Critics Consensus

Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children Is Imaginative but Messy

Plus, Deepwater Horizon is thrilling, Masterminds lacks wit, and Transparent, Luke Cage, Pitch, and Westworld are all Certified Fresh.

by | September 29, 2016 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we have a magical orphanage (Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children, starring Eva Green and Asa Butterfield), Mark Wahlberg to the rescue (Deepwater Horizon, co-starring Kurt Russell and Kate Hudson), bumbling bank robbers (Masterminds, starring Zach Galifianakis and Kristen Wiig) and an awards-season checkmate (Queen of Katwe, starring Lupita Nyong’o and Madina Nalwanga). What do the critics have to say?

Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children (2016) 64%

Tim Burton‘s love of ornate visuals and dark whimsy hasn’t always jibed with the mainstream, but with his adaptation of Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children, he’s tackling a property that’s not only squarely in his wheelhouse, but has enough of an audience to encourage hopes for a blockbuster. Inspired by Ransom Riggs’ YA bestseller, Peculiar follows the adventures of Jake (Asa Butterfield), a grieving boy who stumbles into a time loop populated by strange and wonderful people — just in time to be drawn into their life-or-death battle against a terrifying foe (Samuel L. Jackson). Packed with quirk (and franchise potential), the story sets the table for a cinematic feast of truly Burtonian proportions; unfortunately, reviews describe an end product that’s something less than the sum of its parts. Perhaps too frightening for younger viewers and too loose with the source material for hardcore fans of the books, Burton’s Peculiar Children may prove a hard sell — but one not without its charms for the director’s fans and those seeking something strange and a little dark at the cineplex this weekend.

Deepwater Horizon (2016) 83%

How do you turn a catastrophic real-life disaster into entertainment? It’s tricky, obviously, but with Deepwater Horizon, director Peter Berg proves it can be done. Inspired by the events leading up to the 2010 oil spill that killed 11 crewmen and left a devastating environmental imprint in the Gulf of Mexico, this ensemble thriller stars Mark Wahlberg as a rig worker who leaps into the fray after the explosion that threatens the lives of his crew — and critics say he does a fine job, along with a list of co-stars that includes Kurt Russell, John Malkovich, and Kate Hudson, while Berg remains a dependably deft hand with a senses-rattling set piece. While many critics have hastened to add that Deepwater might have been more satisfying if it took the time to consider the regional aftermath of the events it dramatizes, reviews still point to an absorbing, well-acted action drama with some extra poignant nonfictional heft.

Masterminds (2016) 34%

Comedy is subjective, but even taking individual tastes into account, this weekend’s Masterminds boasts a pretty impressive pedigree: Owen Wilson, Zach Galifianakis, Kristen Wiig, Jason Sudeikis, Leslie Jones, and Kate McKinnon are just a few of the funny people in its ensemble cast, and if that isn’t enough, it also has Napoleon Dynamite director Jared Hess at the helm — as well as a script inspired by the true story of an absurd bank heist sparked by a toxic blend of greed and unrequited love. Alas, critics say most of that potential is squandered here; although the movie almost can’t help but manage a handful of funny moments, they’re smothered in an aggressively wacky caper that mistakes questionable hairstyles for genuine laughs.

Queen of Katwe (2016) 94%

For a cerebral game that may not seem inherently cinematic, chess has served as the backdrop for some pretty entertaining films over the years — a list upon which Disney’s Queen of Katwe can now claim a spot of honor. This inspirational drama finds director Mira Nair commanding a stellar cast led by Lupita Nyong’o and David Oyelowo, and starring newcomer Madina Nalwanga as real-life Ugandan chess champion Phiona Mutesi, and although its portrayal of Mutesi’s life might be guilty of indulging in a few stereotypical Hollywood shenanigans, the story of this unlikely prodigy is undeniably compelling. Critics say Nyong’o and Oyelowo deliver outstanding performances, while Nair has earned some of her best reviews since 2002’s Monsoon Wedding. If it’s feelgood fare you seek this weekend, check your local listings for Queen of Katwe.


What’s Hot on TV

Transparent: Season 3 (2016) 100%

Uniquely its own, and compelling and poignant as ever, Transparent continues to transcend the parameters of comedic and dramatic television with sustained excellence in its empathetic portrayal of the Pfefferman family.

Marvel's Luke Cage: Season 1 (2016) 90%

An immersive, socially conscious narrative and a confident, charismatic lead performance make Marvel’s Luke Cage a stellar sampling of the new Marvel/Netflix universe.

Pitch: Season 1 (2016) 93%

A terrific lead performance and well-constructed setup and timely themes make Pitch a home run.

Westworld: Season 1 (2016) 87%

With an impressive level of quality that honors its source material, the brilliantly addictive Westworld balances intelligent, enthralling drama against outright insanity.

Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Long Way North (Tout en haut du monde) (2016) , a period adventure following a 19th-century teenaged Russian aristocrat on a beautifully animated Arctic quest, is at 100 percent.
  • Sand Storm (Sufat Chol) (2016) , about the effects of entrenched patriarchy on the women of one Israeli family, is at 94 percent.
  • Among the Believers (2016) , a look at a real-life cleric’s efforts to impose Sharia law in Pakistan, is at 91 percent.
  • Harry & Snowman (2016) , a documentary about the bond between Harry de Leyer and his champion horse, is at 89 percent.
  • A Man Called Ove (En man som heter Ove) (2016) , a Swedish import adapting the bestselling novel about an elderly man whose plans for suicide are foiled by unwanted friendships, is at 86 percent.
  • Tharlo (2016) , a Tibetan import about a shepherd caught in a legal bind, is at 86 percent.
  • Do Not Resist (2016) , a documentary about the police in modern America, is at 85 percent.
  • American Honey (2016) , about a teenage runaway’s experiences with a group of potentially unsavory new friends, is at 78 percent.
  • The Apostate (El Apóstata) (2016) , about the bureaucratic entanglements suffered by a Spaniard struggling to excommunicate himself from the Catholic church, is at 76 percent.
  • Denial (2016) , starring Rachel Weisz in a fact-based drama about the legal battle that erupts after an author is accused of being a Holocaust denier, is at 70 percent.
  • Danny Says (2016) , a documentary about the little-known yet incredible career of music industry figure Danny Fields, is at 60 percent.
  • ClownTown (2016) , about a group of stranded friends fighting to survive in a town full of homicidal clowns, is at 13 percent.
  • A Family Man (2017) , starring Gerard Butler and Willem Dafoe in a drama about a headhunter vying for control of the company where he works, is at zero percent.

Tag Cloud

Binge Guide crossover Tumblr NYCC japanese Oscars deadpool Comics on TV Year in Review Polls and Games jamie lee curtis CBS Amazon Prime Video TruTV political drama travel Spike black TNT independent hist romantic comedy italian rt archives IFC Films documentaries Sneak Peek Mary Poppins Returns Set visit sitcom anthology cops comics halloween tv Musicals Shudder SDCC critics Writers Guild of America DC Comics worst movies talk show comic Paramount spanish language FXX tv talk Britbox sequels movie PlayStation Hulu Ellie Kemper Star Trek parents Travel Channel sag awards Black Mirror cartoon Disney Plus joker women ESPN Sundance Now Acorn TV dogs Brie Larson superman Photos El Rey medical drama Classic Film Reality natural history E3 popular stop motion historical drama batman blaxploitation south america National Geographic ABC Signature Biopics CBS All Access Trophy Talk Fantasy TV One Television Critics Association Super Bowl Women's History Month LGBTQ canceled See It Skip It justice league universal monsters golden globes BBC One 99% 2015 Grammys Pet Sematary Exclusive Video green book Valentine's Day 2016 First Look Discovery Channel Disney streaming service 24 frames Tarantino Kids & Family Character Guide serial killer BET cults science fiction Peacock USA Network Trailer spanish Marvel Television godzilla DGA Infographic Chilling Adventures of Sabrina video on demand Music monster movies Pride Month History BET Awards Comic Book Comedy Lifetime Christmas movies discovery Western Lionsgate directors Rocketman Hallmark Christmas movies TV renewals satire die hard RT21 Hallmark fresh spy thriller A&E dc stand-up comedy Song of Ice and Fire Disney Channel kaiju hispanic PaleyFest diversity quibi Mary Tyler Moore television thriller criterion TV ratings Superheroe nfl transformers french halloween canceled TV shows psycho police drama TCA 2017 MTV X-Men WGN adaptation sequel laika Baby Yoda slashers CNN Watching Series hidden camera Extras book Sci-Fi Epix Alien war king kong Freeform Sundance 45 cancelled TV series Tomatazos toy story The CW reboot game show Winners witnail FOX politics Columbia Pictures Animation HBO Max Crunchyroll Netflix game of thrones Esquire nature Walt Disney Pictures casting Thanksgiving American Society of Cinematographers YouTube Premium The Academy President based on movie E! Funimation Amazon screenings book adaptation A24 supernatural harry potter New York Comic Con CW Seed dark Black History Month TIFF DC streaming service Endgame Emmys Action 71st Emmy Awards Red Carpet TLC LGBT facebook sports name the review Country binge trailers Marvel Quiz VICE indiana jones rotten movies we love cooking Creative Arts Emmys Apple TV+ Apple BAFTA Heroines Nat Geo miniseries 21st Century Fox Starz DC Universe romance richard e. Grant kids cancelled television spain TBS Cartoon Network toronto The Walking Dead pirates of the caribbean Comedy Central Trivia franchise reviews Amazon Studios renewed TV shows chucky Fox Searchlight BBC australia Best and Worst 72 Emmy Awards 2018 Toys 2019 what to watch Masterpiece christmas movies YouTube Mindy Kaling cancelled comiccon Election news Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt singing competition Summer Video Games 93rd Oscars TCA Awards Winter TV Film Festival RT History The Walt Disney Company revenge foreign Arrowverse Crackle Captain marvel fast and furious The Arrangement Premiere Dates FX on Hulu Pop CMT cars cinemax period drama Adult Swim spinoff TV Land disaster worst Paramount Plus HBO Musical Mystery 4/20 Chernobyl true crime TCA Winter 2020 TCM asian-american cancelled TV shows award winner San Diego Comic-Con 20th Century Fox Fox News SXSW Family mission: impossible Syfy prank WarnerMedia Elton John 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards child's play Pixar jurassic park Academy Awards Awards Tour obituary movies SundanceTV OneApp Television Academy Christmas Anna Paquin films Logo Nominations dceu Podcast ITV elevated horror biography golden globe awards indie vampires blockbusters space rom-coms doctor who unscripted Paramount Network aliens The Witch PBS animated kong OWN boxoffice ID dramedy Box Office Spring TV classics Film Dark Horse Comics Holidays theme song MCU ghosts crime adventure streaming Disney+ Disney Plus remakes anime VOD Sundance TV all-time BBC America 007 Lucasfilm Reality Competition HBO Go comedies Food Network 2021 mutant VH1 ABC Family Turner Classic Movies Apple TV Plus teaser Pirates crime thriller IFC stoner Nickelodeon Tubi Ghostbusters Vudu YA comic books Calendar Turner football emmy awards breaking bad Rock Warner Bros. latino Emmy Nominations Fall TV Universal Superheroes james bond video scorecard screen actors guild Broadway razzies twilight Mary poppins werewolf Ovation Certified Fresh psychological thriller heist movie best Schedule strong female leads GoT new star wars movies Mudbound concert scary movies DirecTV docuseries children's TV a nightmare on elm street festivals Teen Shondaland YouTube Red free movies Interview composers hollywood crime drama Horror zombie Awards Hear Us Out 2020 docudrama zero dark thirty Opinion Netflix Christmas movies Bravo Marvel Studios versus ABC mockumentary Rom-Com Spectrum Originals finale MSNBC spider-man The Purge Holiday series venice Cannes blockbuster rotten Martial Arts cats Marathons First Reviews 2017 Drama Stephen King AMC Lifetime robots Cosplay documentary zombies superhero Avengers technology telelvision FX archives Rocky nbcuniversal social media NBC Disney USA Star Wars APB TCA Countdown festival ViacomCBS Pop TV GLAAD GIFs Showtime Amazon Prime Legendary dragons Sony Pictures boxing