Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Domino" Topples, "Elizabethtown" Disappoints

by | October 13, 2005 | Comments

This week, the wide releases regale us with tales of beautiful bounty hunters ("Domino"), existential romance ("Elizabethtown"), and masses of deadly condensed water vapor ("The Fog"). Which films will connect with the critics?

The life of the late Domino Harvey would seem custom-made for a film. She was the daughter of a legendary actor (Laurence Harvey), she was supermodel-beautiful, and she worked as a bounty hunter. A story like that would make for a good movie, right? Well, according to the critics, that’s half correct: Tony Scott‘s "Domino," starring Keira Knightley, is certainly more a movie than a biography, but it’s also not terribly good. The scribes say it’s simply a slam-bang, senses-assaulting action flick that gives off little indication that its heroine was a real person. At 18 percent on the Tomatometer, this "Domino" is getting knocked over. It’s also the worst-reviewed film of Scott’s career.

When "Elizabethtown" was screened at the Toronto Film Festival, it didn’t get very good reviews. Director Cameron Crowe told audiences and critics that it was still a work in progress, that more cuts would be made. Well, the new version is now in theaters, and it isn’t faring much better, either. Orlando Bloom and Kirsten Dunst star in this you-can-go-home-again romantic comedy about a man returning to his hometown in Kentucky for his father’s funeral. The critics say Crowe never establishes a coherent tone, and despite the cuts, it’s still overlong. At 29 percent on the Tomatometer, "Elizabethtown" may not be worth a visit.

In a development more ominous than dark clouds on the horizon, "The Fog," a remake of the John Carpenter classic starring Tom Welling, Maggie Grace, and Selma Blair, has not been screened for critics.

Recent Cameron Crowe Movies:
39% — Vanilla Sky (2001)
89% — Almost Famous (2000)
85% — Jerry Maguire (1996)
77% — Singles (1992)
100% — Say Anything (1989)

Recent Tony Scott Movies:
39% — Man on Fire (2004)
67% — Spy Game (2001)
71% — Enemy of the State (1998)
39% — The Fan (1996)
89% — Crimson Tide (1995)

Tag Cloud

Marathons singing competition SundanceTV crime WGN dc Fox News comiccon Bravo 007 biography ratings Epix 21st Century Fox police drama period drama FXX Action VICE CBS Disney TBS DirecTV Horror festivals Superheroe technology Disney Channel Character Guide Ghostbusters Photos Shudder Sony Pictures Grammys Kids & Family Ellie Kemper ABC History 2016 YouTube Red cats Interview Lucasfilm Syfy Toys Martial Arts cinemax political drama Winter TV President ABC Family IFC Calendar justice league E3 TLC GLAAD Comedy Central Fantasy Nickelodeon Star Trek Schedule HBO Adult Swim Oscars transformers Trailer First Look robots GoT Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt SDCC VH1 CNN Paramount Network Drama Musical crime thriller Opinion TCM Masterpiece Hulu LGBTQ APB doctor who Writers Guild of America blaxploitation Polls and Games CBS All Access The Arrangement Valentine's Day romance harry potter Pirates Universal Fall TV Holidays PBS sitcom Rom-Com Emmys Nominations serial killer Country Shondaland dceu Acorn TV Western psycho Esquire discovery ESPN USA A&E Box Office travel Pixar 24 frames El Rey Mary Tyler Moore Lionsgate Sundance Now TNT based on movie MSNBC 2017 Lifetime cooking medical drama Christmas OWN Showtime golden globes science fiction MTV 2015 DC Universe finale Apple E! National Geographic Starz Winners Walt Disney Pictures talk show Spike YA Dark Horse Comics Election Tomatazos streaming SXSW BBC America Sci-Fi Watching Series thriller what to watch Teen Amazon historical drama Best and Worst Pop Infographic Song of Ice and Fire Premiere Dates Warner Bros. sports Comedy Superheroes Certified Fresh dramedy supernatural TCA FX Cartoon Network Reality Competition adventure BBC anime X-Men Cosplay Sneak Peek American Society of Cinematographers cults Mystery Creative Arts Emmys Video Games hist Paramount binge Mindy Kaling CW Seed Awards Marvel Animation crime drama See It Skip It USA Network ITV unscripted BET Food Network Freeform aliens Musicals diversity cops Star Wars mutant spy thriller 20th Century Fox Britbox NBC Podcast Music IFC Films YouTube Premium Trivia PaleyFest Columbia Pictures politics GIFs Comic Book Nat Geo zombie vampires TCA 2017 Tumblr CMT Rocky crossover Super Bowl social media RT History AMC Summer DC streaming service FOX TV DC Comics NYCC Countdown Rock Red Carpet zombies Biopics The CW Crackle Set visit Logo Spring TV war TV Land Ovation Thanksgiving jamie lee curtis composers Reality Extras Year in Review Sundance TIFF San Diego Comic-Con boxoffice docudrama Netflix 45 TruTV