Meet a Critic: Roger Ebert!

RT chats with America's favorite critic.

by | December 19, 2007 | Comments

Wishing him a speedy recovery from his surgery, we’re re-posting our Meet a Critic chat with Roger Ebert — Pulitzer Prize-winning author, screenwriter, and America’s most recognizable (and beloved) film critic.

To paraphrase Roger Ebert himself, “I cannot speak, but I can write.” Although cancer silenced the nation’s best-loved film critic last year, Ebert (ranked by Forbes as the number one pundit in America) recently returned to the movies with a vengeance, publishing to his website an output of new reviews and Answer Man columns that puts entire fully-staffed newsrooms to shame. The qualities that made Ebert a critical celebrity for decades — his wonderfully dry wit, deft writing, and a yearning to be moved by cinema — of course remain intact, but while he’s currently aided by a speaking computer, he shares with RT his hope that he’ll soon recover his own voice.

There are many reasons why Ebert is the heart of the critical community, and in the hearts of the moviegoing public. His influential review show, begun on public access television in 1975 with fellow critic Gene Siskel as Opening Soon at a Theater Near You, blazed a path for the celebrity critic by merging serious film analysis with America’s penchant for spectatorship. Ebert’s reverence for great films (and irreverence for bad ones) gave birth to the coinage of terms like “Dead Teenager Movie” and the idea of an “evil” zero-star film (see: Deuce Bigalow: European Gigolo). And as many know, everyone’s favorite critic penned a handful of delightfully camp B-movies with pal Russ Meyer: Beyond the Valley of the Dolls (1970), Up! (1976), and Beneath the Valley of the Ultra-Vixens (1979).

Catch up with Roger Ebert in our interview below, and look for two of his forthcoming books (Roger Ebert’s Four-Star Reviews 1967-2007 due January from Andrews & McNeel, and a book on Martin Scorsese from the University of Chicago Press in the autumn).

Name: Roger Ebert

Age: 65

Hometown: Chicago

Years reviewing film: 40

How are you these days? (We all miss seeing you on the show and at festivals!)

Roger Ebert: I am cancer-free, and looking forward to what I hope will be a final surgery in late January, in which I may regain the ability to speak. I attended the Toronto Film Festival and plan to be back at my own Ebertfest in April and Cannes in May.

We hear you’ve been using a computerized British voice named Lawrence to speak…

RE: Nope, I’ve got an American accent now. It came with the new Leopard OS for my Mac.

Diving in: Why and how did you become a critic?

RE: I wrote a weekly column for The Daily Illini at Illinois which sometimes involved movies, and did some interviews and think pieces for the Sun-Times before being named to fill the vacancy in April 1967.

Before reviewing film you were a sports writer. How did that transition happen, and how would you compare/contrast the two fields?

RE: I was a sports writer in high school, for my local daily. Not an intern, an actual staff writer. Both fields involve reporting on what you saw with a great deal of subjectivity and latitude in language and style.

Fill in the blank: “If I wasn’t a professional film critic, I’d be an op-ed columnist or a professor of English literature.

Which filmmaker (living or not) would you most like to meet, and why?

RE: I’ve met most of the living and recently departed. Going back further, Buster Keaton, of course.

What is your favorite film?

RE: Citizen Kane. I know it’s the standard answer, but what can I say? I’ve taught it a shot at a time at least 40 times, recorded the commentary track, and could look at it again right now.

Who is your favorite director?

RE: Alphabetically: Altman, Herzog, Keaton, Scorsese.

What’s the worst movie you’ve ever seen?

RE: Too many to choose from.

What’s the best movie you’ve ever written? (Beyond the Valley of the Dolls, Up!, or Beneath the Valley of the Ultra-Vixens) And where did your two noms de plume, R. Hyde and Reinhold Timme, come from?

RE: BVD, of course. The pseudonyms came from Russ Meyer. It was no secret they belonged to me.

Who do you think is a shoo-in come Oscar night?

RE: Diablo Cody (Juno).

You have been well-established as a leading critic for decades. What are the most significant changes you’ve witnessed in cinema as both a movie watcher and a member of the critics’ community?

RE: Film has become a marketed commodity, and the opportunities and audiences for art cinema have grown smaller. There is a general downturn in cultural literacy, perhaps because of television.

How have you changed as a critic over the years? Do you think you become more lenient in your reviewing?

RE: Some say I have. It may be that I tend to select better films to review. I hate the star rating system and refuse to keep count of my stars.

When will we see you back in the balcony on Ebert & Roeper?

RE: Depends on when, or if, I regain a television-quality voice.

Are either of the famous Thumbs™ insured? (And incidentally, when will we see those Thumbs™ again?)

RE: Not insured, only trademarked. If it were up to me, they would have never gone away, but we’ve become mired in endless negotiations with Disney. Maybe they’ll be back soon.

Do you have a favorite seat in a movie theater?

RE: Toward the back, side of the theater farther from the main entrance.

What’s your most memorable on-screen disagreement with Richard Roeper, Gene Siskel, or your previous guest hosts?

RE: Nothing will ever top Siskel disliking Apocalypse Now.

Which non-critic guest host did the best job of filling in on the show in your stead?

RE: Not for me to say.

What other film critics/bloggers/entertainment journalists do you read regularly?

RE: A very wide spectrum. The critic I respect most highly is Stanley Kauffmann of the New Republic, and I wish you listed him on RT.

Beside yourself, who is the sharpest critic working today? Who is the most influential critic?

RE: 1. See above. 2. The NY Times, LA Times, Variety and Hollywood Reporter critics.

What does it take to earn a 4/4 rating from you?

RE: A very good movie. What else can I say?

Has a film ever moved you beyond words? Specifically, are there movies you haven’t added to your Great Movies section that you just haven’t been able to find the words for?

RE: I had a hell of a time dealing with The Birth of a Nation, and still haven’t taken on Triumph of the Will. No film has ever moved me in a positive way more than I could express, not even Tokyo Story.

You have famously changed your mind on at least a few film assessments; The Brown Bunny and The Passenger come to mind especially. Do critics reserve the right to rethink a film’s merits, and how often has this happened to you?

RE: Of course we do. If I’d never changed my mind in 40 years, it would be a sad commentary.

You’ve reserved a special place for “evil” zero-star films like the recent Deuce Bigalow: European Gigolo and Chaos, but we remember in particular your 1980 review for a film called I Spit on Your Grave. How many zero stars have you given to date, and what does it really take to earn such distinction?

RE: I haven’t counted, but in additional to being bad, the movie should be offensive beyond ordinary measure.

What scope of responsibility does a critic have to guide his or her readers toward good films and away from not so good ones?

RE: That is the critic’s responsibility.

What is the state of current film criticism?

RE: Flourishing, in great part because of the internet.

Do you have a favorite review of your own that you’ve written in your career?

RE: I’m pleased that I reviewed 2001 on the night of its first public screening, and got it right, when the initial reaction was largely negative.

What words or phrases do you over-use?

RE: “Labyrinthine,” “cheerful,” “alarmingly,” “indeed,” “a real charmer.”

When you were a kid, what did you want to be when you grew up?

RE: A newspaperman.

What is your most common concession stand purchase?

RE: Raisinettes.

What has been your most bizarre movie-going experience?

RE: Clark Theater, Chicago 1968. Screening of A Hard Day’s Night, guy jumped at the screen from the balcony, screaming “I’m coming, John!” Minor injuries.

Tag Cloud

Comics on TV best scary Emmys italian CBS All Access MCU Quiz cancelled TV shows X-Men aliens transformers witnail marvel comics video 73rd Emmy Awards disaster Pirates First Reviews Nominations Marathons rom-coms Marvel Studios Stephen King GLAAD Teen Biopics cartoon james bond Broadway Esquire Image Comics king arthur rt labs classics Black History Month dexter Creative Arts Emmys Syfy joker 72 Emmy Awards Apple TV Plus Reality Competition VICE nfl free movies ABC Signature Exclusive Video Tarantino travel true crime mcc DC streaming service superman trailers chucky revenge romantic comedy Rock Shondaland book adaptation FX Disney+ Disney Plus Crackle dramedy stand-up comedy comic book movies 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards WGN cults Set visit halloween tv ABC reviews Food Network Musicals nature Britbox dreamworks zombie streaming movies asian-american target unscripted cancelled TV series Spring TV Mary Poppins Returns Marvel crime Rom-Com foreign FOX Martial Arts Election Valentine's Day political drama Universal Hear Us Out crossover docudrama Fox Searchlight dogs Heroines composers BAFTA universal monsters medical drama Comic-Con@Home 2021 Starz The Walking Dead Character Guide discovery Discovery Channel Trailer Apple TV+ Red Carpet thriller obituary Funimation Columbia Pictures Photos Avengers legend The CW HBO Go Holiday anthology spinoff Television Critics Association PBS art house adenture SXSW comedies GIFs TIFF 71st Emmy Awards Fox News Nat Geo Certified Fresh south america CBS pirates of the caribbean Fantasy hispanic heritage month rt archives serial killer historical drama Ghostbusters AMC Chernobyl Mary Tyler Moore Kids & Family mutant comiccon Disney Plus Sci-Fi halloween Disney Channel quibi fresh tv talk supernatural 2019 cars sopranos harry potter Brie Larson Paramount Musical deadpool video on demand 20th Century Fox USA Network theme song spy thriller stop motion Hallmark Christmas movies TCM anime Hulu documentary Pixar Lucasfilm worst movies Horror laika YouTube Red A24 Netflix Christmas movies E! rt labs critics edition diversity Interview police drama cinemax IFC Universal Pictures critics American Society of Cinematographers BBC America facebook Chilling Adventures of Sabrina social media MSNBC book breaking bad child's play YA comic books CMT werewolf blaxploitation Black Mirror Polls and Games Warner Bros. mockumentary kids rotten movies we love Disney Sony Pictures TV movies mission: impossible New York Comic Con high school E3 VOD Acorn TV Masterpiece natural history RT21 Marvel Television FXX basketball know your critic Amazon Prime Turner Classic Movies biography reboot kong PlayStation based on movie Spectrum Originals PaleyFest Mudbound San Diego Comic-Con Year in Review Podcast 2016 SundanceTV comic streaming Shudder OWN doctor who Women's History Month Sundance TV 4/20 dragons Logo lord of the rings nbcuniversal cancelled television science fiction marvel cinematic universe king kong TCA Awards singing competition godzilla Superheroes black cooking indiana jones NBC Comedy TV Captain marvel Action strong female leads all-time suspense finale Disney streaming service biopic Spike Trophy Talk die hard El Rey crime thriller war justice league latino Travel Channel cancelled emmy awards Pet Sematary Netflix Pop Bravo Rocky spider-verse CNN teaser Reality action-comedy jamie lee curtis archives Star Wars ABC Family adventure psychological thriller romance psycho Sundance Now indie Sneak Peek olympics series genre crime drama LGBTQ television japan Wes Anderson Pacific Islander Freeform satire ID zero dark thirty 21st Century Fox heist movie Trivia golden globes Winter TV TCA Winter 2020 APB See It Skip It new york children's TV robots Adult Swim films Lifetime Christmas movies TruTV Vudu posters wonder woman Pop TV HBO Max Premiere Dates versus miniseries Tomatazos National Geographic Drama Baby Yoda Anna Paquin 2018 Hallmark Tubi hidden camera Video Games hispanic Super Bowl Neflix scorecard TBS VH1 period drama superhero TLC Legendary animated Showtime jurassic park Film canceled game show vs. GoT richard e. Grant Superheroe spanish language YouTube DC Universe 007 The Arrangement Lionsgate Comedy Central Emmy Nominations Comic Book remakes screen actors guild australia The Witch 1990s slasher CW Seed ESPN 2021 toronto christmas movies SDCC Epix elevated horror festival Writers Guild of America Sundance kaiju MTV RT History popular ghosts DirecTV Binge Guide Tumblr President independent NBA BBC Cosplay casting Schedule Amazon debate spider-man Animation spanish french OneApp zombies Apple japanese women slashers Awards Tour Infographic TV One live action docuseries YouTube Premium A&E concert Amazon Studios politics DGA Crunchyroll fast and furious green book blockbuster Peacock First Look batman Western Mary poppins Walt Disney Pictures Ovation twilight adaptation a nightmare on elm street 99% Mystery comics movies Winners Ellie Kemper ratings 24 frames Box Office Summer sequel boxing name the review black comedy Grammys game of thrones Endgame The Walt Disney Company Family Christmas Thanksgiving LGBT Rocketman 2017 WarnerMedia dceu Arrowverse comic book movie boxoffice FX on Hulu cats Watching Series blockbusters Countdown 2015 hist screenings sitcom Calendar Oscars spain sequels what to watch The Purge Tokyo Olympics Holidays ITV Mindy Kaling Opinion Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt razzies IFC Films saw 93rd Oscars young adult dark worst sports Cannes monster movies ViacomCBS new zealand TV renewals Paramount Network critic resources Fall TV criterion feel good 2020 BET Awards BBC One renewed TV shows news binge prank new star wars movies hollywood Elton John Music franchise Lifetime Classic Film Cartoon Network telelvision Country Extras gangster USA Nickelodeon venice Pride Month TCA 2017 mob Dark Horse Comics 90s TV Land festivals HBO football History sag awards NYCC live event Film Festival parents Best and Worst cops movie Television Academy technology documentaries scene in color Paramount Plus 45 Star Trek Instagram Live Awards DC Comics BET aapi toy story IMDb TV AMC Plus Amazon Prime Video golden globe awards royal family directors dc space talk show vampires Academy Awards TNT international stoner award winner Toys Song of Ice and Fire rotten scary movies The Academy Alien TCA canceled TV shows Turner