RT Fans Crown The Lord of the Rings: Return of the King as the Best of the Best Picture Winners

Peter Jackson's fantasy epic outpaced Francis Ford Coppola's mafia tale by a wide, convincing margin.

by | February 7, 2020 | Comments

(Click to enlarge.)

The Oscar Best Picture Showdown is officially over, and the RT community has crowned The Lord of the Rings: Return of the King as the best of the Best Pictures! In addition to Best Picture, Peter Jackson’s epic finale to the Lord of the Rings series was nominated for 10 more Oscars at the 2004 Academy Awards, including Best Director, Best Adapted Screenplay, and Best Original Score, and it won every single one of them. That not only matched the most wins for a single film at the Oscars (Ben-Hur and Titanic previously achieved the same distinction), but set the record for the most wins by a film that took home the trophy in every category in which it was nominated. Here, Return of the King defeated all of its opponents, from classic films like All Quiet on the Western Front and The French Connection to more recent hits like Spotlight and No Country for Old Men, by a wide margin before facing off against The Godfather, and even then, Return took the crown with a decisive 59% of the vote.

Over the course of this bracket’s six rounds, almost a million votes were tallied across all of the individual match-ups, so big thanks to everyone in the RT community who participated! Click below to see the results of all the prior rounds, and stay tuned for our next big bracket showdown!

Round 1 Results | Round 2 Results | Round 3 Results | Round 4 Results | Round 5 Results

Final Round Results

Round 1 Results | Round 2 Results | Round 3 Results | Round 4 Results | Round 5 Results

Thumbnail image by ©New Line courtesy Everett Collection

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 Next

Tag Cloud

BET Spectrum Originals batman Comics on TV Ellie Kemper cancelled television book History American Society of Cinematographers 2020 Crunchyroll Shudder Warner Bros. Disney streaming service richard e. Grant Countdown Musicals DC streaming service slashers Superheroe DirecTV Cannes Animation Horror social media cooking versus talk show ghosts Rock Star Trek President political drama Syfy TBS kids robots YA RT21 spain DGA Hallmark Christmas movies Christmas LGBT Fall TV BBC America cops Rocky video foreign vampires cults Country sag awards FXX Heroines Marvel Studios SXSW halloween Stephen King movies CNN cartoon Showtime TIFF Shondaland 20th Century Fox space Turner Classic Movies Opinion Arrowverse composers MSNBC PaleyFest PBS Tubi Academy Awards The Purge Musical Black Mirror unscripted IFC Films romantic comedy BBC Marvel Television See It Skip It Certified Fresh biography dceu Toys justice league natural history crime TCA Winter 2020 sequel Starz Red Carpet FX elevated horror Adult Swim facebook Infographic Mindy Kaling Sony Pictures Music A24 MTV USA Network Tomatazos Paramount science fiction Drama Valentine's Day crossover free movies Amazon Comic Book 71st Emmy Awards werewolf Fantasy tv talk game show Mudbound Premiere Dates Winter TV Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Binge Guide Summer First Look green book San Diego Comic-Con E3 spanish language latino The CW Fox News The Arrangement crime thriller serial killer historical drama Song of Ice and Fire casting sitcom Apple comics The Witch Disney+ Disney Plus Logo dramedy Awards Reality Competition SundanceTV Rocketman spider-man Year in Review The Walking Dead Sundance 2015 indie Film Oscars Superheroes Lifetime Christmas movies MCU YouTube Red theme song revenge FOX WGN Martial Arts Walt Disney Pictures Sneak Peek strong female leads singing competition zombie discovery Photos E! Winners anthology finale Emmys Spike CW Seed Election boxoffice Holidays TLC anime cinemax Pirates Paramount Network Esquire Interview OneApp technology TV joker Baby Yoda Action Peacock Turner National Geographic Food Network SDCC christmas movies psychological thriller what to watch diversity jamie lee curtis 007 Mary Tyler Moore hist Disney Channel Character Guide Biopics LGBTQ television canceled TV shows Television Academy Dark Horse Comics independent medical drama WarnerMedia 2017 2016 Trophy Talk Bravo HBO miniseries Mary Poppins Returns Britbox screen actors guild travel APB Disney TNT Masterpiece blaxploitation Sci-Fi Women's History Month GoT YouTube renewed TV shows Acorn TV Lucasfilm movie blockbuster name the review cars cancelled Reality Video Games First Reviews transformers Epix directors Set visit VH1 Super Bowl screenings X-Men Nominations canceled mutant zombies Writers Guild of America GLAAD dragons police drama YouTube Premium NYCC romance Sundance Now Grammys Elton John Avengers Comedy Central Netflix Vudu Awards Tour comic Nat Geo Trivia Calendar binge Marvel HBO Max adaptation AMC Columbia Pictures children's TV Captain marvel Family Endgame ratings docudrama south america breaking bad Pixar A&E Universal ABC nature Lifetime Nickelodeon Box Office Mystery Hulu aliens teaser documentary dogs Pride Month Ghostbusters Tarantino series Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Classic Film politics disaster DC Comics comiccon Comedy Lionsgate ESPN VICE CMT New York Comic Con TV renewals witnail Quiz reboot spy thriller Sundance TV Hallmark psycho crime drama dc rotten movies we love thriller stand-up comedy OWN golden globes Spring TV Brie Larson cancelled TV shows Schedule true crime Marathons Apple TV+ based on movie hispanic award winner Best and Worst Emmy Nominations TCA DC Universe Ovation quibi Pop Mary poppins ITV GIFs CBS All Access Disney Plus Teen RT History 45 Star Wars Netflix Christmas movies toy story 2019 Kids & Family 21st Century Fox 24 frames mockumentary sports Holiday Freeform NBC cancelled TV series animated harry potter Extras Creative Arts Emmys TCM supernatural Anna Paquin TruTV Discovery Channel Tumblr doctor who Crackle TV Land ABC Family festivals Rom-Com Watching Series Pet Sematary Amazon Prime Video cats Cosplay Western Trailer IFC Amazon Prime Podcast adventure El Rey Chernobyl TCA 2017 Apple TV Plus Film Festival Thanksgiving CBS USA streaming zero dark thirty 2018 spinoff Polls and Games Amazon Studios period drama game of thrones Cartoon Network war