Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Dark Knight Is One Of The Year's Best-Reviewed

Plus, Mamma Mia! is not a super trouper; Chimps is lost in Space.

by | July 17, 2008 | Comments

This week, we’ve got the Caped Crusader (The Dark Knight, starring
Christian Bale and
Heath Ledger), ABBA aficionados (Mamma Mia!, starring
Meryl Streep and
Amanda Seyfried), and space-bound simians (Space Chimps, with voice work by
Andy Samberg and
Jeff Daniels). What do the critics have to say?

The wait is over, Batfans. And the word is good. Critics are calling The Dark Knight one of the year’s best, a brooding, complex, emotionally wrenching film that plumbs the emotional depths of the Batman mythos. The sequel to the series reboot
Batman Begins, TDK finds Bruce Wayne/ Batman (Christian Bale) tangling with his most iconic archenemy, the Joker (Heath Ledger) — while finding the two have more in common than they’d like to admit. The pundits give kudos all around, from
Christopher Nolan‘s white-knuckle direction and provocative script to the able cast that includes
Michael Caine,
Maggie Gyllenhaal, and
Aaron Eckhart. But much of the critical gushing is reserved for the late Ledger, who plays the Joker like a man possessed (some suggest the Academy should take notice of his performance). At 93 percent on the Tomatometer, The Dark Knight isn’t just Certified Fresh. It’s also the best-reviewed Batman movie of all time, and the third best-reviewed wide release of the year, trailing only
WALL-E at (97 percent) and
Iron Man (at 93 percent). (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we revisit all the Batman movies.)

“If only getting the Time Warner cable guy were this easy.”

It is a fact that you can dance. It is also true that you can jive. However, will you have the time of your life at Mamma Mia? Critics aren’t quite going that far. Meryl Streep stars as a single mother whose daughter (Amanda Seyfried) is about to get married, and has invited three men to her wedding in Greece, trying to determine which is her real father; romance and renditions of “S.O.S.” and “Waterloo” ensue. Nobody denies ABBA’s tunes are darned infections (noted fans include
Sid Vicious and
John McCain), and some pundits concede Mamma Mia! has moments of frothy fun. However, others say the movie is ultimately way too sugary, sentimental, and lightweight to truly satisfy, and though Streep is in fine form, others in the cast don’t fare as well with the musical numbers. At 47 percent on the Tomatometer, the scribes aren’t falling “Head Over Heels” for Mamma Mia!

“Let me show you a fast way to wax the banister.”

Monkeys and chimps were some of the earliest space travelers, so an animated take on their exploits would seem like a sure bet for the kiddies, right? Well, critics aren’t going bananas for the CGI feature
Space Chimps
. Ham III (voiced by Andy Samberg) is the good-for-nothing grandson of a space pioneer who finds himself part of team of chimps who have been blasted through a black hole, where they find a planet ruled by and evil monarch. The pundits say Space Chimps is bland and dull, featuring indifferent animation and a tired storyline that may please really little kids but virtually no one else. At
21 percent on the Tomatometer, these Chimps are lost in space.

The mission: Research the effects of zero gravity on the Tomatometer.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Batman Movies:
84% — Batman Begins (2005)
12% — Batman & Robin (1997)
43% — Batman Forever (1995)
87% — Batman: Mask of the Phantasm (1993)
79% — Batman Returns (1992)
69% — Batman (1989)
80% — Batman: The Movie (1966)

Tag Cloud

Pop Spike cancelled TV series Trivia renewed TV shows crossover foreign festivals cinemax Freeform crime thriller zero dark thirty NYCC Super Bowl HBO Max Ellie Kemper 2018 Year in Review Sneak Peek romance vampires ITV TCA USA science fiction Apple Turner HBO unscripted Logo Reality Competition Grammys travel latino USA Network FXX Shondaland Best and Worst Video Games diversity Dark Horse Comics Holidays Comedy WarnerMedia YouTube Red spinoff Holiday cooking Hulu Superheroe Musical adventure 007 war Fall TV ghosts transformers kids Women's History Month E3 movies award winner elevated horror book justice league sag awards The Walking Dead The CW Fox News Rocketman disaster 2016 Mindy Kaling south america Film Festival discovery crime Film hispanic TCM aliens Netflix period drama Disney Plus streaming Rock Awards Paramount Network 2019 FOX CMT History Tarantino true crime Star Wars historical drama anthology Awards Tour facebook Certified Fresh The Purge Pet Sematary LGBT green book zombie Mary Tyler Moore Amazon Prime Apple TV Plus TV Land cartoon RT21 Pixar TIFF VH1 Oscars Martial Arts Captain marvel Netflix Christmas movies Election richard e. Grant CW Seed Toys television RT History Amazon Prime Video Mary poppins Rocky Teen Podcast Countdown Summer CNN IFC psycho Amazon DirecTV Sundance Now romantic comedy SundanceTV APB 20th Century Fox Epix TLC blaxploitation CBS Set visit Walt Disney Pictures Columbia Pictures GIFs NBC technology Binge Guide police drama dceu MTV supernatural Extras Opinion OWN comic Red Carpet 21st Century Fox Lifetime Christmas movies Thanksgiving canceled TV shows medical drama sequel Character Guide Tumblr WGN Kids & Family spanish language Sony Pictures cancelled television Heroines TBS Acorn TV Adult Swim DC streaming service Crackle zombies PBS Stephen King spider-man First Reviews 2020 canceled San Diego Comic-Con witnail GoT Quiz Lifetime The Witch Musicals FX Lucasfilm Family IFC Films Comedy Central Creative Arts Emmys Watching Series anime game show Marvel Television Apple TV+ PaleyFest talk show Action Cannes Spring TV Arrowverse Ghostbusters slashers LGBTQ Marathons Syfy Bravo MCU Trophy Talk spain Esquire dramedy comics TCA 2017 Infographic DGA what to watch natural history President Cosplay Disney+ Disney Plus binge Tomatazos American Society of Cinematographers breaking bad Music A&E Trailer animated revenge Starz batman Writers Guild of America cancelled Television Academy politics cancelled TV shows Turner Classic Movies Sundance children's TV Pride Month adaptation Mudbound robots comiccon series Warner Bros. blockbuster ABC Brie Larson 71st Emmy Awards Comic Book tv talk teaser Emmys YA werewolf cults mutant GLAAD singing competition dragons Marvel doctor who screen actors guild nature BBC America stand-up comedy crime drama joker dc Winners thriller SXSW AMC Song of Ice and Fire rotten movies we love Peacock Endgame Horror Box Office Sci-Fi name the review sitcom biography Disney Mary Poppins Returns X-Men social media Food Network First Look TruTV Emmy Nominations VICE psychological thriller Disney streaming service cops El Rey game of thrones DC Universe Calendar golden globes DC Comics independent TV Nominations Disney Channel Crunchyroll composers Drama Comics on TV National Geographic casting space Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Elton John boxoffice theme song toy story Lionsgate political drama ABC Family free movies Paramount Interview Christmas YouTube Premium Universal TV renewals See It Skip It Showtime Western Valentine's Day Chernobyl Reality TNT Polls and Games Mystery ESPN based on movie miniseries SDCC 45 finale cars Ovation Vudu Britbox indie Winter TV Superheroes E! Pirates 2015 sports Biopics strong female leads Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Black Mirror Animation Rom-Com Hallmark Nat Geo 2017 versus Country BBC ratings YouTube Star Trek harry potter quibi Premiere Dates CBS All Access 24 frames Classic Film cats BET jamie lee curtis Marvel Studios hist serial killer screenings Spectrum Originals Anna Paquin MSNBC mockumentary New York Comic Con Shudder spy thriller The Arrangement Schedule Nickelodeon video Photos christmas movies Fantasy Cartoon Network halloween docudrama A24 Masterpiece Avengers Hallmark Christmas movies