SXSW: "V for Vendetta" Review

by | March 16, 2006 | Comments

"V for Vendetta," which had an advanced screening at South by Southwest Wednesday, is thrilling as cinema but questionable as politics. Well-crafted and often stirring, it’s an overtly political action film that makes a few trenchant points, but it’s tough to come away from the film with a coherent message. But it’s worth seeing nonetheless.

It’s the year 2020, and Britain has become a fascist state. The government has rounded up the undesirables, used the media as a fear-mongering tool, and enforced a strict curfew on its cynical but weary populous. In the bowels of the city, V (Hugo Weaving), a man once imprisoned and tortured for his dissent, is plotting a violent overthrow of the government, as well as revenge against his individual tormenters. He stumbles upon Evey (Natalie Portman), who is first skeptical but eventually becomes his partner in revolution. The action scenes are well-staged, and the movie has a few dark laughs (including a subversive play on Benny Hill). The supporting players, which include John Hurt, Stephen Rea and Stephen Fry, are excellent.

V is a man with a lot on his mind, and while he commits some pretty gruesome acts of revenge, he’s a romantic at heart; he likes Shakespeare, "The Count of Monte Cristo," and Cat Power, and has Jan Van Eyck’s "Arnolfini Wedding Portait" on the wall, all of which are banned under the regime (though it’s never adequately explained how he acquired his martial arts skills and amassed such staggering wealth). The sequence in which Evey makes the transformation from skeptic to fearless freedom fighter (drawing heavily from Dreyer‘s "The Passion of Joan of Arc") is one of the more moving in the film, and never more so than when she reads a letter in her jail cell written by one of the regime’s innocent victims.

But in the wake of 9/11 and the London terrorist attacks, it’s not unreasonable to feel more than a little queasy rooting for this guerilla campaign. The film is on firmer ground in other respects, as when it makes the claim that governments should be beholden to their people (no argument there) or that civic engagement is a necessity, especially in particularly troubled times (ditto). In all, "V for Vendetta" is a provocative film, not least because it’s sometimes unclear what reactions it should be provoking.

Tag Cloud

Marvel Television Masterpiece documentary ABC Family Oscars ESPN anime Starz CBS All Access Sundance TV Western Heroines Kids & Family award winner Esquire richard e. Grant Alien Star Trek free movies Animation Creative Arts Emmys natural history worst reviews Food Network nfl Amazon Prime Video Film Britbox BBC America stop motion Nickelodeon DirecTV social media Black History Month vampires Mudbound Turner Classic Movies Vudu scary movies CMT cinemax First Reviews ABC Fantasy President YouTube Winners Paramount Network indiana jones Holiday Tarantino Amazon Hallmark Netflix Christmas movies 2015 MSNBC scorecard Tubi 71st Emmy Awards binge robots Brie Larson Pet Sematary cats true crime Photos VH1 based on movie Rocky all-time DC streaming service directors Election FX Captain marvel 72 Emmy Awards TCA Awards satire RT History Cannes technology zombies canceled TV shows GLAAD Epix MTV Rom-Com Sony Pictures cancelled black Freeform 2017 Countdown Trophy Talk BBC Polls and Games Netflix Spring TV hollywood HBO Go Sneak Peek hist TruTV Set visit sitcom Action Marvel versus Amazon Prime Reality DC Universe universal monsters Hulu discovery Spike christmas movies Amazon Studios CNN nature cancelled TV series political drama Year in Review Apple TV Plus Valentine's Day stand-up comedy comic sports Best and Worst Emmys TCA 2017 period drama Television Critics Association Thanksgiving Disney+ Disney Plus crossover TCM psychological thriller Comedy GIFs Pirates A24 mission: impossible Family Horror Tumblr dceu Nominations adaptation toy story Disney Channel Pop TV ghosts disaster breaking bad BET Awards IFC GoT french witnail Columbia Pictures SDCC Country finale Song of Ice and Fire Rocketman Crunchyroll serial killer National Geographic Chernobyl Grammys Musicals jamie lee curtis Cosplay video on demand renewed TV shows 4/20 Anna Paquin Fall TV AMC Hallmark Christmas movies LGBTQ Marvel Studios mockumentary Reality Competition Black Mirror SXSW Mystery composers Television Academy The Academy Teen Superheroes USA Lifetime Christmas movies doctor who Elton John Watching Series TNT worst movies Pop Superheroe BAFTA 45 FOX HBO Max Disney streaming service Martial Arts DGA werewolf comedies films biography james bond spanish language Film Festival game show WGN Ghostbusters ID police drama talk show Interview chucky travel strong female leads football screen actors guild harry potter Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt rotten movies we love RT21 Acorn TV Lionsgate blaxploitation NYCC quibi Showtime OWN docudrama Schedule sequels romantic comedy diversity sag awards remakes Musical thriller supernatural 2019 Infographic 2016 historical drama critics El Rey USA Network TLC Star Wars unscripted aliens American Society of Cinematographers concert cults classics 007 Trivia psycho obituary Opinion HBO Mary poppins Comic Book TBS war TV Land Marathons Ovation elevated horror video anthology romance Academy Awards ITV CBS Extras mutant TCA Winter 2020 24 frames The Purge cancelled television medical drama Apple casting MCU asian-american DC Comics X-Men green book animated laika Bravo YA Red Carpet kids OneApp A&E boxoffice name the review Disney Plus stoner reboot Summer Shondaland Christmas Universal comiccon spinoff BBC One Video Games ratings revenge criterion NBC Pixar screenings best Character Guide die hard Adult Swim science fiction 2020 Trailer festival dark Rock Crackle Lifetime VOD APB rt archives LGBT spain Women's History Month children's TV movie Comics on TV CW Seed italian emmy awards singing competition spy thriller teaser cops History miniseries zombie independent blockbuster Disney PBS Holidays archives golden globes indie Paramount festivals south america TIFF The Arrangement The CW spanish The Witch IFC Films Arrowverse spider-man dramedy hispanic series rotten Walt Disney Pictures Lucasfilm Binge Guide PlayStation cartoon Nat Geo franchise cooking news comics Premiere Dates Dark Horse Comics Emmy Nominations Certified Fresh fresh YouTube Red Sundance Stephen King Ellie Kemper what to watch boxing dragons Toys politics Box Office movies Endgame Logo Warner Bros. TV renewals Fox News YouTube Premium justice league Pride Month documentaries comic books Awards Sundance Now canceled PaleyFest Quiz SundanceTV sequel Awards Tour cancelled TV shows Spectrum Originals New York Comic Con zero dark thirty dogs parents Funimation foreign Drama San Diego Comic-Con Shudder Cartoon Network WarnerMedia Winter TV dc latino australia Mary Tyler Moore 21st Century Fox crime 99% halloween Tomatazos batman Travel Channel cars halloween tv Super Bowl 2018 E! BET twilight crime drama fast and furious Chilling Adventures of Sabrina a nightmare on elm street Fox Searchlight joker facebook VICE Mindy Kaling FX on Hulu television See It Skip It book adventure transformers deadpool tv talk superhero space slashers 20th Century Fox Classic Film Biopics Apple TV+ child's play nbcuniversal TCA Avengers Syfy Mary Poppins Returns Baby Yoda Podcast Hear Us Out crime thriller streaming TV venice The Walking Dead toronto Music Sci-Fi japanese FXX Turner Comedy Central Peacock Writers Guild of America E3 theme song Discovery Channel game of thrones First Look Calendar