Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Lucky One Can't Catch a Break

Plus, Think Like a Man is elevated by a great cast, and Chimpanzee offers breathtaking footage.

by | April 20, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a picture-perfect romance (The Lucky One, starring Zac Efron and Taylor Schilling), relationship advice (Think Like a Man, starring Michael Ealy and Meagan Good), and a curious little monkey (Disneynature’s Chimpanzee, narrated by Tim Allen). What do the critics have to say?

The Lucky One


At this point, we know what we’re getting from a film based on a Nicholas Sparks novel: syrupy romance and melodramatic plot twists. Not that there’s anything inherently wrong with that, and critics say The Lucky One has moments of escapism, but it’s ultimately hampered by an overabundance of schmaltzy clichés. Zac Efron stars as a Marine serving in Iraq who finds a photo of an unknown woman in the desert, which he carries with him until the end of his tour of duty and seems to bring him good luck. Upon returning to the States, he treks across the country to find her, and passion ensues. The pundits say The Lucky One is occasionally swoony, but it’s also seriously contrived and formulaic — in other words, it’s pretty similar to other Sparks adaptations.

Think Like a Man


Sometimes an excellent cast can elevate even the most shopworn material. Case in point: Think Like a Man, which critics say would be a pretty mediocre romantic comedy if not for the combined efforts of its players. Based upon Steve Harvey’s self-help tome Act Like a Lady, Think Like a Man, the film follows four guys (including Michael Ealy and Kevin Hart) whose love interests have treated them differently after reading the book. As a result, the guys decide to scour its contents for advice on how to turn the tables on the ladies (whose ranks include Meagan Good, Regina Hall, and Taraji P. Henson). The pundits say the script is pretty generic, but the actors give it their all, and the result is a pretty funny take on modern romance.



Since 2009, Disneynature has celebrated Earth Day with a feature length nature documentary. This year’s selection is Chimpanzee, and critics say it’s a remarkably intimate look at our primate friends – though it’s sometimes over reliant on heavy-handed narration. Chimpanzee is the story of Oscar, a young chimp growing up within an extended family; when things take a dark turn for the little ape, he gets support from an unexpected source. The pundits say Chimpanzee often anthropomorphizes its subjects, but the footage is so amazing — and the chimps are so cute — that you and your family probably won’t mind too much. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down some of cinema’s most memorable chimp movies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • The Day He Arrives, a dramedy about a washed-up filmmaker wandering around Seoul and meeting up with old friends, is at 100 percent.
  • Marley, a documentary on the life and music of reggae’s greatest star, is at 96 percent.
  • Oki’s Movie, about a woman who documents climbing a mountain twice — each time with a different boyfriend — is at 86 percent.
  • Inside Hana’s Suitcase, a doc about the search for information regarding a mysterious suitcase delivered to the Tokyo Holocaust Museum, is at 73 percent.
  • Downtown Express, a drama about a Russian classical violinist whose life changes when he meets an attractive singer-songwriter, is at 71 percent.
  • The Eye of the Storm, starring Charlotte Rampling and Geoffrey Rush in a drama about the children of a dying woman dealing with her negative influence, is at 68 percent.
  • To the Arctic, a doc that follows a family of polar bears through a changing environment, is at 67 percent.
  • The French import Goodbye First Love, a drama about a young woman still profoundly affected by a teenage romance, is at 65 percent.
  • Fightville, a doc about the world of minor league mixed martial arts, is at 50 percent.
  • The Moth Diaries, a horror film about a grieving young woman who suspects one of her classmates is a vampire, is at 20 percent.
  • Darling Companion, starring Diane Keaton and Kevin Kline in a dramedy about an aging couple who rekindle the spark in their relationship while caring for a rescued dog, is at 10 percent (check out director Lawrence Kasdan’s Five Favorite Films here).

Tag Cloud

Summer Mary poppins james bond A&E 24 frames TCA criterion directors slashers Amazon Studios anime video on demand rotten movies we love dceu Crackle Captain marvel 007 ITV comedies National Geographic Pop worst BBC America APB Awards Tour Hallmark Christmas movies robots festivals game show Trophy Talk biography quibi GoT HBO Go ratings Lifetime Christmas movies rt archives IFC politics TCM 2020 Election kids foreign casting period drama Marathons Turner Classic Movies Arrowverse comiccon medical drama nature strong female leads space based on movie Super Bowl black Sundance Now twilight DGA social media Travel Channel discovery Film BAFTA screenings scary movies spider-man sequels natural history Starz franchise See It Skip It Dark Horse Comics Hallmark Toys Emmy Nominations FOX technology Emmys Musical cops The Academy BBC One political drama cinemax Discovery Channel Endgame zombies Comics on TV batman Schedule Netflix Christmas movies reboot Avengers 72 Emmy Awards romance cults adaptation harry potter Spike Trivia comic vampires singing competition Marvel Studios X-Men Crunchyroll boxoffice Thanksgiving cancelled Drama Comedy Central Alien WGN cancelled TV shows Animation RT21 canceled italian Biopics romantic comedy WarnerMedia VICE archives theme song FXX aliens Opinion what to watch canceled TV shows Food Network movie Polls and Games werewolf Rocky Anna Paquin Britbox Extras Trailer spinoff Lifetime Showtime Cartoon Network The Walking Dead thriller best RT History spanish language Martial Arts die hard cancelled television Kids & Family Reality Nominations Peacock news facebook venice Sneak Peek football halloween tv Box Office mockumentary Action superhero parents Tubi 4/20 australia documentaries Western PaleyFest crime thriller finale Paramount Network Teen crime teaser japanese screen actors guild animated Star Trek Hulu ABC 2018 Certified Fresh diversity Family 99% President Christmas spanish worst movies boxing documentary transformers chucky Best and Worst NYCC GLAAD police drama comics independent Holiday Sundance TV psychological thriller movies richard e. Grant Comedy Sci-Fi Esquire game of thrones free movies Cannes Adult Swim spy thriller green book Lionsgate Funimation Disney Plus critics Freeform Cosplay Disney Amazon Mindy Kaling Mudbound Walt Disney Pictures GIFs Superheroes HBO Max dc YouTube Superheroe true crime reviews Infographic First Reviews PBS children's TV Shudder First Look HBO Music TNT Video Games Photos Elton John Brie Larson TruTV MCU Star Wars Amazon Prime joker SundanceTV DC streaming service Paramount Spring TV Winners TIFF MSNBC Rom-Com 2019 toy story asian-american ghosts 45 Winter TV Black History Month SXSW Warner Bros. Valentine's Day DirecTV San Diego Comic-Con Columbia Pictures BBC 2015 child's play cooking travel E3 Apple TV+ Universal Year in Review Rock IFC Films Marvel Television supernatural Apple blaxploitation Syfy PlayStation YouTube Red remakes A24 Tarantino Heroines revenge Nat Geo Chilling Adventures of Sabrina films Writers Guild of America Calendar latino Creative Arts Emmys 2017 Pop TV Awards docudrama composers TV TBS Musicals stop motion comic books Mary Tyler Moore CBS Fantasy Apple TV Plus zombie talk show hispanic concert Watching Series adventure Comic Book dramedy series The Witch TV Land TCA 2017 ABC Family fast and furious Classic Film ESPN Ovation crime drama a nightmare on elm street cats book dogs spain TCA Awards Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt sequel VOD NBC nbcuniversal stoner 21st Century Fox LGBTQ Bravo Podcast Pride Month Black Mirror laika Logo DC Universe Grammys toronto Acorn TV Disney+ Disney Plus stand-up comedy doctor who YA serial killer CW Seed french Fall TV video Interview Television Critics Association breaking bad dark Baby Yoda New York Comic Con Tumblr VH1 Mystery BET YouTube Premium blockbuster cars Film Festival name the review Chernobyl Amazon Prime Video Turner historical drama Countdown sports indiana jones Epix satire hist Shondaland CMT ID halloween USA cancelled TV series E! rotten Red Carpet Nickelodeon emmy awards nfl renewed TV shows jamie lee curtis Television Academy TCA Winter 2020 all-time Ghostbusters justice league Reality Competition Hear Us Out Country TV renewals deadpool Masterpiece tv talk Sundance fresh award winner LGBT sag awards TLC 20th Century Fox miniseries Oscars disaster universal monsters The Arrangement cartoon Song of Ice and Fire mission: impossible dragons witnail christmas movies crossover DC Comics war anthology Quiz streaming classics Tomatazos BET Awards unscripted CBS All Access CNN festival Fox Searchlight zero dark thirty History Mary Poppins Returns 2016 psycho Fox News Ellie Kemper El Rey FX on Hulu scorecard Rocketman AMC Character Guide USA Network obituary sitcom television golden globes versus south america OWN mutant 71st Emmy Awards American Society of Cinematographers Vudu hollywood Marvel Binge Guide Pixar Lucasfilm FX Holidays The Purge Set visit elevated horror Netflix Academy Awards The CW binge Stephen King Disney streaming service Spectrum Originals Pirates MTV OneApp indie Horror Sony Pictures science fiction SDCC Pet Sematary Disney Channel Premiere Dates Women's History Month