Vikings Showrunner Michael Hirst Talks Season 4, Writing Women, and Game of Thrones Comparisons

by | November 29, 2016 | Comments

Vikings - Gustaf Skarsgard as Floki and Travis Fimmel as Ragnar (Jonathan Hession/History)

Last we saw Vikings’ Ragnar Lothbrok (Travis Fimmel), it was some years after his brutal defeat to Rollo (Clive Standen) in Paris, and he’d returned to Kattegat after a long, self-imposed exile. His four sons, now young adults and themselves formidable fighters-in-training, met his return with apprehension and contempt as their estranged father challenged one among them to strike him dead and claim himself king.

After a season of being addled with drug addiction and violent erraticism, Ragnar has taught us to to expect the unexpected from him, yes, but also to not entirely trust him. Even four seasons in, we can’t say for certain what’s veiled behind Fimmel’s steely gaze. The greatest mystery, however, is what’s to come in the anticipated second part of season 4, which premieres with “The Outsider” on Wednesday.

Rotten Tomatoes spoke with writer, creator, executive producer, and showrunner Michael Hirst about expanding season 4 and the forthcoming season 5 to 20 episodes each instead of 10, writing for women, and what sets his Vikings apart from Game of Thrones.

Writer/executive producer Michael Hirst attends the "Vikings" panel during Comic-Con International 2016 (Charley Gallay/Getty Images for HISTORY)

Benjamin Lindsay for Rotten Tomatoes: We’re spoiled this season with 20 episodes. What have been some of the pleasures of working in this expanded format? Was it the plan all along for what this story needed?

Michael Hirst: No, I don’t think so. Normally in TV drama, at the end of a season, you still don’t know whether it’s going to get picked up, and so you’re kind of trying to balance getting an arc to a story that might just finish where it finishes if it’s not picked up, but hoping it will be, so leaving a lot of open ends so you can go back to it. I always, actually, have had a deep belief that Vikings would go forward. And I actually have always had an ending in view, and the ending is several seasons away. I hope we get that.

The challenge for me when History and MTM decided to switch from 10 episodes to 20 was that we were more or less shooting all year, and since I’m the sole writer, that was a big challenge for me. Sometimes, we would have 10 live scripts, and I would be writing, correcting things, rewriting things, trying to move the script forward and everything. It has been challenging, I wouldn’t deny that. But at the same time, I love it. I’ve never stopped loving the process. There’s never any lack of material because the material comes from history. So it’s always a great journey for me.


RT: One of the big surprises at the end of the midseason finale, “The Last Ship,” was the drastic jump forward in time. Was this simply to get Ragnar’s sons up to an age where they could be viable threats or leaders in their own right? What went into the decision to hit fast-forward?

Hirst: Well, from the moment that I started thinking about the show, or at least the moment that the lead characters would be Ragnar and his sons, I realized that I was in it theoretically for the long haul and that this would be one of the few shows that actually showed people growing up and people having children, and the children growing up. We had a lot of ground to cover, and I knew that at least two of Ragnar’s sons became as famous as he did. So that’s a question of how do you deal with those transitions? How do you plausibly deal with people growing up without the audience losing track of where they are?

And we did it before. I decided that I was never going to do [the time jump] in the break. I looked at previous shows where they move forward in time, and it’s nearly always been done in the break between seasons, and I thought that’s really an easy option and it’s kind of fake. You’re not being honest with the audience.

So we did the cut forward in time between Bjorn as a young boy and then casting Alexander [Ludwig] as his older self, and it worked fantastically well. I was always going to do that again, but of course I wanted the sons to mature. I needed the sons. It was a question of when, and it became obvious that the choice was when Ragnar suffered his huge defeat, because in Viking society, if a king or an earl lost the confidence of his people or suffered huge defeats, he would normally be killed and replaced and someone would step in immediately. But Ragnar is too famous for that.

So Ragnar disappears because he’s been defeated and he’s licking his wounds, and time passes. And in that time that he’s away, his sons grow up. That step forward is just long enough for the children to become young adults, and then Ragnar comes back into their lives. And he comes back for two reasons. One: We know that he loves his sons, and he wants to find out what’s happened to them. And the second thing is he has unfinished business in England.

Vikings - Alex Hogh as Ivar (Bernard Walsh/History)

RT: The episode going into this week’s premiere is called “The Outsider,” which could apply to the return of Ragnar, but also the way that Ivar is alienated from society and his family. He’s such an angry character who’s crushed by the pressure of being his father’s son in addition to the pressure of living a normal life as a handicapped Viking. What development went into this character? He seems like one to watch.

Hirst: He is! Not least because the actor [Alex Høgh Andersen] is just phenomenal, and he’s going to be a big star. I always wanted to get to Ivar. Ivar is probably the most famous Viking of all time, notorious for his cruelty, but who knew that the most famous of all time would be a cripple? So from a writer’s point of view, that’s an amazing journey to go on, that’s an amazing character to deal with. He has lots of issues.

There are different interpretations, to be fair, about why he was called Ivar the Boneless, but it seemed to me that the one that was most compelling was that he had Brittle Bone Disease. We did a lot of research. We got in touch with people with Brittle Bone Disease. It’s one of those things that helps me enormously as a writer because I’m constantly trying to connect the past and the present, and so someone who has a condition that people still suffer from today, people can connect with that.

So however badly Ivar behaves, you will never totally lose sympathy with him because you know how difficult his life has been.

Vikings - Alexander Ludwig as Bjorn (Bernard Walsh/History)

RT: Meanwhile, Bjorn is setting out to explore the Mediterranean, while his father wants to return to England. Floki (Gustaf Skarsgård) is even on Bjorn’s side. Is this the first sign of Ragnar being outshined by his sons?

Hirst: Absolutely. I think that maybe Ragnar thought that he could come back and claim the love and attention of his sons, but he’s been away too long, and as they say in Viking society, the smell of failure is pretty strong, so even your sons can reject you.

Bjorn has had a trajectory that was set from the moment he found that map in the raids in Paris, so he feels that his fate is to go to the Mediterranean. So he’s prepared to leave the Heathen Army to Ivar, which may or may not be a good thing. But it does mark [that] finally Bjorn is growing up and becoming a character in his own right.

And actually, historically speaking, again, Bjorn is very famous. He did ultimately sail around the Mediterranean. Amazing things happened to him, and within Viking society, Bjorn Ironside was a very mythical character by the time he died.

Ragnar said that one thing he feared was that his sons would become more famous than he was, and at least two of them do become more famous, and it’s interesting for me to watch their rise. I’ve watched children become men and then I watch the men become myths. It’s just a wonderful process.

I don’t mean to say this, but if you watch Game of Thrones, no one grows up. No one changes, everyone’s the same. In Vikings, things change the whole time. And one of the dynamics is that children become adults and then they have to find their own way in the world.

Vikings: Linus Roache as King Ecbert (Jonathan Hession/History)

RT: That all said, I also get the impression that despite townspeople and his own sons telling Ragnar that the gods have spoken, that his failure seals his fate, we’re not meant to write him off quite yet. The Fates are stepping in.

Hirst: Yes, they have something else in store for him. And actually, he knows that his fate is to go back to England and to confront and see King Ecbert again. That relationship between those two kings was so wonderful and fundamental and interesting. I needed them to get back together again.

The actors of the characters, they both come from different places. Linus Roache is a classically trained actor, and Travis is a natural. He came out of his farm in the outback in Australia. So the two of them are so different; they represent different traditions and cultures and things. I needed fate to bring them back together again and spend some time in each other’s company.

I’d be prepared to say that episodes 4 and 5 of the new season are the best episodes I’ve ever done in TV, and that’s in large part because it involves Ragnar and Ecbert together.

Vikings - Katheryn Winnick as Lagertha (Jonathan Hession/History)

RT: I also love that in this episode that Lagertha is back. She’s such a great character, and it’s a great performance from Katheryn Winnick. Do you pride yourself in writing strong, complex roles for women?

Hirst: I do. I knew that when History bought the show that it was a male-skewed channel, but I think largely because there’s Lagertha, that it now has a huge female following. But also, all the major female characters in the show are different, they’re complex. We don’t use women in the senseless gratuitous way the way that Game of Thrones does. I’m interested in the female characters.

What I’ve done with Katheryn is I told her right from the start that I was going to throw her into every situation that I could think of that contemporary women would understand. Katheryn has just been amazing in all of these situations. One of the reasons that I’ve enjoyed writing female characters is because I did my Ph.D. on Henry James, and Henry James also loved writing women characters. He felt a special empathy for them because he said they always seemed to be trapped behind certain stiff barriers and had to use their imagination to get out of them or had to use some special way that the men didn’t need to fulfill their lives. I’ve got daughters, as well, two of whom are in the show.

It is a big feature of Vikings. Viking society was one of the few societies at the time, totally unlike the Anglo-Saxons or the Franks, where women were respected as an equal. They owned property. They could get divorced. I’m only reflecting what’s actually happening in Viking society.

Vikings - Katheryn Winnick as Lagertha and Josefin Asplund as Astrid (Bernard Walsh/History)

RT: On a grander scale, do you feel like there are present day issues that parallel Vikings? The old adage says that history repeats itself — what do you think we could glean as viewers from Vikings that’s applicable today?

Hirst: Well, I wish it was as simple as that. Even more than that, this show is about personal and political relationships, and they don’t change so much. One of the things I want to say to people is this isn’t really the past. This is how things have always been. You can see yourselves in these people. We’re not Vikings — of course we’re not. But human beings haven’t changed that much.

So I try to write things that resonate all the time in every conceivable way, because otherwise, I think the people won’t be interested. I just want people to engage with these characters at every turn. Who knew that you could empathize with eighth century pagans? That’s really the key to it.

Vikings season 4 returns Wednesday, Nov. 30 at 9 p.m. ET/PT on History

Tag Cloud

2020 documentaries Red Carpet Sundance Now romantic comedy Writers Guild of America Paramount directors VH1 crossover comic books concert best composers cartoon E3 Rock south america TV renewals Grammys Acorn TV superman FX Schedule Star Wars reviews TLC technology Baby Yoda cancelled blaxploitation Set visit Black History Month theme song green book Marvel Television blockbuster jamie lee curtis President OWN facebook TCA Awards supernatural quibi Universal Academy Awards mockumentary golden globe awards PaleyFest Nat Geo Stephen King Rocketman laika rotten American Society of Cinematographers venice twilight Biopics comic news chucky ID Mindy Kaling revenge Holiday Mudbound TBS Black Mirror Animation SDCC 21st Century Fox Amazon Studios FX on Hulu social media Extras king kong psycho criterion Binge Guide CMT critics Paramount Network Opinion GoT Polls and Games Comedy toy story slashers comics kids Sony Pictures OneApp period drama Mary Poppins Returns robots festivals GIFs jurassic park Emmys children's TV movies spider-man worst Spectrum Originals Hulu screen actors guild IFC Films NYCC classics First Look ESPN See It Skip It Pet Sematary Watching Series dceu New York Comic Con 45 die hard Netflix godzilla Apple TV+ Endgame video on demand versus medical drama Holidays Mary Tyler Moore james bond Shondaland Valentine's Day Musicals spanish indiana jones Superheroe mutant A24 spy thriller SXSW natural history festival First Reviews Hear Us Out The Academy tv talk child's play Freeform Food Network Countdown TCA Winter 2020 Marvel Studios Awards MCU Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt DC Universe 20th Century Fox ABC remakes 71st Emmy Awards Summer DC Comics BBC America Thanksgiving Certified Fresh black serial killer telelvision YouTube Premium Tarantino Elton John scary movies boxing Action Winners nbcuniversal Amazon Prime Video indie X-Men blockbusters Film Festival Country miniseries hidden camera Fox Searchlight Captain marvel italian CNN Paramount Plus elevated horror Nominations free movies Superheroes canceled The Purge Lifetime canceled TV shows Disney+ Disney Plus Crunchyroll Awards Tour 2018 Tumblr Broadway Western sequels razzies The Witch Pop TV NBC GLAAD spinoff all-time politics Song of Ice and Fire Trophy Talk Tomatazos Fall TV justice league rotten movies we love Britbox Anna Paquin Ovation animated YouTube Red MSNBC Amazon Nickelodeon Pop TV Land LGBT LGBTQ Sundance TV BAFTA asian-american finale Character Guide kaiju Comics on TV Year in Review BET comedies Brie Larson parents emmy awards cancelled TV shows Spike Ellie Kemper VOD DirecTV toronto Esquire Syfy war Winter TV popular universal monsters rom-coms Photos cars based on movie monster movies Podcast ABC Family Disney Channel ghosts Video Games halloween Lifetime Christmas movies australia foreign TCA Emmy Nominations police drama Arrowverse television political drama CBS All Access TCA 2017 aliens Warner Bros. richard e. Grant Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Interview Turner Classic Movies dc Election romance Apple TV Plus Pride Month football Shudder 007 RT21 fast and furious USA rt archives 2017 Cosplay The CW Cannes women USA Network Walt Disney Pictures travel cults TruTV Exclusive Video Television Academy Disney streaming service ITV A&E superhero obituary binge BBC One TV One streaming Hallmark San Diego Comic-Con Trivia kong Reality scorecard deadpool thriller discovery video dragons zero dark thirty 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards ViacomCBS cancelled TV series satire Classic Film Reality Competition Trailer Star Trek fresh Film renewed TV shows nature Oscars Comedy Central The Walt Disney Company cancelled television zombies docudrama MTV Rom-Com zombie 72 Emmy Awards Horror disaster game of thrones true crime Infographic Dark Horse Comics Starz prank TNT Creative Arts Emmys FXX space crime Disney AMC The Walking Dead 2021 Discovery Channel Marathons TCM Sundance cooking dramedy historical drama Ghostbusters Rocky TV hollywood nfl Disney Plus Travel Channel Women's History Month WGN Alien crime thriller Epix Hallmark Christmas movies Marvel christmas movies Peacock Columbia Pictures History trailers biography spanish language dark screenings Lionsgate Cartoon Network adventure Vudu Logo japanese Drama Spring TV Christmas DC streaming service Mary poppins WarnerMedia franchise Quiz book ABC Signature science fiction halloween tv Masterpiece boxoffice Heroines sag awards sitcom witnail stand-up comedy Calendar Musical ratings Sci-Fi SundanceTV National Geographic breaking bad casting sports Sneak Peek adaptation RT History HBO Go Toys mission: impossible Netflix Christmas movies PBS anime APB name the review Music stop motion 2015 Pirates reboot Pixar PlayStation talk show worst movies 2016 Television Critics Association documentary french joker Family Comic Book Box Office Legendary psychological thriller anthology Premiere Dates cinemax spain teaser El Rey Amazon Prime strong female leads harry potter movie BET Awards Martial Arts DGA hispanic crime drama vampires what to watch Mystery diversity latino Bravo Adult Swim comiccon 24 frames cats Super Bowl independent TIFF YA Fox News archives unscripted series game show films Teen Turner Funimation Best and Worst Showtime transformers HBO YouTube singing competition IFC stoner award winner Lucasfilm docuseries VICE Apple BBC Crackle 2019 pirates of the caribbean werewolf golden globes 4/20 hist CW Seed E! doctor who The Arrangement Fantasy dogs HBO Max batman Chernobyl Kids & Family FOX 99% CBS a nightmare on elm street Avengers sequel cops Tubi