RTIndie: Early Fest Reviews For Into the Wild, The Darjeeling Limited, and Margot at the Wedding

I'm Not There, Juno also premiere

by | September 5, 2007 | Comments

This week at RTIndie, we check out the early buzz from Telluride and Venice, where some of the fall’s most anticipated indies have premiered. And our DVD Pick of the Week is a doc that takes a closer look at the Lost Boys of Sudan.

Anticipated Indies Get Early Notices At Venice, Telluride

From the Venice and Telluride film festivals come word on some of the fall’s most buzzworthy flicks, helmed by a few of the biggest names in the indie world — Sean Penn, Wes Anderson, Todd Haynes, and Noah Baumbach, just to name a few.

Premeiring at Telluride, Penn’s Into the Wild has gotten strong reviews at the fest. The film stars Emile Hirsch in the based-on-a-true-story of a young man who abandoned his possessions for a life in the wilderness. “A story of youthful narcissism that never neglects the poignant humanity at its core, Into the Wild speaks to the yearnings and frailties in all of us,” writes Kevin Lally of Film Journal International. “Into the Wild could easily whet its audience’s wanderlust,” writes Harvey S. Karten of Compuserve.

Into The Wild

Another Telluride film with positive early buzz is Jason Reitman‘s comedy Juno, starring Ellen Page and Michael Cera in the story of a young couple who must make some tough decisions in the wake of an unplanned pregnancy. The critics are calling it a smart film that plays some difficult situations for laughs, thanks to a sharp script from Diablo Cody. “This might seem like odd material for a comedy, but trust me, Cody’s script is pure gold — expect big things in the future from this first-time screenwriter,” wrote Cinematical‘s Kim Voynar. “The way the torrents of archly amusing, vocabulary-bending dialogue trip off the tongues of the characters, you know you’re in the hands of some manner of distinctive writer,” said Variety‘s Todd McCarthy.

On the other hand, Wes Anderson’s latest, The Darjeeling Limited, has received mixed-to-negative reviews after its premiere in Venice. The film, starring Adrien Brody, Owen Wilson, and Jason Schwartzman, tells the story of three estranged brothers on a chaotic trip across India in search of spiritual enlightenment. It received a middling thumbs-down from Alissa Simon in Variety (“Breaking no new ground thematically, pic comes closer to The Royal Tenenbaums than The Life Aquatic With Steve Zissou, but without achieving the poignance of Rushmore“) and an outright pan by Ray Bennett in the Hollywood Reporter (“A third-rate Hope and Crosby picture with no big laughs and nothing to say as the completely self-involved threesome ride the rails in a circle back to their dull and uninteresting lives”).

The Darjeeling Limited

Also getting mixed notices from scribes is Anderson buddy Noah Baumbach’s latest, Margot at the Wedding, starring Nicole Kidman, Jennifer Jason Leigh, and Jack Black. Margot tells the story of a pair of sisters whose relationship is tested over one’s marriage plans. “Baumbach has followed up his acclaimed 2005 breakthrough The Squid and the Whale with another wryly observed, giddily cringe-inducing, bracingly original winner,” writes Michael Rechtshaffen of the Hollywood Reporter. But, says Eugene Novikov of Film Blather, “these people are so intensely unlikable, and the film so unwilling to help them toward any sort of redemption, that Margot becomes a sour and unrewarding experience.”

Margot at the Wedding

One of Venice’s odder — and most anticipated — entries is Todd Haynes’ impressionistic, unconventional Bob Dylan biopic, I’m Not There. The film stars Heath Ledger, Christian Bale, Cate Blanchett (as Dylan!), and Richard Gere in a series of loosely-connected vignettes anchored upon Dylan’s life, music, and influence. And the scribes say it’s weird. “It’s a curiosity that could delight or turn off loyal Dylan fans and may prove too oddball to draw in younger and mainstream audiences,” the Hollywood Reporter‘s Bennett writes in a largely positive review).

Telluride ran from Aug. 29 to Sept. 1; Venice runs from Aug. 29 to Sept. 8. Wild, Margot, I’m Not There, and Juno will all be playing at the Toroto International Film Festival, which starts Thursday; check back for RT’s reports from the fest.

RTIndie DVD Pick of the Week: God Grew Tired of Us

Recently, documentary filmmakers increasingly find themselves making films to fill in the gaps left by the networks. Like Darfur, the story of the Lost Boys of Sudan was one such under-publicized atrocity that went on to inspire multiple theatrical and televised docs between 2003 and today. The first major release, Meghan Mylan and John Shenk‘s Lost Boys of Sudan went theatrical in 2004 and the second release, the star supported God Grew Tired of Us came out in the winter of 2007 and will hit DVD this month. Narrated by Nicole Kidman and produced by Brad Pitt, Dermot Mulroney, and Catherine Keener, God Grew Tired of Us follows three South Sudanese men (no longer boys) from their UN sponsored huts in Sudan’s neighboring Chad to church sponsored homes in Pittsburg and Syracuse. You don’t have to be a star to see the appeal these men wield. Directors Christopher Dillon Quinn and Tommy Walker show these men endure the culture shock of planes, prepared foods and indoor lighting with sweetness and not a bit of placation. Ultimately, the men’s homesickness and ardor to save the nation that fathered them is a foray into their stories that’s accessible no matter what country you hail from. At 91 percent on the Tomatometer, God Grew Tired of Us is certified fresh; James Greenberg of the Hollywood Reporter called it “an incredibly powerful story of renewal, commitment and the resiliency of the human spirit.”

God Grew Tired of Us

Sara Schieron contributed to this article.

Tag Cloud

cinemax Pixar CBS Super Bowl Holidays high school serial killer leaderboard OneApp reboot GoT asian-american 99% Cannes Polls and Games pirates of the caribbean YouTube Premium cartoon nfl art house 2018 harry potter boxoffice Trailer Film Festival Thanksgiving Neflix 21st Century Fox miniseries classics dragons DGA boxing halloween Disney Plus Kids & Family Character Guide comic Comic-Con@Home 2021 TIFF teaser latino Biopics cars FX on Hulu Syfy mutant Reality The Walking Dead PaleyFest Hear Us Out TCA 2017 Mystery indie Apple TV+ romance Oscars period drama VH1 game show 4/20 GLAAD anthology Lionsgate Nickelodeon Esquire supernatural zombie Emmys Universal Pictures AMC Plus mcc worst movies popular Christmas FOX cooking Heroines Opinion black Paramount Network batman cancelled 90s natural history kids king kong rom-coms comiccon ABC Signature canceled TV shows Acorn TV Spring TV olympics science fiction Broadway halloween tv USA Network toy story medical drama Mary poppins historical drama prank comic book movies worst romantic comedy 2016 Pride Month Mary Poppins Returns Awards Tour IFC Films Holiday psychological thriller Superheroe Comics on TV Warner Bros. sports space The Academy The Walt Disney Company psycho tv talk Crackle ID Musicals cancelled television hispanic heritage month versus Ghostbusters crime thriller Apple TV Plus adenture 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards cancelled TV shows Paramount Plus joker Calendar Universal TV Land Chernobyl Columbia Pictures Premiere Dates Rom-Com superman a nightmare on elm street DC Universe political drama TV One football NYCC award winner criterion foreign Watching Series Fantasy monster movies Sundance Marvel Studios 2019 USA Apple 20th Century Fox cults Dark Horse Comics streaming Music nbcuniversal archives venice 2020 Election Certified Fresh ABC book hidden camera movies thriller Tumblr Amazon marvel cinematic universe facebook Spike disaster kaiju trailers sopranos Tokyo Olympics RT21 rt archives renewed TV shows ghosts TNT richard e. Grant suspense Showtime Comedy Central police drama YouTube Red E3 First Look spy thriller Hallmark Fox Searchlight Image Comics hist dexter video BET LGBTQ cats Turner king arthur Black History Month Adult Swim Rocketman Chilling Adventures of Sabrina live event wonder woman Instagram Live Valentine's Day revenge marvel comics best Netflix Christmas movies Awards genre Star Trek hollywood HFPA The Arrangement Alien Lucasfilm Action FX rotten movies we love Trophy Talk ABC Family APB screenings scorecard cancelled TV series trophy women dreamworks biography Travel Channel zombies social media series WGN golden globe awards SDCC legend unscripted documentaries Sundance TV Tarantino festivals slasher Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt remakes debate Arrowverse Captain marvel TruTV Pop TV Winners IFC composers reviews MCU parents Nat Geo dogs Endgame YouTube theme song mockumentary DirecTV Tags: Comedy Family scary movies 71st Emmy Awards saw Stephen King australia IMDb TV TBS DC streaming service telelvision The CW independent robots Creative Arts Emmys Elton John Animation werewolf Television Academy Ovation royal family transformers all-time comic books critic resources Trivia indiana jones 1990s cops laika christmas movies HBO Summer Masterpiece Binge Guide Britbox breaking bad 24 frames animated Netflix game of thrones BET Awards Star Wars Horror new star wars movies anime Shudder TV movies Toys crime drama diversity blockbusters gangster spinoff based on movie Schedule 2015 dceu sag awards vampires critics BBC Wes Anderson south america crime Pet Sematary stand-up comedy BBC One deadpool RT History Comic Book Brie Larson E! SXSW Infographic Fargo NBC festival Red Carpet blaxploitation Reality Competition strong female leads The Purge superhero Grammys Spectrum Originals See It Skip It HBO Go die hard stop motion franchise scene in color A24 Ellie Kemper MSNBC chucky MTV Fox News Sneak Peek ratings posters sequel 73rd Emmy Awards true crime Tomatazos Disney History President Shondaland Black Mirror casting BAFTA Disney+ Disney Plus San Diego Comic-Con sequels spanish language Legendary television children's TV Academy Awards Tubi emmy awards japanese Film Martial Arts binge james bond Pacific Islander discovery Avengers Mindy Kaling spanish green book TCA X-Men italian 72 Emmy Awards VOD Disney Channel Country Set visit Sony Pictures movie Western OWN stoner Fall TV Mudbound war aapi Amazon Prime golden globes GIFs Pop HBO Max child's play lord of the rings Rocky news ITV Best and Worst new zealand SundanceTV jurassic park rt labs singing competition video on demand Hulu Discovery Channel canceled TCA Winter 2020 Superheroes sitcom Teen kong Starz Cosplay hispanic Peacock Interview American Society of Cinematographers Logo Epix Drama dark Countdown free movies Video Games comedies young adult TV target DC Comics finale spider-man Bravo Prime Video Amazon Prime Video rotten films concert A&E what to watch vs. Marvel Women's History Month quibi Cartoon Network zero dark thirty ESPN obituary Lifetime Winter TV CMT rt labs critics edition FXX PBS CW Seed The Witch Marvel Television 45 book adaptation heist movie Baby Yoda justice league Marathons TLC fast and furious 2017 AMC japan biopic adaptation adventure Hallmark Christmas movies directors dc BBC America Nominations spider-verse basketball El Rey feel good Photos Hollywood Foreign Press Association docuseries NBA doctor who PlayStation live action Walt Disney Pictures comics TV renewals aliens black comedy french 79th Golden Globes Awards toronto Musical talk show godzilla 2021 witnail Year in Review Exclusive Video Podcast mob technology First Reviews Food Network Song of Ice and Fire Emmy Nominations TCA Awards Mary Tyler Moore know your critic docudrama TCM Comedy Rock Lifetime Christmas movies New York Comic Con comic book movie travel razzies Box Office Anna Paquin CNN Writers Guild of America Amazon Studios satire Freeform Quiz action-comedy LGBT Crunchyroll National Geographic jamie lee curtis Pirates twilight new york nature Vudu Funimation scary Television Critics Association Turner Classic Movies 007 VICE crossover Classic Film YA spain streaming movies international Sundance Now elevated horror mission: impossible Paramount WarnerMedia documentary Sci-Fi universal monsters name the review 93rd Oscars fresh Extras blockbuster dramedy Disney streaming service slashers politics CBS All Access screen actors guild ViacomCBS