Toronto Film Fest, Day 4: George A. Romero's Diary of the Dead and Lars and the Real Girl Reviews

Zombies and blow-up dolls in today's Toronto report.

by | September 9, 2007 | Comments

I was majorly intrigued by George A. Romero’s Diary of the Dead‘s premise. Not just because it’s Romero, but because it’s seen entirely through the digital camera lens of student filmmakers. A Cloverfield-esque approach to zombie movies? What’s not to get excited about? Diary was obviously shot on a shoestring budget and, early in his career, Romero did wonders working around non-existent production values. But here, he embraces it too eagerly. Constant stilted voiceovers, amateurish acting, and tons of stock footage supposedly creates the illusion that this is a raw, unadulterated filmmaking. Instead, these tacky flourishes consistently distract and pull the viewer out of the movie. The whole concept is interesting but completely falls apart even before the first half is over. If your girlfriend is being zombie mauled and screaming for help, wouldn’t you — oh, I don’t know — put down your damn camera?

Diary at times feels like it’s supposed to be a parody of zombie films, but it certainly doesn’t have enough jokes. And there are barely any scares. What’s surprising is how talky this whole affair is. Most of the movie is spent watching these jerks squabble and argue. Day of the Dead somewhat suffered from the same problem, but it also had that fantastic zombie onslaught at the end. Diary just peters out (you’ve never seen so few zombies in a zombie flick), recycling the same ending Romero used in the original Night of the Living Dead. Such a cruel disappointment.

Lars and the Real Girl: serious contender for best film of the festival. At first, the movie seemed too good to be true: it hads a unique premise, stars the always reliable Ryan Gosling, and had a stupendous trailer. Surely, the other shoe would have to drop and the movie — about a delusional introvert named Lars (Gosling) who wheelchairs a blow-up doll around as his new girlfriend much to the horror of his family and coworkers — would end up being a one-joke quirkfest. The movie is slow to start and it does slightly nudge the audience to laugh at Lars. But it gets better and better with each passing scene. Its dialogue feels real and its characters are all honestly drawn. There were disturbing scenes which got me down that the rest of the audience would laugh at, and there were scenes I laughed out loud at as everyone else was tearing up. That’s what I especially admire about Lars. It incredibly never wavers from the perfect tone: it’s funny, creepy, and sweet all at once, all the time.

Tag Cloud

die hard Discovery Channel A&E stop motion DirecTV TruTV Turner Classic Movies CBS All Access BET adventure Marvel based on movie laika Calendar Baby Yoda Comic Book National Geographic stoner parents Logo cancelled rotten movies we love Lionsgate Extras PBS The Walking Dead golden globes screenings Tomatazos sag awards historical drama fast and furious 2019 a nightmare on elm street Watching Series APB Stephen King Awards Tour social media Marvel Television DC Comics Mary Tyler Moore Awards kids casting crime drama independent Black History Month MTV BBC Showtime Superheroes Sci-Fi 4/20 The Witch Mindy Kaling Film breaking bad 2017 Freeform halloween Grammys disaster theme song Funimation movie VH1 Shondaland Starz Television Academy stand-up comedy Trailer Netflix comics 72 Emmy Awards Animation travel psychological thriller Spike directors crime movies Epix USA Spectrum Originals foreign TCA Winter 2020 Mary poppins science fiction dceu chucky Acorn TV Valentine's Day Schedule politics Pride Month children's TV First Look X-Men comiccon Mary Poppins Returns documentary doctor who dark Year in Review zombies Musical OneApp ghosts Pop cats discovery Action Sony Pictures Reality Competition Polls and Games ESPN latino batman 24 frames Teen miniseries Paramount singing competition BBC America indie satire series SXSW Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Family canceled TV shows nbcuniversal BET Awards Binge Guide Trophy Talk Fox News cancelled TV shows television BBC One Walt Disney Pictures Disney streaming service Travel Channel 2018 comic Lifetime Dark Horse Comics quibi Western cults MSNBC Classic Film dramedy Ovation dragons SundanceTV Trivia jamie lee curtis medical drama First Reviews blaxploitation Star Wars Interview Drama History Netflix Christmas movies facebook 21st Century Fox Comedy VICE AMC crossover Mystery renewed TV shows vampires Ellie Kemper game show Red Carpet DGA GIFs Captain marvel asian-american criterion TV Sundance Now cinemax Toys CMT 2020 Lucasfilm Musicals 71st Emmy Awards Masterpiece Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt supernatural Song of Ice and Fire diversity hispanic Martial Arts Disney Plus Set visit Summer slashers Reality best E! thriller tv talk YA LGBTQ anime twilight YouTube Adult Swim indiana jones Disney game of thrones Best and Worst Brie Larson RT21 emmy awards sports police drama Vudu romantic comedy E3 LGBT Amazon franchise video Oscars all-time worst revenge 45 Podcast boxoffice green book cancelled TV series San Diego Comic-Con dogs Black Mirror Tumblr aliens Universal strong female leads FX HBO witnail Crackle ITV Music Mudbound ABC Family spy thriller elevated horror Warner Bros. Countdown talk show unscripted GLAAD spinoff Cannes WGN Film Festival FXX political drama natural history The Purge FX on Hulu Marathons A24 Lifetime Christmas movies classics Emmys reviews Cosplay Pirates Bravo CNN Rom-Com El Rey award winner Pop TV TBS Comedy Central war Kids & Family anthology Academy Awards mission: impossible DC Universe Avengers SDCC zombie justice league Nat Geo finale documentaries spider-man Crunchyroll CW Seed New York Comic Con Cartoon Network richard e. Grant robots cooking NYCC 2016 cars Winter TV TCA Awards news Apple TV Plus Thanksgiving YouTube Red child's play free movies Sundance TV concert what to watch Rocketman American Society of Cinematographers blockbuster canceled cops Box Office FOX Peacock Creative Arts Emmys toy story Arrowverse Disney+ Disney Plus OWN Star Trek CBS book transformers rotten Syfy TNT Rocky animated 2015 hist Biopics Winners christmas movies Endgame ABC The Arrangement obituary Tarantino streaming Columbia Pictures TV renewals spain mockumentary sequel nature HBO Max Shudder Holidays HBO Go Britbox space Paramount Network USA Network sitcom universal monsters video on demand PaleyFest name the review TCA 2017 versus comedies IFC Films Hear Us Out Character Guide Esquire Christmas Television Critics Association south america serial killer adaptation Video Games Rock TCM IFC Super Bowl DC streaming service Apple Infographic Marvel Studios Certified Fresh Women's History Month Heroines cancelled television teaser WarnerMedia technology Comics on TV Pixar TCA Photos TIFF Horror ratings 20th Century Fox screen actors guild Sneak Peek Ghostbusters Premiere Dates BAFTA Pet Sematary cartoon The CW Turner Fantasy superhero President Fall TV RT History Nominations MCU festivals Amazon Prime Video biography composers romance Food Network Writers Guild of America YouTube Premium mutant Amazon Prime Tubi critics Spring TV 007 Anna Paquin crime thriller werewolf Quiz Nickelodeon VOD binge Chernobyl true crime hollywood Superheroe NBC films Elton John GoT Amazon Studios joker TV Land docudrama Sundance TLC Hallmark psycho Election harry potter period drama reboot Country PlayStation Hallmark Christmas movies Disney Channel Apple TV+ spanish language Holiday Emmy Nominations See It Skip It scary movies dc zero dark thirty Opinion Hulu