The Cast of Black Sails Reacts to This Week's Big Twist

[Spoilers] Captain Flint's big reveal is a brave choice.

by | February 21, 2015 | Comments


On Saturday night’s installment of Black Sails, “XIII” (episode 205), we finally understand the motivations behind the character of Captain Flint (Toby Stephens).

Since the first season, this Royal-Navy-officer-turned-pirate-captain has been an enigma — along with his relationship to Miranda Barlow (Louise Barnes). But with the reveal of Flint’s homosexuality, it becomes clear why he had to leave London (he and his lover were caught), why he was so angry (the love of his life was committed to an institution for their affair), why Mrs. Barlow is so invested in the future of Nassau (it was Thomas’ cause), and what the significance of the book was (it was given from Thomas to Flint as a symbol of their love).

With these new insights, Rotten Tomatoes chatted with the cast of Black Sails about their reaction to the big twist.


“I think that the fans are going to love it because I think it further justifies [Flint’s character]… I mean, there’s going to be people who are pissed, like, ‘F— that. You can’t do that to pirates,’ you know what I mean? I’m really excited for that conversation to happen because it’s probably a rare thing… To go back and show his history and a homosexual relationship that is basically what has made him become a pirate, is, I think, awesome.

“I remember when we read [episode] five last year… we were all like texting, like, ‘Oh my God.’ Then we’re on set like, ‘Did you read that? Holy s—“… he was basically persecuted by the people who were supposed to be his community and the government. So I think it’s going to be essentially the foundation for the rest of the show and I think that — you know what? The people who don’t like it will have to ask their questions about why they don’t like things to themselves.

Sean Cameron Michael (Richard Guthrie): ‘How brave is Starz to go there with that?’

“I had no idea they were going to go in that direction and when I got the script for it and it said, “Flint turns to Thomas and they kiss.” I was like, ‘What? Seriously? F—. Whoa. Okay.’ And I was like, ‘Reread it. Where are my glasses? Let me reread this. Seriously?’ I was really, really shocked, and I was like, ‘F—. How brave. How brave are the writers. How brave is Starz to go there with that’… I think it’s beautiful that Black Sails can go there, that the story can go there. And I think what then happens is with all the flashbacks in season two, which are beautiful and amazing, it’s almost like one wants to quickly then rewind the tape, quickly go back to season one and go, ‘Were there any clues there?’ But I think it’s great and I think it’s really, really brave that Starz is going there with it.”

Jessica Parker Kennedy (Max): ‘It’s an awesome twist.’

“When I found out, I was shocked beyond shocked that that’s where the writers were going to take the show. I think it’s just a really interesting choice. I mean, I suppose in a lot of ways he really needed a secret and it’s an interesting one for them to choose to have him be…. But that being said… homosexuality is just something that’s been around forever. It’s not something new. I mean, it’s so interesting because we have the show with all these bisexual characters… It’s an awesome twist. It’s an awesome twist because it comes out of left field and it’s not what you’re imagining.”

Louise Barnes (Miranda Barlow): ‘It felt so modern and so open minded.’

“They’re not people who live easily within the confines of normal society at that time, but that she loved her husband, and he loved her, and the relationship that Flint and Thomas had by no means belittled the relationship she had with Thomas, it felt so modern and so open minded… There were no compromises. It wasn’t as if she felt cheated.

“There’s that beautiful scene where she’s trying to encourage him… she’s saying, ‘This is your opportunity to make this right,’ and the scene shows that their relationship is so complex and is based in respect and deep admiration and love for each other… There are very few people you have a relationship with where you can call them on their s—, you know? And she does. She says, ‘No, that’s not why you’re here,’ and she’s the only person who can do that to him.”

HANNAH NEW (ELEANOR GUTHRIE): ‘We believe in the story lines.’

“I feel like women could escape those kind of constraints of society because the idea of a romantic friendship between women was something that was kind of accepted in a way and very present in literature. I think that for male relationships, it was never really explored at all openly. I was really relieved that that was an aspect of history that was going to finally be seen on TV because you just never have seen that in a context of Naval men who are supposed to be these symbols of machoism but actually have created this amazing friendship that has blossomed into something very beautiful.

“So I was just really excited that the the show was brave enough to take that on… We believe in the story lines, and we believe that the people will be invested enough in these characters to know that it’s a very important aspect of the story we’re trying to tell. I think, personally, the audiences that we’re trying to reach are going to be just super-happy that there’s some kind of representation, and so, for me, I’m just really excited to see people finally go, ‘At last, at last.”

Toby Schmitz (Jack Rackham): ‘They’ve been setting it up from the beginning.’

“God, it’s good. You know what I loved about it? The kiss is nothing in what the big reveal is. It just sets off a sequence. It was this huge sequence and in the middle of it, there’s a kiss. Before I saw it, I rather momentarily thought, ‘Oh, that’ll be the big ‘Wow’ moment,’ but it’s all the stuff that comes after it. Because, right up to the kiss, I think you’re going, ‘Oh my God, this is a three-way salon idea,’ and then the emotional fallout of how much he loved him and how much he felt ashamed is the real power of the next six or seven minutes after the kiss. That’s the knock-out television I thought. It’s the sequence after the kiss. I thought, ‘Well, I haven’t seen that on telly and definitely not on a pirate genre-mash show.’ I thought it was great and they’ve been setting it up from the beginning, that this is a sexually fluid world. There’s different rules here.

“I keep thinking about Berlin 1922 or San Francisco 1967 when the gloves are off about partner swapping, about going with your actual gut and finding out who you are sexually, and then the emotional fallout of that.”

Clara Paget (Anne Bonny): ‘I was very proud of them for putting that in.’

“I loved it because, obviously, going along with my story line as well, it’s just exploring these relationships in this time where gay and lesbian — it wasn’t defined. It still isn’t. For some reason, we’d like to define it and put it in boxes nowadays. So I loved that story line and making a male do it for once. We’ve seen the girl-on-girl stuff and it was time to show that. And, you know, they?re at sea. It’s like being in the army or in the navy. Of course you’re going to create these bonds. It’s a generally male society, so it makes total sense. I think it’s great and it’s brave that they touched on that… because they’re these macho guys. To show that side on television with pirates is brave. I was very proud of them for putting that in.”

Black Sails airs Saturdays on Starz at 9 pm. Season two is currently Fresh at 100 percent. Read reviews here.

Tag Cloud

Esquire theme song suspense cinemax Pacific Islander Teen Tokyo Olympics Star Wars Holidays superhero stand-up comedy ID green book cats DGA Britbox toronto YouTube Premium El Rey Disney streaming service Star Trek Alien Extras Set visit quibi American Society of Cinematographers Paramount Plus marvel comics sopranos reviews summer preview Comedy Central a nightmare on elm street award winner justice league Calendar wonder woman 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards popular AMC biography cars Premiere Dates documentary Logo Hollywood Foreign Press Association BAFTA 4/20 SundanceTV Walt Disney Pictures mcc Comedy Super Bowl Mudbound Reality Competition nbcuniversal streamig Columbia Pictures scene in color Trophy Talk Kids & Family Food Network 72 Emmy Awards LGBT Syfy video on demand SDCC SXSW 2022 Tags: Comedy Summer spinoff Lifetime HFPA Exclusive Video natural history crime National Geographic DC Universe vampires book President Endgame Pirates miniseries Trivia Character Guide renewed TV shows Sneak Peek Mary Tyler Moore Rom-Com Disney Channel spanish franchise comic book movie Awards godzilla halloween tv First Reviews ITV cancelled festivals rotten docuseries worst robots Trailer slasher Spike Oscar Best Actor king kong Emmys telelvision 79th Golden Globes Awards live action Academy Awards universal monsters Acorn TV mutant Broadway Disney+ Disney Plus MCU MTV Chilling Adventures of Sabrina feel good cartoon Paramount breaking bad rotten movies we love Thanksgiving christmas movies composers Netflix Christmas movies anthology movie 90s The Witch 45 streaming japanese Wes Anderson latino Biopics Funimation OWN Cosplay television spain BBC America The Walking Dead Shudder MSNBC Comic-Con@Home 2021 international Elton John sequels Oscars mob series boxing NBC Pet Sematary mockumentary scorecard art house all-time Disney Plus DC Comics FX on Hulu HBO Max Photos directors Nominations Heroines WarnerMedia Ellie Kemper Warner Bros. vs. cooking new star wars movies kids unscripted Peacock crime thriller RT21 rt labs Tomatazos golden globes Mindy Kaling prank Travel Channel italian aliens Sundance TV VOD harry potter 2021 HBO reboot discovery Television Academy CW Seed young adult free movies DC streaming service CBS All Access adventure nature monster movies 2017 BET Awards Sony Pictures Lucasfilm zombies asian-american Rock royal family Avengers Fall TV werewolf Best and Worst psycho Turner debate TV foreign black emmy awards target Crackle what to watch Film ghosts Masterpiece USA Spring TV screen actors guild Horror Marvel Studios dragons The CW Valentine's Day canceled Legendary Grammys Women's History Month archives cancelled TV series The Purge scary movies YouTube Hulu ABC Signature comedies japan leaderboard Binge Guide screenings social media halloween E3 finale nfl Amazon Prime Quiz 21st Century Fox docudrama posters Marvel Television spider-verse Country Interview anime Crunchyroll Year in Review X-Men Fox News Arrowverse APB ViacomCBS Sundance Now Bravo Apple TV+ Mystery rt archives trophy IFC independent book adaptation GIFs romantic comedy joker Action Polls and Games SXSW dramedy First Look crossover Christmas 2020 new zealand crime drama politics TV renewals Lionsgate fast and furious Film Festival political drama trailers RT History movies adenture Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Ghostbusters war FX Brie Larson Superheroe venice Nat Geo comic book movies Captain marvel hollywood ratings adaptation summer TV preview football VICE Amazon Hallmark Christmas movies Lifetime Christmas movies spanish language YA Paramount Network Rocky Hallmark game show Fargo TruTV 73rd Emmy Awards Image Comics BBC One sitcom Drama richard e. Grant cancelled TV shows Showtime Western 99% jamie lee curtis concert Emmy Nominations hist genre The Arrangement mission: impossible animated Rocketman know your critic action-comedy jurassic park golden globe awards legend disaster superman ESPN History Amazon Studios kaiju Apple 1990s Chernobyl thriller Comics on TV diversity Musical TIFF AMC Plus hispanic heritage month video dogs WGN 94th Oscars documentaries Prime Video Red Carpet twilight South by Southwest Film Festival medical drama Shondaland BBC news space south america game of thrones Sci-Fi black comedy HBO Go stoner Apple TV Plus Holiday laika Discovery Channel critics blockbuster 2019 Neflix Podcast VH1 Starz TCA Awards A24 ABC Ovation Vudu parents E! rt labs critics edition psychological thriller talk show saw pirates of the caribbean Infographic CBS razzies IFC Films tv talk blockbusters 93rd Oscars TBS Tubi PaleyFest comic Pixar die hard A&E Pop Tumblr versus french aapi Epix Amazon Prime Video NBA Music CNN festival witnail new york marvel cinematic universe New York Comic Con Turner Classic Movies IMDb TV name the review dark Sundance science fiction hidden camera comic books 71st Emmy Awards Countdown dc Winners dexter Instagram Live The Walt Disney Company technology remakes Black Mirror Opinion elevated horror strong female leads indiana jones spy thriller films Best Director 2018 Nickelodeon slashers Hear Us Out Animation zero dark thirty zombie TLC CMT PBS sports Marvel Universal GoT Musicals worst movies sequel police drama blaxploitation teaser true crime FOX spider-man sag awards high school San Diego Comic-Con Comic Book LGBTQ indie australia Best Picture scary binge Certified Fresh The Academy Marathons YouTube Red transformers supernatural Classic Film Song of Ice and Fire Television Critics Association Creative Arts Emmys obituary serial killer 2016 child's play romance olympics Winter TV women OneApp FXX dceu king arthur GLAAD rom-coms james bond TCA Winter 2020 streaming movies Reality lord of the rings Freeform Awards Tour chucky See It Skip It biopic DirecTV Disney cults basketball comics live event canceled TV shows revenge TNT NYCC Anna Paquin 2015 singing competition Superheroes historical drama TCA Martial Arts Pop TV Stephen King Writers Guild of America Fox Searchlight Election toy story cops Tarantino Family PlayStation 007 heist movie Schedule critic resources comiccon Spectrum Originals TV One Best Actress Baby Yoda facebook MGM TCA 2017 batman TCM Adult Swim TV movies Cannes Box Office Black History Month BET Cartoon Network Dark Horse Comics travel boxoffice ABC Family Mary poppins Watching Series stop motion Netflix Fantasy 20th Century Fox doctor who Mary Poppins Returns Pride Month children's TV satire based on movie hispanic summer TV Video Games best dreamworks Toys deadpool classics obi wan casting USA Network period drama 24 frames TV Land cancelled television fresh Universal Pictures kong criterion gangster