Who Is the Best Joker?

The iconic villain has been portrayed on the big screen by several actors for over half a century, but who played him best?

by | October 4, 2019 | Comments

Joaquin Phoenix is making all the headlines with his magnetic performance in Todd Phillips’ Joker, but before he came along to give us all the creeps, who played the character best? We decided to look back at the history of the singularly iconic villain as portrayed on screen and take on the impossible task of figuring out the answer to that question. So how did we do it? Watch as Mark Ellis takes every big-screen version of the Joker and pits them against each other in four categories: Box Office/Tomatometer, Most Memorable, Most Dastardly Plan, and, of course, the Wild Card round. Check out the video to see who gets crowned the ultimate Clown Prince of Crime, and let us know in the comments who your favorite is!

Joker opens everywhere on October 4.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Kids & Family Red Carpet Box Office SXSW Lucasfilm Photos ABC Family Amazon Studios movies LGBTQ batman Cosplay comics Mary poppins children's TV Sundance Pop TV Freeform X-Men disaster YouTube Red MCU BET USA Network Hallmark Film Festival unscripted OWN cults transformers MTV joker 2017 Amazon Prime south america Holidays Binge Guide strong female leads FXX Grammys streaming Pirates FX on Hulu PBS 2015 miniseries Fantasy video slashers Set visit green book technology CMT doctor who binge Nickelodeon Avengers Superheroe Black History Month dogs Thanksgiving reviews 2016 Travel Channel cancelled TV shows YouTube Premium IFC Films Television Academy spy thriller cops talk show Classic Film Tomatazos Syfy Mary Tyler Moore Quiz Christmas breaking bad Toys zombie Calendar sag awards Showtime based on movie The Witch Chilling Adventures of Sabrina adaptation spider-man foreign Hallmark Christmas movies composers El Rey Ghostbusters Universal blaxploitation Turner game of thrones The Arrangement casting Elton John Martial Arts Marvel Television harry potter spinoff facebook war Apple TV Plus CBS serial killer HBO game show Certified Fresh Paramount Endgame 007 Tarantino Bravo Ellie Kemper Netflix Baby Yoda TV dc hispanic Acorn TV dceu Comedy anime Winners justice league Hulu A24 sitcom social media werewolf blockbuster Trailer Year in Review Rocketman Peacock discovery Cartoon Network Crunchyroll Tumblr President WGN tv talk CBS All Access Trophy Talk elevated horror singing competition cats movie Spectrum Originals Logo Election MSNBC Sony Pictures GIFs Disney Channel DC streaming service Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Disney streaming service Film Interview Fall TV Paramount Network Walt Disney Pictures Drama Spring TV Adult Swim 2020 History finale television Sneak Peek Food Network medical drama docudrama NYCC Amazon Video Games Chernobyl spain BBC America RT21 45 Lifetime Opinion YouTube TBS Marvel Studios renewed TV shows VH1 festivals true crime latino Comics on TV PaleyFest mutant Podcast Star Trek Emmys cinemax Lifetime Christmas movies Funimation TLC Musicals Turner Classic Movies zombies psychological thriller Star Wars 24 frames romantic comedy Mudbound politics Mystery Country sequel 2018 TCA police drama Pet Sematary Dark Horse Comics E! Fox News TruTV nature Arrowverse Crackle Holiday Starz LGBT BBC Mary Poppins Returns series Horror GoT Captain marvel Winter TV toy story Summer canceled TV shows A&E Disney TNT Anna Paquin richard e. Grant Britbox CW Seed ratings Apple Reality Animation animated travel Reality Competition dramedy theme song independent Oscars Emmy Nominations versus romance 71st Emmy Awards 21st Century Fox halloween Esquire period drama TV Land Premiere Dates political drama Apple TV+ SDCC SundanceTV crime drama Academy Awards Netflix Christmas movies spanish language name the review Family natural history Pixar sports Character Guide WarnerMedia zero dark thirty Lionsgate Heroines Schedule witnail Nat Geo screen actors guild The Purge Spike teaser Rom-Com biography Polls and Games dragons adventure space historical drama DC Comics Awards Tour free movies aliens Stephen King Nominations The Walking Dead Sundance TV IFC Rocky DirecTV Teen christmas movies First Look New York Comic Con GLAAD CNN comiccon anthology TCM Disney+ Disney Plus First Reviews FOX universal monsters revenge stand-up comedy supernatural AMC Countdown See It Skip It documentary Disney Plus Women's History Month crime 2019 jamie lee curtis E3 OneApp Pride Month directors 20th Century Fox Mindy Kaling ESPN diversity cancelled Musical ABC APB YA HBO Max ITV comic RT History book TCA Winter 2020 Writers Guild of America The CW Shondaland Amazon Prime Video Comedy Central NBC Marathons cooking Trivia mockumentary Shudder Columbia Pictures DC Universe Vudu Action reboot award winner USA crime thriller Best and Worst TV renewals DGA hist Warner Bros. TIFF boxoffice Superheroes quibi Western Creative Arts Emmys canceled Infographic VICE Super Bowl Comic Book screenings Valentine's Day Rock rotten movies we love Brie Larson indie franchise scary movies Watching Series thriller Awards Cannes National Geographic Extras kids Music robots San Diego Comic-Con golden globes Masterpiece psycho cartoon Discovery Channel Ovation Sci-Fi Song of Ice and Fire science fiction ghosts Tubi what to watch Biopics Pop Sundance Now Marvel cars FX vampires TCA 2017 American Society of Cinematographers cancelled television crossover cancelled TV series Black Mirror Epix