Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Charlotte's Web" Is Good, Indeed; Smith Is Strong, "Pursuit" Less So; "Eragon" Gets Burned

by | December 14, 2006 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a barnyard full of talking animals ("Charlotte’s Web," starring Dakota Fanning and the voices of Julia Roberts and Robert Redford), a real-life rags-to-riches story ("The Pursuit of Happyness," starring Will Smith), and a tale of dragons and swordplay ("Eragon," starring Edward Speleers and Jeremy Irons). What do the critics have to say?

If there’s one thing critics can agree on with "Charlotte’s Web," it’s how much they all loved the children’s novel. If there’s another, it’s how much they like the big screen adaptation, about a bunch of talking farm animals and a pig saved by a very literate spider. Though some feared that the simple story would be modernized with the ironic and brash attitudes afflicting recent kid flicks, the pundits are in awe of the quiet, humble replication of E.B. White’s genteel and distinguished prose. Also, they really like Robert Redford doing the voice of Ike the wussy horse. At 89 percent Tomatometer, this is some movie, indeed.

"How about you and I cruise in my Power Wheels sometime?"

Will Smith has been in pursuit of an Oscar for a while, and with "The Pursuit of Happyness" the critics think this could be where he catches up with the Academy. Smith, as a homeless single father trying to climb the corporate ladder, is garnering widespread praise for his performance, though said praise isn’t quite being doled out upon the film itself. The critics are calling "Happyness" a slick Hallmark card of a movie, a bit too obsessed with the desire to inspire. At 56 percent on the Tomatometer, the critics are split on whether "Happyness" is worth it for Smith’s heartfelt presence alone.

"Once upon a time, in the Kingdom of Periodic Stock Dividends…"

Scribes have posited several excuses as to the overwhelming awfulness of "Eragon" (the movie’s source books were written by a teenager, it’s being directed by a first-timer, etc.), but few critics are terribly forgiving of the derivative plot. "Eragon" spins a tale of a peasant boy (Speleers) who is suddenly entrusted with a dragon and must, with the help of a mentor (Irons), train, grow strong, and defeat an evil emperor. The way the critics describe it, the makers of the "Star Wars"-esque"Eragon" should soon be expecting an annoyed phone call from George Lucas, though the movie’s current nine percent Tomatometer might be insult enough. (At the scene for "Eragon"’s London Premiere was RT-UK’s Joe Utichi; check out his writeup here.

"Wait, what movie are we from again?"

Also playing this week in limited release: Oscar hopeful "Dreamgirls," starring Beyonce Knowles, Jamie Foxx, and Eddie Murphy in the tale of a Motown group’s rise and fall, is at 83 percent (check out RT’s interview with co-star Jennifer Hudson here); "The Secret Life of Words," starring Tim Robbins and Sarah Polley in a tale of high drama on an oil rig, is at 80 percent; "Automatons," a zero-budget dystopian sci-fi flick, is at 67 percent; "Breaking and Entering," a story of the tangled webs weaved after a burglary starring Jude Law and Juliette Binoche, is at 48 percent; "The Good German," Steven Soderbergh’s "Casablanca"-esque drama set in post-WWII Berlin starring George Clooney and Cate Blanchett, is at 26 percent; and "Home of the Brave," about the trials of vets returning home from Iraq starring Samuel L. Jackson, Jessica Biel, and 50 Cent, is at 15 percent.

"I’m giving the wardrobe guy the evil eye."

Recent Will Smith Movies:
69% — Hitch (2005)
35% — Shark Tale (2004)
59% — I, Robot (2004)
25% — Bad Boys II (2003)
38% — Men in Black II (2002)

Recent Dakota Fanning Movies:
63% — Dreamer (2005)
73% — Nine Lives (2005)
73% — War of the Worlds (2005)
13% — Hide and Seek (2005)
74% — In the Realms of the Unreal (2004)

Tag Cloud

FX police drama Universal YA travel WGN Starz APB what to watch crime Superheroes Disney 45 TNT Sci-Fi SDCC Logo Nat Geo 007 based on movie BBC TCA discovery X-Men FXX Best and Worst Calendar singing competition FOX historical drama Music E! Horror Premiere Dates science fiction Masterpiece Election Video Games DC Universe Cartoon Network harry potter Lionsgate docudrama Red Carpet Extras Action political drama SundanceTV Martial Arts boxoffice History Spring TV dramedy Valentine's Day CNN Marvel Fox News Teen Fantasy MTV Nominations sitcom HBO Crackle Writers Guild of America Mystery Animation First Look Super Bowl Schedule 2015 comiccon adventure Countdown serial killer Pirates technology Hulu zombie A&E AMC E3 Musical Star Wars Rock Drama Reality Competition OWN ABC TCA 2017 Watching Series Cosplay war Lifetime BET USA MSNBC diversity Marathons The CW Holidays The Arrangement Esquire GoT DC Comics Bravo Sundance crime drama Trivia TCM cops Pop social media Comedy Food Network cooking LGBTQ Warner Bros. Disney Channel cats cinemax TV Showtime TV Land crime thriller Set visit Ghostbusters PBS CMT Freeform Thanksgiving Star Trek 2016 Nickelodeon President Oscars Mary Tyler Moore Emmys sports Winter TV ESPN NBC TLC aliens Dark Horse Comics talk show Photos PaleyFest supernatural Polls and Games Mindy Kaling 2017 thriller psycho BBC America NYCC American Society of Cinematographers RT History Syfy Rocky IFC Comic Book Paramount GIFs VICE Amazon TIFF Tomatazos CBS All Access Toys ABC Family romance Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Winners Netflix vampires Year in Review politics Certified Fresh CBS Grammys Rom-Com Summer Biopics biography El Rey Character Guide Musicals Tumblr Trailer 24 frames Comedy Central Opinion Podcast TBS composers Ellie Kemper Interview GLAAD Adult Swim DirecTV Country transformers Box Office Infographic Reality Sneak Peek period drama ITV VH1 TruTV Fall TV Kids & Family Awards