10 Years of Golden Tomatoes

Looking back on current and past winners.

by | January 13, 2009 | Comments

With the Golden Globes and countless other ceremonies having come and pass, awards season (aka Slumgdogathon 2009) is approaching the final bend. But there’s still at least one more major stop before the Oscars: Rotten Tomatoes’ very own reckoning of the awesome movies of last year. We call ’em the Golden Tomato Awards, which we spread across 17 categories celebrating the Freshest of the Fresh movies (or in the case of one category, the Rottenest). Check out Golden Tomato Awards 2008, and then read on here for some factoids and fun tidbits about the winners!

GTA 2008 brought forth some familiar faces: Pixar, The Dark KnightHellboy II, and The Wrestler made off with some gold veggies. But small distributors also
scored, fending off the major studios’ arthouse arms that usually dominate. Magnolia Pictures (for Man on Wire), Roadhouse Attractions (Teeth), and First Look Studios (Transsiberian) all received their first Golden Tomatoes this year.

Now it’s been a roller coaster year for Warner Bros. Their Batty superhero/action/crime epic became the second-highest grossing movie ever (not accounting for inflation) and did pretty well for itself critically, as seen with its Tomatometer and Golden Tomato. But, a more dubious distinction for the studio: their first Moldy Tomato Award for One Missed Call. The January horror remake about deadly phone calls (memorably riffed on in Forgetting Sarah Marshall) struck up the rare zero percent Tomatometer. For reference, One Missed Call is only the second zero percent Moldy Tomato winner (the other being 2000’s 3 Strikes).

At the other end, this year’s multiple-award recipient, Man on Wire, is only the second 100% Tomatometer winner. The other? Toy Story 2, which took home the Best-Reviewed Wide Release award and Best Animated award in 1999, and has since been mythologized as Rotten Tomatoes’ best-reviewed movie ever.

And speaking of Woody and company, it’s impossible to talk about movie love without mentioning Pixar, the studio with an unprecedented streak of adoration from
the critical community. With  Wall-E, Pixar is closely edging towards 20 Golden Tomato category wins, far ahead of second place studios Dreamworks, Disney, and Miramax (nine wins each). Including this year, Pixar has won Best-Reviewed Wide Release for five of the past 10 years.

Along with Pixar’s efforts, well-executed animated features find rapturous audiences among critics.

Wallace & Gromit: The Curse of the Were-Rabbit
and  Chicken Run (both directed by Nick Park and distributed by Dreamworks) took home the Best-Reviewed
trophy in 2006 and 2000, respectively. Best-Reviewed Wide Releases are also commercial hits, always grossing over $200 million, with the exception of Wallace &
Gromit
($56 million) and Chicken Run ($106 million). Looks like American audiences are yet to totally sync up with Park’s British humor.

Though Nick Park has the rare accomplishment of having his films twice bestowed with some kind of Golden Tomato, Christopher Nolan leads the directorial pack
with four movies (MementoInsomniaBatman BeginsThe Dark Knight). Peter Jackson trails behind him with three for his Lord of the Rings trilogy.

Next: See all of the past Golden Tomato award winners!

 

Best-Reviewed Wide Releases

 

2007

Ratatouille

Ratatouille

2006

Casino Royale

Casino Royale

2005

Wallace and Gromit



Wallace & Gromit: The Curse of the Were-Rabbit

2004

The Incredibles

The Incredibles

2003

Finding Nemo

Finding Nemo

 

 

2002

The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers



The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers

2001

The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring



The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring

2000

Chicken Run

Chicken Run

1999

Toy Story 2

Toy Story 2

 

 


 

Best-Reviewed Limited Releases
(category began in 2004)

 

2007

Once

Once

2006

The Queen

The Queen

2005

Good Night and Good Luck



Good Night, and Good Luck.

2004

Sideways

Sideways

 

 


 

Action/Adventure Animation (began in 2000)
2007:
The Bourne
Ultimatum
2007: Ratatouille
2006: Casino Royale 2006:
Cars
2005:
Batman Begins
2005: Wallace & Gromit: The Curse of the
Were-Rabbit
2004:
Spider-Man 2
2004: The Incredibles
2003: Finding Nemo 2003: Finding Nemo
2002: The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers 2002: Spirited Away
2001:
Spy Kids
2001: Monsters, Inc.
2000:
Space Cowboys
2000: Chicken Run
1999:
Princess
Mononoke
Comedy Documentary (began in 2003)
2007:
Juno
2007:
Sicko
2006:
Borat
2006:
Wordplay
2005:
The 40
Year-Old Virgin
2005:

March of the Penguins
2004:
Mean Girls
2004:
Super Size
Me
2003: Finding Nemo 2003:

Spellbound
2002:
About a Boy
2001:
Shrek
2000: Chicken Run
1999:
Being
John Malkovich
Drama Horror
2007: Away From Her 2007:
Grindhouse
2006: The Queen 2006:
The Descent
2005: Good Night, and Good Luck 2005:

George A. Romero’s The Land of the Dead
2004: Sideways 2004:
Shaun of
the Dead
2003:
Lost
in Translation
2003:
28 Days
Later
2002:
Catch
Me if You Can
2002:
Signs
2001:
Memento
2001:

With a Friend Like Harry
2000:
You
Can Count on Me
2000:

Shadow of the Vampire
1999:
The
Straight Story
1999:
The
Blair Witch Project
Kids/Family Romance
2007:
Enchanted
2007:
Atonement
2006:
Lassie
2006:
The
Science of Sleep
2005:
Millions
2005:

Brokeback Mountain
2004:
Two Brothers
2004:

Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
2003: Finding Nemo 2003: Lost in Translation
2002:
Spirited
Away
2002:
Spider-Man
2001:
Monsters,
Inc.
2001:
Amelie
2000:
The
Emperor’s New Groove
2000:
High
Fidelity
1999:
Toy Story 2
1999:
Notting Hill
Sci-Fi/Fantasy (began in 2000) Thriller (began in 2000)
2007:

Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix
2007:
No
Country for Old Men
2006:
Children
of Men
2006:
The Departed
2005:

Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire
2005:
A
History of Violence
2004:

Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban
2004:
Collateral
2003:

The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King
2003:
City of God
2002: The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers 2002:
Insomnia
2001: The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of
the Ring
2001:
Memento
2000:
X-Men
2000:
Frequency
Foreign (began in 2004) Musical (began in 2007)
2007:
The
Lives of Others
2007: Once
2006:
Pan’s
Labyrinth
2005:
Kung Fu
Hustle
2004:
Hero
UK Film (began in 2007) Australian Film (began in 2007)
2007:
Hot Fuzz
2007:
Ten Canoes
Moldy Tomato (began in 2000)
2007:
Because
I Said So
2006:
Basic
Instinct 2
2005:
Alone in
the Dark
2004:
Twisted
2003:
Gigli
2002:
Rollerball
2001:
Say It
Isn’t So
2000:
3 Strikes

Tag Cloud

Drama Countdown Paramount Network prank Film golden globes BBC America 24 frames king kong BAFTA Year in Review sequel American Society of Cinematographers PaleyFest elevated horror james bond Universal Discovery Channel crossover Classic Film miniseries Calendar debate worst IFC Films scene in color Nickelodeon Quiz Nat Geo dark binge Sony Pictures Shudder E3 canceled TV shows docudrama witnail comic Netflix action-comedy 4/20 adenture comics mob RT21 Exclusive Video comic book movie Universal Pictures Star Wars Celebration art house basketball Podcast Pride Month Image Comics theme song The Academy 2017 period drama unscripted Starz mutant TCA Paramount Plus video on demand Fantasy trailers crime thriller kong Black History Month The Purge Sundance TV young adult The Walking Dead Disney Plus cops Elton John book adaptation rt labs crime drama ratings book superhero Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Marvel Studios festivals Spectrum Originals interviews war Mudbound true crime hist scorecard festival South by Southwest Film Festival teaser feel good spanish language Awards Spike The Walt Disney Company Baby Yoda Heroines heist movie Creative Arts Emmys YouTube japanese TBS ABC universal monsters HBO MCU Disney streaming service hispanic telelvision 90s Superheroe cooking Fargo Photos Biopics indie social media Certified Fresh cancelled political drama DC Comics 45 disaster leaderboard razzies canceled politics hidden camera Women's History Month science fiction robots IFC NYCC gangster sag awards Acorn TV joker japan Tags: Comedy biopic sequels Crunchyroll DGA dceu singing competition Pirates Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Binge Guide Premiere Dates revenge Hallmark Christmas movies BBC One Lionsgate Musicals hispanic heritage month CBS summer TV Rocky halloween Captain marvel monster movies Winners Spring TV Rock Pop godzilla king arthur Fox News remakes venice El Rey die hard worst movies television suspense Action VH1 doctor who summer TV preview Reality Competition blockbuster high school dreamworks Star Trek LGBTQ LGBT New York Comic Con YouTube Premium Emmys Reality Comedy Central ESPN Box Office San Diego Comic-Con Columbia Pictures TV renewals dramedy TV One Amazon cults Syfy Broadway dragons Country indiana jones streaming movies Avengers best IMDb TV TruTV halloween tv know your critic Bravo CMT AMC Best and Worst concert strong female leads kaiju TV movies reviews streaming Grammys boxoffice comedies 79th Golden Globes Awards Schedule zero dark thirty new york critics Oscars tv talk First Look broadcast Fall TV CW Seed Hallmark critic resources PlayStation Western Nominations 2018 Best Picture 007 Chernobyl saw Mystery cancelled TV shows Tokyo Olympics Holidays news Comic-Con@Home 2021 what to watch SXSW 2022 Legendary Masterpiece Instagram Live discovery NBA OWN sports Teen Martial Arts 2015 golden globe awards trophy Best Actress 99% all-time romance Cosplay Pixar DirecTV a nightmare on elm street APB olympics Mary Poppins Returns spy thriller 1990s The Witch Esquire Neflix green book SDCC historical drama aliens Warner Bros. streamig Trophy Talk TNT italian zombies Disney+ Disney Plus jurassic park versus adaptation AMC Plus latino Song of Ice and Fire Tubi scary The Arrangement series RT History 20th Century Fox cancelled TV series jamie lee curtis crime new zealand mission: impossible Food Network toronto child's play aapi children's TV Wes Anderson Endgame cats 2020 73rd Emmy Awards 72 Emmy Awards wonder woman FXX game show international Pacific Islander spider-verse Sundance Now Rocketman supernatural facebook award winner TCA 2017 Disney Lucasfilm marvel comics Video Games Academy Awards obi wan Character Guide Lifetime ghosts Alien casting NBC TCM rotten movies we love HBO Go President Watching Series BBC black comedy lord of the rings Fox Searchlight summer preview royal family Thanksgiving cars Ovation Cartoon Network Emmy Nominations spain SundanceTV YA blaxploitation Dark Horse Comics MGM vampires documentaries Musical Epix ABC Family Toys Television Critics Association stand-up comedy Tumblr movies breaking bad Arrowverse FOX chucky Anna Paquin satire slasher YouTube Red composers stoner archives VICE psychological thriller posters harry potter VOD Tomatazos Amazon Prime Video dexter Polls and Games Oscar Peacock A&E spinoff cancelled television HBO Max reboot Shondaland anime talk show BET parents Ellie Kemper 93rd Oscars Ghostbusters deadpool technology Mindy Kaling animated fresh comiccon WarnerMedia scary movies 21st Century Fox BET Awards natural history Marvel mockumentary Mary poppins Showtime USA Network Marathons criterion adventure Tarantino rt archives vs. A24 directors Best Actor fast and furious Best Director football comic books 2021 spider-man 94th Oscars mcc independent 71st Emmy Awards Super Bowl Vudu Election documentary kids Awards Tour laika History nature Lifetime Christmas movies Amazon Studios GLAAD richard e. Grant Interview PBS Star Wars Trailer sitcom MSNBC zombie anthology Disney Channel women popular biography Superheroes Hulu dc Sundance CBS All Access Sony Opinion christmas movies ID CNN TV finale GoT Music legend 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards screenings Comic Book Valentine's Day 2016 Television Academy First Reviews Marvel Television USA films justice league diversity australia Christmas target TIFF screen actors guild Family Black Mirror french slashers OneApp superman classics Holiday romantic comedy Writers Guild of America serial killer SXSW Rom-Com Britbox live action National Geographic batman Apple TV Plus genre docuseries Travel Channel 2019 Freeform black Sci-Fi rt labs critics edition nfl TCA Winter 2020 Winter TV renewed TV shows quibi sopranos Apple TV+ Brie Larson Walt Disney Pictures FX on Hulu WGN Paramount franchise free movies twilight See It Skip It werewolf comic book movies hollywood Focus Features Horror E! Turner video Apple The CW transformers Sneak Peek boxing Infographic Hollywood Foreign Press Association emmy awards Funimation marvel cinematic universe game of thrones space nbcuniversal dogs Trivia HFPA asian-american south america Red Carpet Pet Sematary X-Men Comics on TV ViacomCBS Logo ABC Signature GIFs Cannes TCA Awards Paramount Pictures based on movie Animation blockbusters Comedy toy story spanish cinemax foreign cartoon police drama new star wars movies Crackle TLC Amazon Prime psycho Adult Swim Extras DC Universe thriller obituary pirates of the caribbean DC streaming service Mary Tyler Moore rom-coms Stephen King travel Summer name the review live event stop motion TV Land Hear Us Out MTV Film Festival Turner Classic Movies movie Pop TV ITV FX Prime Video Kids & Family Set visit Netflix Christmas movies medical drama rotten