From the highly acclaimed to the aw-that’s-a-shame, these are the best and worst reviewed television series by network. Unsurprisingly, networks with just a few shows, like BBC America and TBS, fared much better overall than those with more. Even with 10 shows on the docket, though, HBO still managed to stay entirely Fresh; its lowest-rated series is Animals at 60 percent. See below for the full breakdown.

Networks

Series included are currently on the air and have not aired their final episode as of May 18th, 2016.

iNTRO

Fall TV Scorecard 2015

The 2015 fall TV season has brought us a plentiful harvest of new shows — a few movie adaptations, a couple of TV reboots, and a whole lot of Rob Lowe. We witnessed the birth of new hits, as others made their way to cancellation heaven.

So, if you’ve been telling yourself that you’re going to catch up with all the new shows, but don’t know where to begin, Rotten Tomatoes is counting down all the best and not-so-best shows of the fall. Where will your new favorites rank? Click through to find out!

 

 

It’s time for our weekly Fall Premieres TV Review Countdown. Here are the best (and worst) premieres for the week of Friday, November 13. See how this week’s shows Into the Badlands, W/Bob and David, and Donny! stack up against each other on the Tomatometer!

Donny Deutsch, ad-mad-extraordinaire-turned-talk-show-host is enjoying the newest incarnation of his career — playing himself.

In Donny!, USA Network’s new soft-scripted comedy about his own life, Deutsch, who once helmed the real CNBC talk show The Big Idea With Donny Deutsch, plays the host of a fake Dr. Phil-style daytime show (also called Donny!), tackling an array of contemporary issues. On his fake talk show, Donny has an executive producer in his ear (Emily Tarver), who keeps him from looking too idiotic in public — and off camera, his character has a coterie of assistants who try to save him from the same issues he discusses on his show.

Rotten Tomatoes chatted with Deutsch and Tarver about how Donny! came to be, and how a non-actor ended up playing himself on TV. Turns out improv is not all that different from life in the board room. Here’s what we learned!


DONNY! IS INSPIRED BY A TODAY SHOW SEGMENT

Deutsch, who’s often a talk show guest himself, said that the inspiration for Donny! came out of his recurring spot on the Today show called “The Professionals,” which featured him, Star Jones, and Dr. Nancy Snyderman sounding off on various topics.”

“We’d have all these different guests and talk show hosts,” Deutsch told Rotten Tomatoes. “Having met so many people in the media, you see their personas, and when the cameras goes off, you see this other thing; [that] was kinda the inspiration for it.”

That’s just the beginning of where the art-versus-reality line gets fuzzy. Not only will the host have a fake show within the show inspired from his frequent visits to the Today show, but he’ll also have an episode where he visit Kathy Lee and Hoda!


 THE DIALOGUE OF DONNY! IS HEAVILY IMPROVISED

Donny! — like Larry David’s Curb Your Enthusiasm to which the show is heavily indebted — is what USA is calling “soft-scripted,” meaning that the situations are on the page, but the dialogue itself is more of a guideline than a bible.

“Since I’m so new to this, I didn’t know the rules that we were breaking,” Deutsch said. “We’d have a script and we’d read it once and Emily [Traver] and I would start f—ing around, and it was just like, ‘What’s going to make the best scene?'”

Tarver, a seasoned improviser who got her start at New York’s famous Upright Citizen Brigade theater, explained how she and Deutsch would map out the beats of a scene and then merely try to talk like real people. “There’s a little bit of overlap, which I always really enjoy when I see a show like Parenthood,” the actress said. “I love that show and that aspect of how people talk. People don’t wait for someone else to stop talking.” As if on cue, Deutsch interrupted, “Especially me.”


DEUTSCH HAS BEEN IMPROVING FOR YEARS — HE JUST DIDN’T KNOW IT

Tarver described herself as “completely, absolutely, whole-heartedly amazed” at Deutsch’s improv chops. “I think when you study improv, you can get bogged down in the rules of it,” she said. “The whole thing about improv, especially at UCB, is don’t think, just do — just do whatever’s there and that’s how Donny performs. I kinda don’t want him to ever take a class or to ever listen to anyone.

“It’s interesting,” Deutsch added, reflecting on his pre-improv career. “I would sit in client meetings and I’d hear what they are saying and react and take it down a path that I wanted to go down. And then for years and years and years doing live television — whether it’s been interviewing people or being interviewed — that’s all improv. I mean, it’s basically thinking on your feet, producing in your head, and saying, “Okay, this person said this. What if I take it here or go there?” Just instinctively doing it. So actually I had a lot of training — not with formal acting — it was just very in the moment and fun.”


DONNY’S ‘DADDY BACKGROUND’ PLAYS A BIG ROLE

As in his real life, being a dad is a big part of playing the role of Donny, whose two TV kids are portrayed by Fiona Robert and Jacob Thomas Anderson. “I have a grown daughter who is 27 now,” said Deutsch. “I have an 8- and 12-year-old at home and I’m very open with them. They’ve only known this life. I’m very comfortable bringing a woman home who I’ve just gone on one date with; they know it’s not their new mommy. They know it’s a date that Daddy’s going out on, and they’re like, ‘Cool.'”

Deutsch tries to play the dad stuff as true to his real life as possible. “What’s fun about this show for me is everything that I’ve done has informed it. My advertising background, my talk show background, and my daddy background,” he explained. “So, if I’m doing this scene where I’m talking to my kids, I’m just talking to my  [TV] kids like I talk to my [real] kids. It’s not hard. I’m just playing an idiotic version of myself and I don’t have to do it word for word, so they made it easy for me.”


PLAYING AN IDIOTIC VERSION OF YOURSELF IS FUN

Deutsch is aware of how his persona comes off in Donny! and he embraces the freedom of being self-deprecating. “What’s interesting is in the episode with Christie Brinkley, there’s a funny scene where I talk to my assistants about how I take women back to my home and give them a tour,” Deutsch, who shoots the series in his real-life six-story New York City mansion, explained to Rotten Tomatoes. “It gets very seductive. I’m narrating it [to the assistants] but that’s actually what happens and I’m aware of it. So a woman will come in and go, “Oh, you collect art!” and I go, “Yeah,” and in their heads, they are thinking, ‘Oh, wow, he’s got some culture.’ Then you bring them up into the kid’s floor, and it’s ‘Oh my God — he’s a good dad!’ I’m actually aware of this happening, so all I’m doing is just making fun of my ridiculous life.”

The seduction only last so long, however. “I usually end up getting burned one way or the other,” Deutsch laughed. “The women always come out on top in every element of the show and that’s the way it kinda happens in my life also. I’ve always surrounded myself with strong, fantastic women… I fashion myself quite the ladies man, but I usually come up short.”


EXPECT A LOT OF CAMEOS BY DONNY’S REAL-LIFE FAMOUS FRIENDS

Christie Brinkley isn’t the only cameo in Donny! Expect appearances from his friends in the media, including Reverend Al Sharpton, Morning Joe’s Mika Brzezinski and Joe Scarborough, Regis Philbin, Maria Menounos, Billy Bush, and Russell Simmons this season.

“There’s a couple of more surprises that show up,” Deutsch teased. “Everybody was just totally into it. I think if the show does well, much like Curb was to entertainment in L.A., this will be a big media stop because people love making fun of themselves and they love making fun of me. That was one of the big draws to come on.”

Donny! premieres tonight on USA Network at 10:30 p.m. and also stars Hailey Giles, Meera Kumbhani, and Jessica Renee Russell.

With fall comes the return of your favorite TV shows, but it also means that dozens of network hopefuls will be debuting in the weeks. To prime you on what’s hitting the airwaves this season, we have a rundown of the new TV shows, including where and when to find them!


Tag Cloud

justice league television comics reboot 71st Emmy Awards The Walking Dead IMDb TV stoner Apple toronto Interview The CW Mystery disaster spain OWN Box Office adenture series Quiz DC Comics monster movies Universal true crime dreamworks Academy Awards San Diego Comic-Con RT21 politics Paramount Network vampires Super Bowl VOD Tomatazos LGBT History See It Skip It Country worst movies Comic-Con@Home 2021 73rd Emmy Awards hollywood Song of Ice and Fire cults legend venice Amazon art house Sundance Now GIFs batman BBC America HFPA Esquire animated FX on Hulu football thriller The Purge scorecard foreign Marvel Hallmark Christmas movies ratings live action A&E nature game show Sundance Hallmark TCA 2017 facebook Turner Rocky psychological thriller 2016 ViacomCBS Martial Arts superhero stop motion Broadway name the review Masterpiece crime drama Crunchyroll spy thriller mockumentary japanese TIFF concert Rock Calendar razzies 2018 ID BBC rt labs technology high school ITV japan Musical festival Anna Paquin composers Tokyo Olympics RT History Binge Guide cancelled TV shows Crackle anthology Emmy Nominations PlayStation Spring TV Showtime a nightmare on elm street Tarantino Valentine's Day Lifetime Marvel Television comedies SDCC Shudder telelvision universal monsters Christmas Polls and Games hist canceled TCA genre indiana jones mcc theme song book blockbuster Film rotten movies we love Awards suspense Video Games Thanksgiving DGA DC Universe Chilling Adventures of Sabrina ABC Family hidden camera cartoon cinemax Television Academy video worst Film Festival Family 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Starz cats halloween tv sitcom award winner President 90s BAFTA Biopics news Reality spider-verse Mary Poppins Returns Syfy golden globes deadpool Columbia Pictures Mudbound movie 4/20 independent Apple TV+ Warner Bros. finale screen actors guild CW Seed natural history WarnerMedia Trailer travel Election kong Winter TV sopranos Fox Searchlight diversity Certified Fresh rotten BET Awards supernatural Food Network debate The Academy Musicals indie blaxploitation 2015 American Society of Cinematographers dogs Marathons free movies comic book movies women live event Epix new zealand Sci-Fi Hulu FOX Extras ESPN 24 frames Elton John Brie Larson joker dc comiccon Set visit rt archives game of thrones Cannes Watching Series Acorn TV basketball A24 space vs. boxing FX AMC romance The Witch young adult Universal Pictures strong female leads richard e. Grant die hard kaiju Disney Plus Women's History Month green book Wes Anderson reviews Star Wars SXSW TruTV cancelled asian-american spanish language adaptation PaleyFest New York Comic Con Red Carpet crossover slashers Creative Arts Emmys Rom-Com cooking Photos Oscars gangster zombie Nat Geo 79th Golden Globes Awards OneApp Trivia latino sequels wonder woman lord of the rings criterion 2020 Best and Worst serial killer Stephen King crime thriller sports nfl First Reviews anime marvel comics saw Teen Marvel Studios Fox News NYCC stand-up comedy spider-man NBC Peacock marvel cinematic universe IFC Films VH1 93rd Oscars First Look comic books Sundance TV Fargo PBS parents National Geographic casting TLC aliens Sneak Peek HBO Max Pirates kids Cosplay sequel twilight Pop medical drama 007 ABC Comedy emmy awards Lionsgate Shondaland book adaptation Animation USA Hear Us Out 72 Emmy Awards all-time leaderboard Netflix The Walt Disney Company south america festivals Mary Tyler Moore TBS discovery cancelled television pirates of the caribbean canceled TV shows Lifetime Christmas movies mutant Disney best child's play Vudu Holidays MCU children's TV archives zero dark thirty Music video on demand Amazon Prime Apple TV Plus Classic Film Infographic Black History Month Netflix Christmas movies HBO Comics on TV Comic Book Character Guide TCA Winter 2020 screenings GLAAD 2021 AMC Plus Alien heist movie WGN Prime Video documentaries quibi Avengers Summer Baby Yoda crime unscripted comic book movie doctor who singing competition historical drama Superheroe witnail YouTube Premium Toys dexter Paramount YouTube Red period drama TNT Winners elevated horror aapi franchise ghosts Pacific Islander versus dragons FXX black royal family 45 Funimation Britbox scary Spike El Rey Opinion harry potter dramedy biography spinoff robots james bond scary movies classics Exclusive Video documentary Action DirecTV 99% boxoffice X-Men Schedule comic Paramount Plus Arrowverse jamie lee curtis TV Land Superheroes USA Network CBS All Access E3 transformers Heroines scene in color Hollywood Foreign Press Association 2017 Western trailers miniseries Comedy Central Sony Pictures binge streaming Fantasy Year in Review APB HBO Go psycho Kids & Family feel good action-comedy know your critic Drama films Endgame breaking bad posters BBC One LGBTQ king kong Amazon Studios 1990s police drama Pop TV CNN teaser Chernobyl godzilla international fast and furious Pixar Nominations Adult Swim golden globe awards werewolf target critics Freeform ABC Signature VICE slasher popular Reality Competition dceu adventure Ovation tv talk TV One revenge MSNBC directors jurassic park streaming movies blockbusters Captain marvel The Arrangement Premiere Dates Trophy Talk Instagram Live Walt Disney Pictures E! new star wars movies sag awards Tubi Countdown australia Emmys cancelled TV series Neflix Tumblr king arthur Disney streaming service 21st Century Fox Logo Pride Month Spectrum Originals TCA Awards NBA Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Travel Channel war chucky Ghostbusters trophy hispanic heritage month movies remakes GoT DC streaming service Disney Channel cars Television Critics Association halloween mission: impossible Disney+ Disney Plus Bravo Lucasfilm Grammys romantic comedy TV renewals toy story Turner Classic Movies YA Mindy Kaling SundanceTV social media IFC olympics satire renewed TV shows what to watch Awards Tour docuseries YouTube critic resources Star Trek cops Image Comics nbcuniversal Amazon Prime Video Rocketman fresh 20th Century Fox prank BET biopic Black Mirror Fall TV Writers Guild of America zombies political drama rom-coms mob based on movie TCM new york black comedy Horror dark Ellie Kemper Legendary Nickelodeon christmas movies laika spanish italian talk show CBS superman Pet Sematary hispanic 2019 docudrama science fiction rt labs critics edition french obituary TV movies Holiday CMT Mary poppins Cartoon Network Podcast Dark Horse Comics MTV Discovery Channel Tags: Comedy TV