Marvel Movie Madness! Part 24: Spider-Man 3

The infamous closing out the trilogy.

by | July 1, 2011 | Comments

Enter Marvel Movie Madness, wherein Rotten Tomatoes watches all of the significant Marvel movies ever made. Full Marvel Movie Madness list here. Tune in! We give you our thoughts, and you give us yours.


Part 24: Spider-Man 3 (2007, 63% @ 241 reviews)

Directed by Sam Raimi, starring Tobey Maguire, Kirsten Dunst, Thomas Haden Church, James Franco

Ryan: It has to be said: This is the most problematic of the three Sam Raimi Spider-Man films. There are too many characters, too many simultaneous subplots, too many villains, too many meandering lulls in between the big action sequences. With two-plus years to work on the third installment, and with two solid films behind them, Raimi and Co. were perfectly poised to hit another one out of the park. Unfortunately, the director’s ambition seems to have gotten the better of him on this go-round.

First off, at 138 minutes, Spider-Man 3 is much too long for its own good. They were considering splitting the movie up into two parts, but decided against that when they couldn’t figure out a good place to break the story in half, and this sort of “we’ve got a lot of stuff here, but we don’t quite know what to do with it” mentality shows. Next, if Doc Ock felt like a “villain of the week” in SM2, we get double the (dis)pleasure here with Sandman and Venom, who both really feel shoehorned into the central story revolving around Peter, Mary, and Harry, and whose exits from the movie are unsatisfying.

One thing I will say, though, that might place me in the minority, is that I didn’t mind “emo” Peter Parker as much as a lot of people did. When he pulls his bangs down over his eyes and starts strutting down the street with that crooked grin on his face, I can’t help but chuckle. And when he goes nuts inside the jazz club, it makes me laugh out loud. I’ll admit it: I sort of liked the ridiculous nature of it all, and I felt like Raimi was just having fun. Then again, maybe Raimi having too much fun was the problem with the movie as a whole.


Luke: Yeah, it’s definitely the most uneven of the films, with too much going on than it can give attention to properly. That said, I didn’t enjoy this significantly less than part two, despite its flaws. On the plus side, part three at least feels poised to be a sequel to the first film by addressing Harry’s vengeance story. Things get momentarily tense. Harry gets a hoverboard. And then — oh that’s convenient — he gets amnesia for a huge stretch of the film. Properly done, Goblin junior should have been sufficient to carry the villain duties of the movie, but instead, as Ryan says, we get Sandman and Venom shoehorned in, their stories paced awkwardly, and then a sudden, unbalanced cacophony of supervillainy right at the end — when it felt too late. Sandman at least had a reason for the conflict (Peter’s uncle); the real waste here is Venom, who looks the most badass of any of the villains thus far, but gets shortchanged in the melee. (And why did they need to keep revealing Topher Grace’s decidedly non-threatening face during the fight scenes?) Again, the finale is yet another kidnapping of MJ and her precarious high-wire suspension — don’t these villains ever learn from their predecessors’ mistakes? — with varying quality CGI that to me felt like the most rushed of the series.

The love story, meanwhile, just goes round and round and round to the point where I did not care anymore, and the evil Spider-Man suit was cool briefly — until the script had no more use for it so decided that he could easily — somehow; cooking oil? — just take it off and throw it aside. As for the infamous “emo” fringe and dance sequence, I’m with Ryan — I thought it was funny; moreover, it was one of the rare points in the film where Raimi actually seemed to be enjoying himself. And that’s the thing: the director expends so much effort in this movie goofing in the comedic margins that I wonder whether he was bored by everything else. I know I was. I’d had enough of Spider-Man by the end and am not eager to return to his world just yet (especially when it’s made by the guy who directed 500 Days of Summer).


Tim: Oh, c’mon, guys. That dance sequence was painful. Not only does it interrupt what was sure to be a perfectly good version of “Fever,” it also provides yet another excuse to leave Gwen Stacy sitting on the sidelines (her character just feels like a missed opportunity throughout). If you want a good dance sequence in this flick, I suggest taking another look at the scene in which amnesiac Harry and heartbroken M.J. perk up by making omelets while grooving to Chubby Checker — that at least had a feeling of spontaneity, something this movie is sadly lacking. However, I agree with you that Spider Man 3 had the same problem as the first round of Batman sequels — too many bad guys. What we need is an epic showdown that feels urgent and personal, and by giving us two antagonists (two and a half, if you count the Green Goblin), it’s more bombastic than tense.

To its credit, Spider-Man 3 has a solid first half; I liked the fact that being a superhero was taking a toll on M.J. and Pete, not least because his ego had gotten out of control. I found Aunt May’s reminiscences about the day Uncle Ben proposed to be kind of touching, and Peter’s landlord proves himself to be a gruff but thoroughly decent guy; what’s nice about all three Spider-Man films is that the characters are, in general, fundamentally decent people who strive to do the right thing (even the bad guys!). Spider-Man 3 doesn’t totally deserve its toxic reputation, but it’s kind of a bummer that the franchise succumbed to blockbuster bloat after two superior installments.

Luke: Tim, really? It’s fine to hate on the goofball dance routine — I guess that’s the consensus anyway — but to defend it by praising the freakin’ egg cooking scene?

Tim: What can I say? I like eggs.

More Marvel Movie Madness:

Tag Cloud

spinoff Podcast Polls and Games Columbia Pictures Classic Film 2019 cancelled television mission: impossible Ellie Kemper Chilling Adventures of Sabrina singing competition Film Festival cinemax book DGA hispanic Spike Tumblr Writers Guild of America kids game of thrones travel Binge Guide Shudder Lucasfilm Comic Book TCM Food Network Martial Arts Country Arrowverse Infographic blaxploitation E3 Summer TNT canceled TV shows Apple TV+ FX Television Academy SXSW Emmy Nominations Stephen King Amazon Studios crime witnail See It Skip It latino science fiction slashers Vudu cancelled TV series Lifetime Christmas movies Trophy Talk Year in Review 2018 MSNBC cooking Avengers Hallmark Christmas movies Countdown crossover south america cats Awards award winner criterion Winter TV Apple 2017 WGN breaking bad 007 Fantasy Paramount Network elevated horror name the review DirecTV The Walking Dead ABC Family WarnerMedia Winners sports technology Crackle Trivia game show Amazon Prime FX on Hulu finale Pop TV free movies comedies AMC TIFF spider-man period drama NYCC Peacock Western Character Guide TLC dc Masterpiece Travel Channel a nightmare on elm street Universal RT History Mary poppins based on movie child's play Warner Bros. Captain marvel Teen Awards Tour The Purge movie indie Action APB Superheroes Bravo FOX psycho Starz children's TV 2020 zombies justice league scary movies disaster Ghostbusters adaptation NBC series jamie lee curtis diversity Set visit CW Seed E! Sony Pictures Black Mirror reviews Watching Series Pet Sematary Amazon Prime Video RT21 BBC VH1 Black History Month The Arrangement best Premiere Dates Disney Trailer zombie crime drama SundanceTV revenge Rom-Com Extras ratings asian-american Paramount boxoffice historical drama dark Marvel Television Emmys TCA tv talk what to watch toy story Pixar dragons canceled sitcom Christmas HBO Max Academy Awards IFC Films ABC SDCC Cosplay Disney streaming service cancelled TV shows sag awards dceu Calendar politics Ovation parents anthology LGBT talk show biography Esquire 2015 TCA 2017 71st Emmy Awards Musical supernatural dogs Mudbound vampires Comics on TV Comedy Central Lionsgate DC streaming service Logo theme song TV police drama Photos Sundance Now ITV ESPN OneApp Sundance TV Pop Certified Fresh Discovery Channel Marvel Oscars Holiday adventure Turner Classic Movies Heroines Animation documentary 21st Century Fox cops teaser cars video sequel screenings stoner CMT christmas movies Turner Adult Swim Reality Competition Disney Plus cancelled directors HBO Mindy Kaling Fox News A&E El Rey 20th Century Fox composers USA Network PBS Sundance X-Men strong female leads PaleyFest robots Biopics Dark Horse Comics foreign Best and Worst Valentine's Day YouTube Premium mockumentary Holidays Epix green book Netflix Tarantino Reality natural history BBC America political drama Family First Look versus Spring TV Thanksgiving Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt spanish language Hulu Elton John Rocky Pride Month GLAAD Kids & Family Video Games blockbuster GIFs 24 frames Chernobyl The Witch franchise Britbox Freeform Creative Arts Emmys Pirates President harry potter facebook Nickelodeon Hallmark Toys spain TBS Grammys Mystery New York Comic Con A24 VICE TV renewals Disney+ Disney Plus Interview Anna Paquin Syfy Funimation reboot USA romance screen actors guild werewolf DC Comics richard e. Grant ghosts medical drama crime thriller social media Comedy History streaming Drama Film golden globes cartoon anime LGBTQ 4/20 National Geographic Quiz 2016 rotten movies we love chucky YouTube Red Amazon Lifetime Mary Tyler Moore Crunchyroll Star Wars Showtime casting Music IFC Star Trek Box Office cults Shondaland Apple TV Plus YA Horror Election Super Bowl animated Women's History Month doctor who stand-up comedy DC Universe serial killer renewed TV shows docudrama The CW TruTV Sneak Peek TV Land San Diego Comic-Con discovery comic hist war Mary Poppins Returns American Society of Cinematographers Hear Us Out binge Baby Yoda Acorn TV independent First Reviews unscripted Marathons Tubi dramedy Cartoon Network Endgame Netflix Christmas movies transformers Fall TV television spy thriller space OWN psychological thriller quibi zero dark thirty Opinion true crime Tomatazos die hard festivals Spectrum Originals batman universal monsters Song of Ice and Fire GoT Cannes CNN Superheroe FXX joker mutant TCA Winter 2020 Nominations comiccon nature Rocketman Nat Geo CBS All Access Marvel Studios 45 Rock Schedule MTV romantic comedy movies Musicals BET YouTube Brie Larson comics aliens Walt Disney Pictures MCU Red Carpet thriller Disney Channel halloween Sci-Fi CBS concert miniseries