Who Is the Best Joker?

The iconic villain has been portrayed on the big screen by several actors for over half a century, but who played him best?

by | October 4, 2019 | Comments

Joaquin Phoenix is making all the headlines with his magnetic performance in Todd Phillips’ Joker, but before he came along to give us all the creeps, who played the character best? We decided to look back at the history of the singularly iconic villain as portrayed on screen and take on the impossible task of figuring out the answer to that question. So how did we do it? Watch as Mark Ellis takes every big-screen version of the Joker and pits them against each other in four categories: Box Office/Tomatometer, Most Memorable, Most Dastardly Plan, and, of course, the Wild Card round. Check out the video to see who gets crowned the ultimate Clown Prince of Crime, and let us know in the comments who your favorite is!

Joker opens everywhere on October 4.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

President BBC Logo nature CBS All Access debate Nat Geo Pop Travel Channel emmy awards Amazon comic Masterpiece scorecard Turner Classic Movies BBC One 2019 Dark Horse Comics disaster Hallmark kids cats Calendar breaking bad adenture boxoffice slasher 90s Legendary 2020 CBS tv talk talk show Drama BBC America zombies king kong richard e. Grant action-comedy parents Emmy Nominations italian Netflix halloween batman TLC PlayStation canceled TV shows Baby Yoda hispanic comic book movie comics quibi Red Carpet IFC Crunchyroll Esquire true crime free movies nbcuniversal name the review Reality SDCC scary crime Year in Review fast and furious Elton John Broadway popular FX Nominations ABC Signature documentary TCA Winter 2020 Sci-Fi elevated horror DGA ghosts Marvel Television werewolf Musicals heist movie Summer chucky ESPN critics crime thriller Photos X-Men Reality Competition See It Skip It YA dragons Ellie Kemper IMDb TV 007 joker Binge Guide cops Lucasfilm Western psycho Music VICE scary movies teaser satire live event Netflix Christmas movies 45 toronto GoT laika strong female leads Chernobyl Countdown Writers Guild of America sequels Video Games natural history AMC Plus Film Festival directors dc Britbox Valentine's Day E3 spanish PaleyFest Television Critics Association DC Universe Apple TV Plus genre Rocketman international black comedy rotten Pirates CW Seed reviews IFC Films HBO Go latino blockbuster Fall TV all-time Horror binge Tumblr Trophy Talk golden globes thriller Sundance Now USA franchise travel jurassic park hollywood Academy Awards comedies TCA 2017 DC streaming service Comedy Central NYCC slashers social media Rocky OWN Pet Sematary Amazon Prime VOD Lifetime Christmas movies target space Awards dogs twilight kong Cannes OneApp Neflix theme song First Look obituary new star wars movies know your critic Paramount Network cancelled television Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt lord of the rings NBC Fox News Family women rotten movies we love festival deadpool APB Endgame Pixar 2018 Disney streaming service TCM Paramount Plus Trivia Avengers Superheroe diversity Captain marvel Pride Month anthology Fantasy Musical SundanceTV Tarantino Teen Epix cars BAFTA Animation adventure boxing Holiday composers new york superman children's TV transformers gangster Biopics biography hidden camera Rock TIFF stoner romantic comedy 2017 animated spain Walt Disney Pictures Oscars south america cults Spike mission: impossible Nickelodeon Schedule Columbia Pictures 2016 japan Mindy Kaling Election TBS VH1 Food Network Sneak Peek Sundance sag awards 71st Emmy Awards Mary poppins witnail USA Network miniseries war Podcast Universal Pictures 93rd Oscars marvel comics Universal criterion History 24 frames documentaries A&E Mary Poppins Returns Hear Us Out series serial killer Acorn TV Marathons Syfy Heroines ABC Fox Searchlight saw leaderboard Interview marvel cinematic universe Infographic Alien Shudder aapi sequel Comic Book Showtime indie 2015 spanish language spider-man The Walt Disney Company rt archives video New York Comic Con Extras high school ITV feel good worst movies RT21 biopic die hard technology Country Song of Ice and Fire Hallmark Christmas movies ABC Family kaiju blockbusters Warner Bros. book First Reviews Lifetime television halloween tv king arthur Paramount art house Christmas crime drama christmas movies harry potter Star Trek book adaptation stop motion Disney Channel 20th Century Fox sports Spectrum Originals Funimation toy story stand-up comedy casting Toys cartoon Quiz Image Comics CNN dexter HBO Max Sony Pictures dark Holidays new zealand RT History SXSW MTV 21st Century Fox Crackle Watching Series FX on Hulu Vudu FOX Box Office spy thriller doctor who period drama Turner live action unscripted legend crossover rt labs critics edition Super Bowl Tokyo Olympics Instagram Live Adult Swim Film historical drama Character Guide comiccon venice Winter TV hispanic heritage month Star Wars Martial Arts Ovation screenings TV renewals Certified Fresh FXX San Diego Comic-Con Premiere Dates Emmys The Walking Dead Ghostbusters TV Land YouTube Premium PBS revenge worst A24 what to watch facebook rt labs child's play The Arrangement Marvel Studios young adult green book canceled finale Amazon Studios mockumentary godzilla The Academy TCA Awards versus BET Awards LGBT prank Grammys Action mcc Women's History Month Disney+ Disney Plus trophy comic book movies Chilling Adventures of Sabrina black political drama Winners supernatural sopranos cancelled renewed TV shows classics discovery ratings DirecTV Discovery Channel Pop TV Amazon Prime Video ID movie a nightmare on elm street Arrowverse spider-verse GLAAD AMC Starz TV movies BET mutant game of thrones anime WGN hist 4/20 science fiction australia TCA politics streaming robots critic resources GIFs cooking Thanksgiving Apple Freeform video on demand Cartoon Network National Geographic zombie The Witch psychological thriller based on movie romance archives jamie lee curtis mob spinoff dramedy Stephen King wonder woman ViacomCBS olympics DC Comics YouTube Red cancelled TV shows Mary Tyler Moore Apple TV+ Mudbound 73rd Emmy Awards E! cancelled TV series news nfl singing competition TNT razzies reboot medical drama Anna Paquin aliens Superheroes Brie Larson zero dark thirty Polls and Games suspense The CW vs. Lionsgate movies El Rey 72 Emmy Awards Comedy posters CMT festivals Comics on TV MSNBC Pacific Islander dceu game show basketball monster movies TV One American Society of Cinematographers Marvel royal family The Purge Exclusive Video police drama streaming movies docudrama justice league Bravo concert universal monsters trailers asian-american Shondaland WarnerMedia Tubi sitcom independent Disney Plus Wes Anderson 99% superhero scene in color remakes 2021 TV blaxploitation Peacock 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards comic books MCU football fresh Disney james bond Television Academy Hulu pirates of the caribbean Tomatazos Creative Arts Emmys Classic Film Spring TV indiana jones films docuseries foreign YouTube adaptation Kids & Family Awards Tour Cosplay Trailer Comic-Con@Home 2021 Fargo rom-coms screen actors guild Set visit telelvision cinemax award winner TruTV Black Mirror french 1990s japanese golden globe awards best HBO Mystery NBA Best and Worst LGBTQ Rom-Com Opinion Sundance TV vampires Black History Month dreamworks