Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Year One Fails To Beget Laughs

Plus, The Proposal is a so-so rom-com.

by | June 18, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got Biblical bloopers (Year One, starring Jack Black and Michael Cera) and an engagement of convenience (The Proposal, starring Sandra Bullock and Ryan Reynolds). What do the critics have to say?


Year One

On paper, Year One sounds so promising; it’s an Old Testament goof starring Jack Black and Michael Cera (as well as an embarrassment of other top comedic talent) directed by Harold Ramis. Unfortunately, critics say the film’s jokes are nearly as ancient and musty as its protagonists. Black and Cera star as a pair of lazy hunter-gatherers who have been banished from their tribe. They become nomads and unwittingly provide a guided tour of the Book of Genesis, meeting the likes of Cain and Abel and visiting Sodom along the way. Critics say that as a satire, Year One is more profane than sacred, lacking the smarts of such previous historical comedies as History of the World: Part 1 or Monty Python’s Life of Brian. Worse, as a comedy it’s undisciplined, relying too much on the actors’ mugging at the expense of funny situations or dialogue. (Check out our collection of some of Jack Black’s most memorable movie faces.)


The Proposal

No one attends a romantic comedy expecting a reinvention of the wheel; what they want is a fresh take on the familiar. So while some critics find The Proposal sweet and charming, others say it’s formulaic to the point of tedium. Sandra Bullock stars as a high-powered (but ice-cold) book editor who’s in a pickle: as a Canadian citizen, her work visa is about to expire. So she enlists her assistant (Ryan Reynolds) to marry her to stay in the country, and travels with him to meet his wacky family in Alaska. Will these crazy kids make it? Some pundits say The Proposal is better than most of its genre, with good chemistry from its leads and a scene-stealing supporting turn from Betty White. Others, however, say it squanders its actors with increasingly farcical proceedings and generic plotting. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down Bullock’s best-reviewed movies, as well as our interview with Betty White, where she tells us her Five Favorite Films.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • $9.99, aa stylistically bold stop-motion meditation on the meaning of life, is at 86 percent.
  • Under Our Skin, a documentary about the threat of Lyme disease, is at 83 percent.
  • End of the Line, a doc about the perils of overfishing, is at 81 percent.
  • The Windmill Movie, an autobiographical film by film professor and director Richard P. Rogers that was completed after his death by one of his students, is at 63 percent.
  • Dead Snow, a Norwegian horror/comedy about an army of Nazi zombies, is at 61 percent.
  • Woody Allen‘s Whatever Works, starring Larry David and Patricia Clarkson in the tale of an upper-crust New Yorker who longs to lead a bohemian existence, is at 53 percent.

Tag Cloud

Syfy debate TCA cooking comic Mudbound parents CBS Crunchyroll halloween tv Neflix mob ViacomCBS Pet Sematary SundanceTV biography NYCC streaming movies Infographic BAFTA Musicals dreamworks Classic Film Logo Holidays VOD Watching Series WarnerMedia Brie Larson 2020 Comedy Pop TV justice league TCA Winter 2020 classics Endgame Set visit Lucasfilm PaleyFest teaser movies Rock Video Games spanish genre Pop LGBTQ binge A24 ghosts The Walking Dead Hallmark Christmas movies Prime Video toronto know your critic cats TV One Star Trek comic books TV Land renewed TV shows heist movie 71st Emmy Awards Amazon Studios DirecTV 73rd Emmy Awards Stephen King christmas movies GLAAD supernatural zero dark thirty AMC Mary Tyler Moore elevated horror worst adenture remakes Fantasy superman TCA 2017 based on movie 2019 BBC Certified Fresh Quiz spanish language The Purge marvel comics Hulu Fox Searchlight The Academy First Look Summer cancelled television free movies TV Film Festival best crime Esquire dceu mutant aapi documentary cinemax FX Writers Guild of America Sundance hollywood Marathons wonder woman mission: impossible HBO Go movie Polls and Games Netflix Christmas movies Oscars king kong directors comics Kids & Family dexter NBC See It Skip It doctor who Instagram Live Winners Horror rt archives Reality IMDb TV BET Awards films Rocky ratings superhero hidden camera TV movies spider-man blaxploitation mcc 24 frames The Arrangement PBS Ovation A&E Anna Paquin popular zombies Amazon Prime Video docudrama The Walt Disney Company facebook Disney+ Disney Plus Crackle BBC One romantic comedy Family composers BET Bravo Academy Awards Fargo Walt Disney Pictures reboot Disney Plus LGBT boxoffice Animation sopranos olympics WGN gangster Dark Horse Comics women Mystery posters Opinion rotten fresh Apple TV Plus Disney Channel VICE sag awards historical drama nfl Fox News period drama TIFF series pirates of the caribbean feel good spain anthology art house slashers Sony Pictures Lifetime Western strong female leads Spike australia 93rd Oscars Discovery Channel screen actors guild dc royal family Cannes DC Universe The Witch jamie lee curtis asian-american Turner APB Peacock Trailer Photos Television Critics Association USA Network chucky Ellie Kemper emmy awards ESPN MSNBC Captain marvel TNT 2015 Paramount Network rt labs rotten movies we love ABC Signature Lionsgate Film Paramount james bond Toys canceled TV shows Tumblr FXX king arthur Thanksgiving Grammys cancelled TV shows cartoon criterion Avengers new star wars movies science fiction canceled cancelled legend scary unscripted reviews San Diego Comic-Con CBS All Access harry potter CMT Trophy Talk name the review Valentine's Day SDCC Comedy Central Turner Classic Movies Sundance TV E3 45 GoT Music The CW new york golden globes FX on Hulu YouTube Premium ABC Teen Chernobyl OWN Television Academy El Rey cancelled TV series Mindy Kaling quibi game show History Epix green book DC Comics Amazon video Paramount Plus award winner miniseries sports TV renewals Broadway PlayStation crime thriller blockbusters Black History Month Election Starz Christmas Spectrum Originals sequel TCA Awards DC streaming service franchise Pixar satire hispanic heritage month Britbox black french Year in Review VH1 Marvel Studios Song of Ice and Fire game of thrones television Elton John MCU Emmy Nominations lord of the rings south america dogs 72 Emmy Awards 79th Golden Globes Awards sequels news kids richard e. Grant leaderboard robots Chilling Adventures of Sabrina razzies cults Funimation black comedy discovery a nightmare on elm street new zealand TruTV stoner Winter TV war AMC Plus Universal Pictures child's play halloween spy thriller crossover RT History Women's History Month hispanic Shondaland Countdown Travel Channel indie critics indiana jones OneApp serial killer Heroines kaiju Holiday politics biopic IFC young adult Box Office batman disaster prank Columbia Pictures Sneak Peek foreign Lifetime Christmas movies National Geographic Image Comics 4/20 Star Wars screenings what to watch universal monsters adventure children's TV BBC America FOX 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards American Society of Cinematographers blockbuster werewolf MTV dramedy space independent Tags: Comedy jurassic park Red Carpet archives Emmys singing competition comic book movies action-comedy scene in color 2016 animated Tomatazos Shudder DGA psychological thriller rom-coms crime drama Acorn TV Showtime Tokyo Olympics Extras Warner Bros. casting comic book movie high school President YA Interview book international Freeform Ghostbusters breaking bad monster movies Premiere Dates Mary Poppins Returns die hard 21st Century Fox live action true crime travel psycho dragons Drama Rocketman marvel cinematic universe Apple Nat Geo 90s First Reviews joker 2018 diversity TLC latino Netflix HBO stand-up comedy scary movies laika anime Legendary trophy TBS scorecard Country all-time ABC Family GIFs technology natural history Wes Anderson rt labs critics edition target Cartoon Network thriller italian telelvision Comic-Con@Home 2021 streaming spinoff medical drama RT21 007 IFC Films Sundance Now Hollywood Foreign Press Association social media Pacific Islander vs. YouTube Red video on demand golden globe awards boxing X-Men documentaries Nominations Action Superheroe 2021 Awards Tour Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt 99% Superheroes CNN New York Comic Con festival romance Disney talk show Trivia Tarantino spider-verse transformers Creative Arts Emmys cars Awards Adult Swim Pride Month Schedule basketball Super Bowl Character Guide Black Mirror Mary poppins YouTube worst movies finale NBA Baby Yoda Amazon Prime SXSW aliens trailers Apple TV+ political drama Cosplay Masterpiece football mockumentary E! Hallmark Spring TV critic resources tv talk TCM ITV Marvel hist Sci-Fi theme song 1990s Hear Us Out deadpool fast and furious Reality Competition sitcom CW Seed Biopics zombie stop motion Binge Guide vampires Comic Book comedies 2017 Arrowverse HFPA venice Vudu kong festivals Musical twilight Best and Worst Food Network Martial Arts nbcuniversal Universal japanese Podcast Nickelodeon revenge witnail japan Pirates Disney streaming service HBO Max saw Comics on TV book adaptation adaptation nature 20th Century Fox comiccon cops versus godzilla concert Rom-Com USA toy story suspense Alien Exclusive Video obituary Marvel Television Fall TV dark Calendar ID docuseries live event Tubi police drama slasher