Total Recall

The 2014 Best Picture Nominees

In this special edition of Total Recall, we take a closer look at this year's contenders.

by | January 16, 2014 | Comments

Oscars

Awards season is in full swing, and film fans everywhere are either debating their picks for who’s about to win or arguing over those who’ve already won. That goes double for us at RT, and to celebrate our annual embrace of Oscar fever, we’ve decided to dedicate this week’s list to the films getting ready to duke it out for this year’s Best Picture Academy Award. With room for real-life stories, a little computer romance, some hard-hitting drama, and even some action and/or comedy, this year’s batch of nominees is certainly an eclectic bunch — so let’s take a look at them all, reminisce about how many we’ve seen, and then hit the comments section to weigh in on their odds of winning come March 2. It’s time for Total Recall!

American Hustle

92%

Former enfant terrible David O. Russell has practically become synonymous with Oscar prestige of late. Both The Fighter and Silver Linings Playbook were major award players (and acting trophy winners), and you couldn’t design a more Academy-friendly movie than his latest, American Hustle. It’s got period glam, a rollicking sort-of true story, and more big acting (and hair) than you can wave a SAG award at: Jennifer Lawrence and Christian Bale (Russell Oscar alums, both), Amy Adams, Jeremy Renner, Robert De Niro and Bradley Cooper will make this one a favorite across categories. As Toronto Star‘s Peter Howell states, “It’s one of the year’s cleverest films, and also one of the best.”

Captain Phillips

93%

If there’s one thing Oscar can’t get enough of, it’s America’s national acting treasure and most loved citizen, Tom Hanks. With dual acclaimed performances — as Walt Disney in Saving Mr. Banks and the besieged captain in Paul Greengrass’s real-life thriller — it’s a good chance the multiple Academy Award winner will be revisiting the podium this year. He’s got solid support in this tense high-seas nail-biter, too: Barkhad Abdi gives him a run for his acting dollar as the desperate Somali hijacker, and Greengrass is in typical queasy faux-doco form. In the words of EW‘s Owen Gleiberman, “Greengrass keeps you off balance — he’s a jittery poet of reality.”

Dallas Buyers Club

92%

Really, it doesn’t get any more Best Picture-friendly than this. Consider: the real-life story of a homophobic redneck (Matthew McConaughey) who contracts AIDS and has a change of heart while selling medication to the gay community. Consider: two straight actors (McConaughey and Jared Leto) either in states of emaciation or extreme drag, both catnip to Academy voters. Oh, and consider that the movie has actually been well-reviewed, too. “McConaughey delivers the performance of his career,” says Ann Hornaday at the Washington Post, “characterized not just by an astonishing physical transformation but by a wellspring of deep compassion and fearlessness.” The actors are locks for nods and odds-on for wins. Can the movie follow suit?

Gravity

96%

Alfonso Cuarón’s interstellar adventure came freighted with high expectations, and delivered both commercially and critically — making it the kind of all-round winner the industry loves to reward. Dazzling in its digital virtuosity, the Sandra Bullock-George Clooney starrer used the latest advancements in CG technology for the old-fashioned purpose of bringing audiences to the edge of their seats, where they dutifully remained, in thrall, for 90 minutes. “Cuarón brilliantly manages to create both awe at his glorious space vistas,” noted The Guardian‘s Peter Bradshaw, “and knuckle-gobbling tension at what’s happening in the foreground.”

Her

94%

It’s not often that a movie about a man who falls in love with his computer finds itself in the running for the Best Picture Oscar, but critics have flipped for Spike Jonze’s near-future romance between a lonely letter-writer (Joaquin Phoenix) and the sultry-voiced operating system (voiced by Scarlett Johansson) inside his device. It’s a tender and comedic but also intelligent look into the way humans interact, told in a distinct voice that could only be Jonze’s. As Scott Foundas at Variety put it, Her is a “singular, wryly funny, subtly profound consideration of our relationship to technology–and to each other.”

Nebraska

91%

Another year, another Alexander Payne joint rolls on in to the Kodak Theatre. The director behind Sideways and The Descendants has earned himself typically rave reviews for his latest road trip into the decaying heart of small town America, this time driven by a genuinely moving performance from veteran actor Bruce Dern. As a grizzled old coot squaring off against a vanishing landscape, Dern is the soul of the picture — and his acting nod might rub off on Payne. As Amy Nicholson writes, in the L.A. Weekly, the film “takes the heartland and strips the Norman Rockwell off it like cheap aluminum siding.”

Philomena

91%

Philomena was largely pegged as an outsider for a Best Picture nomination, but one shouldn’t underestimate the power of Stephen (The Queen) Frears in crowd-pleasing, comedic-but-heartstring-tugging mode. And in truth, he’s earned it, too, for Philomena is a handsome road trip that doesn’t overplay its potentially sentimental themes. Much of that can be attributed to the fine performances of Judi Dench (ever the Oscar fave) and a relatively unsung Steve Coogan, who does excellent work as Philomena’s righteously angry traveling companion. “The story touches on some of the thorniest issues of Catholic doctrine and tempers its righteous anger with a tone more sad than bitter,” noted J.R. Jones at the Chicago Reader.

12 Years a Slave

95%

Steve McQueen’s harrowing adaptation of Solomon Northup’s memoir has been riding a wave of critical acclaim ever since it wowed audiences in Telluride and Toronto, so it’s no surprise to see it leading the Oscar frontrunners for Best Picture. And with good reason, too: the British director’s art-film pedigree lends this grim tale a chilly atmosphere, while the performances — Chiwetel Ejiofor, Michael Fassbender and Lupita Nyong’o among them — represent powerful shadings of the human spirit, for good and for evil. As the Los Angeles Times‘ Kenneth Turan observed, “When a director who never ever blinks takes on a horrific subject, a nightmare in broad daylight is the inevitable result.”

The Wolf of Wall Street

80%

Always bet on Marty when it comes to the Oscars. Despite roundly snubbing him for all of his masterpieces back in the day, the Academy has been kind to late-period Scorsese, with wins for The Departed and a nod for Hugo, and now another — and a well-deserved one at that — for his tour de force takedown of fiscal folly. Plenty are calling this a return to the form of the man who made GoodFellas and — oh wait, that was the year Dances with Wolves won. Never mind. Still, this one’s got as good a chance as Scorsese’s had of late. As Todd McCarthy put it, writing for The Hollywood Reporter, it represents, “The wages of greed and excess portrayed in grand, operatic, often very funny style.”

Take a look through the rest of our Total Recall archives. And don’t forget to check out all the nominees here.

Finally, here’s Bob Hope’s monologue from the 1953 Academy Awards ceremony — the first to be televised:

Tag Cloud

politics TV renewals A24 Tubi Emmy Nominations asian-american thriller Geeked Week GLAAD Lifetime Best Actress El Rey 21st Century Fox serial killer joker American Society of Cinematographers basketball streaming Comics on TV Shudder debate Academy Awards finale Indigenous Pride Month rom-coms Amazon Prime christmas movies comic book movies talk show docuseries war aapi golden globe awards Valentine's Day sequel versus Disney scene in color free movies MTV comics Warner Bros. Rocketman FX on Hulu FX new york monster movies comic foreign supernatural Oscar Ellie Kemper Fantasy king kong justice league golden globes TCM teaser popular science fiction Quiz New York Comic Con halloween CBS All Access harry potter deadpool scary movies know your critic Freeform legend Esquire Super Bowl Broadway sag awards Reality Competition true crime HFPA what to watch summer preview zombie remakes vampires AMC Plus Disney+ Disney Plus Drama independent live action Paramount Disney Plus gangster LGBT Star Wars psychological thriller Teen Calendar nature PBS cooking quibi Fall TV video YouTube Premium Shondaland Netflix Christmas movies Marvel 94th Oscars prank Fox Searchlight cancelled dark diversity Family marvel cinematic universe critic resources binge WGN book casting 2020 social media Grammys Disney streaming service VICE revenge films toronto Image Comics FOX APB Travel Channel dreamworks scary space classics Instagram Live spanish NBA nbcuniversal Ovation The Academy 45 Nickelodeon slashers 2018 IFC Films Country TV One GIFs Interview TCA hollywood The Walt Disney Company Baby Yoda elevated horror rt archives genre Wes Anderson Holiday Nominations Spike comiccon Reality halloween tv Funimation BET Awards scene in color film series nfl historical drama screen actors guild Oscars Tokyo Olympics Marathons Exclusive Video television dceu technology Pop TV mockumentary rotten movies we love Binge Guide Tumblr worst movies french Elton John BAFTA Superheroe TLC Marvel Television ITV Mindy Kaling Trailer canceled TV shows sports facebook AMC Musical saw based on movie Avengers name the review transformers X-Men target scene in color sopranos Polls and Games Peacock ABC Signature Schedule Food Network Legendary Focus Features Hollywood Foreign Press Association Black Mirror 71st Emmy Awards USA Network Paramount Pictures sequels Brie Larson Film Festival TIFF Bravo DC Comics cars laika Paramount Network zero dark thirty Action Dark Horse Comics Star Wars Celebration italian boxoffice dogs Hallmark Christmas movies 90s RT21 Captain marvel Film 79th Golden Globes Awards Universal Pictures black medical drama Election ratings USA Women's History Month james bond HBO Musicals CNN DC Universe screenings Best and Worst NBC Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Mary Tyler Moore Pop dragons singing competition South by Southwest Film Festival Sneak Peek news Fargo international documentary crime Neflix Sundance TV Thanksgiving Hear Us Out GoT feel good SXSW 2022 YouTube Red kaiju festivals stand-up comedy die hard Creative Arts Emmys cartoon concert 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards toy story Awards 1990s Video Games BBC One south america ESPN HBO Max Martial Arts theme song cancelled TV shows NYCC crime drama SDCC Awards Tour The Arrangement PaleyFest DirecTV spinoff Universal Music jurassic park scorecard green book First Reviews Set visit spain comic books ABC Family best Tarantino broadcast hispanic heritage month 99% Certified Fresh YouTube Comedy Central lord of the rings blaxploitation ghosts TruTV IFC robots RT History scene in color series MSNBC doctor who Best Director VH1 vs. movies A&E summer TV TCA Awards indie cults stoner Pacific Islander San Diego Comic-Con Hulu Apple TV Plus award winner hispanic archives mission: impossible women Winter TV police drama rotten 20th Century Fox Turner Heroines National Geographic heist movie superman Toys Box Office ViacomCBS Writers Guild of America See It Skip It CMT blockbuster Britbox kong documentaries E3 strong female leads TV movies Amazon Studios Mary poppins Comic-Con@Home 2021 hist sitcom Winners Lifetime Christmas movies spider-man cinemax biopic travel batman adaptation festival Horror Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Summer posters Acorn TV Starz Trivia TBS new zealand richard e. Grant Showtime HBO Go Animation discovery latino Classic Film TCA Winter 2020 hidden camera CBS docudrama witnail OneApp ABC Sony biography spy thriller Cosplay OWN Rocky game of thrones Christmas slasher DC streaming service Star Trek Countdown MCU Holidays unscripted Spectrum Originals YA Television Critics Association suspense VOD Photos Rom-Com all-time boxing anthology child's play cats TNT crime thriller Television Academy 73rd Emmy Awards live event ID universal monsters natural history critics Comedy summer TV preview miniseries jamie lee curtis PlayStation fast and furious franchise olympics adenture BET Epix book adaptation LGBTQ worst SXSW game show Adult Swim anime royal family kids Podcast 72 Emmy Awards 93rd Oscars king arthur Anna Paquin Arrowverse Logo cancelled TV series dc The Witch blockbusters canceled young adult Watching Series FXX Emmys Trophy Talk cops chucky trailers political drama Discovery Channel fresh art house MGM Prime Video WarnerMedia Alien comic book movie twilight telelvision reviews E! Masterpiece wonder woman Superheroes indiana jones Cannes video on demand streamig Comic Book criterion cancelled television Pet Sematary Chernobyl Hallmark Tomatazos Rock 2016 IMDb TV Walt Disney Pictures Extras Premiere Dates 007 4/20 Ghostbusters Vudu high school leaderboard Mary Poppins Returns mob directors Netflix Marvel Studios marvel comics Spring TV mutant Sundance werewolf obi wan comedies Kids & Family Sci-Fi Biopics dexter tv talk Song of Ice and Fire spanish language Stephen King The CW obituary renewed TV shows animated SundanceTV Turner Classic Movies Crunchyroll Paramount Plus spider-verse period drama Red Carpet Disney Channel First Look Lionsgate football dramedy BBC America venice The Purge series target Black History Month TV Land rt labs critics edition disaster Mudbound DGA new star wars movies 24 frames pirates of the caribbean History psycho TCA 2017 japanese children's TV Infographic a nightmare on elm street Pirates Tags: Comedy japan Syfy black comedy streaming movies composers Native Columbia Pictures stop motion trophy Sony Pictures Best Picture crossover 2017 reboot Fox News zombies romance Apple interviews Mystery movie Nat Geo adventure Sundance Now 2019 Apple TV+ President satire CW Seed Western BBC Amazon Cartoon Network Pixar Year in Review Amazon Prime Video The Walking Dead mcc 2021 Crackle Best Actor godzilla aliens rt labs emmy awards Endgame parents 2015 romantic comedy australia Lucasfilm Character Guide breaking bad action-comedy Opinion TV superhero razzies