Rotten Tomatoes Predicts the Oscars 2017

by | February 23, 2017 | Comments

In 2016, as a direct response to the #OscarsSoWhite controversy that cast a shadow over last year’s ceremony, the Academy of Motion Pictures Arts and Sciences invited over 600 new members, significantly comprised of women and people of color. While it’s difficult to say whether this will ultimately have a substantial impact on this year’s winners, it was still something we had to consider when we put our heads together and attempted to figure out who would walk away with trophies this weekend. Last year we were 16/24, and there are some tough categories this year, so we’re keeping our fingers crossed! See below to read through our full list of Oscar predictions.

Best Picture: La La Land (2016) 91%

Since Damien Chazelle’s love letter to Los Angeles hit the festival circuit last Fall, plenty of pundits have been predicting this as not simply a contender, but the favorite to win Sunday’s big prize.  Yes, there’s been a backlash, and Moonlight seems to be gaining some late-race momentum, but in the end, La La Land will take Best Picture.

Best Director: Damien ChazelleLa La Land (2016) 91%

Photo by Alberto E. Rodriguez / Getty Images for DGA

There’s a chance this year that we’ll see a split between the awards for Directing and Best Picture, but if that happens, it will only be because Moonlight takes Best Picture. La La Land expertly balances big dance numbers and smaller character moments, and we think that will propel Damien Chazelle into the win here.

Best Actor: Denzel WashingtonFences (2016) 92%

Denzel is our late-breaking favorite here, most notably winning Best Actor at this years’ SAG Awards. The acting branch of the Academy is the largest branch, and we predict that SAG win will match up with an Oscar win on Sunday night.

Best Actress: Emma StoneLa La Land (2016) 91%

This is another category where we think the recent SAG winner will strike gold again on Oscar night. Stone puts in a terrific performance that’s going to resonate with any Academy member that’s endured a painful audition process.

Best Supporting Actor: Mahershala AliMoonlight (2016) 98%

Mahershala Ali is a strong favorite in this category. Dev Patel is close, but Ali has won a dozen other awards (according to our leaderboard), and we think the streak will continue on Oscar night.

Best Supporting Actress: Viola Davis, Fences (2016) 92%

If there’s one “gimme” for the night, it’s this one. You can argue that it’s not exactly a supporting role, but that doesn’t matter. Viola Davis is going to walk with this one.

Best Original Screenplay: Manchester by the Sea (2016) 96%

We’ve predicted that Kenneth Lonergan’s film will get mostly shut out in various categories on Sunday night, but we think this is the one race that it’s mostly likely to win. The other nominees are strong contenders, but we think Manchester by the Sea will take home this one (and only this one).

Best Adapted Screenplay: Moonlight (2016) 98%

Barry Jenkins did some impressive work adapting Tarell Alvin McCraney’s play into a film, most notably rearranging the structure into a more linear story and letting relatively sparse dialogue have dramatic impact. We think the voters will notice too, and that Jenkins can count on at least one award of his own on Sunday night.

Best Animated Feature: Zootopia (2016) 97%

This isn’t a lock, but Zootopia arguably has the broadest appeal of all the movies in the category. The strongest challenger here is Kubo, but we think Zootopia will still win.

Best Foreign Language Film: The Salesman (Forushande) (2017) 96%

Asghar Farhadi has previously won this same award for A Separation in 2011, and we think he’ll win again this year.

Best Documentary Feature: O.J.: Made in America (2016) 100%

This is another category with some great contenders, but we think O.J.: Made in America will be the ultimate winner, narrowly edging out 13th and I Am Not Your Negro.

Best Cinematography: La La Land (2016) 91%

There was a lot of disagreement in the Tomatoplex over this category. Each of the nominees had their champions on the RT team, but after thinking about the dance numbers, especially the opening number on the freeway, most of our votes went to La La Land.

Best Film Editing: Arrival (2016) 94%

We think Arrival takes this one largely due to how it deftly moves through various times in Louise’s life, and how that jumping around is the key to understanding the movie.

Best Production Design: Hail, Caesar! (2016) 86%

This Coen brothers farce recreated 50s-era Tinseltown with such flair that we think it’s going to resonate with Academy members more than the other nominees.

Best Costume Design: Jackie (2016) 87%

So many of the reviews for this movie mention how the film really nailed Jackie’s look and style. We think that Academy voters will have noticed that too.

Best Original Score: La La Land (2016) 91%

The Oscar for music has to go to the musical this year right? We’ll frankly be shocked if this doesn’t happen.

Best Original Song: “City of Stars,” La La Land (2016) 91%

Although there’s a risk that the two songs from La La Land will sabotage each others’ chances, we’re still pretty sure that “City of Stars” will be the winner here.

Best Visual Effects: The Jungle Book (2016) 95%

This category caused a lot of disagreement in the Tomatoplex. A lot of us really think that Doctor Strange could take this one, but more of us think that the seamless mix of CGI and practical effects in The Jungle Book will get the most votes.

Best Makeup & Hairstyling: Suicide Squad (2016) 27%

In spite of the Tomatometer, we think Suicide Squad will eke out a win over the other contenders here.

Best Sound Mixing: Rogue One: A Star Wars Story (2016) 84%

There’s a great mix of familiar and new audio elements in the Star Wars universe, and that’s going to help make Rogue One an Oscar winner on Sunday night.

Best Sound Editing: Arrival (2016) 94%

The various sounds created for this film that become such an essential part of the story are going to cement a win for Arrival.

Best Animated Short: Piper (2016)

Believe it or not, Pixar hasn’t won an Oscar for Best Animated Short since For the Birds back in 2002. We think their latest avian adventure, the adorable Piper, will win the hearts of the Academy.

Best Live Action Short: Enemies within (Ennemis intérieurs) (2016)

The tense, topical Enemies Within (Ennemis Intérieurs) – about a French police officer interrogating an Algerian immigrant – touches on such hot-button issues as immigration, terrorism, and patriotism at a moment when tensions are rife across continents. Several of the Live Action shorts are lighter in tone, but Enemies Within feels particularly urgent.

Best Documentary Short: The White Helmets (2016) 100%

It’s not uncommon for the short docs to tackle heavy subject matter, but this year’s slate is especially heartbreaking, with three entries focusing on the Syrian Civil War. The White Helmets, which follows volunteer rescue workers operating in the war zone, has a power and immediacy that is certain to resonate with Academy voters.

Tag Cloud

The Arrangement singing competition Rom-Com MSNBC Watching Series Columbia Pictures Lifetime Holidays BBC political drama boxoffice cults anthology Walt Disney Pictures festivals CW Seed Calendar sequel 2016 Tomatazos Nat Geo Syfy Extras Awards Heroines elevated horror Elton John USA finale FX robots Sci-Fi based on movie science fiction travel spy thriller MCU jamie lee curtis E! Comic Book Mudbound YA miniseries strong female leads CBS TIFF Masterpiece Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Schedule period drama justice league hist Fox News Animation TV SundanceTV Cannes Mary Poppins Returns richard e. Grant Countdown Winter TV ratings Sneak Peek Polls and Games Universal composers New York Comic Con ABC Family mutant 45 Set visit First Look cinemax 24 frames IFC TV Land San Diego Comic-Con TBS PaleyFest police drama nature Sundance Now YouTube Red Esquire Emmys GLAAD Britbox Shudder serial killer true crime Awards Tour Film Festival Oscars Video Games Lucasfilm FXX CMT Comics on TV Winners Bravo IFC Films Stephen King A&E Mystery vampires Spectrum Originals 2018 psychological thriller Country Trivia Writers Guild of America SDCC space BET Podcast Pixar Showtime Cartoon Network Rocketman Logo 007 Premiere Dates Marvel Photos Hulu Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt 2017 doctor who NYCC crime thriller Character Guide natural history APB sports PBS Election dceu historical drama facebook comic Martial Arts Freeform Spike Christmas harry potter DC Comics talk show Super Bowl Trailer technology unscripted Tarantino El Rey supernatural Comedy Central Netflix Music Mindy Kaling Musicals Shondaland romance Food Network Paramount 2019 Horror crime drama YouTube Premium X-Men Certified Fresh Song of Ice and Fire ABC Star Wars Amazon Prime Best and Worst medical drama Toys Sony Pictures Pirates Interview zombies Action Brie Larson TLC casting BBC America Drama streaming teaser Ellie Kemper Mary poppins anime Starz Epix History television theme song Crackle 20th Century Fox Valentine's Day LGBTQ Mary Tyler Moore DC streaming service President green book Red Carpet DC Universe Summer MTV discovery Western GoT adaptation The CW Amazon Box Office diversity Fall TV Biopics Tumblr Rock Marathons GIFs Star Trek Adult Swim biography zero dark thirty mockumentary DirecTV Spring TV what to watch DGA Opinion CNN Anna Paquin witnail ITV Kids & Family Ovation Women's History Month Grammys SXSW thriller sitcom USA Network award winner psycho HBO VH1 Infographic dragons Reality Superheroe Pet Sematary Vudu dramedy Reality Competition Musical Nickelodeon Ghostbusters E3 spider-man Dark Horse Comics zombie VICE CBS All Access Captain marvel crossover Black Mirror Paramount Network 2015 Nominations golden globes Teen TNT Disney Channel transformers See It Skip It adventure AMC Disney National Geographic crime binge TCM TCA cops Creative Arts Emmys TruTV RT21 NBC TCA 2017 blaxploitation Acorn TV Pop Rocky FOX Sundance 21st Century Fox Superheroes Fantasy cooking war Trophy Talk disaster RT History Comedy OWN The Witch Quiz comiccon Lionsgate American Society of Cinematographers politics aliens WGN ESPN cats Cosplay Year in Review social media Warner Bros. dc Thanksgiving Apple docudrama