News

Toy Story 4 First Reviews: Pixar Triumphs Again with a Surprisingly Daring Adventure

Critics say the return of Woody and the gang is a worthwhile one, full of heart, humor, and themes that will resonate with young and old.

by | June 13, 2019 | Comments

Few movie franchises maintain the level of perfection that Toy Story has. The first two installments of Pixar’s flagship film series have perfect scores on the Tomatometer. Toy Story 3, which was nominated for Best Picture, is close with 98%. Now Toy Story 4 is on its way to theaters, and initial reviews are pointing to another very high Tomatometer score (it’s currently at 100%).

Thanks to familiar friends, popular new additions, and another deep story involving the meaning of life, we’ll put to rest any complaints that Pixar is making too many sequels. If it’s the last of them, it ends on a great note, but if not, Toy Story can reach for the sky and go to infinity and beyond, as far as critics are concerned.

Here’s what critics are saying about Toy Story 4:


Did we really need another sequel after Toy Story 3?

Part 3 ended so perfectly and succinctly that Part 4 could only disappoint. Except, the film doesn’t. Surprisingly, Toy Story triumphs.
– Robert Daniels, 812filmreviews

Toy Story 4 does an even better job than Toy Story 3 of managing mature themes while remaining kid-friendly.
– Karen Han, Polygon

Toy Story 4 proves to be a much more compelling conclusion, while still leaving the door open for future adventures.
– Molly Freeman, ScreenRant

Where the ending of Toy Story 3 simply deferred to the cycle of life, this finale ties a much stronger bow around the franchise by cutting to its core.
– David Ehrlich, IndieWire

Director Josh Cooley has delivered the movie Toy Story 3 should have been.
– Peter Debruge, Variety

Toy Story 4 is an unnecessary franchise extension savvy enough for self-criticism.
– Darren Franich, Entertainment Weekly


Walt Disney Studios

(Photo by Walt Disney Studios)

Could this actually be the best Toy Story yet?

The movie feels like more of an action-adventure tale than the previous movies, but with the same emotional tug that will make you go through a box of tissues while watching it.
Jason Guerrasio, Business Insider

In my mind, there’s no question Toy Story 4 is the weakest movie in the series. But it’s also the riskiest and the most pleasantly unpredictable.
Matt Singer, ScreenCrush

Not as good as the first three, but it also has a very different tone.
Bob Chipman, Escapist Magazine


How does it differ from the others?

Toy Story 4 breaks from the franchise’s tradition, focusing more on newer toys.
Molly Freeman, ScreenRant

Something feels a little different this time…. this movie starts — it starts! — with a suicidal toy and only gets stranger from there.
Matt Singer, ScreenCrush


How does it fit into the Pixar canon overall?

Toy Story 4 is the best Pixar sequel since Toy Story 2.
Matt Goldberg, Collider

This [is] the most fluid and enjoyably kinetic Pixar film since Ratatouille.
David Ehrlich, IndieWire

It pushes Pixar into some of its most daring territory in years. Which, ironically, makes it feel like something of a throwback to the days when Pixar regularly surprised us with its originality and its sophistication.
Angie Han, Mashable

Subpar Pixar… Pixar, like its former funder Apple, has conditioned audiences to expect more than a nice little movie. We want to be amazed.
Johnny Oleksinski, New York Post


Walt Disney Studios

(Photo by Walt Disney Studios)

Will it make us laugh?

Toy Story 4 is easily one of the funniest movies Pixar has ever made.
Matt Goldberg, Collider

Is it funny? The funniest of the quartet, in fact, thanks to a weird new character.
Johnny Oleksinski, New York Post

Delivers plenty of gonzo-funny moments.
Richard Lawson, Vanity Fair


And Cry?

Pixar’s sentient toys can still make us cry.
Tomris Laffly, Time Out

[Bring a] hankie…if you’ve seen just one of these movies, you know it’s basically survival gear.
Rafer Guzman, Newsday

The final 10 minutes, in particular, devastates tear ducts.
Robert Daniels, 812filmreviews

Toy Story 4 doesn’t hit the emotional highs of the previous films… the ending is moving, though now you distrust any finality with this saga.
Darren Franich, Entertainment Weekly


Is it a good movie for all ages?

[The movie’s theme] offers a good lesson for the kids in the audience, and will no doubt strike a chord with the adults.
Molly Freeman, ScreenRant

Toy Story 4 feels less like a family film than a film for adults their that children might also like.
Angie Han, Mashable


Walt Disney Studios

(Photo by Walt Disney Studios)

Will it empower girls in the audience?

Yes, Bo wears pants now, but… her femininity has nothing to do with how well she holds her own in a fight or survives in the wild and risks breaking along the way.
Karen Han, Polygon

Her strength is never commented upon — she just is strong, arguably stronger both mentally and physically than her old boy toy.
Josh Spiegel, Slashfilm

Bo Peep has been fleshed out and made so ingratiating and self-confident that she now emerges as something close to the heart of the film.
Todd McCarthy, Hollywood Reporter


How are the new toys?

Forky alone is enough to elevate this potential cash-grab…the hero we need in 2019…He’s everything these films have been working towards.
David Ehrlich, IndieWire

Everyone’s gonna like Forky.
Richard Lawson, Vanity Fair

The best voice performance might be Tony Hale as Forky.
Matt Singer, ScreenCrush

Duke Caboom almost doesn’t merit mentioning. He’s great, but the sequel doesn’t need him to juice up the proceedings.
Karen Han, Polygon

[Christina] Henricks offers equal parts menace and vulnerability to Gabby Gabby, bringing to life the series’ most compelling ‘villain.’
Molly Freeman, ScreenRant


Toy Story 4

(Photo by Walt Disney Studios)

What about the animation?

The textures, colors, and control of lighting exhibit an incredible command of composition not seen since the glory days of Disney… Toy Story 4 is a landmark achievement in the pure creation of computer animation.
Robert Daniels, 812filmreviews

The first of these movies to be composed in widescreen, Cooley’s feature debut is by far the most cinematic of the series, doing incredible things with lighting.
Peter Debruge, Variety

Locales and toys are rendered in astounding animation that I fear is in danger of being overlooked because most of the characters are 20 years old.
Matt Singer, ScreenCrush

Makes 1995’s Toy Story look like the brick-maze screensaver from Windows 95.
Johnny Oleksinski, New York Post


Are there any issues?

Occasionally too busy and loose with its logical rigor, Toy Story 4 doesn’t quite connect all the dots.
Tomris Laffly, Time Out

If there are slight downsides to Toy Story 4, it’s that the rest of the toys from Bonnie’s room have become so comfortable with their new place that they don’t factor in quite as heavily to the story.
Josh Spiegel, Slashfilm

Toy Story 4 at times feels more like a high-budget episode of television than a sweeping film.
Johnny Oleksinski, New York Post


Toy Story 4

(Photo by Walt Disney Studios)

Should they keep going with the franchise?

If they can maintain this level of wonderful, keep ’em coming.
Alonso Duralde, The Wrap

I just do not see how they can outdo themselves should they go forward with another film.
Danielle Solzman, Solzy at the Movies


Or is it time to say, “So long, partner?”

[Toy Story] comes to a sweet, emotionally apt conclusion now with a fine capper on a generally perfect series.
Josh Spiegel, Slashfilm

Quite the swan song for the cowboy…If Toy Story 4 is the final film in the series, it would be an otherwise perfect conclusion.
Danielle Solzman, Solzy at the Movies

The Toy Story franchise really should come to a close with Toy Story 4… It’s hard to imagine the series going out on a better note than this.
Matt Goldberg, Collider


Toy Story 4 opens in theaters June 21, 2019. 

#1

Toy Story 4 (2019)
97%

#1
Adjusted Score: 121158%
Critics Consensus: Heartwarming, funny, and beautifully animated, Toy Story 4 manages the unlikely feat of extending -- and perhaps concluding -- a practically perfect animated saga.
Synopsis: Woody, Buzz Lightyear and the rest of the gang embark on a road trip with Bonnie and a new toy... [More]
Directed By: Josh Cooley

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

rotten Walt Disney Pictures ABC sequel Pirates space nbcuniversal harry potter Teen transformers 21st Century Fox sequels tv talk A24 breaking bad Broadway period drama Rock halloween jamie lee curtis Heroines biography 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards stoner Christmas Television Critics Association New York Comic Con VH1 See It Skip It Nat Geo television TCM First Reviews emmy awards mockumentary Music robots kong laika Paramount Network Turner Classic Movies 20th Century Fox diversity PlayStation Valentine's Day scorecard E3 cinemax YouTube Red deadpool cancelled TV shows Shondaland true crime sports venice award winner Netflix Christmas movies binge 90s Horror Binge Guide Baby Yoda Apple TV Plus TCA Winter 2020 war TV critics what to watch mission: impossible Stephen King dceu romantic comedy Family Netflix blockbuster Comic-Con@Home 2021 Toys doctor who comic book movie halloween tv 45 feel good basketball disaster TNT women RT21 thriller Marathons Apple TV+ Awards Tour Captain marvel Marvel crossover marvel comics Mary poppins mutant vampires ESPN crime zombie football Disney+ Disney Plus 2018 Reality Competition spanish cooking Nominations Comic Book stop motion BBC America chucky 73rd Emmy Awards TV One A&E The Walt Disney Company Showtime hispanic Election Endgame live action Sundance documentaries WGN lord of the rings FX on Hulu travel OWN Ellie Kemper news legend E! critic resources saw OneApp Disney Plus Holidays 93rd Oscars teaser zero dark thirty Cannes Spike hist Comedy Universal Countdown dark Amazon Studios Winter TV Starz aliens Travel Channel TLC SDCC San Diego Comic-Con CBS All Access scary movies spanish language Pet Sematary 24 frames popular fresh directors ITV MCU boxing VICE serial killer Image Comics indiana jones golden globe awards Winners razzies HBO Max free movies die hard all-time The Purge Television Academy Mystery Red Carpet Legendary hispanic heritage month 2019 Ghostbusters TCA 2017 Anna Paquin Certified Fresh reviews 2021 Biopics political drama latino Cartoon Network DC streaming service Adult Swim Character Guide movie Best and Worst Women's History Month australia IFC Films cats medical drama spider-man Musicals video Mindy Kaling FXX ABC Signature joker ViacomCBS Reality Sneak Peek Black History Month animated ABC Family Black Mirror Wes Anderson Chilling Adventures of Sabrina richard e. Grant theme song know your critic nature Sundance TV wonder woman Opinion Lucasfilm DC Universe boxoffice christmas movies The Academy Tarantino cancelled TV series Tubi Pacific Islander Drama SXSW Freeform Star Trek PBS GLAAD social media Syfy Action target crime thriller CNN new star wars movies BET Awards pirates of the caribbean new zealand versus Nickelodeon Superheroes Grammys Elton John MTV Esquire universal monsters witnail Hear Us Out new york olympics aapi BBC Photos Mudbound child's play Star Wars Song of Ice and Fire video on demand worst Lionsgate toy story hidden camera Dark Horse Comics Trivia Musical fast and furious GIFs spy thriller Fox Searchlight comic book movies werewolf elevated horror comic politics Awards Logo king arthur documentary TV renewals AMC Holiday Amazon Prime BAFTA Trailer anthology RT History Animation Year in Review Calendar CW Seed Peacock Pride Month spinoff dragons posters mcc Columbia Pictures blaxploitation NYCC cars Paramount Box Office kids Sundance Now sitcom discovery CMT canceled TV shows movies suspense HBO Go indie unscripted Fox News Acorn TV TV movies technology book adaptation james bond italian Disney Channel SundanceTV black 007 APB 2020 Pop TV supernatural twilight Avengers comics hollywood revenge rt labs Sci-Fi comic books independent cops Thanksgiving Marvel Television TCA Awards Shudder batman 99% concert GoT Pixar comedies canceled streaming The Witch south america MSNBC jurassic park zombies 2016 Rocketman ID NBC based on movie USA Comedy Central cults Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt BET slasher Infographic royal family El Rey asian-american dogs young adult Tumblr BBC One Pop miniseries gangster historical drama casting foreign action-comedy VOD films Paramount Plus Video Games Turner Country rt archives Amazon Prime Video dramedy Creative Arts Emmys Rocky godzilla YA Crackle talk show Rom-Com TCA Apple Podcast strong female leads 2017 Tokyo Olympics satire Extras biopic Set visit psycho YouTube Classic Film scene in color YouTube Premium Lifetime Christmas movies The CW First Look classics stand-up comedy Warner Bros. FOX justice league japan Trophy Talk spain Vudu obituary high school DC Comics Spectrum Originals streaming movies natural history a nightmare on elm street series The Walking Dead Chernobyl Arrowverse sag awards NBA The Arrangement Discovery Channel Western 71st Emmy Awards Masterpiece book History dexter Epix Ovation docuseries Watching Series game of thrones cartoon blockbusters Super Bowl 2015 cancelled television criterion Polls and Games anime japanese 72 Emmy Awards cancelled slashers Food Network kaiju Marvel Studios trailers FX finale USA Network adenture Brie Larson Emmy Nominations TIFF Sony Pictures Hallmark quibi Exclusive Video heist movie Comics on TV composers Film international king kong HBO golden globes Premiere Dates President green book toronto Cosplay franchise psychological thriller Martial Arts crime drama marvel cinematic universe Disney streaming service Superheroe CBS docudrama debate Crunchyroll romance game show french children's TV name the review nfl Emmys 1990s screenings DirecTV Disney prank IFC National Geographic monster movies Britbox Summer Oscars Academy Awards festivals adaptation LGBT Fantasy renewed TV shows Lifetime X-Men screen actors guild singing competition DGA American Society of Cinematographers superman TV Land comiccon Quiz 4/20 worst movies Spring TV telelvision Writers Guild of America Hulu Schedule rotten movies we love archives police drama dc Kids & Family TruTV parents WarnerMedia ratings adventure Mary Tyler Moore TBS remakes Amazon Mary Poppins Returns festival Funimation Tomatazos LGBTQ Alien science fiction rom-coms Bravo best facebook rt labs critics edition Film Festival Hallmark Christmas movies Interview PaleyFest reboot ghosts Fall TV superhero