Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Footloose is Toe-Tapping Fun

Plus, The Thing doesn't have enough scares, and The Big Year is a slow but aimiable comedy.

by | October 14, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got Sunday shoe removal (Footloose, starring Kenny Wormald and Julianne Hough), an Antarctic abomination (The Thing, starring Mary Elizabeth Winstead and Joel Edgerton), and a bird watching competition (The Big Year, starring Jack Black and Owen Wilson). What do the critics have to say?



Did the world really need a new Footloose? Apparently yes, say critics, who find this update of the 1984 musical smash an energetic, toe-tapping good time. Kenny Wormald stars as the new kid in a town that has banned loud music and dancing. Can our hero melt the cold hard of Rev. Moore – and woo his daughter (Julianne Hough) in the process? The pundits say the plot is as silly as ever, but the exuberant cast and the high-energy production numbers make for a giddy night at the movies. (Check out Quaid’s best-reviewed movies, as well as director Craig Brewer’s Five Favorite Films.)

The Thing


Remake fever has spread to even the most desolate corners of the globe; unfortunately, critics say the all-new The Thing ODs on CGI mayhem, eschewing the chilling atmospherics that made its 1951 and 1982 predecessors so memorable. Mary Elizabeth Winstead stars as a paleontologist who joins a research team that has discovered an alien craft buried in Antarctica — and soon, the base camp is bedeviled by a terrifying life form. The pundits say The Thing is slicker and more effects heavy than past versions, but it lacks a strong sense of storytelling.

The Big Year


A languidly-paced comedy with a terrific cast, The Big Year isn’t always laugh-out-loud funny, critics say, but patient viewers may find it amusing in fits and starts. Jack Black, Owen Wilson, and Steve Martin star as a trio of rival birders who set out on a mission to observe the rarest feathered creatures in the wild – and deal with their personal issues in the process. The pundits say The Big Year is amiable and appealing, but its slow pace and lack of momentum makes it only occasionally funny.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

dramedy Horror Netflix NBC Masterpiece USA Esquire Reality Competition FX Universal period drama Musicals Superheroes TCA The CW biography Star Wars Ghostbusters Comedy Set visit RT History Best and Worst thriller diversity PaleyFest adventure E! Valentine's Day GoT Nickelodeon 2017 Character Guide WGN Reality Cartoon Network 2016 X-Men Winter TV Countdown Photos Premiere Dates Fantasy Winners police drama MSNBC Marvel science fiction Drama Oscars Exclusive Video DirecTV 007 Lionsgate TBS Music Amazon Writers Guild of America TCA 2017 Grammys Disney Channel Bravo politics Calendar Trivia harry potter PBS TNT Sci-Fi Rom-Com Food Network GLAAD GIFs HBO social media Nat Geo Trailer Mary Tyler Moore Awards IFC Interview Freeform Nominations Animation Fox News Video Games crime thriller Podcast Pop DC Comics CBS All Access 24 frames Box Office APB President Disney Tumblr cops ABC A&E Holidays Summer Comedy Central El Rey Certified Fresh Year in Review VH1 Emmys crime drama Martial Arts Schedule Election MTV docudrama Super Bowl Spring TV Opinion Starz Comic Book serial killer Pirates travel Syfy Sundance Fall TV Adult Swim sports Infographic SundanceTV BBC America FOX ITV Biopics singing competition CNN discovery Mystery Lifetime war Hulu comiccon vampires 2015 ESPN Country TruTV Action Red Carpet Crackle BET TV Rocky Logo Thanksgiving FXX CBS TCM Watching Series ABC Family AMC Star Trek History aliens Polls and Games OWN cooking BBC boxoffice SDCC NYCC TV Land Sneak Peek Rock Marathons CMT Extras Toys LGBTQ American Society of Cinematographers sitcom technology TIFF First Look Kids & Family Teen Showtime cinemax VICE Tomatazos Cosplay