Meet a Critic: Roger Ebert!

RT chats with America's favorite critic.

by | December 19, 2007 | Comments

Wishing him a speedy recovery from his surgery, we’re re-posting our Meet a Critic chat with Roger Ebert — Pulitzer Prize-winning author, screenwriter, and America’s most recognizable (and beloved) film critic.

To paraphrase Roger Ebert himself, “I cannot speak, but I can write.” Although cancer silenced the nation’s best-loved film critic last year, Ebert (ranked by Forbes as the number one pundit in America) recently returned to the movies with a vengeance, publishing to his website an output of new reviews and Answer Man columns that puts entire fully-staffed newsrooms to shame. The qualities that made Ebert a critical celebrity for decades — his wonderfully dry wit, deft writing, and a yearning to be moved by cinema — of course remain intact, but while he’s currently aided by a speaking computer, he shares with RT his hope that he’ll soon recover his own voice.

There are many reasons why Ebert is the heart of the critical community, and in the hearts of the moviegoing public. His influential review show, begun on public access television in 1975 with fellow critic Gene Siskel as Opening Soon at a Theater Near You, blazed a path for the celebrity critic by merging serious film analysis with America’s penchant for spectatorship. Ebert’s reverence for great films (and irreverence for bad ones) gave birth to the coinage of terms like “Dead Teenager Movie” and the idea of an “evil” zero-star film (see: Deuce Bigalow: European Gigolo). And as many know, everyone’s favorite critic penned a handful of delightfully camp B-movies with pal Russ Meyer: Beyond the Valley of the Dolls (1970), Up! (1976), and Beneath the Valley of the Ultra-Vixens (1979).

Catch up with Roger Ebert in our interview below, and look for two of his forthcoming books (Roger Ebert’s Four-Star Reviews 1967-2007 due January from Andrews & McNeel, and a book on Martin Scorsese from the University of Chicago Press in the autumn).

Name: Roger Ebert

Age: 65

Hometown: Chicago

Years reviewing film: 40

How are you these days? (We all miss seeing you on the show and at festivals!)

Roger Ebert: I am cancer-free, and looking forward to what I hope will be a final surgery in late January, in which I may regain the ability to speak. I attended the Toronto Film Festival and plan to be back at my own Ebertfest in April and Cannes in May.

We hear you’ve been using a computerized British voice named Lawrence to speak…

RE: Nope, I’ve got an American accent now. It came with the new Leopard OS for my Mac.

Diving in: Why and how did you become a critic?

RE: I wrote a weekly column for The Daily Illini at Illinois which sometimes involved movies, and did some interviews and think pieces for the Sun-Times before being named to fill the vacancy in April 1967.

Before reviewing film you were a sports writer. How did that transition happen, and how would you compare/contrast the two fields?

RE: I was a sports writer in high school, for my local daily. Not an intern, an actual staff writer. Both fields involve reporting on what you saw with a great deal of subjectivity and latitude in language and style.

Fill in the blank: “If I wasn’t a professional film critic, I’d be an op-ed columnist or a professor of English literature.

Which filmmaker (living or not) would you most like to meet, and why?

RE: I’ve met most of the living and recently departed. Going back further, Buster Keaton, of course.

What is your favorite film?

RE: Citizen Kane. I know it’s the standard answer, but what can I say? I’ve taught it a shot at a time at least 40 times, recorded the commentary track, and could look at it again right now.

Who is your favorite director?

RE: Alphabetically: Altman, Herzog, Keaton, Scorsese.

What’s the worst movie you’ve ever seen?

RE: Too many to choose from.

What’s the best movie you’ve ever written? (Beyond the Valley of the Dolls, Up!, or Beneath the Valley of the Ultra-Vixens) And where did your two noms de plume, R. Hyde and Reinhold Timme, come from?

RE: BVD, of course. The pseudonyms came from Russ Meyer. It was no secret they belonged to me.

Who do you think is a shoo-in come Oscar night?

RE: Diablo Cody (Juno).

You have been well-established as a leading critic for decades. What are the most significant changes you’ve witnessed in cinema as both a movie watcher and a member of the critics’ community?

RE: Film has become a marketed commodity, and the opportunities and audiences for art cinema have grown smaller. There is a general downturn in cultural literacy, perhaps because of television.

How have you changed as a critic over the years? Do you think you become more lenient in your reviewing?

RE: Some say I have. It may be that I tend to select better films to review. I hate the star rating system and refuse to keep count of my stars.

When will we see you back in the balcony on Ebert & Roeper?

RE: Depends on when, or if, I regain a television-quality voice.

Are either of the famous Thumbs™ insured? (And incidentally, when will we see those Thumbs™ again?)

RE: Not insured, only trademarked. If it were up to me, they would have never gone away, but we’ve become mired in endless negotiations with Disney. Maybe they’ll be back soon.

Do you have a favorite seat in a movie theater?

RE: Toward the back, side of the theater farther from the main entrance.

What’s your most memorable on-screen disagreement with Richard Roeper, Gene Siskel, or your previous guest hosts?

RE: Nothing will ever top Siskel disliking Apocalypse Now.

Which non-critic guest host did the best job of filling in on the show in your stead?

RE: Not for me to say.

What other film critics/bloggers/entertainment journalists do you read regularly?

RE: A very wide spectrum. The critic I respect most highly is Stanley Kauffmann of the New Republic, and I wish you listed him on RT.

Beside yourself, who is the sharpest critic working today? Who is the most influential critic?

RE: 1. See above. 2. The NY Times, LA Times, Variety and Hollywood Reporter critics.

What does it take to earn a 4/4 rating from you?

RE: A very good movie. What else can I say?

Has a film ever moved you beyond words? Specifically, are there movies you haven’t added to your Great Movies section that you just haven’t been able to find the words for?

RE: I had a hell of a time dealing with The Birth of a Nation, and still haven’t taken on Triumph of the Will. No film has ever moved me in a positive way more than I could express, not even Tokyo Story.

You have famously changed your mind on at least a few film assessments; The Brown Bunny and The Passenger come to mind especially. Do critics reserve the right to rethink a film’s merits, and how often has this happened to you?

RE: Of course we do. If I’d never changed my mind in 40 years, it would be a sad commentary.

You’ve reserved a special place for “evil” zero-star films like the recent Deuce Bigalow: European Gigolo and Chaos, but we remember in particular your 1980 review for a film called I Spit on Your Grave. How many zero stars have you given to date, and what does it really take to earn such distinction?

RE: I haven’t counted, but in additional to being bad, the movie should be offensive beyond ordinary measure.

What scope of responsibility does a critic have to guide his or her readers toward good films and away from not so good ones?

RE: That is the critic’s responsibility.

What is the state of current film criticism?

RE: Flourishing, in great part because of the internet.

Do you have a favorite review of your own that you’ve written in your career?

RE: I’m pleased that I reviewed 2001 on the night of its first public screening, and got it right, when the initial reaction was largely negative.

What words or phrases do you over-use?

RE: “Labyrinthine,” “cheerful,” “alarmingly,” “indeed,” “a real charmer.”

When you were a kid, what did you want to be when you grew up?

RE: A newspaperman.

What is your most common concession stand purchase?

RE: Raisinettes.

What has been your most bizarre movie-going experience?

RE: Clark Theater, Chicago 1968. Screening of A Hard Day’s Night, guy jumped at the screen from the balcony, screaming “I’m coming, John!” Minor injuries.

Tag Cloud

First Reviews RT History scorecard First Look justice league aliens Polls and Games Bravo PBS adventure Tumblr romantic comedy Cosplay biography AMC indiana jones crossover children's TV films best police drama Tubi 2019 Cannes doctor who Martial Arts Trophy Talk Comics on TV teaser Sony Pictures OWN ratings Creative Arts Emmys game show Showtime GLAAD Britbox San Diego Comic-Con Disney Plus IFC Films criterion National Geographic Trivia FXX Superheroes Nominations Kids & Family President blaxploitation USA Song of Ice and Fire Disney Channel Adult Swim Year in Review PlayStation scary movies DC Universe Mindy Kaling Marvel Studios what to watch Nickelodeon south america halloween Spectrum Originals all-time OneApp NBC football TIFF TCA Winter 2020 2018 medical drama Character Guide war Starz mutant Ellie Kemper Pop TV book spinoff PaleyFest Biopics Calendar History slashers directors worst Premiere Dates romance Discovery Channel VICE diversity sports Music science fiction Red Carpet cults 45 stand-up comedy Winter TV Disney streaming service Hear Us Out Awards breaking bad GIFs dark spider-man docudrama Spring TV WarnerMedia Pixar social media versus Sundance TV psychological thriller American Society of Cinematographers IFC green book TV ITV sag awards comics Pop Star Wars Trailer Photos spanish language Drama Oscars streaming MTV animated cancelled TV series ESPN reboot Musical New York Comic Con remakes Shondaland Tarantino Animation Horror zombies independent Teen YouTube Red Grammys 007 asian-american stoner BBC One TCA 2017 Rocky foreign Writers Guild of America strong female leads A24 spain Food Network Set visit renewed TV shows BBC America based on movie anime golden globes Marvel Television miniseries kids video on demand nbcuniversal BET Awards 2020 elevated horror spy thriller revenge Peacock Masterpiece Disney Comedy anthology Tomatazos A&E cars CBS All Access facebook Rom-Com classics TV Land Black Mirror Certified Fresh Reality Competition Mystery Travel Channel hist adaptation VH1 Binge Guide Arrowverse Fantasy chucky Lionsgate dramedy CNN TV renewals politics E! Mary Poppins Returns sitcom joker Musicals Toys Rocketman Video Games disaster laika vampires X-Men Dark Horse Comics nature festival Baby Yoda Quiz award winner 20th Century Fox comic cancelled TV shows Countdown parents DC Comics Interview Funimation werewolf harry potter name the review period drama MCU cinemax The Witch 21st Century Fox casting zero dark thirty documentaries The Arrangement LGBTQ Summer LGBT RT21 natural history binge twilight El Rey screenings YouTube Premium rotten worst movies emmy awards Star Trek Western SDCC Opinion Schedule 2015 Lucasfilm Logo DC streaming service Infographic Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Columbia Pictures Super Bowl TLC Action Heroines Election SXSW die hard technology movie SundanceTV series mockumentary 2017 Syfy FOX TruTV space tv talk Box Office news Turner Classic Movies Comic Book BET Paramount Network CMT satire historical drama Turner Awards Tour dogs indie Marathons DGA Family Superheroe Amazon Prime Walt Disney Pictures Apple true crime theme song mission: impossible Extras 72 Emmy Awards Apple TV Plus sequel game of thrones Sundance Now zombie Pet Sematary The CW talk show concert Mary Tyler Moore TCA Freeform E3 robots Watching Series Epix Mary poppins VOD HBO Max crime drama discovery Sundance Universal crime thriller Pirates cartoon 2016 Netflix Anna Paquin Holidays MSNBC 71st Emmy Awards Marvel Television Critics Association ABC Family Classic Film sequels canceled TV shows Elton John Hulu Emmys comedies free movies The Walking Dead Hallmark Christmas movies transformers Winners stop motion Cartoon Network political drama NYCC Ghostbusters Crunchyroll Esquire Chernobyl HBO Go Emmy Nominations Television Academy Chilling Adventures of Sabrina child's play dceu 24 frames Brie Larson video Thanksgiving Spike cops TCA Awards ghosts finale Amazon cats richard e. Grant Warner Bros. Fox News BBC GoT USA Network Paramount supernatural Best and Worst screen actors guild APB thriller nfl Christmas Valentine's Day documentary TCM CBS WGN travel Nat Geo YouTube fast and furious reviews television 4/20 cooking Film Festival Amazon Prime Video hollywood unscripted Stephen King FX Disney+ Disney Plus obituary movies Lifetime BAFTA franchise Captain marvel FX on Hulu Sci-Fi toronto CW Seed composers Hallmark Crackle dragons boxoffice HBO Country Black History Month dc a nightmare on elm street The Purge latino Vudu TBS canceled venice hispanic comiccon cancelled ABC festivals rotten movies we love Comedy Central batman blockbuster critics Lifetime Christmas movies Ovation Podcast serial killer Rock Avengers Sneak Peek Reality TNT jamie lee curtis Pride Month Amazon Studios Holiday Women's History Month Academy Awards cancelled television witnail Mudbound universal monsters Shudder Fall TV Acorn TV psycho YA toy story Netflix Christmas movies Film quibi DirecTV Endgame See It Skip It crime Apple TV+ singing competition christmas movies superhero