SXSW: "V for Vendetta" Review

by | March 16, 2006 | Comments

"V for Vendetta," which had an advanced screening at South by Southwest Wednesday, is thrilling as cinema but questionable as politics. Well-crafted and often stirring, it’s an overtly political action film that makes a few trenchant points, but it’s tough to come away from the film with a coherent message. But it’s worth seeing nonetheless.

It’s the year 2020, and Britain has become a fascist state. The government has rounded up the undesirables, used the media as a fear-mongering tool, and enforced a strict curfew on its cynical but weary populous. In the bowels of the city, V (Hugo Weaving), a man once imprisoned and tortured for his dissent, is plotting a violent overthrow of the government, as well as revenge against his individual tormenters. He stumbles upon Evey (Natalie Portman), who is first skeptical but eventually becomes his partner in revolution. The action scenes are well-staged, and the movie has a few dark laughs (including a subversive play on Benny Hill). The supporting players, which include John Hurt, Stephen Rea and Stephen Fry, are excellent.

V is a man with a lot on his mind, and while he commits some pretty gruesome acts of revenge, he’s a romantic at heart; he likes Shakespeare, "The Count of Monte Cristo," and Cat Power, and has Jan Van Eyck’s "Arnolfini Wedding Portait" on the wall, all of which are banned under the regime (though it’s never adequately explained how he acquired his martial arts skills and amassed such staggering wealth). The sequence in which Evey makes the transformation from skeptic to fearless freedom fighter (drawing heavily from Dreyer‘s "The Passion of Joan of Arc") is one of the more moving in the film, and never more so than when she reads a letter in her jail cell written by one of the regime’s innocent victims.

But in the wake of 9/11 and the London terrorist attacks, it’s not unreasonable to feel more than a little queasy rooting for this guerilla campaign. The film is on firmer ground in other respects, as when it makes the claim that governments should be beholden to their people (no argument there) or that civic engagement is a necessity, especially in particularly troubled times (ditto). In all, "V for Vendetta" is a provocative film, not least because it’s sometimes unclear what reactions it should be provoking.

Tag Cloud

Teen vs. RT21 Masterpiece streaming movies Sundance Now festival psychological thriller technology comic books trailers olympics Instagram Live biography Set visit The Walt Disney Company Marathons 72 Emmy Awards Quiz anime YouTube Premium FXX The CW APB Star Trek directors spy thriller monster movies SDCC Comics on TV ID reboot Ovation CNN based on movie zero dark thirty Vudu Grammys Christmas movies Sundance TV Paramount Plus Mary Poppins Returns Baby Yoda TV renewals Epix franchise lord of the rings New York Comic Con Food Network sitcom singing competition free movies dexter spanish language 4/20 Lionsgate king kong jurassic park Certified Fresh comic Pacific Islander Tags: Comedy Apple TV Plus Watching Series Pixar mutant cancelled TV shows Adult Swim talk show marvel cinematic universe Peacock popular sag awards ABC Marvel Studios thriller Infographic films rt archives Academy Awards Universal Pictures 2020 YouTube laika Mary poppins Winners mission: impossible Disney streaming service PBS Apple Legendary true crime Sci-Fi disaster 79th Golden Globes Awards E3 new star wars movies quibi comic book movies venice A24 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Country Pop TV MCU X-Men Thanksgiving Comic Book screenings art house animated VH1 Writers Guild of America E! Dark Horse Comics game of thrones video scorecard TruTV toy story See It Skip It Box Office TCA Winter 2020 international sopranos blaxploitation AMC Plus composers 2016 crime drama sequel women crime thriller Warner Bros. dark Endgame 45 worst movies The Arrangement cooking BET Awards harry potter basketball The Witch Tumblr saw Podcast Emmy Nominations adventure Disney ViacomCBS Comedy critics Election spider-verse 1990s Trivia Hollywood Foreign Press Association dragons Television Critics Association Hear Us Out Creative Arts Emmys Netflix Christmas movies strong female leads what to watch 20th Century Fox IFC Films period drama kids australia mob Film Festival worst marvel comics medical drama chucky zombie GoT Cosplay Bravo boxing japan serial killer dceu 2017 Holidays Ellie Kemper Schedule travel Mindy Kaling mcc Pirates universal monsters dreamworks cinemax VICE cancelled TV series crime romance screen actors guild TV One heist movie fast and furious Showtime Amazon legend TV Land politics Neflix live action war Esquire Kids & Family Mary Tyler Moore hollywood a nightmare on elm street Pride Month twilight Sundance 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards DC Comics TCA Awards sequels godzilla Apple TV+ black comedy latino new zealand richard e. Grant Turner stoner know your critic kong Lucasfilm DGA Wes Anderson news MSNBC aliens Paramount Network Black History Month Superheroes BBC America finale CBS All Access binge black indiana jones Film History Starz Fox News trophy superhero Shudder ITV First Look boxoffice obituary Lifetime Christmas movies Animation supernatural criterion Disney+ Disney Plus book indie dc casting comedies Comedy Central ABC Family Western superman psycho FOX Netflix Hulu Rock The Purge BBC One San Diego Comic-Con Martial Arts revenge batman rt labs critics edition NBC Fox Searchlight hispanic SXSW Pop child's play Shondaland The Walking Dead Musical PlayStation 93rd Oscars new york Nominations debate GIFs 24 frames Tokyo Olympics emmy awards Music 99% Disney Plus Family Holiday Fargo 007 rom-coms Reality Competition USA halloween teaser Lifetime Women's History Month Spike Turner Classic Movies science fiction Interview streaming best cancelled zombies transformers south america Marvel Television Alien 2015 TV movies asian-american VOD razzies Avengers Trophy Talk live event Syfy Cartoon Network wonder woman football TV WGN Nat Geo TCA GLAAD Premiere Dates Marvel book adaptation Fall TV BAFTA Emmys Horror TNT Britbox First Reviews rotten movies we love NBA dramedy Sony Pictures slasher Reality Biopics WarnerMedia Fantasy robots Awards AMC Spring TV 71st Emmy Awards Exclusive Video docudrama golden globe awards green book dogs Superheroe IFC BBC pirates of the caribbean canceled TV shows 21st Century Fox PaleyFest CBS Calendar 2019 blockbuster Countdown Comic-Con@Home 2021 Star Wars National Geographic genre 2018 deadpool facebook satire HBO Go Photos Crackle prank social media TLC TBS Mudbound all-time Toys spinoff scene in color royal family nbcuniversal Universal slashers DC streaming service Broadway 2021 theme song breaking bad feel good Binge Guide 73rd Emmy Awards Character Guide Drama DC Universe Rocketman sports miniseries spider-man OWN scary movies Year in Review Columbia Pictures biopic docuseries scary leaderboard Elton John Stephen King Red Carpet independent series nature Television Academy Hallmark CMT Captain marvel LGBTQ king arthur cars critic resources TCA 2017 Song of Ice and Fire Walt Disney Pictures unscripted Prime Video telelvision YouTube Red hidden camera FX on Hulu target Polls and Games halloween tv action-comedy festivals TCM mockumentary blockbusters Summer doctor who italian LGBT 90s Discovery Channel IMDb TV children's TV NYCC hist Oscars toronto crossover Tomatazos Chernobyl Pet Sematary versus MTV political drama Freeform cancelled television BET canceled Arrowverse parents suspense spain Video Games Ghostbusters comic book movie Funimation Awards Tour romantic comedy vampires Musicals Image Comics Amazon Prime Video tv talk YA natural history rt labs aapi HBO Max game show Cannes high school HBO Rocky ABC Signature TIFF gangster Super Bowl Nickelodeon Crunchyroll Acorn TV historical drama archives Paramount Brie Larson HFPA Black Mirror Best and Worst American Society of Cinematographers die hard Rom-Com FX A&E documentary Opinion Valentine's Day kaiju comics Travel Channel remakes Tarantino cartoon Amazon Studios Extras diversity ratings The Academy christmas movies Classic Film posters cats cops video on demand witnail foreign DirecTV joker stop motion Sneak Peek comiccon SundanceTV Tubi CW Seed El Rey ESPN Action Hallmark Christmas movies jamie lee curtis werewolf Trailer award winner documentaries reviews OneApp name the review Anna Paquin classics Amazon Prime movie justice league President Disney Channel hispanic heritage month fresh cults anthology Spectrum Originals concert Mystery rotten discovery young adult adaptation Winter TV Chilling Adventures of Sabrina adenture USA Network japanese Logo golden globes french elevated horror space RT History spanish james bond police drama nfl stand-up comedy renewed TV shows Heroines ghosts television