6 Things To Know About the Writers of Amazon's Lord of the Rings Series

JD Payne and Patrick McKay are running the show, but you probably haven't heard of them. Here's what we found out - and what it could mean for the series.

by | July 29, 2018 | Comments

(Photo by Courtesy of Amazon)

This weekend, Amazon revealed the writers they hired to create their Lord of the Rings streaming series. Viewers still have not seen any credited work by JD Payne and Patrick McKay, so a lot of fans are still wondering just who are these guys who are going to take us back to Middle Earth?

Rotten Tomatoes did some research on the writing team of Payne and McKay. Through the latest announcements and some previous interviews with the writers, here is everything we found out the two men charged with brining Middle Earth to streaming.


(Photo by © Amazon)

Normally when a Network buys a show, they green light a creator’s take; to snag Lord of the Rings, Amazon won the bidding (rumored at $250 million) without any concept in place. Then they interviewed writers and creators to entertain different takes on the franchise. Payne and McKay won.

“It’s such a vast world, there are so many different ways to go with that property,” Head of Amazon Studios Jennifer Salke (pictured) said. “We had an abundance of enthusiasm in the creator/writer community for the project. So there was a lot of time spent talking about different takes. The next phase is a big development process as they build out this world.”


(Photo by © Paramount)

They’re not only writing the next Star Trek but have been attached to adaptations of Flash Gordon, Godzilla Vs. King Kong, Micronauts, Midas, Goliath, The Deadliest Warrior, and Boilerplate. They also worked on Star Trek: Beyond with Roberto Orci on a script so this will not be their first ride on the Starship Enterprise, although Doug Jung and Simon Pegg ended up finishing Beyond.

Payne and McKay wrote the upcoming Jungle Cruise movie for Dwayne Johnson, based on the Disneyland ride. Now, if they can get a whole movie out of a ride, then the Tolkien trilogy – plus prequel and appendices – should be more than enough source material for a long-running TV series.


(Photo by Courtesy of Amazon)

Payne gave an interview in 2014 to discuss his faith and his screenwriting career. Tolkien is a text often related to the Mormon Church, so perhaps he can bring that angle to the series.

During college Payne served in a mission in Rome. It was there he truly fell in love with telling stories. “While in Italy, in the hours and days and months of interacting incessantly with thousands of people, I became fixated upon the power of story,” McKay told MormonArtist.

Of course, many have cited religious parallels between Tolkien’s work and Mormonism and other religions. Since the show will not be adapted directly from the book, perhaps Payne will have a chance to draw new connections between religion in our world and in the world of Middle Earth, if he chooses to.


(Photo by © New Line)

According to Amazon’s press release, Payne and McKay met in a high school debate club. The 2014 interview puts their meeting in 1997. That’s two decades of writing and developing together, and by 2014 they had written 15 screenplays together, according to the Payne interview.

“Our worldviews are sometimes contrasting, but always complementary,” Payne told MormonArtist. “Between the two of us, we almost never get stuck, be it in brainstorming, pitching, drafting, revising, or any other part of the process.”

In an interview with TrekCore, McKay detailed more of their high school collaborations. They directed a play and then began wrrting one together. Payne went to Yale for engineering and McKay went to a creative writing grad school in Washington, D.C. but they remained partners.


Various sources report that the series will take place before The Fellowship of the Ring, with Tolkien site reporting that their sources say it will be about a young Aragorn, Viggo Mortensen’s character in the trilogy.

So, they’ll be called on to write original work – of sorts. Some of the original screenplays the duo have written include The Black List screenplay Escape. Law Zero was also to be an original futuristic sci-fi action movie for Warner Brothers, but it never got made.


(Photo by © New Line)

In the press release announcing their gig on Lord of the Rings, Payne and McKay said, “We feel like Frodo, setting out from the Shire, with a great responsibility in our care. It is the beginning of the adventure of a lifetime. The rich world that J.R.R. Tolkien created is filled with majesty and heart, wisdom and complexity.”

Now do those sound like guys to follow into Mordor or what?

Tag Cloud

films 90s Mary Tyler Moore Family reboot latino scary cancelled TV shows festival Writers Guild of America TCA 2017 South by Southwest Film Festival supernatural stand-up comedy streaming MCU blockbusters mutant Comic-Con@Home 2021 PaleyFest rotten Tarantino Lifetime Christmas movies crossover satire CBS All Access new york Comics on TV Emmy Nominations stop motion dceu book adaptation TV One BBC One Fall TV Apple TV+ space Television Critics Association Music 93rd Oscars hist Infographic Quiz international miniseries Instagram Live TNT 99% 2016 HBO talk show Winter TV japan Tomatazos GLAAD Comedy Central series Kids & Family italian Sundance ABC Family interviews Mudbound DC Universe PlayStation video archives television Lucasfilm Shondaland versus live action Vudu Television Academy Fantasy romance Adult Swim Wes Anderson AMC jamie lee curtis nfl Universal Pictures YouTube worst movies Captain marvel toronto CBS young adult streaming movies Extras SXSW scene in color Freeform 1990s Toys Awards Black Mirror doctor who Certified Fresh Ghostbusters Creative Arts Emmys Reality Competition video on demand Anna Paquin witnail Thanksgiving remakes joker police drama know your critic documentaries Watching Series prank TV movies Holidays composers popular Universal Best Picture The Purge See It Skip It child's play indiana jones Showtime unscripted Britbox Star Trek Hulu TIFF Summer SundanceTV medical drama classics Native cancelled television WGN spider-verse women Sci-Fi Alien hispanic The CW VH1 2018 Box Office Star Wars Logo Marvel cults dogs worst Best Actress TLC Academy Awards comics Paramount Plus Classic Film docuseries mcc saw Shudder theme song concert trailers NYCC Film Festival adventure Calendar anthology black comedy biopic 45 First Look crime Discovery Channel AMC Plus facebook target screen actors guild suspense Photos game show gangster canceled TV shows Pop TV Image Comics Musical Hallmark Christmas movies Warner Bros. chucky Song of Ice and Fire movie docudrama richard e. Grant Teen 94th Oscars marvel cinematic universe Marvel Studios dragons A&E spanish monster movies 20th Century Fox American Society of Cinematographers ABC Signature Biopics Christmas new star wars movies Winners Election DirecTV Sundance TV Red Carpet 2017 New York Comic Con jurassic park 73rd Emmy Awards TCA Rocketman Oscars hispanic heritage month Disney Plus feel good TBS scorecard Super Bowl IFC dc cooking free movies Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Ellie Kemper 007 psycho TV Land E3 mob japanese Marvel Television First Reviews CNN Acorn TV Ovation diversity 21st Century Fox kaiju Sundance Now Brie Larson olympics art house tv talk lord of the rings christmas movies period drama wonder woman 2020 Pet Sematary breaking bad RT History basketball finale Film 2015 parents CMT travel comic book movie comic books Pixar canceled DC streaming service Holiday Cosplay heist movie DC Comics laika OneApp Paramount Network kong DGA Emmys Women's History Month Syfy OWN romantic comedy hollywood RT21 justice league rom-coms Netflix Christmas movies zombie blaxploitation Western franchise ID Marathons Endgame posters Nickelodeon spinoff trophy political drama sports cartoon Black History Month politics children's TV Dark Horse Comics Star Wars Celebration LGBT TCA Winter 2020 The Arrangement Crackle Baby Yoda Cartoon Network Travel Channel BET new zealand MGM Trophy Talk award winner Amazon Prime Video golden globes TCM Prime Video FOX Apple target scene in color sequel halloween sag awards Paramount die hard disaster Interview Chilling Adventures of Sabrina HBO Max Pop SXSW 2022 game of thrones Best and Worst cars Legendary Sneak Peek Countdown renewed TV shows Hallmark Disney Nominations directors book adaptation fast and furious critic resources Trailer boxoffice X-Men Nat Geo Premiere Dates royal family Arrowverse Avengers Pirates Disney Channel obi wan CW Seed Binge Guide mockumentary emmy awards LGBTQ Epix dreamworks APB documentary crime thriller name the review President TV renewals genre Neflix FX Spike true crime teaser Apple TV Plus golden globe awards YouTube Premium FX on Hulu historical drama San Diego Comic-Con social media Video Games james bond YouTube Red USA Network BET Awards robots Peacock Reality El Rey Pride Month HFPA telelvision dramedy Disney streaming service transformers Disney+ Disney Plus Walt Disney Pictures spain harry potter Esquire Lionsgate cops 24 frames superhero Spectrum Originals fresh Crunchyroll Mary poppins National Geographic anime Sony Pictures spider-man Lifetime scary movies 2019 Pacific Islander ratings hidden camera a nightmare on elm street Schedule Spring TV Turner Classic Movies movies obituary binge vampires Stephen King legend 72 Emmy Awards Horror Character Guide 79th Golden Globes Awards HBO Go cancelled NBC green book black Animation sitcom TV rotten movies we love nature singing competition Bravo leaderboard streamig VOD comic book movies Indigenous psychological thriller GoT Rock biography Amazon Broadway live event Trivia The Walking Dead cinemax Fox News Oscar Tubi Cannes 4/20 debate sequels comic werewolf comedies kids MSNBC Exclusive Video Netflix Best Actor Comedy adenture dark revenge summer TV preview FXX Fargo 2021 quibi natural history stoner BBC America scene in color film series Starz rt labs critics edition strong female leads Funimation Tags: Comedy E! GIFs Country Fox Searchlight spy thriller Superheroes french slashers serial killer all-time south america 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards ViacomCBS Podcast elevated horror nbcuniversal football crime drama war Valentine's Day science fiction venice based on movie scene in color series twilight Drama Tokyo Olympics aapi The Witch batman discovery Mary Poppins Returns critics Sony PBS Paramount Pictures Chernobyl WarnerMedia king arthur History universal monsters Focus Features TCA Awards TruTV Mindy Kaling cancelled TV series Rocky thriller ghosts Masterpiece cats pirates of the caribbean toy story criterion Turner razzies reviews Awards Tour Comic Book Set visit Amazon Studios broadcast Best Director godzilla Hear Us Out rt archives ITV casting dexter independent technology deadpool high school spanish language zombies news Action asian-american Elton John ESPN zero dark thirty Superheroe SDCC comiccon sopranos BAFTA Martial Arts Polls and Games animated Mystery vs. best IFC Films Tumblr VICE Food Network halloween tv NBA indie aliens rt labs YA festivals BBC summer TV marvel comics IMDb TV mission: impossible blockbuster A24 71st Emmy Awards action-comedy MTV screenings slasher The Walt Disney Company Year in Review The Academy what to watch boxing superman king kong summer preview Grammys Hollywood Foreign Press Association Musicals australia Amazon Prime Opinion foreign USA Heroines ABC Rom-Com Columbia Pictures Geeked Week