Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Lucky One Can't Catch a Break

Plus, Think Like a Man is elevated by a great cast, and Chimpanzee offers breathtaking footage.

by | April 20, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a picture-perfect romance (The Lucky One, starring Zac Efron and Taylor Schilling), relationship advice (Think Like a Man, starring Michael Ealy and Meagan Good), and a curious little monkey (Disneynature’s Chimpanzee, narrated by Tim Allen). What do the critics have to say?

The Lucky One


At this point, we know what we’re getting from a film based on a Nicholas Sparks novel: syrupy romance and melodramatic plot twists. Not that there’s anything inherently wrong with that, and critics say The Lucky One has moments of escapism, but it’s ultimately hampered by an overabundance of schmaltzy clichés. Zac Efron stars as a Marine serving in Iraq who finds a photo of an unknown woman in the desert, which he carries with him until the end of his tour of duty and seems to bring him good luck. Upon returning to the States, he treks across the country to find her, and passion ensues. The pundits say The Lucky One is occasionally swoony, but it’s also seriously contrived and formulaic — in other words, it’s pretty similar to other Sparks adaptations.

Think Like a Man


Sometimes an excellent cast can elevate even the most shopworn material. Case in point: Think Like a Man, which critics say would be a pretty mediocre romantic comedy if not for the combined efforts of its players. Based upon Steve Harvey’s self-help tome Act Like a Lady, Think Like a Man, the film follows four guys (including Michael Ealy and Kevin Hart) whose love interests have treated them differently after reading the book. As a result, the guys decide to scour its contents for advice on how to turn the tables on the ladies (whose ranks include Meagan Good, Regina Hall, and Taraji P. Henson). The pundits say the script is pretty generic, but the actors give it their all, and the result is a pretty funny take on modern romance.



Since 2009, Disneynature has celebrated Earth Day with a feature length nature documentary. This year’s selection is Chimpanzee, and critics say it’s a remarkably intimate look at our primate friends – though it’s sometimes over reliant on heavy-handed narration. Chimpanzee is the story of Oscar, a young chimp growing up within an extended family; when things take a dark turn for the little ape, he gets support from an unexpected source. The pundits say Chimpanzee often anthropomorphizes its subjects, but the footage is so amazing — and the chimps are so cute — that you and your family probably won’t mind too much. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down some of cinema’s most memorable chimp movies.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • The Day He Arrives, a dramedy about a washed-up filmmaker wandering around Seoul and meeting up with old friends, is at 100 percent.
  • Marley, a documentary on the life and music of reggae’s greatest star, is at 96 percent.
  • Oki’s Movie, about a woman who documents climbing a mountain twice — each time with a different boyfriend — is at 86 percent.
  • Inside Hana’s Suitcase, a doc about the search for information regarding a mysterious suitcase delivered to the Tokyo Holocaust Museum, is at 73 percent.
  • Downtown Express, a drama about a Russian classical violinist whose life changes when he meets an attractive singer-songwriter, is at 71 percent.
  • The Eye of the Storm, starring Charlotte Rampling and Geoffrey Rush in a drama about the children of a dying woman dealing with her negative influence, is at 68 percent.
  • To the Arctic, a doc that follows a family of polar bears through a changing environment, is at 67 percent.
  • The French import Goodbye First Love, a drama about a young woman still profoundly affected by a teenage romance, is at 65 percent.
  • Fightville, a doc about the world of minor league mixed martial arts, is at 50 percent.
  • The Moth Diaries, a horror film about a grieving young woman who suspects one of her classmates is a vampire, is at 20 percent.
  • Darling Companion, starring Diane Keaton and Kevin Kline in a dramedy about an aging couple who rekindle the spark in their relationship while caring for a rescued dog, is at 10 percent (check out director Lawrence Kasdan’s Five Favorite Films here).

Tag Cloud

james bond south america Paramount Network docuseries crossover Apple SDCC basketball discovery laika concert game show Toys Disney Plus TV movies OneApp 99% IFC Films cults National Geographic facebook Fall TV Tubi Funimation Amazon Studios Sony Pictures book adaptation king arthur YA 71st Emmy Awards SXSW king kong Fox Searchlight Legendary franchise black movie spider-man independent Hallmark Masterpiece kids police drama thriller USA comic books christmas movies international aliens renewed TV shows CBS heist movie justice league Apple TV Plus Wes Anderson italian Awards Tour Binge Guide 45 latino boxing Spectrum Originals Fox News live action batman Starz boxoffice all-time NYCC nbcuniversal Tarantino Endgame Women's History Month Ovation Peacock video on demand RT History fast and furious emmy awards DGA sequel cancelled TV shows Animation Walt Disney Pictures PBS Syfy HBO Go 4/20 romantic comedy stoner cartoon award winner tv talk Marathons FX ABC binge transformers doctor who Avengers CBS All Access legend stop motion 1990s The Arrangement Disney Channel Marvel MSNBC Travel Channel ratings NBC docudrama E3 Election Trophy Talk Esquire Musical Video Games crime thriller ITV Super Bowl HBO Max DC Comics strong female leads rotten movies we love Ghostbusters 2019 blockbusters FX on Hulu Nat Geo japanese 93rd Oscars YouTube Premium reviews Star Trek natural history dramedy green book razzies MCU comics Biopics slashers Christmas Comic-Con@Home 2021 canceled TV shows satire Pop First Reviews 90s Valentine's Day Black History Month Pixar werewolf comic Lifetime Christmas movies obituary hollywood TCA Awards olympics History stand-up comedy TCA Winter 2020 Kids & Family Comics on TV Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt TCM period drama historical drama blockbuster animated American Society of Cinematographers documentaries medical drama Television Critics Association aapi Mary Tyler Moore Extras remakes ID telelvision PlayStation sequels 20th Century Fox 2015 Broadway Classic Film Turner Classic Movies Countdown trailers adaptation TV Land true crime FXX Warner Bros. Premiere Dates Marvel Studios Creative Arts Emmys Certified Fresh indie spy thriller A24 streaming movies diversity Sundance Now Rock Tomatazos 2018 Mindy Kaling Opinion Amazon documentary kong hispanic Podcast PaleyFest Bravo Grammys Turner video Reality The Walt Disney Company worst movies Hear Us Out halloween tv based on movie Paramount Plus SundanceTV Film The CW Oscars cancelled television Freeform Rom-Com Music miniseries pirates of the caribbean Pacific Islander Horror Tumblr VH1 robots Polls and Games Captain marvel crime parents Family Schedule WarnerMedia halloween Photos reboot anthology Disney Pride Month revenge hidden camera spanish language The Academy Awards a nightmare on elm street Netflix Christmas movies San Diego Comic-Con Teen disaster Food Network prank spinoff dark cats Lifetime Black Mirror classics Britbox what to watch The Walking Dead Image Comics 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards New York Comic Con Summer versus Columbia Pictures science fiction Universal romance Red Carpet First Look die hard godzilla TV MTV Western TNT directors Nominations Discovery Channel Paramount Adult Swim technology sitcom dceu Spike asian-american elevated horror biography best Holidays Marvel Television TCA 2017 cars Year in Review Character Guide screen actors guild Hallmark Christmas movies new star wars movies Lionsgate WGN Arrowverse Logo anime TruTV women ABC Signature blaxploitation lord of the rings children's TV X-Men cinemax television 2021 foreign indiana jones A&E Pet Sematary Epix Mary Poppins Returns El Rey casting marvel cinematic universe Crackle toronto comiccon The Purge Netflix Heroines Star Wars war Cannes VOD deadpool child's play Musicals singing competition NBA GLAAD Shudder ABC Family USA Network Pirates Academy Awards monster movies Mudbound vampires Action mutant psychological thriller book AMC E! Superheroes sports Sci-Fi Shondaland spain superman Elton John Mary poppins Vudu saw know your critic Pop TV BBC Hulu mockumentary Film Festival universal monsters DC Universe target comedies APB theme song DC streaming service rom-coms 21st Century Fox golden globes rt archives DirecTV spanish criterion zombies Interview harry potter golden globe awards TV renewals CMT series RT21 Brie Larson Television Academy Nickelodeon joker ViacomCBS Trailer 007 Acorn TV political drama VICE Box Office twilight films Sundance streaming LGBTQ Amazon Prime IFC Mystery The Witch Watching Series festival news CNN new york nature Winter TV free movies Calendar witnail Cosplay french Sneak Peek supernatural toy story popular Set visit Writers Guild of America travel President BBC America GIFs canceled ghosts 24 frames Sundance TV scorecard Apple TV+ Drama name the review cancelled TV series BET Awards Chilling Adventures of Sabrina dogs critics high school social media Crunchyroll quibi cops archives Cartoon Network zombie scary movies Showtime Emmy Nominations Lucasfilm Disney streaming service composers fresh Comedy Central LGBT talk show FOX venice Comic Book Rocky crime drama richard e. Grant sag awards mission: impossible Stephen King dc superhero TBS Tokyo Olympics hist YouTube Red Amazon Prime Video adventure ESPN Best and Worst zero dark thirty serial killer teaser finale Holiday Trivia Comedy australia TLC Disney+ Disney Plus worst See It Skip It Martial Arts Quiz cancelled TIFF 2020 screenings GoT OWN 2016 scene in color Spring TV BBC One Infographic breaking bad dragons HBO Winners suspense 2017 Reality Competition Fantasy festivals Rocketman Emmys politics wonder woman Baby Yoda Dark Horse Comics Chernobyl nfl BAFTA football new zealand CW Seed game of thrones rotten adenture chucky jurassic park 72 Emmy Awards jamie lee curtis space Anna Paquin Alien unscripted Superheroe japan Country kaiju Exclusive Video BET cooking TV One psycho TCA Ellie Kemper movies YouTube Song of Ice and Fire Thanksgiving