Video Interviews

Who Is the Best Spider-Man?

The iconic web-slinger is one of our most rebooted superheroes, but who is the best Spider there ever was: Holland? Maguire? Garfield? We're settling the debate, now!

by | March 19, 2020 | Comments

Tom Holland is riding high as Marvel Studios’ current live-action Spider-Man, but he is far from the first to slip on the Spidey suit. Some would say it was Tobey Maguire, with his three Spider-Man films directed by Sam Raimi, who kicked off the superhero movie era as we know it and respect must be paid; others would say Andrew Garfield was an underrated web-slinger who perhaps failed to soar less because of his performance than the movies that surrounded it. Others would counter with a GIF of Maguire dancing. We’re here to settle the debate once and for all – at least Mark Ellis is. Our Vs. host is breaking down the Spider-Men by Tomatometer, box office, and the villains they faced to determine once and for all who wore it best – “it” being the blue-and-red suit, of course.


Check out clips of some of Spider-Man’s best moments

Tag Cloud

richard e. Grant disaster American Society of Cinematographers NYCC sag awards Tubi USA Network christmas movies YouTube Year in Review FXX Classic Film period drama Lifetime Christmas movies Paramount Plus remakes olympics Superheroes Election Neflix spider-man Crunchyroll docudrama X-Men 007 true crime documentary Thanksgiving Sundance TV Winners Star Wars DC Comics Funimation Hallmark Christmas movies HBO Ovation franchise Television Academy quibi MCU Starz best Stephen King wonder woman TV One kaiju marvel comics Wes Anderson Freeform Turner Classic Movies ID VH1 Mindy Kaling lord of the rings french Universal Pictures foreign dexter know your critic Fox Searchlight book halloween tv Disney new zealand NBA 2015 Bravo asian-american superhero Biopics comic books jamie lee curtis Holidays HBO Go crime thriller rotten movies we love italian Captain marvel high school cinemax Rom-Com binge sequel child's play Amazon Studios romance Pet Sematary blockbuster 21st Century Fox BET Awards science fiction casting aliens IFC Films debate zombie biopic Masterpiece game show Reality Competition based on movie The Arrangement DC streaming service Mary Tyler Moore cults trailers singing competition kong documentaries halloween Character Guide Action politics 2018 superman renewed TV shows facebook Showtime Disney+ Disney Plus cancelled TV series Rocketman mutant Walt Disney Pictures Watching Series IFC Instagram Live Valentine's Day Marvel A24 serial killer Lionsgate Columbia Pictures king arthur scene in color Family new star wars movies VOD Pacific Islander Fantasy streaming popular ESPN dreamworks Elton John Schedule critic resources mob 2020 Britbox series sopranos TCA crossover Drama Song of Ice and Fire Alien Rock YouTube Red ITV stoner space Chernobyl dc medical drama Super Bowl Awards Set visit Interview SDCC blaxploitation Lifetime HBO Max comic PaleyFest SundanceTV finale YA gangster Tokyo Olympics cats Warner Bros. mission: impossible Dark Horse Comics Calendar adenture Pixar twilight docuseries Spike Arrowverse genre news cooking Avengers children's TV 71st Emmy Awards The Academy animated TCA Awards Musical name the review reboot Podcast psychological thriller spy thriller venice Lucasfilm 2021 revenge See It Skip It green book 2019 robots transformers WarnerMedia latino Fall TV worst legend action-comedy universal monsters dark hist comic book movie nature fresh Vudu Writers Guild of America dramedy Sundance Oscars Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Disney streaming service canceled TV shows Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Infographic GoT Disney Plus Hear Us Out Epix die hard TIFF tv talk History RT History Netflix CMT The Witch Teen Paramount Sony Pictures scorecard black comedy Country Apple TV Plus DGA 73rd Emmy Awards free movies Comic-Con@Home 2021 Exclusive Video LGBT Martial Arts Cartoon Network Extras Grammys cops japan Food Network Film First Look ABC comedies Awards Tour black zero dark thirty sports Video Games TV indie 1990s supernatural Box Office OneApp witnail book adaptation Black History Month Opinion TV renewals king kong stop motion discovery Baby Yoda Crackle golden globes Film Festival Travel Channel sequels TBS concert heist movie reviews Cosplay cancelled television TV movies police drama dceu royal family Esquire what to watch social media Mary poppins Comic Book slasher DirecTV YouTube Premium FOX rt labs critics edition travel fast and furious adaptation Music Amazon Prime hollywood rt archives Polls and Games Television Critics Association Binge Guide miniseries scary movies The Purge parents Hulu Tarantino marvel cinematic universe BBC Rocky award winner target prank Legendary emmy awards cancelled elevated horror mockumentary Cannes National Geographic deadpool Sci-Fi biography Mystery satire slashers CNN festivals MTV ABC Signature composers scary nfl feel good Disney Channel comiccon suspense Spring TV Heroines The Walking Dead Star Trek TNT CBS art house Certified Fresh boxoffice Amazon Prime Video Image Comics E! football cartoon Fox News japanese 2017 CW Seed south america Winter TV Musicals TCM boxing Universal saw romantic comedy spanish movie Apple TV+ nbcuniversal Emmy Nominations Horror sitcom streaming movies Red Carpet PBS ratings BBC America Best and Worst vampires critics Academy Awards Women's History Month Quiz GIFs 24 frames spanish language doctor who Toys OWN razzies cars chucky live action international breaking bad Black Mirror canceled hispanic USA LGBTQ 99% Trivia AMC Plus godzilla television The CW toy story australia Western Pop TV video screenings A&E Christmas 72 Emmy Awards werewolf vs. CBS All Access unscripted Premiere Dates dragons PlayStation mcc spinoff Sneak Peek batman worst movies classics game of thrones new york FX Syfy hispanic heritage month TLC anthology justice league 2016 Pride Month NBC President spider-verse historical drama thriller IMDb TV RT21 Marvel Television Creative Arts Emmys AMC Adult Swim Mary Poppins Returns TCA Winter 2020 Peacock 90s talk show Superheroe young adult Pirates telelvision Shudder screen actors guild First Reviews diversity rom-coms monster movies Trailer Anna Paquin a nightmare on elm street Brie Larson Animation toronto Nominations Marvel Studios harry potter technology SXSW Logo psycho 45 MSNBC ViacomCBS all-time ghosts Shondaland Acorn TV zombies obituary 93rd Oscars 4/20 teaser BBC One anime Endgame rotten versus Emmys crime drama VICE TCA 2017 spain APB San Diego Comic-Con strong female leads Kids & Family ABC Family directors political drama adventure Pop Marathons hidden camera crime El Rey festival BAFTA natural history TV Land Reality Trophy Talk WGN Hallmark Amazon Comics on TV Ellie Kemper comic book movies Broadway archives blockbusters GLAAD independent golden globe awards Netflix Christmas movies Photos jurassic park indiana jones war Summer basketball FX on Hulu Turner theme song TruTV Nat Geo Discovery Channel Spectrum Originals stand-up comedy video on demand Tumblr E3 Mudbound DC Universe Ghostbusters New York Comic Con cancelled TV shows Paramount Network Nickelodeon joker comics posters BET Apple Holiday pirates of the caribbean james bond aapi films Comedy Central kids dogs live event laika The Walt Disney Company 20th Century Fox Tomatazos Sundance Now women movies rt labs Countdown Comedy criterion