Judge Grants Co-Creator's Heirs Share of Superman Copyright

Ruling could complicate future Man of Steel movies.

by | April 1, 2008 | Comments

Superman’s path back to the big screen — already proving itself to be surprisingly long and winding after 2006’s Superman Returns — may have just gotten even longer and more treacherous.

Last week, a federal judge ruled that the heirs of the character’s co-creator, Jerry Siegel, were entitled to a share of the Superman copyright — and have been since 1999. The ruling left unanswered a number of questions, such as monies owed in the last nine years, or whether the Siegels are owed a portion of the profits from Superman Returns.

Though the ruling has far-ranging implications for Time Warner’s ability to exploit Superman, it was actually focused on a very narrow piece of the character’s history — specifically, elements present in his first appearance in Detective Comics’ Action Comics Vol. 1. Though this leaves the vast majority of Superman’s story in the hands of Time Warner, his origin and basic ingredients are now shared with the Siegels. As the New York Times notes, the spillover from the ruling could be significant, threatening to “complicate Warner’s plans to make more films featuring Superman, including another sequel and a planned movie based on DC Comics’ Justice League of America, in which he joins Batman, Wonder Woman and other superheroes to battle evildoers.” And that isn’t all. Per the Times:

If the ruling survives a Time Warner legal challenge, it may also open the door to a similar reversion of rights to the estate of [co-creator Joe] Shuster in 2013. That would give heirs of the two creators control over use of their lucrative character until at least 2033 — and perhaps longer, if Congress once again extends copyright terms — according to Marc Toberoff, a lawyer who represents the Siegels and the Shuster estate.

Siegel and Shuster famously parted with the rights to Superman in 1937, accepting $130 in exchange for DC owning the character “forever” — but a 1976 law, summed up by the Times, “permits heirs, under certain circumstances, to recover rights to creations,” prompting the Siegels to bring suit against Time Warner in 1997.

Source: The New York Times

Tag Cloud

Star Trek BBC TNT Winter TV ESPN DC Comics SDCC Lifetime Trivia WGN Paramount Marvel social media FXX Teen VICE Infographic El Rey Comedy Schedule Nominations RT History CMT Disney Channel MTV IFC Nickelodeon crime drama Freeform Red Carpet FOX Crackle ITV Box Office biography MSNBC Mystery Music NYCC TCA 2017 DirecTV Rock Rom-Com Pirates singing competition Comic Book BBC America transformers NBC Bravo Trailer E! SundanceTV Awards HBO Netflix harry potter 2017 cops TLC Star Wars sitcom Biopics Superheroes CNN TIFF ABC Oscars Masterpiece Sci-Fi Podcast Martial Arts Musical Cosplay romance period drama Universal Hulu aliens Super Bowl President AMC based on movie Valentine's Day Warner Bros. zombie Nat Geo Mary Tyler Moore boxoffice LGBTQ Holidays Watching Series CBS FX binge Drama psycho politics Rocky X-Men Countdown Premiere Dates 45 YA Emmys Amazon Reality DC Universe Pop Election OWN Logo GoT science fiction Best and Worst Video Games war Esquire Food Network technology BET TV Land crime Certified Fresh Set visit The CW cinemax VH1 cooking historical drama Polls and Games Country police drama crime thriller PBS Extras Syfy Sundance APB CBS All Access Writers Guild of America Opinion Ellie Kemper Horror Marathons diversity GLAAD serial killer TCA travel Character Guide what to watch E3 Photos adventure First Look Fox News Cartoon Network History Toys American Society of Cinematographers Ghostbusters talk show TV Starz Reality Competition Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt ABC Family Calendar The Arrangement Sneak Peek 007 Summer PaleyFest comiccon GIFs Adult Swim Dark Horse Comics Fall TV Showtime Grammys Spring TV Action cats Musicals Year in Review Disney Tumblr composers 2015 dramedy TCM Tomatazos political drama Mindy Kaling 2016 Lionsgate Fantasy Winners sports TBS Thanksgiving discovery USA supernatural thriller Animation 24 frames vampires Kids & Family TruTV Comedy Central docudrama A&E Interview