What the New Fargo Cast Thought About Season One

by | October 12, 2015 | Comments

As the highly-acclaimed FX series Fargo returns for a second season tonight, rewinding the clock back to 1979, viewers will meet a new all-star cast that includes Kirsten Dunst as Peggy Blomquist, a small-town beautician with big dreams; Jesse Plemons as her husband Ed, an assistant butcher; Patrick Wilson as a younger version of Minnesota State Patrolman Lou Solverson (played in season one by Keith Carradine); Cristin Milioti as Betsy, his sweet cancer-stricken wife (and mother to young Molly Solverson); Ted Danson as Hank Larsson, the sheriff of Rock County, Minnesota and Betsy’s father; and Jeffrey Donovan as Dodd Gerhardt, a hot-tempered goon who wants to take over his family’s crime syndicate.

Rotten Tomatoes visited the season-two set of Fargo in Alberta, Canada this past April. And while we can’t tell you about the episode they were shooting for a few more weeks, we can share that the stars were very vocal about season one. Here’s what the new cast thought about the first season of Fargo. [Warning: Season one spoilers below.]


Season one of Fargo was just a binge-able to the new cast as it is to the rest of us.

“I hadn’t seen the first season of Fargo, but I loved the movie,” said Plemons. “I then watched the first season in one day.” Plemons, who was the first star to be cast in season two, also binge-read the first six episodes of season two before calling his agent and swiftly accepting the gig.

Dunst also tore through season one and felt like she was watching “an incredible movie” with each episode. From the series opening, when it opens with a foreword about being based on a true story, Dunst was hooked. “That was in the [1996] movie, too,” she said. “They just set up such a feeling right away that it’s hard not to get immediately sucked into the show and into this world.”

“I just couldn’t believe how quickly you become hooked in that first episode.” said Milioti. “It’s because of how it plays into the gray aspect of life.”


“I was watching the first episode with a little doubt in my eye, you know?” confessed Donovan. “And then, when Martin Freeman takes that ball-peen hammer and hits his wife square in the head and she has this look of shock, you think for one second that she’s going to yell at him, right? You think it’s going to be, ‘How dare you hit me?’… and then there’s this little trickle of blood, and he sees it — and he doesn’t say it — but he’s like, ‘Holy f—,’ I just went, ‘Oh, they did it! They brought humor to a murder!’ All in one explosion of a moment in life. That is so hard to do. I am telling you, that is an impossible thing to do. That’s when I knew the series was going to be great.”

Danson explained how the funny bits bring a touch of humanity to the Fargo universe. “Humor is so human,” he said. “So if you find that in the midst of all this chaos and savagery, I think it’s your saving grace.”


“When Lorne [Billy Bob Thornton] says to Lester [Freeman], ‘Do you want me to kill him, yes or no?’ You’re sitting there and you’re like, “What would I do?'” Milioti recalled about the hospital scene. “He sort of says yes and he doesn’t know what’s happened… It’s all sort of confusing and happening so fast. He’s just gone through this horrible thing and he’s just been pummeled in front of these kids. Then you see how quickly it gets out of hand, and I think that that’s so well done. I know there are so many shows now with an anti-hero. I know that phrase is over-used, but I love that.”

Wilson loved watching Martin’s journey and caring about him even though he had done awful things. “He’s a liar; he murdered his wife,” he recalled. “I know she was bad, but, really? He hit her with a hammer! But I just think he was a really wonderful character.”


It’s safe to say that the new cast of Fargo was as taken with Billy Bob Thornton’s performance as the menacing bowl-cut hitman as the critics.

“I did a movie with Billy so I knew he would always bring it,” explained Wilson. “I think a defining moment for me in this series is when [Lester and Lorne] catch up in Vegas and Lorne is a dentist, and you’re like, ‘What is happening?’ You love that he will take you around this corner. You’re like, ‘I know it’s going to come back. I know we’re going to meet up with the story line. There we gonow we’re in the restaurantokay…”

Danson had a colorful description of Thornton. “You could just tell that all the actors were having the time of their lives because the writing is so good [in season one]. Everyone,” he said. “Billy Bob was such a delicious crocodile.”

Fargo premieres tonight on FX at 10 p.m. Season two is currently Certified Fresh; read reviews here. Also read our interview with showrunner Noah Hawley about pulling off a second season.

  • New season is off to s great start. And yes, Billy Bob was pretty delicious in Season 1. Great television.

  • rackinfrackin

    Am I the only one who was disappointed with the first 2 episodes of Season 2? SO much less compelling than Season 1. And with desperate, un-FARGO movie-like gambits like UFOs and Ronald Reagan. It’s the dreaded Sophomore Syndrome, I’m afraid…

    • Vadim Weinig

      Completely agree! I was about to stop watching until I watched episode 3 and suddenly it all becomes almost as good as season 1 again… No one beats Billy-Bob’s performance though, he was just immense!

Tag Cloud

New York Comic Con Discovery Channel video Travel Channel San Diego Comic-Con Ellie Kemper Shudder PlayStation E3 animated Lucasfilm LGBTQ Netflix A24 canceled cars Action boxoffice a nightmare on elm street Women's History Month Pirates Pop satire Netflix Christmas movies Vudu independent space First Reviews all-time FOX parents TCA Martial Arts south america History Food Network Lifetime spider-man blockbuster dark worst nbcuniversal cooking Certified Fresh Dark Horse Comics festivals Comedy Central Mary Poppins Returns james bond YouTube Premium Trailer Black Mirror rt archives award winner ID laika Syfy Heroines police drama American Society of Cinematographers Television Critics Association Sundance franchise Academy Awards Sony Pictures YA Paramount Network streaming spinoff The Walking Dead X-Men Mindy Kaling FX strong female leads slashers Apple Horror Sci-Fi Sundance TV MTV BBC One Holidays RT History Superheroe screen actors guild FX on Hulu 20th Century Fox Super Bowl toy story Red Carpet Country BAFTA best Hallmark Christmas movies Spike Adult Swim Star Trek Podcast stop motion TCA Awards scorecard Kids & Family YouTube Red Showtime disaster 2015 canceled TV shows foreign quibi Apple TV+ 2017 2019 Photos E! comics historical drama crime thriller Hallmark technology 4/20 sequel Emmys Cosplay werewolf Binge Guide psychological thriller spanish DC Universe documentary Starz twilight Rock Funimation films comic books Star Wars christmas movies Pride Month video on demand Acorn TV venice OWN Christmas Alien DirecTV screenings Election blaxploitation doctor who Rocketman Nat Geo facebook zombie cinemax TLC composers 72 Emmy Awards sag awards PaleyFest rotten movies we love mutant A&E joker Grammys Turner Classic Movies science fiction biography Tubi Comedy Superheroes based on movie renewed TV shows crime VH1 President Toys war Comic Book GoT spanish language fast and furious Mary Tyler Moore CBS Stephen King 2016 Oscars USA Lifetime Christmas movies SundanceTV Esquire Set visit NBC 99% Summer FXX travel political drama CW Seed teaser IFC Films Pop TV docudrama serial killer Cannes USA Network Animation Box Office mockumentary transformers period drama Musical Spring TV sequels stoner cults french OneApp Music Crackle die hard dceu anime Song of Ice and Fire romance Polls and Games BBC binge zombies Reality Cartoon Network scary movies APB deadpool children's TV SDCC miniseries what to watch Universal Spectrum Originals HBO Go Walt Disney Pictures TCM Holiday Mudbound movie Best and Worst indie politics Britbox TIFF remakes spain Marvel Studios ABC Family 24 frames 2018 007 TV Land Arrowverse dc series Disney Channel mission: impossible National Geographic reviews Disney Amazon Studios Ghostbusters obituary chucky Sundance Now halloween The Purge Trivia Turner Nickelodeon Captain marvel TNT Logo VICE The CW fresh boxing The Witch Rocky TBS rotten TCA 2017 Ovation MCU australia Shondaland universal monsters Endgame directors dogs news Creative Arts Emmys Thanksgiving NYCC Apple TV Plus ghosts Trophy Talk comiccon Emmy Nominations adaptation hist ESPN BBC America festival Extras aliens Columbia Pictures Film Disney+ Disney Plus ITV GIFs Marvel Television television YouTube nfl toronto Nominations Infographic DC streaming service elevated horror Anna Paquin CNN natural history Fantasy discovery Tomatazos movies Lionsgate football cancelled TV series First Look game show theme song Biopics comedies tv talk Awards japanese WGN kids archives child's play Mary poppins jamie lee curtis richard e. Grant unscripted HBO finale Valentine's Day Hear Us Out spy thriller Film Festival golden globes SXSW Amazon Baby Yoda Tumblr Marvel PBS Chernobyl classics The Arrangement ratings Watching Series 71st Emmy Awards cats dramedy Fox Searchlight talk show Elton John worst movies sports Character Guide superhero GLAAD emmy awards robots Awards Tour Comics on TV Pet Sematary crossover vampires romantic comedy medical drama Year in Review DC Comics singing competition See It Skip It Writers Guild of America thriller 21st Century Fox Warner Bros. Pixar game of thrones latino Freeform true crime Mystery Marathons supernatural cancelled TV shows HBO Max AMC asian-american Sneak Peek IFC TCA Winter 2020 hispanic BET MSNBC BET Awards Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Brie Larson Classic Film Winter TV Television Academy WarnerMedia adventure CBS All Access TV halloween tv nature Fall TV Amazon Prime Family The Academy comic crime drama cartoon reboot Rom-Com Avengers Countdown Tarantino cops Disney streaming service CMT name the review Paramount Crunchyroll TV renewals Schedule cancelled DGA Western black cancelled television Fox News dragons sitcom 45 Black History Month Calendar Video Games Drama Epix casting Interview justice league concert Quiz Bravo zero dark thirty hollywood Musicals ABC Premiere Dates psycho book 2020 VOD breaking bad criterion Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Teen Disney Plus Opinion Masterpiece documentaries anthology revenge indiana jones free movies Reality Competition italian diversity green book LGBT TruTV harry potter witnail stand-up comedy El Rey social media RT21 Peacock Amazon Prime Video critics Hulu batman versus Winners