Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Dark Knight Is One Of The Year's Best-Reviewed

Plus, Mamma Mia! is not a super trouper; Chimps is lost in Space.

by | July 17, 2008 | Comments

This week, we’ve got the Caped Crusader (The Dark Knight, starring
Christian Bale and
Heath Ledger), ABBA aficionados (Mamma Mia!, starring
Meryl Streep and
Amanda Seyfried), and space-bound simians (Space Chimps, with voice work by
Andy Samberg and
Jeff Daniels). What do the critics have to say?

The wait is over, Batfans. And the word is good. Critics are calling The Dark Knight one of the year’s best, a brooding, complex, emotionally wrenching film that plumbs the emotional depths of the Batman mythos. The sequel to the series reboot
Batman Begins, TDK finds Bruce Wayne/ Batman (Christian Bale) tangling with his most iconic archenemy, the Joker (Heath Ledger) — while finding the two have more in common than they’d like to admit. The pundits give kudos all around, from
Christopher Nolan‘s white-knuckle direction and provocative script to the able cast that includes
Michael Caine,
Maggie Gyllenhaal, and
Aaron Eckhart. But much of the critical gushing is reserved for the late Ledger, who plays the Joker like a man possessed (some suggest the Academy should take notice of his performance). At 93 percent on the Tomatometer, The Dark Knight isn’t just Certified Fresh. It’s also the best-reviewed Batman movie of all time, and the third best-reviewed wide release of the year, trailing only
WALL-E at (97 percent) and
Iron Man (at 93 percent). (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we revisit all the Batman movies.)

“If only getting the Time Warner cable guy were this easy.”

It is a fact that you can dance. It is also true that you can jive. However, will you have the time of your life at Mamma Mia? Critics aren’t quite going that far. Meryl Streep stars as a single mother whose daughter (Amanda Seyfried) is about to get married, and has invited three men to her wedding in Greece, trying to determine which is her real father; romance and renditions of “S.O.S.” and “Waterloo” ensue. Nobody denies ABBA’s tunes are darned infections (noted fans include
Sid Vicious and
John McCain), and some pundits concede Mamma Mia! has moments of frothy fun. However, others say the movie is ultimately way too sugary, sentimental, and lightweight to truly satisfy, and though Streep is in fine form, others in the cast don’t fare as well with the musical numbers. At 47 percent on the Tomatometer, the scribes aren’t falling “Head Over Heels” for Mamma Mia!

“Let me show you a fast way to wax the banister.”

Monkeys and chimps were some of the earliest space travelers, so an animated take on their exploits would seem like a sure bet for the kiddies, right? Well, critics aren’t going bananas for the CGI feature
Space Chimps
. Ham III (voiced by Andy Samberg) is the good-for-nothing grandson of a space pioneer who finds himself part of team of chimps who have been blasted through a black hole, where they find a planet ruled by and evil monarch. The pundits say Space Chimps is bland and dull, featuring indifferent animation and a tired storyline that may please really little kids but virtually no one else. At
21 percent on the Tomatometer, these Chimps are lost in space.

The mission: Research the effects of zero gravity on the Tomatometer.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Batman Movies:
84% — Batman Begins (2005)
12% — Batman & Robin (1997)
43% — Batman Forever (1995)
87% — Batman: Mask of the Phantasm (1993)
79% — Batman Returns (1992)
69% — Batman (1989)
80% — Batman: The Movie (1966)

Tag Cloud

werewolf game show HBO quibi toronto Netflix justice league Fall TV sag awards Amazon TCA Awards First Reviews Disney+ Disney Plus HBO Go Marvel Television New York Comic Con A&E critics Tumblr Crunchyroll comic Emmy Nominations FX women DC streaming service emmy awards comedies kong romantic comedy Sundance cancelled television Tokyo Olympics Polls and Games CNN IFC Creative Arts Emmys australia Television Academy nbcuniversal international spinoff Academy Awards Avengers Cartoon Network Television Critics Association asian-american deadpool Rock technology Dark Horse Comics Election Paramount Network screen actors guild Mindy Kaling Anna Paquin hollywood golden globes Holiday Sundance Now target Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Pet Sematary The Walking Dead anthology PlayStation Comic-Con@Home 2021 book The Arrangement Amazon Studios high school Syfy FXX cancelled TV shows spain crime drama children's TV movie Baby Yoda ghosts Star Wars OWN Exclusive Video Drama Nominations aapi cops prank Schedule Grammys 2016 crossover green book reboot godzilla psycho razzies Disney Plus scorecard trailers The Purge Ovation series Brie Larson Freeform Mary Tyler Moore zombie versus dramedy documentaries animated elevated horror new york canceled marvel cinematic universe political drama natural history Musical Awards blockbuster ratings worst movies Endgame TBS teaser Pop science fiction Hallmark Winter TV History sequel Musicals 20th Century Fox Sony Pictures Winners Marathons toy story The Academy Mystery RT History halloween Music Hulu child's play rotten nfl Lifetime ABC Family cartoon SXSW spanish language witnail stoner best GIFs anime movies Kids & Family ViacomCBS 99% Paramount kids pirates of the caribbean YA Elton John comic books criterion Emmys Pixar X-Men mockumentary unscripted TV Tomatazos Epix Mudbound VOD Premiere Dates YouTube Premium true crime Masterpiece historical drama dark Pacific Islander nature Broadway richard e. Grant streaming GoT films Apple TV Plus APB TruTV romance Image Comics travel 1990s CBS Star Trek suspense lord of the rings cars BET E3 Hear Us Out diversity 2017 heist movie Wes Anderson Netflix Christmas movies ABC Signature concert boxing franchise sequels adenture Disney Channel Western video on demand Showtime Summer Shudder Food Network based on movie Acorn TV thriller italian Shondaland Set visit ITV Teen Paramount Plus disaster what to watch Lionsgate Toys Black Mirror FOX Turner aliens saw festivals japanese binge rotten movies we love GLAAD PBS Infographic Bravo LGBTQ See It Skip It Extras joker Arrowverse Binge Guide strong female leads space Marvel Studios Comics on TV Reality Vudu Comic Book VICE 2020 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Alien streaming movies TNT telelvision 2019 finale 90s canceled TV shows Black History Month Film Turner Classic Movies Cannes spider-man Lucasfilm 24 frames venice scary movies Apple TV+ 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards USA ID Interview YouTube news tv talk Opinion game of thrones TV movies Christmas free movies Superheroes WGN south america Women's History Month archives Trophy Talk 72 Emmy Awards Cosplay spy thriller book adaptation Trivia parents cats james bond festival NBC 45 First Look ESPN Quiz adaptation medical drama name the review documentary adventure RT21 japan Sundance TV spanish Disney Rocky comics Year in Review stand-up comedy video BBC America Writers Guild of America BBC One Tubi screenings indie Thanksgiving Character Guide popular Podcast renewed TV shows mission: impossible award winner WarnerMedia Comedy SDCC zombies Pirates Nat Geo mutant Funimation kaiju Captain marvel king kong casting singing competition halloween tv Universal indiana jones Comedy Central Starz 2021 Animation period drama cancelled television twilight blaxploitation cooking Stephen King scene in color USA Network American Society of Cinematographers Sci-Fi Heroines TIFF basketball Walt Disney Pictures The Witch TV renewals President 007 dogs Super Bowl superhero Britbox Columbia Pictures docuseries crime thriller Nickelodeon Red Carpet Lifetime Christmas movies discovery Trailer Chernobyl TCM El Rey crime live action Countdown Classic Film a nightmare on elm street police drama YouTube Red Ellie Kemper Film Festival olympics IFC Films Spring TV vampires social media Best and Worst cults TV One SundanceTV Logo Country doctor who Oscars new star wars movies Action ABC satire hispanic Hallmark Christmas movies Spike french Certified Fresh Amazon Prime Video golden globe awards monster movies obituary National Geographic sitcom Ghostbusters CBS All Access Marvel football dceu Family harry potter Warner Bros. MSNBC Box Office The CW Discovery Channel theme song CMT cancelled TV series DC Comics new zealand foreign VH1 TLC Fox Searchlight PaleyFest 4/20 AMC The Walt Disney Company supernatural Video Games cinemax hist Spectrum Originals San Diego Comic-Con 71st Emmy Awards NBA 93rd Oscars Travel Channel superman dragons independent Valentine's Day comiccon Watching Series jurassic park boxoffice DGA transformers blockbusters Pride Month latino rt archives Apple Esquire fresh MTV DirecTV composers zero dark thirty Pop TV Song of Ice and Fire CW Seed stop motion war NYCC Sneak Peek Horror Holidays politics 2018 Reality Competition Disney streaming service chucky serial killer LGBT Mary Poppins Returns sports Amazon Prime docudrama Photos TCA Fox News black BBC TV Land Fantasy facebook revenge Legendary miniseries Tarantino A24 Peacock biography christmas movies laika TCA Winter 2020 reviews die hard E! TCA 2017 know your critic remakes Adult Swim fast and furious Crackle all-time BET Awards legend robots dc Mary poppins Awards Tour universal monsters Biopics Rocketman MCU worst BAFTA classics Martial Arts talk show HBO Max jamie lee curtis OneApp Superheroe psychological thriller DC Universe hidden camera batman slashers directors FX on Hulu breaking bad Calendar rom-coms Rom-Com 21st Century Fox 2015