic Movies versus Heroines Funimation Dark Horse Comics psycho Set visit Tarantino TCM