Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: Third Time's Not the Charm for "Shrek"

by | May 17, 2007 | Comments

America is going green this week: "Shrek the Third" (featuring the voices of Mike Meyers, Eddie Murphy, and Antonio Banderas) is our single new wide release. Critics loved the first two, how do they feel about this one?

Shrek’s third outing finds our green antihero in an unusual predicament: the king has died, and Shrek is next in line to ascend to the throne. Typically, he wants nothing of it and must set off to find a replacement. Hijinks, fart jokes, and ironic postmodern deconstruction ensue. But critics say "Third" has gone too far with the "Shrek" formula: it relies too heavily on pop culture references and fairy tale spoofs, marginalizing the heart and charm that made the first two classics. Also, the sheer amount of new and returning characters has given the best characters – Shrek, Donkey, and Fiona – the least screen time in any "Shrek" yet. "Shrek the Third" is at 42 percent, a far cry from "Shrek"’s and "Shrek 2"’s 89 and 88 percent Tomatometers, respectively.

"I…am not right-handed."

And opening in limited release: "Once," a crowd-pleasing drama about two street musicians (check out our interview with director John Carney), is at 100 percent; "Severance," a British import of shock horror and droll comedy, is at 74 percent; "Brooklyn Rules," a drama set in the titular borough circa 1985, is at 56 percent; "Flanders," the new art pic from festival fave Bruno Dumont, is at 50 percent; "The Wendell Baker Story," a light-hearted drama featuring possibly more Wilson Brothers than we’re equipped to handle, is at 40 percent; "Fay Grim," the new action/thriller/comedy from quirky auteur Hal Hartley, is at 40 percent; "Even Money," a cautionary tale about the ills of gambling, is at 20 percent; and "The Last Sin Eater," the second release of Fox Faith’s Christian parable, is at 20 percent.

In "Flanders" field.

And medals, commendations, and accolades to unbreakable_samurai and SplendidIsolation who both came closest to guessing "Delta Farce"’s three percent Tomatometer last week. We, too, were surprised by its extraordinarily high rating.

Recent Mike Meyers Movies
88% – Shrek 2 (2004)
14% – View From the Top (2003)
12% – Dr. Seuss’ The Cat in the Hat (2003)
55% – Austin Powers in Goldmember (2002)
89% – Shrek (2001)

Tag Cloud

Awards Tour aliens psycho DC Comics slashers Instagram Live 45 Wes Anderson quibi Lionsgate Stephen King Netflix 79th Golden Globes Awards legend rotten movies we love Disney technology Mindy Kaling Set visit news Universal japan Creative Arts Emmys The Walt Disney Company VH1 Avengers 2021 golden globes video gangster YouTube Red marvel comics robots Legendary Trophy Talk DC Universe critics 20th Century Fox Pop streaming Logo Warner Bros. TV One cops remakes sopranos 007 doctor who trailers green book Nominations BAFTA Comics on TV Freeform Western lord of the rings 2017 Emmys Election ID 2018 99% Ghostbusters CW Seed spinoff HFPA Certified Fresh Reality Image Comics Discovery Channel dexter stop motion richard e. Grant docuseries BBC One Rocky strong female leads TV movies IMDb TV Bravo Musical Schedule dogs tv talk historical drama Universal Pictures comics E3 rotten harry potter criterion rt labs critics edition superhero critic resources RT21 heist movie NBA razzies toronto dragons Polls and Games finale wonder woman cartoon Rom-Com parents CMT Video Games Exclusive Video Showtime stand-up comedy Walt Disney Pictures Television Academy Tokyo Olympics A&E Emmy Nominations Sundance Now The Purge USA Hallmark Christmas movies ESPN supernatural DGA children's TV free movies mob kaiju golden globe awards mockumentary adventure BET Awards name the review godzilla Pixar Epix target game show crime drama serial killer TLC Red Carpet reviews Toys indiana jones biopic Best and Worst President spanish language art house diversity live action Chernobyl Alien Lifetime Amazon Prime Kids & Family Hear Us Out olympics book cancelled TV series zero dark thirty ABC Family indie zombies royal family Song of Ice and Fire universal monsters MTV Tags: Comedy Awards TV renewals NYCC travel Action Box Office First Look Broadway Mudbound Disney Channel El Rey Captain marvel pirates of the caribbean superman black child's play ghosts Valentine's Day trophy adenture 71st Emmy Awards Apple TV+ romantic comedy New York Comic Con Photos hidden camera young adult Marvel Disney+ Disney Plus Amazon Studios telelvision Nickelodeon Holiday action-comedy saw docudrama jurassic park football Winners rt archives facebook slasher discovery Rocketman VOD Crackle Trivia book adaptation Syfy social media Tarantino First Reviews Martial Arts documentaries Thanksgiving Musicals disaster directors unscripted halloween tv PaleyFest Spectrum Originals SDCC vs. Pop TV toy story movies Quiz Pet Sematary YouTube Sneak Peek Holidays scene in color anime Extras Hollywood Foreign Press Association south america USA Network aapi canceled See It Skip It The Arrangement scary archives Marathons films Women's History Month The CW PlayStation dceu ratings adaptation MSNBC blockbusters Lucasfilm Elton John Cannes political drama debate The Academy based on movie emmy awards Fantasy Food Network X-Men Biopics Mary Poppins Returns AMC Superheroes video on demand Sci-Fi Comedy Calendar leaderboard Super Bowl Netflix Christmas movies zombie scary movies Cosplay Black Mirror TV Comic-Con@Home 2021 kong biography Horror new star wars movies Spring TV dark Turner documentary versus asian-american 90s TIFF Apple crime new york RT History worst animated rt labs politics composers Shudder Paramount Plus best Hulu award winner Brie Larson nature Shondaland comic 21st Century Fox venice Vudu 2020 stoner Lifetime Christmas movies cinemax miniseries canceled TV shows Rock hist Reality Competition worst movies christmas movies Chilling Adventures of Sabrina know your critic Watching Series obituary AMC Plus science fiction television revenge teaser Country jamie lee curtis DirecTV Apple TV Plus History Pirates deadpool Year in Review Marvel Studios VICE HBO franchise Paramount Network justice league Fox Searchlight Mystery 72 Emmy Awards Film Disney streaming service Mary poppins Animation natural history dreamworks 24 frames talk show blockbuster E! marvel cinematic universe james bond Amazon Prime Video sag awards cults Academy Awards sequels fast and furious Masterpiece TBS crossover SXSW movie FX blaxploitation Sony Pictures streaming movies foreign king kong TCM WarnerMedia Peacock Sundance Funimation Columbia Pictures festival Arrowverse cancelled TV shows Star Trek chucky reboot renewed TV shows transformers black comedy series Countdown batman Fargo Baby Yoda spanish werewolf japanese Writers Guild of America spain IFC DC streaming service prank game of thrones Pride Month NBC posters Dark Horse Comics spider-man vampires Travel Channel sitcom high school dc dramedy 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Family OWN MCU romance Anna Paquin Heroines Comedy Central ViacomCBS Binge Guide cancelled television mission: impossible WGN cars elevated horror TCA 2017 boxoffice Infographic halloween cats rom-coms classics kids comiccon genre sports breaking bad 93rd Oscars Tomatazos twilight HBO Max Television Critics Association war National Geographic IFC Films Teen APB 73rd Emmy Awards The Witch king arthur Music SundanceTV Nat Geo Amazon Opinion Britbox GIFs 2019 Mary Tyler Moore comedies 2015 mutant Winter TV joker Tumblr Marvel Television CBS Tubi TCA comic book movies comic book movie Acorn TV hollywood YA period drama popular a nightmare on elm street PBS Fall TV Summer psychological thriller A24 crime thriller Esquire live event spy thriller YouTube Premium HBO Go binge australia screen actors guild ABC Signature LGBT 1990s hispanic heritage month CNN space what to watch 2016 Paramount Crunchyroll satire FXX San Diego Comic-Con die hard GoT LGBTQ all-time Classic Film GLAAD TV Land Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Drama OneApp basketball international 4/20 police drama Hallmark Trailer American Society of Cinematographers singing competition Star Wars FOX comic books french TruTV italian Premiere Dates ABC FX on Hulu Turner Classic Movies BBC America nfl Interview true crime festivals Sundance TV Spike scorecard latino Superheroe Fox News laika TCA Awards suspense fresh Comic Book concert Starz Grammys Christmas Adult Swim Ovation casting nbcuniversal Film Festival Neflix boxing Oscars hispanic screenings Black History Month spider-verse women Cartoon Network Disney Plus cancelled cooking Endgame sequel Pacific Islander feel good Prime Video BBC anthology new zealand TNT thriller independent Character Guide monster movies ITV Podcast witnail The Walking Dead CBS All Access TCA Winter 2020 BET medical drama theme song Ellie Kemper mcc