"Clerks II" Getting Some Premature Critical Love

by | June 19, 2006 | Comments

After screening at Cannes to an eight-minute standing ovation, "Clerks II" is beginning to garner precious positive reviews from print and online critics, who have given Kevin Smith‘s latest film an 88% Unofficial Tomatometer rating.

The MGM release isn’t due in theaters until July 21, but early reviews from the pic’s Cannes debut and other sneak screenings are already trickling in. Among 8 early reviews, 7 are positive critiques that applaud Smith’s return to his raunchy roots, while the lone negative review (written by Kevin Smith enthusiast Phil Villareal) declares "Clerks II" an eagerly anticipated disappointment.

The raves:

"After Jersey Girl, some felt that Smith had spunked his mojo, and heading back to Clerksworld could so easily have been a mad dash back to the comfort zone. It’s good to report, then, that Clerks II is what Smith does so well; it’s a tender, scabrous and very, very funny comedy that picks up 12 years after the original."

Damon Wise, Empire Online

"What Kevin has slyly done in his own ass-to-mouth, donkey show kinda way – has crafted his own modern mid-thirties geek retelling of AMERICAN GRAFFITTI."

Harry Knowles, Ain’t It Cool Movie Reviews

The OKs:

"Filled with tart dialogue and the kind of pop culture diatribes that propelled the original Clerks, this is a return to both the form and the substance that brought Smith to public attention in the first place."

Pop Syndicate

"If ‘Clerks II’ doesn’t have quite the scabrous kick of its predecessor, the chance to revisit a classic premise must have renewed the writer in Smith, whose banter here often achieves a sharpness and quality that haven’t been in evidence since 1999’s ‘Dogma.’"

Justin Chang, Variety

The pan:

"The film’s problems are myriad. The new clerk, an ultraconservative Christian 19-year-old ‘Transformers’ and ‘Lord of the Rings’ geek played by Trevor Fehrman, is a sloppy caricature that strives and fails for the bizarro elegance of a Screech or an Urkel."

"The original was gleefully nasty for the sake of ingenious pop culture jabs, while the sequel, sadly, is raunchy for the sake of gag-inducing obscenity alone. The same is true about Smith’s trademark consumer satire."

"Sadly, ‘Clerks II’ was so bad that it actually had me pining for ‘Jersey Girl.’"

Phil Villareal, Scripps News

The sequel to Smith’s indie breakout "Clerks" (85% on the Tomatometer) has the potential to bring up the cult fave director’s own Tomatometer ranking, which started out strong with 1994’s "Clerks," dipped with 1995’s "Mallrats" (58%), peaked with 1997’s "Chasing Amy" (93% Tomatometer), and subsequently declined following 1999’s "Dogma" (67%), 2001’s "Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back" (53%), and 2004’s "Jersey Girl" (41%).

Tag Cloud

suspense indiana jones psychological thriller Rocketman theme song IFC Films Television Critics Association Sundance Now sag awards Turner The Purge Stephen King Lucasfilm fast and furious AMC Plus blockbusters indie zombie Trailer mcc Musical popular Paramount Plus Thanksgiving critic resources E! FX 2016 Toys hist ITV Captain marvel golden globe awards basketball mockumentary razzies TCA Winter 2020 Tags: Comedy TCA Awards MGM VOD APB 2020 cops docudrama revenge The Walking Dead 20th Century Fox Paramount Pictures Heroines Apple series mutant psycho ABC Nat Geo Comics on TV Tarantino natural history screenings Comic-Con@Home 2021 emmy awards hollywood Anna Paquin TV One rotten DC Comics Character Guide animated finale Superheroe President ABC Signature Endgame venice target films Sony Pictures heist movie marvel cinematic universe Star Wars best Neflix aliens YA cats Travel Channel Interview Television Academy TCA 2017 universal monsters Watching Series international rotten movies we love WarnerMedia Classic Film diversity PlayStation Esquire Britbox movie Showtime witnail Best and Worst politics latino DGA ghosts Vudu Shudder Family CBS All Access Chernobyl Reality Competition doctor who legend dreamworks summer TV preview Spike LGBTQ LGBT anime football El Rey Hallmark classics young adult Grammys Wes Anderson Video Games know your critic Netflix OWN Syfy Amazon Prime Video technology crime concert Tumblr Adult Swim cinemax Cannes Musicals war Winter TV wonder woman blaxploitation Crunchyroll art house Red Carpet Sundance TV BBC America Set visit saw Martial Arts The Academy See It Skip It new star wars movies Podcast Marvel Television Focus Features trophy all-time TCA Avengers cancelled SundanceTV Amazon Studios olympics Premiere Dates kong PaleyFest 45 justice league stop motion Rock festival Disney Plus Box Office vs. japan Spring TV obituary USA 2021 CBS dark Shondaland DC streaming service political drama Disney Channel IFC television supernatural dc IMDb TV 1990s Fox Searchlight game show game of thrones Pacific Islander social media satire Emmys romance Sony Crackle Pirates Pop TV Peacock trailers superhero marvel comics spain Marvel TV renewals italian Opinion james bond Lifetime cancelled TV series TV Holiday tv talk miniseries live action deadpool scene in color series Star Trek twilight thriller TNT summer TV Election Hulu comedies halloween tv Arrowverse 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Ellie Kemper renewed TV shows VICE Freeform Best Actress Native Emmy Nominations broadcast HBO true crime RT21 teaser elevated horror Extras Logo adaptation First Reviews Song of Ice and Fire Quiz genre comic books FXX Amazon obi wan composers biography golden globes festivals Masterpiece period drama Superheroes Bravo fresh Lifetime Christmas movies archives Biopics GLAAD VH1 ID TV Land Exclusive Video YouTube Red children's TV streaming Acorn TV Trivia canceled TV shows hispanic heritage month A24 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt video on demand mob PBS green book name the review 99% The Arrangement telelvision discovery Animation Disney+ Disney Plus 24 frames Netflix Christmas movies Cartoon Network 71st Emmy Awards AMC french Baby Yoda Fall TV TruTV Spectrum Originals BAFTA slashers ESPN Photos Disney Alien HBO Max reviews franchise Universal Film royal family south america summer preview rt labs Nominations Summer leaderboard SXSW rom-coms 21st Century Fox video Black Mirror CMT GoT ratings Western Polls and Games Kids & Family spider-verse SXSW 2022 science fiction news 2015 australia Film Festival breaking bad Dark Horse Comics Sneak Peek E3 hispanic Pet Sematary cancelled TV shows kids independent Action San Diego Comic-Con Indigenous TLC werewolf spinoff godzilla police drama Christmas Certified Fresh Holidays book adaptation japanese 2017 RT History Comedy Central 72 Emmy Awards Fantasy blockbuster parents canceled king arthur asian-american anthology new york foreign laika worst Warner Bros. joker South by Southwest Film Festival USA Network Columbia Pictures prank screen actors guild a nightmare on elm street talk show stoner dragons Image Comics historical drama BBC Year in Review 79th Golden Globes Awards superman sopranos Marathons Creative Arts Emmys Paramount Network women cars 4/20 Calendar TCM scene in color film series action-comedy Drama debate stand-up comedy Awards robots Mindy Kaling biopic movies mission: impossible jurassic park Women's History Month sequels crime thriller child's play comic book movie rt labs critics edition zombies Super Bowl comic interviews vampires Music Mystery Epix 2018 TIFF spanish boxoffice casting critics live event die hard Marvel Studios First Look Tokyo Olympics kaiju posters Trophy Talk Oscar Lionsgate CW Seed HFPA Prime Video disaster what to watch Mary poppins based on movie remakes scary movies Starz book OneApp YouTube toronto dramedy Mudbound streaming movies National Geographic Pop harry potter target scene in color Ovation ViacomCBS toy story BET Rom-Com gangster unscripted comics A&E Teen travel Discovery Channel Instagram Live space 93rd Oscars Sci-Fi new zealand MCU hidden camera Legendary Apple TV Plus lord of the rings dceu FOX spanish language DC Universe spy thriller reboot nfl Country Sundance king kong high school Best Picture Mary Poppins Returns feel good cults scene in color MSNBC 2019 BBC One 90s DirecTV facebook versus binge Nickelodeon cooking X-Men Walt Disney Pictures MTV award winner Hallmark Christmas movies Rocky FX on Hulu jamie lee curtis TBS Horror Hollywood Foreign Press Association pirates of the caribbean christmas movies monster movies comic book movies YouTube Premium Tomatazos Comic Book Disney streaming service Comedy American Society of Cinematographers Cosplay BET Awards Winners serial killer Academy Awards Pride Month Schedule Best Director richard e. Grant chucky Pixar Funimation Apple TV+ SDCC NBC Binge Guide 94th Oscars Paramount sequel black Tubi worst movies strong female leads Universal Pictures dogs WGN Fox News scorecard Ghostbusters boxing batman nature HBO Go zero dark thirty sitcom Countdown CNN adenture Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Valentine's Day black comedy ABC Family docuseries 007 streamig spider-man The CW New York Comic Con crossover The Walt Disney Company Geeked Week scary directors Black History Month documentary GIFs romantic comedy Reality Oscars sports medical drama Elton John Amazon Prime Star Wars Celebration NBA Food Network slasher Infographic nbcuniversal halloween cartoon TV movies aapi free movies Mary Tyler Moore documentaries Fargo History comiccon Brie Larson Turner Classic Movies singing competition 73rd Emmy Awards criterion transformers Best Actor Broadway Awards Tour Hear Us Out adventure The Witch quibi rt archives crime drama dexter cancelled television Writers Guild of America NYCC