Critics Consensus

Sonic the Hedgehog Is Familiar but Fine Family Fun

Plus, The Photograph is soulful if slow, Downhill is disappointing, Potrait of a Lady on Fire and Ordinary Love are Certified Fresh, and guess Fantasy Island's Tomatometer.

by | February 13, 2020 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a blue speedster (Sonic the Hedgehog, starring James Marsden and the voice of Ben Schwartz), a budding romance (The Photograph, starring Issa Rae and the voice of LaKeith Stanfield), a fateful fight-or-flight fiasco (Downhill, starring Will Ferrell and Julia Louis-Dreyfus), and a dangerous getaway (Fantasy Island, starring Lucy Hale and Michael Peña). What are the critics saying?


Sonic the Hedgehog (2020) 63%

Over the course of the past couple decades and change, movies based on video games have earned a reputation as subpar entertainment, to be generous. Critically speaking, things trended a bit upward in 2018 with Rampage (51%) and the Tomb Raider reboot (52%), and 2019 saw the genre’s first two Fresh entries in Pokémon: Detective Pikachu (69%) and The Angry Birds Movie 2 (73%), which currently sit at #2 and #1, respectively, on our list of all video game movies ranked. With that context in mind, we come to 2020 and Sonic the Hedgehog, an animated/live-action hybrid adventure in which the titular Sega hero (voiced by Ben Schwartz) travels to Earth from his home planet, befriends a local sheriff (James Marsden), and attempts evade capture by the nefarious Dr. Robotnik (Jim Carrey), who hopes to harness Sonic’s power for evil. The film endured a minor controversy when its first trailer premiered and longtime fans cried foul at Sonic’s subtly creepy character design, but after the folks behind the film pushed its release date back and reworked the visuals, most moviegoers seemed optimistic. As it turns out, those moviegoers weren’t entirely misguided, as critics say Sonic the Hedgehog is mostly wholesome family fun, with a lively performance from Carrey that harkens back to his 1990s heyday. The jokes may not all land, but there are a lot of them that come at you, and while the rest of the film largely caters to a younger audience, there’s enough in there for adults to ensure a trip to the theater won’t be entirely mind-numbing.


The Photograph (2020) 74%

Being that Friday is Valentine’s Day, it’s only appropriate that at least one of the big releases is a romance. This year, that romance is The Photograph, which stars Issa Rae as Mae, a museum curator whose estranged photographer mother suddenly dies, leaving clues to her storied life behind for her daughter. As Mae begins to pick up the pieces, a journalist named Michael (LaKeith Stanfield) shows up looking to write a story about her mother, and the two of them find they share an undeniable connection. Critics say The Photograph, which cuts between Mae’s relationship with Michael and her mother’s own love story in the past, is a quiet, soulful romance that explores the ways in which one generation’s decisions can echo into the next. While Rae and Stanfield are arguably better known for their comedic work, the reviews point out their easy chemistry as dramatic leads, with a solid supporting cast — which includes Lil Rel Howery, Teyonah Paris, and Chelsea Peretti — helping to flesh out the narrative. Some may find the film a tad languid for their tastes, and the storytelling may not be quite clever enough to offer many surprises, but The Photograph rests on the strength of its stars, who all do admirable work.


Downhill (2020) 37%

On the flipside of The Photograph, we have Downhill, which charts the steady breakdown of a marriage after a near tragedy. Said couple is played by Will Ferrell and Julia Louis-Dreyfus, who play Pete and Billie Staunton, an American couple with two kids who travel to Europe for an Alpine ski vacation. When a controlled avalanche set off by the resort induces a momentary panic, Pete flees the scene and abandons his family, causing a rift between him and Billie that forces them to reexamine their relationship. Directed and adapted by Nat Faxon and Jim Rash (The Way Way Back), Downhill is an English-language remake of the 2014 Swedish dark comedy Force Majeure, and critics say what could and should have been a fantastic reinterpretation is merely a pale imitation of its predecessor. While Ferrell and Louis-Dreyfus have proven in the past that they can handle subtler material, reviews say Ferrell’s character in particular seems to have lost the edge that made his existential dilemma in the original film so palpable, and the overall softening of the themes at play undermines the satire at its core. In the end, Downhill is a safer, watered-down rendition of the story, neither as darkly funny nor as poignantly subversive as its Swedish counterpart, and it’s likely to go down as something of a missed opportunity.


Fantasy Island (2020) 8%

For anyone too young to remember, Fantasy Island began as a television series that ran from 1977 to 1984, centering around a mystical vacation destination where visitors could live out their fantasies… for a price. The proprietor of the island, one mysterious Mr. Roarke (played by Ricardo Montalbán), mostly used the fantasies as a means of teaching his guests valuable moral lessons, and while the admittedly Faustian premise rarely turned deadly, there was often a hint of menace in its Twilight Zone-esque storylines. All of that said, leave it to Blumhouse to take that premise and put a horror spin on it in this week’s Fantasy Island, in which Michael Peña’s Mr. Roarke plays host to a group of young visitors who get a lot more than they bargained for when they disembark “ze plane” in hopes of fulfilling their wildest fantasies. Things don’t quite work out according to plan, of course, and their jaunty, indulgent adventures quickly take a turn for the horrific. We’d love to tell you what the critics thought of Fantasy Island, but reviews won’t start pouring in until Friday morning, so in the meantime, guess that Tomatometer.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • The Rest of Us (2020) , starring Heather Graham in a drama about a woman who connects with her recently deceased ex-husband’s new family, is at 100%.
  • Portrait of a Lady on Fire (Portrait de la jeune fille en feu) (2020) , a period drama about a woman hired to secretly paint the portrait of a reluctant bride, only for the two to fall in love, is Certified Fresh at 98%.
  • VFW (2020) , an action-horror film about a group of veterans at a bar fending off an attack from drug-dealing mutants, is at 95%.
  • After Midnight (Something Else) (2020) , a horror-mystery about a man mourning a recent break-up who is visited by an unseen creature at night, is at 94%.
  • Come As You Are (2020) , a road-trip comedy about a trio of young disabled men who make a run to Canada to visit a brothel that caters to special needs, is at 94%.
  • Ordinary Love (2020) , starring Liam Neeson and Lesley Manville in a drama about an aging couple dealing with the wife’s breast cancer diagnosis, is Certified Fresh at 92%.
  • The Cordillera of Dreams (La cordillera de los sueños) (2020) , a documentary rumination on the Andes mountains and their influence on the culture and history of Chile, is at 85%.
  • I Was at Home, But... (Ich war zuhause, aber...) (2020) , a non-linear drama about a woman struggling with life and her relationship to her teenage son after the death of her husband, is at 83%.
  • A Simple Wedding (2020) , a romantic comedy about a young Iranian-American woman who falls for a DJ and struggles against her disapproving family’s traditional views, is at 78%.
  • Buffaloed (2020) , starring Zoey Deutch in a comedy about a teen who hatches a sketchy plan to pay for her college tuition, is at 72%.
  • Olympic Dreams (2020) , a romantic comedy about an Olympic cross-country skier who falls in love with a dentist, is at 64%.
  • The Times of Bill Cunningham (2020) , a documentary profile of the titular photographer’s remarkable life, is at 60%.
  • The Kindness of Strangers (2020) , an ensemble drama about six struggling people in New York City whose lives intersect, is at 14%.

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

Captain marvel President TCM El Rey New York Comic Con Nat Geo TBS ghosts spy thriller The Walking Dead See It Skip It YouTube Red Mary poppins Polls and Games stand-up comedy Arrowverse Baby Yoda Sundance TV classics Red Carpet football festivals DirecTV renewed TV shows indiana jones child's play dark thriller CW Seed casting The Witch Comedy Christmas Video Games social media vampires Tarantino theme song travel Lifetime Comedy Central Creative Arts Emmys Amazon Prime Esquire MSNBC APB Classic Film sitcom Mystery TV Western Black Mirror Superheroe green book Warner Bros. composers cancelled television Discovery Channel Oscars Rocketman mission: impossible natural history Nickelodeon ESPN Turner Mary Poppins Returns Mudbound emmy awards mutant 72 Emmy Awards Binge Guide all-time zombie Mindy Kaling disaster 21st Century Fox Columbia Pictures Fantasy criterion ITV jamie lee curtis FX Grammys supernatural Certified Fresh Funimation Freeform Martial Arts Comics on TV spider-man Turner Classic Movies diversity First Look Family sequel miniseries hispanic Marathons movies Masterpiece comics Ghostbusters cancelled dragons christmas movies worst movies 2018 Kids & Family rotten Calendar romantic comedy crime 2019 golden globes Apple TV+ FXX Epix DGA E3 Brie Larson FOX Vudu Ovation The Arrangement cancelled TV shows revenge Lucasfilm die hard screenings Emmy Nominations Heroines Emmys Biopics YouTube Premium Pixar HBO Go batman Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt satire halloween CMT dc Photos cartoon facebook tv talk elevated horror Lifetime Christmas movies Comic Book Writers Guild of America National Geographic Anna Paquin scary movies Character Guide hollywood transformers Star Wars Pop TV blaxploitation Mary Tyler Moore Paramount period drama medical drama adventure DC Universe Spectrum Originals Tomatazos Television Critics Association E! Apple TV Plus NYCC Disney Channel Sundance TIFF Marvel Television CNN BBC America boxoffice Rock BBC One police drama PBS documentary dogs Box Office slashers SDCC DC streaming service USA Network Quiz Trivia RT21 sequels Pet Sematary Valentine's Day Walt Disney Pictures Disney Plus Elton John cooking witnail VICE game show dceu anime parents Paramount Network Chilling Adventures of Sabrina 2017 mockumentary comedies breaking bad Hallmark Christmas movies CBS asian-american werewolf based on movie 2020 robots Best and Worst TV renewals news versus Pride Month American Society of Cinematographers A&E History VOD LGBTQ Television Academy historical drama Fall TV Interview crime thriller SundanceTV Spike 24 frames docudrama blockbuster Hear Us Out Star Trek rotten movies we love indie space Pop true crime Schedule hist Music TV Land Reality Competition Infographic A24 Tubi Holiday twilight laika dramedy obituary Film The CW children's TV Avengers remakes discovery Teen chucky book comiccon Bravo Shudder science fiction cults Superheroes cancelled TV series sag awards Countdown fast and furious screen actors guild Nominations Chernobyl 45 Winter TV BAFTA Crackle SXSW Premiere Dates Musical Dark Horse Comics HBO Max TruTV Rom-Com WGN reviews worst Shondaland stop motion nbcuniversal Netflix Christmas movies Rocky technology joker Country Trophy Talk series San Diego Comic-Con Apple canceled TV shows what to watch TCA 2017 talk show TCA Winter 2020 Fox News MCU Awards political drama cinemax video on demand award winner The Purge foreign Super Bowl politics Peacock ABC Family spinoff Amazon canceled Sony Pictures streaming 2016 Cartoon Network Watching Series Disney+ Disney Plus television OWN Winners doctor who finale IFC Films Logo video strong female leads aliens Sneak Peek psycho movie anthology Stephen King YA Crunchyroll Tumblr Animation independent Academy Awards festival TLC AMC nfl spain name the review 71st Emmy Awards YouTube TCA Awards Universal Sci-Fi biography GIFs films nature quibi Trailer Acorn TV serial killer Thanksgiving ratings Holidays FX on Hulu ABC Horror Women's History Month Syfy Showtime Disney streaming service BET Musicals Travel Channel latino animated Amazon Prime Video Extras south america 007 TCA IFC GoT CBS All Access Song of Ice and Fire Cannes 4/20 comic cops First Reviews game of thrones Cosplay HBO Disney MTV Ellie Kemper crossover toronto Amazon Studios war Britbox Spring TV X-Men DC Comics franchise Marvel 2015 toy story zombies best venice Hulu romance Election Summer free movies critics superhero PlayStation Podcast harry potter RT History VH1 binge Action sports Lionsgate Sundance Now Awards Tour Netflix cats Black History Month Year in Review Reality directors Endgame stoner scorecard Adult Swim Set visit LGBT NBC justice league Opinion richard e. Grant concert BBC PaleyFest reboot GLAAD zero dark thirty Marvel Studios BET Awards Food Network unscripted spanish language OneApp WarnerMedia Toys Film Festival 20th Century Fox teaser TNT psychological thriller adaptation a nightmare on elm street documentaries universal monsters singing competition crime drama kids Hallmark Starz cars USA Pirates Drama