Who Is the Best Joker?

The iconic villain has been portrayed on the big screen by several actors for over half a century, but who played him best?

by | October 4, 2019 | Comments

Joaquin Phoenix is making all the headlines with his magnetic performance in Todd Phillips’ Joker, but before he came along to give us all the creeps, who played the character best? We decided to look back at the history of the singularly iconic villain as portrayed on screen and take on the impossible task of figuring out the answer to that question. So how did we do it? Watch as Mark Ellis takes every big-screen version of the Joker and pits them against each other in four categories: Box Office/Tomatometer, Most Memorable, Most Dastardly Plan, and, of course, the Wild Card round. Check out the video to see who gets crowned the ultimate Clown Prince of Crime, and let us know in the comments who your favorite is!

Joker opens everywhere on October 4.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

romance action-comedy adaptation TV movies Writers Guild of America Sundance Now comic book movie discovery critics Acorn TV batman debate IFC Films New York Comic Con Image Comics marvel cinematic universe FOX Valentine's Day Trophy Talk twilight scene in color series Biopics sequel summer TV preview PlayStation Comic Book 20th Century Fox Mary Poppins Returns elevated horror chucky 4/20 lord of the rings target E3 72 Emmy Awards adenture Ellie Kemper cancelled television sports Paramount Network spanish language TIFF Sci-Fi Indigenous Anna Paquin USA Spike streaming Universal rt archives casting Emmy Nominations Polls and Games hollywood movie indiana jones ABC Family hispanic heritage month Fargo IFC crime screen actors guild what to watch films scary movies wonder woman Apple TV+ Marathons Marvel Television Awards Tour Warner Bros. Infographic spider-man MCU monster movies Elton John CBS Amazon Studios TCA 2017 Country Musicals composers strong female leads Avengers book free movies Captain marvel SundanceTV king arthur blockbusters Oscars psychological thriller critic resources war period drama cinemax spanish black kids Sneak Peek godzilla Rocky Starz Brie Larson animated interviews rotten Sony Logo universal monsters canceled art house italian based on movie YA cancelled TV series The Witch fast and furious MSNBC cooking Academy Awards DC Comics Grammys Horror know your critic Sundance TV criterion ABC joker spy thriller live action Focus Features The Walking Dead Martial Arts Holiday festival Rock breaking bad Heroines Tarantino TCA Winter 2020 slasher Esquire Lifetime Christmas movies trophy vampires reviews RT History harry potter Walt Disney Pictures aapi HBO Go game show Star Trek OneApp vs. cancelled toy story Disney+ Disney Plus Mystery MTV boxing indie Awards obituary Shudder biopic 90s Reality Competition Chernobyl San Diego Comic-Con Britbox APB news historical drama A24 independent politics Summer Television Critics Association SXSW justice league Mary poppins Apple video on demand high school obi wan The Purge SXSW 2022 women talk show halloween nbcuniversal HBO Max DC Universe 99% Pride Month Election Paramount Family fresh docuseries Star Wars Celebration Western VOD child's play worst south america sopranos Fox Searchlight TBS Spring TV rt labs critics edition social media DC streaming service Pixar classics Freeform spinoff NBC comic books Amazon Prime Crunchyroll natural history Quiz blaxploitation pirates of the caribbean First Reviews E! 2016 heist movie king kong comic ITV 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards dceu GoT BET Awards cars NBA American Society of Cinematographers Superheroe new star wars movies Television Academy mcc CBS All Access supernatural Disney streaming service Amazon Prime Video HBO Columbia Pictures Rom-Com parents ViacomCBS game of thrones Epix National Geographic new york Stephen King television YouTube golden globes cops binge Fantasy Peacock dramedy Nickelodeon summer preview franchise The CW nfl teaser LGBTQ Pop anime Schedule Disney GIFs TCM spider-verse singing competition mockumentary Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt CNN Black Mirror disaster Pop TV dragons crime thriller Character Guide canceled TV shows stop motion a nightmare on elm street target scene in color Travel Channel Universal Pictures Oscar The Academy Comedy Teen werewolf miniseries Best Actor documentaries Pacific Islander Ghostbusters Disney Plus tv talk romantic comedy TV GLAAD Calendar Hallmark Christmas movies Kids & Family basketball MGM young adult cults comiccon AMC Plus Funimation WGN Mindy Kaling Cartoon Network renewed TV shows 21st Century Fox Arrowverse 2018 TV Land cartoon Cosplay Opinion genre quibi Winners live event transformers series comedies ESPN latino Sundance kong Neflix Cannes Premiere Dates scene in color film series crossover Toys Showtime Best and Worst El Rey travel RT21 Comedy Central IMDb TV Creative Arts Emmys Star Wars festivals cats golden globe awards BBC America christmas movies Music Film Festival Musical Crackle versus 24 frames Animation Adult Swim Netflix spain Tumblr Hollywood Foreign Press Association dc hispanic dogs Best Director Alien rom-coms doctor who children's TV psycho popular VICE Sony Pictures richard e. Grant scorecard french DGA Binge Guide Geeked Week Watching Series prank streaming movies venice name the review 2021 die hard Lionsgate 79th Golden Globes Awards sitcom new zealand Super Bowl FXX Marvel Studios marvel comics best revenge 007 zero dark thirty TruTV laika Dark Horse Comics Baby Yoda Lucasfilm 2017 The Walt Disney Company Legendary Winter TV streamig See It Skip It witnail Mary Tyler Moore Paramount Pictures robots zombies remakes technology legend Photos mission: impossible mob Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Ovation BAFTA Bravo crime drama Amazon Prime Video international slashers australia facebook hist Drama toronto jamie lee curtis 93rd Oscars feel good Interview movies true crime olympics Christmas Red Carpet Tags: Comedy Black History Month Marvel posters gangster 45 94th Oscars Spectrum Originals Rocketman Trailer BBC President X-Men japanese CMT superhero asian-american stand-up comedy TLC HFPA Nat Geo Turner Classic Movies football Hear Us Out Discovery Channel Certified Fresh Fall TV royal family Action Apple TV Plus NYCC The Arrangement Tokyo Olympics Tomatazos directors dreamworks deadpool Pet Sematary TCA worst movies black comedy Women's History Month theme song biography BET AMC nature razzies japan scary rotten movies we love First Look Wes Anderson TNT Extras Thanksgiving History Comic-Con@Home 2021 1990s medical drama foreign Lifetime screenings broadcast diversity OWN suspense james bond superman Vudu docudrama blockbuster Endgame Countdown Trivia aliens 71st Emmy Awards 2015 PaleyFest YouTube Red reboot hidden camera Box Office Food Network science fiction Year in Review halloween tv comic book movies summer TV sag awards finale scene in color concert video Native TV renewals Syfy thriller SDCC ghosts 73rd Emmy Awards book adaptation Pirates comics Reality leaderboard LGBT Broadway ABC Signature anthology trailers BBC One space archives Film South by Southwest Film Festival Set visit kaiju ID police drama DirecTV green book Hulu mutant Turner telelvision jurassic park all-time USA Network dexter award winner Instagram Live Song of Ice and Fire cancelled TV shows sequels Exclusive Video Paramount Plus PBS Masterpiece Emmys Superheroes TV One ratings VH1 emmy awards Mudbound CW Seed FX Podcast WarnerMedia Nominations Hallmark saw Classic Film Comics on TV 2020 Shondaland rt labs dark 2019 Netflix Christmas movies stoner A&E satire Holidays Best Picture Video Games Tubi adventure zombie TCA Awards Best Actress unscripted boxoffice serial killer political drama YouTube Premium documentary FX on Hulu Disney Channel Fox News