Five Favorite Films

Karina Longworth's Five Favorite Films

The creator of podcast 'You Must Remember This' shares her love for five oft-forgotten Golden Age gems.

by | November 13, 2018 | Comments

(Photo by Emily Berl)

Few “Best Podcast” lists fail to include You Must Remember This, Karina Longworth’s deep dive into the forgotten corners of Hollywood history. Across 134 episodes, with a handful of bonus “flashback” editions, Longworth has produced fascinating looks at the Blacklist years, the rivalry between Bette Davis and Joan Crawford, MGM’s glory days, the tragically short lives of a number of young starlets, and, most famously, the Manson murders and their relationship to Hollywood. The podcast is produced with a deliberately noir-ish tone, and has featured guest voice actors including John Mulaney and Patton Oswalt. Longworth, a writer and film critic, told Rotten Tomatoes that when she started the podcast in 2014, she had little idea it would blow up to be as big as it is today. “I had this idea in my head and I just knew that I could do every aspect of it to make it happen, and so I thought of it as a calling card that might lead to something else. Then it did become a job.”

This month, with new episodes of the podcast still being produced, she releases a new book, Seduction: Sex, Lies, and Stardom in Howard Hughes’s Hollywood. Hughes is the book’s title character, but as with her podcast, it is often those who orbit the biggest names who fascinate Longworth. “I was more interested in some of the actresses he was involved with,” says Longworth. “I figured I could kind of use him as the spine of a book that’s about all these different actresses’ experiences; have it be about what their lives were like before they encountered him and how being involved with him, either professionally or personally, or both, changed their life and career.”

Ahead of the book’s release on November 13, Longworth spoke about five of her favorite films from those she discovered, or rediscovered, in her research on Hughes and the people in his life.


Souls for Sale (1923)

The first one would be Souls For Sale, which was actually written and directed by Howard Hughes’ uncle, Rupert Hughes. It was based on a novel that Rupert Hughes wrote. He had been an author and a playwright and he had been brought to Hollywood in 1918 as sort of an effort that Samuel Goldwyn did to bring famous authors into the movies to try increase the qualities of movies.

Rupert Hughes had just fallen in love with Hollywood and once it started being attacked after the scandals of the 1920s, he wanted to defend what he felt was an industry that was getting a bad rap. He wrote this novel and they made a movie out of it called Souls For Sale, and it’s about the daughter of a fire-and-brimstone preacher who escapes her brand new husband, who she has a bad feeling about, and ends up in a movie and immediately becomes a huge star. It basically tells the story of this girl encountering the movie industry, and at every moment where something sort of dirty or scandalous could happen, she actually finds that the people in Hollywood are really hard-working and upstanding citizens and are a higher quality of human than – for instance – her treacherous husband.

It’s a really interesting movie. It’s definitely an artifact of its time and place – and you could say that more literally about it than many other movies because it has kind of a documentary element about it. The director really goes out of his way to show you what the studio lots looked like in 1923, and he films other directors like Charlie Chaplin working. It’s a movie that I had never heard of before as I was doing research [for the book], and I think it’s probably the earliest sort of Hollywood movie about Hollywood.

Christopher Strong (1933)

This is Katharine Hepburn’s second movie, and it’s directed by a female director, Dorothy Arzner, who’s one of only a couple of prominent female film directors during the sound era of the 20th Century. It’s just a really interesting film about a supposedly liberated woman, and how she navigates a professional life and a personal life, and how she kind of stays trues to her ideals in a world where – while there may be rhetoric supporting the idea of a new woman – really what the world values is women being domestic.

Katharine Hepburn plays basically an Amelia Earhart-type aviatrix who has never had a romance, and she ends up meeting and falling in love with a married man who has never been unfaithful to his wife, and disaster ensues. The name of the film is the name of the man that she falls in love with, but it’s definitely her story.

Kitty Foyle (1940) 80%

Next would be Kitty Foyle, which is the movie that Ginger Rogers won her Oscar for. She is obviously mostly remembered for a singing and dancing star from the Astaire and Rogers musicals, but this is a melodrama – there was no singing or dancing. It basically tells the story of a girl who grows up on the wrong side of the tracks and falls in love with a wealthy heir to a big Philadelphia fortune, and has to navigate romance and class and all of these different issues.

It’s a very conservative film and it’s very didactic. It’s extremely problematic in a lot of ways, but I find it fascinating. The performance that she gives, though… I think a lot of times, some of these great stars, they win an Oscar for a movie that’s not their best work, or it’s sort of given as a consolation prize for them not winning for something that is a classic. I think people think that about Kitty Foyle because nobody watches it any more, and people only remember Ginger Rogers as a dancer, but her performance in this movie is stunning.

The character she’s playing has to sort of take on different personas over the course of her life and with different people in her life. The way that Ginger Rogers performs those unique and distinct versions of the same person is just really incredible. Obviously, there’s a huge degree of difficulty to a career based on singing and dancing. I wrote about this in my book, but there’s that old line about Ginger Rogers that “She had to do everything Fred Astaire did, but backwards and in heels.” The whole idea of her stardom is about how much harder it is for a woman to do the same things that a man does. But all of that said, I think there’s a degree of difficulty to this performance that is the kind of thing that is really, true great acting and great stardom, but it’s the kind of thing where the labor doesn’t show, and so people don’t talk about it in that way.

Where Danger Lives (1950)

This is a film noir that was produced by RKO Studios while Howard Hughes was the controlling owner of it. It stars Robert Mitchum and a woman named Faith Domergue, who was Hughes’ discovery and girlfriend who he basically became involved with when she was a teenager, really, and kept promising that he was going to make her a big star – and didn’t. But this movie is the finest showcase she ever got for her unique talents, which – I don’t know that she was a great actress – but she’s really good in this film as a femme fatale who you would initially think is sort of a vulnerable victim. Then, slowly, over the course of the movie, she reveals that she’s actually running the whole show and is incredibly devious.

Did you discover a number of RKO gems like this in the course of researching the book?

Oh, yeah. I mean, I think that Howard Hughes definitely ran RKO Studios into the ground. There was a lot of bad press while he was running it for basically just not knowing how to make a studio succeed. But at the same time, I think with the distance of time, we can look at the output that he made or he approved the making of, [and see there is] an enormous amount of genre films that are considered sort of B-movie classics. Two of the other ones that I talk about in the book that I really like also star Robert Mitchum: His Kind Of Woman and a film called Macao. They both also star Jane Russell.

Caught (1949) 100%

It was was directed Max Ophuls and it stars Robert Ryan as a character who was intended to be based on Howard Hughes. Max Ophuls had been hired by Hughes’ production company, RKO, early to make the film that was actually supposed to be Faith Domergue’s big starring vehicle, and that movie just turned into a disaster. The production of it dragged along over five or six years with many different directors.

After Ophuls got fired from it, he got hired to make an adaptation by another company of a novel called Wild Calendar. He told the screenwriter that he was paired with that he didn’t want to actually adapt the novel; he wanted to use the structure of the novel to make a film about how terrible he thought Howard Hughes was. They basically culled the notes of everything that they’d ever heard about Howard Hughes and Ophuls’ personal experiences, and the screenwriter, Arthur Laurents, went out and he met women who had had encounters with Hughes and then put it all together in this film which is about a shop girl who gets involved with a mysterious millionaire.

The mysterious millionaire’s played by Robert Ryan, who was an actor who made a lot of different kinds of movies, and to a lot of film noir fans and B-Movie, genre film fans, he’s considered a great star, but he really looks like Howard Hughes in a lot of ways. They’re both very tall and lanky and have kind of a similar jaw. Even though Hughes knew this movie was being made – he insisted that he be sent dailies – he asked for some changes so that people wouldn’t think it’s him. The character and the performance are a lot like him. Nowadays, especially given everything we know about Howard Hughes, the similarities are impossible to ignore.


Seduction: Sex, Lies, and Stardom in Howard Hughes’s Hollywood is available November 13. 

Tag Cloud

spinoff MTV cartoon television dc directors TV FXX Year in Review Discovery Channel disaster The CW kids 24 frames comics PaleyFest Esquire History comiccon critics elevated horror Lifetime Christmas movies reboot Paramount Network Apple facebook Red Carpet werewolf ABC Family Rom-Com Tumblr crime Sci-Fi AMC child's play Travel Channel Hulu CMT crime thriller blaxploitation sequel joker 45 Best and Worst police drama 21st Century Fox GIFs canceled TV shows Cannes Hallmark Christmas movies space TCA 2017 Columbia Pictures Reality Trailer toronto DC streaming service twilight festivals APB TruTV reviews cancelled TV shows sports slashers scorecard war SundanceTV Netflix Trivia cooking Mudbound A24 20th Century Fox name the review Set visit comedies Sony Pictures HBO Max jamie lee curtis Television Critics Association Disney Channel ghosts spain robots video on demand fast and furious SDCC adaptation Stephen King christmas movies Marvel Studios Sundance TV Certified Fresh nbcuniversal zero dark thirty 2019 Rocketman spanish language Walt Disney Pictures Creative Arts Emmys Spike Valentine's Day Country theme song Thanksgiving true crime Holidays Television Academy Spectrum Originals satire X-Men Tarantino Freeform Paramount Sundance Now latino unscripted Pixar Box Office classics nfl CW Seed ESPN Disney streaming service Toys hispanic YouTube Premium a nightmare on elm street dramedy OneApp hist Britbox zombies Video Games TLC ratings 2015 Fall TV historical drama 2018 National Geographic TV Land singing competition BAFTA Teen HBO Comedy Ghostbusters dogs cinemax Schedule Election Winners 2020 talk show Song of Ice and Fire Turner worst stand-up comedy Watching Series franchise Animation Dark Horse Comics renewed TV shows PBS Music Turner Classic Movies LGBT MCU Extras Vudu casting Emmy Nominations CNN CBS All Access Women's History Month foreign Pop Binge Guide cults tv talk breaking bad RT History TCA Winter 2020 FX dceu mockumentary sag awards free movies canceled game show Acorn TV Ellie Kemper Christmas Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Comics on TV Interview Crackle crime drama discovery Premiere Dates psychological thriller crossover BBC FOX Peacock cancelled medical drama Amazon Prime Video Polls and Games Winter TV dark American Society of Cinematographers golden globes independent concert criterion USA Disney+ Disney Plus Bravo Horror harry potter Chilling Adventures of Sabrina E3 Martial Arts WGN miniseries Crunchyroll Lucasfilm Summer Heroines cancelled television social media Nickelodeon Comic Book transformers Cartoon Network cancelled TV series indie MSNBC Mary poppins composers Nat Geo emmy awards Rock Superheroe mission: impossible screen actors guild nature BET Awards IFC rotten movies we love Chernobyl TCA Holiday See It Skip It LGBTQ GoT Sundance Superheroes DirecTV VH1 The Purge Netflix Christmas movies The Walking Dead Kids & Family NBC GLAAD stop motion Marvel Fox News Film south america Musicals VOD cats rotten mutant award winner anime chucky Fantasy Black History Month TBS FX on Hulu Starz series versus Super Bowl revenge richard e. Grant First Look ABC Amazon Shondaland travel spider-man Baby Yoda Mystery Arrowverse YA San Diego Comic-Con Marathons video PlayStation Masterpiece WarnerMedia sitcom dragons all-time Mary Poppins Returns Adult Swim Rocky VICE blockbuster 007 Amazon Prime Logo E! Comedy Central universal monsters science fiction NYCC 2016 The Witch Food Network parents political drama DGA documentaries quibi movies batman Pirates 4/20 Biopics superhero binge halloween Mindy Kaling period drama laika spy thriller Emmys Family Awards ITV natural history indiana jones Lifetime Film Festival New York Comic Con Character Guide SXSW Quiz news First Reviews Apple TV Plus Pop TV BBC One Opinion Drama Oscars serial killer Showtime best diversity Cosplay venice Endgame remakes Disney Plus psycho Anna Paquin Elton John football Epix cars Calendar Awards Tour Shudder Ovation The Arrangement comic supernatural Pet Sematary OWN game of thrones cops Countdown zombie aliens Captain marvel adventure strong female leads YouTube Red children's TV Tubi animated Tomatazos thriller Sneak Peek screenings based on movie TIFF scary movies Disney CBS Action asian-american movie documentary TNT Classic Film Mary Tyler Moore Black Mirror Western Avengers 2017 Amazon Studios Warner Bros. stoner Apple TV+ Universal Hear Us Out Lionsgate romance films Brie Larson vampires teaser finale politics Reality Competition Spring TV El Rey 72 Emmy Awards Star Wars TCA Awards obituary worst movies toy story green book BBC America festival Trophy Talk technology RT21 Grammys what to watch justice league hollywood Academy Awards Infographic DC Universe TCM doctor who Pride Month DC Comics streaming book TV renewals boxoffice YouTube Writers Guild of America Podcast 71st Emmy Awards Funimation Musical die hard Syfy Photos romantic comedy anthology A&E docudrama HBO Go biography witnail Marvel Television Nominations USA Network President sequels Hallmark Star Trek BET IFC Films