Weekly Ketchup

Yearly Ketchup: The Most Rotten Movie Development News of 2019

A month-by-month round-up of the worst news to come out of Hollywood this year.

by | January 3, 2020 | Comments

Few industries enjoy taking really, really long extended holiday vacations quite like Hollywood, and when we get to this time of the year, there’s rarely much in the realm of “movie development news” to discuss. Last week, we covered the year’s biggest Fresh news stories, and this week, we’re looking at the ones we deemed most Rotten instead.


Warner Bros.
(Photo by Warner Bros.)

Kevin Hart’s Tomatometer has been getting better in the last few years, starting with his partnership with Dwayne Johnson in Central Intelligence (which carried into their Jumanji movies), and including his voice role in Captain Underpants: The First Epic Movie (Certified Fresh at 88%). Before 2016, however, his track record mostly carried a broad series of Rotten splotches, with only a few Fresh tomatoes, and most of those were for his comedy concert films. Hart had several new movies announced in 2019 (including Black Friday, Extreme Job, and remakes of Scrooged and Uptown Saturday Night), but it all started in January with the long-in-development board game adaptation of Monopoly. The idea of a movie based on the classic Monopoly board game has been kicking around for over a decade, including a time when Ridley Scott was attached, but the Monopoly movie we’ll actually get sounds a drastic switch. Kevin Hart will star in Monopoly for Lionsgate and Hasbro, with his Ride Along director Tim Story also on board.


Jaap Buitendijk/Paramount Pictures
(Photo by Jaap Buitendijk/Paramount Pictures)

If you were a big fan of Brad Pitt and director Marc Foster’s zombie movie World War Z, February brought some bad news. After years of near-starts and delays, Paramount Pictures finally, apparently definitively, pulled the plug on a World War Z sequel. Pre-production was reportedly already well underway for a six month shoot in Atlanta and other nations around the world, but that also meant the budget exploded to over $190 million, and that was the breaking point for Paramount. Technically, it sounds like World War Z might come back, even with a sequel, in the future, but if it does, it would be with a much lower budget, without Foster directing, and possibly without Brad Pitt as well. [Editor’s note: an earlier version listed David Fincher as editor of World War Z. This has been corrected and we regret the error.]


20th Century Fox Film Corp.
(Photo by 20th Century Fox Film Corp.)

In March, Disney finalized its $71.3 billion deal to acquire the entertainment assets of the Fox film and TV studios. The deal was widely applauded by Marvel Comics fans who are eager to see the X-Men and Fantastic Four characters and properties now available for Marvel Studios in their future movies (though probably not until after 2022). However, that also meant that some/many of the projects that Fox had been developing would be shelved, including X-Force, X-23, Kitty Pryde, and Madrox the Multiple Man. We’ll never know what those movies might have been like, and it’s definitely possible some would have been Rotten (given Fox’s record on recent X-Men movies). They’re good examples, however, of the wide scope of Marvel movies we would have gotten if Marvel and Sony also had Fox developing movies every year. How long will it take now for Marvel Studios to go deep enough into their catalog to greenlight movies like Kitty Pryde and Madrox the Multiple Man?


STX Entertainment
(Photo by STX Entertainment)

After Bad Moms earned $183 million globally in the summer of 2016, it was followed by the sequel A Bad Moms Christmas in 2017. That second film introduced grandmother characters played by Christine Baranski, Cheryl Hines, and Susan Sarandon, and in April, we learned that they’re going to get their own movie called Bad Moms’ Moms. It’s not yet known if Kristen Bell, Kathryn Hahn, and Mila Kunis will reprise their roles as well, or if the third movie might introduce the next set of older great-grandmas (who could then get their own movie called Bad Moms’ Moms’ Moms). Both Bad Moms and A Bad Moms Christmas earned Rotten Tomatometer scores at 58% and 30%, respectively.


@ Paramount Pictures
(Photo by @ Paramount Pictures)

Some of the year’s most Rotten stories represent missteps that were eventually corrected, but we are looking at these stories as they were at the time. In this case, Paramount appeared to get the message within the same week, but still, at the time, the reaction was very negative. After all, Paramount Pictures should’ve seen this one coming. In April, the first Sonic the Hedgehog trailer debuted, and the collective fan backlash against Sonic’s design was even louder this time. (The eyes are too small, the nose is at the wrong angle, and the teeth. Where to even begin on the teeth?) The Sonic the Hedgehog missteps were only accentuated by the timing of the trailer in the same week as the first Pokemon Detective Pikachu reviews, as that film has not one but dozens of video game characters that look pretty much exactly like they do in the games. The good news, however, is that Sonic the Hedgehog director Jeff Fowler quickly responded on Twitter, “The message is loud and clear… you aren’t happy with the design & you want changes.” Those changes came later in the year as we got a new Sonic the Hedgehog trailer in which he did indeed look a lot more like he does in the games. Sonic the Hedgehog is now scheduled as a Valentine’s release on 2/14/2020.


Paramount Pictures
(Photo by Paramount Pictures)

It’s now been over four years since 2015’s Paranormal Activity: The Ghost Dimension earned the franchise’s lowest box office to date, domestically earning one fifth less than the first film. The Paranormal Activity movies were also relatively affordable to produce, so it was probably inevitable that Paramount Pictures would want to start making them again. Producer Jason Blum (of Blumhouse Productions) is now developing Paranormal Activity 7 for Paramount, although the premise isn’t yet known (though it seems obvious that it will probably be another “found footage” horror film). The Tomatometer scores for the last three films (24%, 39%, and 15%, respectively) don’t offer much hope for the next installment, unfortunately. Since this news broke in June, Paramount has scheduled Paranormal Activity 7 for release on March 19, 2021, up against the second Tomb Raider movie starring Alicia Vikander, and the week before The Boss Baby 2.


TriStar Pictures courtesy Everett Collection
(Photo by TriStar Pictures courtesy Everett Collection)

One of the oddest examples of movies that ended up getting two sequels to justify it becoming a “trilogy” might arguably be 1989’s Look Who’s Talking (Rotten at 59%), which was followed in 1990 by Look Who’s Talking Too (Rotten at 14%), and in 1993 by Look Who’s Talking Now (Rotten at 0%). John Travolta and Kirstie Alley starred in those movies about talking babies, and in the third movie, talking dogs. Despite those critical drubbings, Sony Pictures is now developing a Look Who’s Talking reboot to be written and directed by Jeremy Garelick, whose 2015 comedy The Wedding Ringer earned a Rotten score at 27%. It’s not yet known if Bruce Willis or any of the other voice actors might return for the reboot (but they probably won’t).


Sony Pictures
(Photo by Sony Pictures)

As with the Sonic the Hedgehog hullabaloo, this is another example of something that was horrible news at the time but has since been course-corrected. We are referring to that period in late summer when Sony and Marvel almost parted ways over future Spider-Man movies starring Tom Holland. Just over a month later, the two studios “made nice” and were able to announce a third Spider-Man movie set in the MCU for release on July 16, 2021. As for what their initial boondoggle was about, Disney and Marvel reportedly wanted 50% of “the cut” of Sony’s Spider-Man movies in return for Kevin Feige’s participation and all of the cross-promotion that a Sony/Disney/Marvel partnership brings with it. Sony then responded with a series of Tweets that used words like “mischaracterized” and “disappointed,” which may have been a response to criticism from some fans who were quick to side with Disney, Kevin Feige, and Marvel Studios.


Paramount Pictures courtesy Everett Collection
(Photo by Paramount Pictures courtesy Everett Collection)

Superhero movies are what people seem to talk about the most, but movie-for-movie, they are easily outnumbered by the real trend in studio releases, which is the continuing stream of remakes, reboots, and reimaginings. We hear about remakes all year round, but September of 2019 featured an especially high number of such stories, all within three weeks. It started with the news that a remake of the 1997 action thriller Face/Off is now in development. Although it feels like the 1997 action thriller only gets mentioned now when someone wants to make a joke, the film starring Nicolas Cage and John Travolta actually maintains an impressive Certified Fresh Tomatometer score of 92%. The following week brought news about remakes of The Craft, House Party, and Set It Off, as well as out-of-context stories about a remake of The Princess Bride. The month ended with another remake announcement, this time concerning 1991’s New Jack City.


In the 1980s, former Get Smart star Don Adams had something of a late career resurgence as the voice of the animated super detective Inspector Gadget. Although that show only ran for two seasons and 86 episodes, its cultural imprint was strong enough that Walt Disney Pictures produced a live-action movie in 1999 (Rotten at 21%), which was followed in 2003 by a direct-to-video sequel (Rotten at 40%). Despite the critical drubbings of those two previous live-action movies, Walt Disney Pictures appears ready to reboot Inspector Gadget, as the studio is now working with the producers of this year’s Aladdin remake and current Saturday Night Live writers Mikey Day and Streeter Seidell to do exactly that.


Most stories we might consider Rotten are based on Tomatometer scores and such, but few of them inspire the sort of reaction that erupted when it was revealed in November that one of Hollywood’s most beloved prematurely departed movie stars will be “revived” using CGI. James Dean died with just a few films to his credit (three in lead roles, not counting earlier uncredited roles) as the star of East of Eden, Rebel Without a Cause, and Giant, all three of which came out in 1955 or 1956 (he died on September 30, 1955). That said, James Dean will “star” in his fourth movie in an independent Vietnam War-era drama called Finding Jack, about the plight of military dogs following the end of the war. The filmmakers plan on using old film footage and photographs of Dean to create a photorealistic depiction of the actor following the acquisition of the rights to his name and likeness from his surviving family members. The news attracted immediate reactions from stars like Chris Evans (who probably doesn’t want someone casting him in a movie 100 years from now), but the film’s director said the backlash came as a surprise to him.


In December, many movie fans were probably surprised when Aladdin star Mena Massoud stated that he hadn’t yet had a single audition following the film’s box office success of over a billion dollars worldwide. Nearly an “unknown” before Aladdin, Massoud had won that role as part of a massive casting call that Disney staged for both Aladdin and Jasmine in 2017. Considering how much attention Mena Massoud’s revelation made at the time, you might think Disney would’ve held back on a subsequent announcement, because the two stories together paint a particularly pretty. Nevertheless, Disney+ has announced plans for an Aladdin spinoff movie starring Billy Magnussen as his minor character of Prince Anders, a minor character who didn’t exist in the original animated film and was newly created for the live-action adaptation. It’s not yet known if any other Aladdin co-stars will also be cast.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

politics romance historical drama golden globes USA Network Hallmark Christmas movies Comic Book supernatural CMT canceled Film Festival fast and furious Paramount Network Cosplay YouTube Red spinoff Ovation GIFs asian-american Writers Guild of America Pop History quibi YouTube Premium 007 Disney Channel CBS All Access halloween Summer GLAAD Western Nominations 2015 Turner Rocketman based on movie TLC Emmy Nominations series Rock TV all-time Anna Paquin versus critics TV renewals 4/20 Chilling Adventures of Sabrina science fiction jamie lee curtis A&E Peacock BBC One green book cancelled natural history movies E3 Toys BET Awards Columbia Pictures ESPN SXSW vampires anthology Stephen King DC Universe Showtime PaleyFest psychological thriller Infographic 2019 Awards Tour ghosts TBS dark Trivia Masterpiece satire cinemax Red Carpet ABC Family ITV Character Guide batman unscripted BBC police drama BAFTA elevated horror Superheroes movie concert NBC OneApp Action Sundance TV comedies tv talk MCU screen actors guild Oscars Valentine's Day DGA Disney Emmys Mindy Kaling hist New York Comic Con Lucasfilm E! Calendar witnail Black History Month SDCC cartoon IFC Films news Superheroe Endgame Syfy Crackle composers Horror streaming IFC Musical crime Spring TV Fantasy dc singing competition Comedy Chernobyl Spectrum Originals hispanic Christmas BET Warner Bros. docudrama The Arrangement RT History Lifetime casting WarnerMedia Amazon Prime justice league FX on Hulu sag awards Family Star Wars Trailer Pixar Holidays spanish language Schedule TCA 2017 social media cancelled TV shows TV Land book Cannes HBO Max Song of Ice and Fire thriller OWN Marvel renewed TV shows Baby Yoda adventure binge reboot Biopics TCA Awards spain Pirates cooking comics The Purge TCA dramedy El Rey mockumentary cats miniseries die hard National Geographic finale universal monsters Opinion doctor who Disney streaming service CW Seed talk show independent DC streaming service Pet Sematary Shondaland VH1 Sneak Peek Acorn TV indiana jones Apple TV Plus video on demand 24 frames FXX award winner latino scary movies dogs Super Bowl technology Amazon Studios DirecTV Women's History Month transformers robots Hear Us Out rotten revenge Nat Geo Certified Fresh Walt Disney Pictures Sci-Fi Ghostbusters Grammys 71st Emmy Awards anime Shudder Apple TV+ spy thriller 20th Century Fox emmy awards crime drama TIFF Trophy Talk crossover space theme song medical drama comiccon Britbox See It Skip It dragons Apple Sundance Logo Creative Arts Emmys 2017 Disney+ Disney Plus criterion Mary Tyler Moore what to watch Paramount toy story Tumblr 45 LGBT Best and Worst ratings WGN political drama BBC America TNT stoner video discovery Amazon Prime Video worst Heroines Netflix dceu Classic Film Tarantino Marvel Television Winners PBS Winter TV YouTube Binge Guide Marathons Elton John war obituary canceled TV shows richard e. Grant GoT USA aliens Discovery Channel serial killer Starz Marvel Studios DC Comics 21st Century Fox San Diego Comic-Con Amazon Arrowverse Set visit Hallmark Polls and Games Adult Swim Rom-Com Star Trek Nickelodeon hollywood superhero strong female leads HBO nbcuniversal Crunchyroll YA Teen blaxploitation Travel Channel screenings facebook diversity Freeform Interview rotten movies we love game of thrones free movies mutant Election AMC Pride Month romantic comedy sports television Comics on TV Quiz Television Critics Association TCM true crime child's play TruTV Television Academy Ellie Kemper documentaries Academy Awards biography foreign Sony Pictures south america adaptation Mystery Rocky werewolf Reality Competition game show Captain marvel stand-up comedy X-Men name the review HBO Go joker Video Games MTV Pop TV Black Mirror Universal Podcast laika films slashers Drama Mary poppins Sundance Now Hulu twilight Bravo Netflix Christmas movies 2016 Film Year in Review directors Epix children's TV Awards a nightmare on elm street documentary Fall TV Premiere Dates CNN harry potter Musicals Disney Plus Brie Larson Tomatazos animated blockbuster Martial Arts travel Lifetime Christmas movies zombie The CW disaster American Society of Cinematographers CBS VOD classics zombies Comedy Central crime thriller Animation indie cops chucky cars The Witch comic VICE boxoffice Box Office Lionsgate sequel First Reviews Esquire Extras stop motion NYCC Photos period drama MSNBC psycho festivals Thanksgiving Funimation FOX 2020 APB Kids & Family Watching Series nature cancelled television sitcom franchise Country 72 Emmy Awards Turner Classic Movies TCA Winter 2020 ABC LGBTQ mission: impossible best cancelled TV series Countdown FX SundanceTV A24 parents PlayStation christmas movies teaser reviews zero dark thirty Music Cartoon Network Food Network cults Vudu Reality Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Avengers Mudbound President Mary Poppins Returns Holiday 2018 Spike breaking bad spider-man kids Dark Horse Comics The Walking Dead Fox News First Look RT21 Tubi