Moldy Tomatoes: The 10 Worst Movies of the Last 10 Years

RT highlights the worst-reviewed movie for each year we've been around.

by | August 7, 2008 | Comments

Let’s face it. You love bad movies, we love bad movies. That’s why we’re
called Rotten Tomatoes and it’s why a movie needs a 60% Tomatometer to be
considered Fresh — we want to see films sweat to be considered good. Now
nothing cleanses the palette like a bad movie. They encourage us to actively
appreciate our favorites even more while (hopefully) giving us a good laugh. You
already read our
Golden Tomatoes article,
now continue for the 10 worst movies of each year of Rotten Tomatoes’ existence
(which are sorted using the same weighted scores that we use on our big features
lists).

 




more info…
1998’s Worst-Reviewed:


Jawbreaker

Black comedies are hard to pull off consistently (even the American masters,
the Coen Brothers, succeed only slightly more than half the time), and one set
during high school runs the risk of being zero interest to critics, who have
long since conquered high school, college, and probably a few midlife crises.
But Jawbreaker, detailing a beautiful girl clique’s attempt to cover up a
murder, tries its hardest to make it work. And by making it work, we mean
shamelessly stealing from Heathers, Clueless, and John Waters while failing to
establish a consistent tone. “Not quite a satire, not quite an homage,” writes
Liam Lacey of the Globe and Mail, “Jawbreaker falls into a third category:
audaciously unoriginal.”

Runners-Up:

I Still Know What You Did Last Summer
,
54
,
A Night at the
Roxbury

Best-Reviewed:
The Truman Show

 




more info…
1999’s Worst-Reviewed:


Chill Factor

People think Cuba Gooding Jr’s post-Oscar career was a crash and burn when it
was actually more like greasy fiery wreckage slowly descending on America. He
was memorable in his first movie after Jerry Maguire (As Good as it Gets, a
pretty good flick itself!), What Dreams May Come was an ambitious epic that,
through no fault of his own, backfired, and the potboiler Instinct could’ve
been an intense thriller in different filmmaking hands. But the moment we all
knew something was amiss at Camp Cuba? Chill Factor, a pale imitation of
Wages
of Fear
and Speed that lacks the suspense of the former and the actorly
chemistry that characterized the latter (though considering Gooding’s co-star
is Skeet Ulrich, that’s probably a good thing). Jonathan Rosenbaum brings the
vitriol: “This action-adventure movie shows the usual contempt for life,
humanity, art, the audience, intelligence, characterization, and plot.”

Runners-Up:
Eye of
the Beholder
,
End of Days
,
The Mod Squad

Best-Reviewed:
Toy Story 2

 




more info…
2000’s Worst-Reviewed:


Battlefield Earth

Co-producer and star John Travolta kick-started 2000 with was supposed to be
the start of an new sci-fi franchise, an epic to (subtly) spread the name of
Battlefield Earth author L. Ron Hubbard, founder of Scientology. But
instead, what Travolta gave us was the first truly awful movie of the new
millennium, a one-dimensional, grimy-looking movie filled with drab colors and
way too many dreadlocks. In space, no one can hear you scream, but here on
Earth, we can definitely hear Boxoffice Magazine’s Wade Major: “Utterly inane
and innocuous in the most harmless, uninteresting way — the fruit of an
overrated star’s overblown ego, recklessly indulged by studio excess.”

Runners-Up:
Bless the Child
,
I Dreamed of
Africa
, Lost
Souls

Best-Reviewed:
Chicken Run

 




more info…
2001’s Worst-Reviewed:


Corky Romano

On one of his comedy albums, Andy Dick — no stranger to critical poundings
himself — rhymed “Chris Kattan” with “horse-faced troll of a man.” None of the
critics who sat through 2001’s Kattan-led Corky Romano stooped quite
that low in their reviews of the year’s most rotten movie, but they weren’t
exactly kind to the alleged mob comedy, either: Emily Blunt urged readers not
to see it “if you respect anyone in the cast or comedy in general,” while
Stephen Himes of Film Snobs was beautifully succinct, summing up Corky
as “very, very bad.” You can’t keep a good man down, though; in recent years,
Kattan has starred in such notable productions as a deleted scene in Superbad
and the upcoming CBS series Gameshow in My Head.

Runners-Up: Glitter,
Say It Isn’t So,
Summer Catch
Best-Reviewed:
Monsters Inc.

 

 





more info…
2002’s Worst-Reviewed:


Ballistic:
Ecks vs. Sever

Take the number 100, remove the 1 from the front, and what do you have? A pair
of zeros, that’s what — which can either refer to this movie’s supremely
dreadful Tomatometer rating, or the two stars themselves. Okay, so that’s
probably a little harsh, considering that Antonio Banderas and Lucy Liu have
entertained us in other films — but on the other hand, even in the context of
take-the-money-and-run paycheck roles, Ballistic: Ecks vs Sever makes Reindeer
Games
look like Casablanca. The plot is undeserving of analysis, or
even a summary; the most fitting epitaph for this, the worst-reviewed movie in
our site’s history, might come courtesy of Film Quips’ John R. McEwen, who
asked: “Antonio Banderas, Lucy Liu, have you no pride? Have you no standards?
Have you no shame? Don’t you pay attention to what’s written on the papers
you’re signing?”

Runners-Up:
The Master of Disguise
,
Rollerball
,
Serving Sara

Best-Reviewed:


The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers

 




more info…
2003’s Worst-Reviewed:




Gigli

You try to look all cool and stuff now, America, but we were there at the turn
of the century, and we remember — you were all gaga over Bennifer. 2003’s Gigli
was supposed to be the cinematic culmination of the nation’s paparazzi-fueled
love affair with Ben Affleck and Jennifer Lopez, but a funny thing happened on
the way to the box office: we got tired of them. Oh, and also, Gigli
stunk. And actually, critics didn’t find that last part so funny — Empire’s
Simon Braund, for instance, referred to it as “torture,” saying it was
“impossible to imagine how it could have been worse,” and the Guardian’s Peter
Bradshaw deemed it “awe-inspiringly, world-historically awful.”

Runners-Up:
Darkness Falls
,
A Man Apart
,
Gods and Generals

Best-Reviewed:
Finding Nemo

 




more info…
2004’s Worst-Reviewed:

Twisted

Sure, it’s an accomplishment (if not necessarily an honor) to be called the
worst-reviewed movie of your respective release year. And nearly all the
movies on this list are at least celebrated and for their sheer badness,
passed around amongst hip moviegoers for ironic viewing accompanied with shot
glasses. 2004’s worst movie, Twisted, runs the gamut of reasons why critics
hate a bad thriller: the “screenplay is a compendium of by-the-book clichés,”
the “direction leaves the material stranded in a limbo between po-faced and
trashy,” and the main actor’s (in this case, Ashley Judd) “approximation of
drunkenness is worrying to behold,” writes Time Out. But here’s the (har har)
twist: not only is Twisted the worst-reviewed of its year, it harbors the
extra-dubious distinction of having been completely forgotten. Seriously, have
you thought about Twisted since the Friday it opened and you decided to avoid
it at all costs?

Runners-Up: Godsend,

Christmas with the Kranks
,
The Whole Ten Yards

Best-Reviewed:
The Incredibles

 




more info…
2005’s Worst-Reviewed:


Alone in the Dark

Uwe Boll. Christian Slater. Tara Reid. Meet the Holy Trinity of the Moldy
Tomatoes, gang! Even by game-to-film standards, 2005’s Alone in the Dark
is shockingly bad — something that even the most ardent fans of the popular
game must have known as soon as they saw the talent assembled behind the
scenes. Would you believe it took three people to write this screenplay,
loaded with corn-scented dialogue like “fear is what protects you from the
things you don’t believe in”? The critics who watched it all unfold onscreen
were just as dumbfounded; Rue Morgue Magazine’s Jovanka Vuckovic, for
instance, called it “overblown, amateurish gibberish.”

Runners-Up: The
Perfect Man
,
White Noise
,
Yours, Mine, &
Ours

Best-Reviewed:
Murderball

 




more info…
2006’s Worst-Reviewed:


Basic Instinct 2

 

If it had been made 15 years earlier, it probably would have been one of
the biggest hits of the year, no matter how bad the reviews were. But there
weren’t many people looking for a sequel to Basic Instinct in 2006, and
most of Basic Instinct 2‘s potential audience was scared away by
negative reviews from critics like the Austin Chronicle’s Marc Savlov, who
dismissed it as “garish” and “deliciously awful,” or Reel.com’s Brie Beazley,
who boiled all 117 minutes down to six words: “Everything about this movie is
bad.”

Runners-Up:
All the King’s Men
,
The Covenant
,
Deck the Halls

Best-Reviewed:
The Queen

 




more info…
2007’s Worst-Reviewed:


Because I Said So

It had Diane Keaton in winsome neurotic matron mode, and the trailer featured
a shot of adorable Mandy Moore in her skivvies — Because I Said So
should have been a nice, winter-sized hit for the rom-com crowd when it was
released in February of 2007. Such a shame, then, that the script was stuffed
with clichés, and Keaton’s character consisted of little more than reheated,
watered-down bits of the roles she’d played in recent films such as Something’s
Gotta Give
. As Sean Means of the Salt Lake Tribune noted, Because I
Said So
“could have been retooled as a horror thriller,” and “that version
probably would have been funnier, too.”

Runners-Up: The
Number 23
,
Good Luck Chuck
,
Premonition
Best-Reviewed:
Ratatouille

 

Since you’ve made it to the end, you have indeed proven your worth as a true
acolyte of crap cinema. For further research, check out our
Worst of the
Worst
feature, where we’ve compiled the 50 worst-reviewed movies on Rotten
Tomatoes.

  • TheGreatEater

    Wow … this was horribly unreadable. The paragraph section was horribly slaughtered. Was that done on purpose? Or did you just forget to go through and give this basic editing to give some semblance of structure?

    I mean the breaks would be one thing if it was rhyming [thus making it poetic], or had a syllable flow [making it artistic]. This is just straight up slaughtered. I’ve seen more worsely written fanfics in terms of structure.

    Is there any chance that you can fix it?

  • arby

    Rebel Wilson is a smoking hot bbw !

Tag Cloud

Set visit Vudu toy story Emmy Nominations christmas movies OneApp space serial killer Oscars TNT sitcom Showtime American Society of Cinematographers Fox News Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt LGBTQ sports Logo FOX dc foreign X-Men elevated horror Hallmark Pirates GIFs theme song SundanceTV cops El Rey Trophy Talk MCU facebook Sneak Peek Character Guide dramedy Family YA Red Carpet Apple TV+ cooking political drama Calendar 007 Esquire Tomatazos Marvel Studios Columbia Pictures Black Mirror FXX comics TCA 2017 Summer DC streaming service directors supernatural latino ABC Family Tumblr witnail zero dark thirty Elton John spinoff Superheroe Sci-Fi USA Network Chernobyl Dark Horse Comics Acorn TV WGN VH1 war Freeform Apple TV Plus video AMC Emmys CBS Horror Star Wars Nickelodeon Comedy Central kids TIFF Baby Yoda Marvel mockumentary 2016 MSNBC Film Valentine's Day Britbox zombies aliens Fall TV Adult Swim HBO Max golden globes See It Skip It natural history Box Office crossover Marvel Television Lifetime 20th Century Fox Thanksgiving teaser Country Netflix award winner movie Pixar TV sequel Trivia First Look Teen Superheroes Mindy Kaling cats Grammys disaster GoT OWN ratings Winners Universal LGBT dragons documentary talk show TV renewals doctor who Election romantic comedy singing competition adventure Pride Month Martial Arts dogs Comic Book Spectrum Originals Extras psycho revenge Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Song of Ice and Fire finale Super Bowl Amazon Studios Hallmark Christmas movies Action Paramount Spike DC Comics The Walking Dead Marathons transformers VICE south america Ovation harry potter game of thrones BBC independent Schedule Starz indie Christmas Photos romance Avengers crime SXSW television anime E! Stephen King Walt Disney Pictures TLC New York Comic Con Classic Film cults politics Lifetime Christmas movies A&E Apple children's TV technology Mystery GLAAD Crunchyroll Holidays anthology nature Polls and Games casting Winter TV The Witch quibi Video Games Rom-Com ESPN BBC America Creative Arts Emmys 2017 spider-man boxoffice Quiz RT History 2020 Trailer spy thriller composers DirecTV Hulu Holiday Biopics Toys social media animated based on movie sag awards HBO Best and Worst science fiction BET TV Land Mary Poppins Returns Black History Month stand-up comedy E3 joker Ghostbusters Pop Shondaland RT21 Turner APB Certified Fresh cancelled TV shows 71st Emmy Awards Rocky DGA Lucasfilm hispanic 2019 robots Sundance FX comiccon discovery Turner Classic Movies crime thriller The CW crime drama Amazon Prime Interview Food Network Anna Paquin police drama Heroines 45 Rocketman NYCC Animation Pet Sematary Comedy Mudbound canceled TV shows Masterpiece Nominations WarnerMedia Nat Geo History Disney Plus Countdown Reality Competition spain Sony Pictures Paramount Network Rock historical drama book Academy Awards PaleyFest Writers Guild of America halloween thriller series Western Mary poppins Tarantino Arrowverse CBS All Access Peacock blaxploitation jamie lee curtis Ellie Kemper Spring TV binge President Disney+ Disney Plus ITV cinemax biography Fantasy vampires unscripted spanish language YouTube Epix Musical true crime justice league canceled screenings hist Sundance Now cartoon Cartoon Network docudrama reboot cancelled Mary Tyler Moore slashers Amazon Prime Video IFC free movies YouTube Red Disney Channel ghosts CNN DC Universe TruTV TCM Endgame Binge Guide Disney Film Festival Drama Television Academy strong female leads National Geographic Syfy cars TBS comic Tubi Premiere Dates richard e. Grant TCA Winter 2020 Reality streaming Kids & Family cancelled TV series IFC Films rotten movies we love Women's History Month Watching Series versus what to watch 24 frames Netflix Christmas movies USA game show San Diego Comic-Con Lionsgate Infographic Podcast SDCC Shudder cancelled television CMT festivals mutant travel breaking bad batman YouTube Premium Amazon adaptation Sundance TV 21st Century Fox tv talk miniseries ABC name the review diversity Warner Bros. NBC Brie Larson Music period drama Bravo medical drama dceu Disney streaming service green book zombie 2018 Captain marvel Crackle CW Seed Awards Discovery Channel Cosplay Musicals The Purge movies First Reviews blockbuster Star Trek MTV Cannes A24 werewolf renewed TV shows screen actors guild Awards Tour TCA psychological thriller 2015 The Arrangement Year in Review Comics on TV Opinion PBS