Indiana Jonesin': How Does the Latest Chapter Measure Up?

We compare Kingdom of the Crystal Skull to Raiders, Temple of Doom, and Last Crusade

by | May 21, 2008 | Comments

Everyone has their favorite Indiana Jones movie — and their own thoughts on if Raiders of the Ark is better than Last Crusade. (Sorry, Temple of Doom — there’s no contest). So how does this week’s long-awaited third sequel, Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull, measure up to its predecessors?

Popular opinion holds Indiana Jones’ first on-screen appearance in Raiders of the Lost Ark as the best in the series. (It does, in fact, have the highest Tomatometer rating.) Third installment Last Crusade follows closely in second place in the hearts of most fans, with the oft-maligned second film, Temple of Doom, bringing up the rear. And despite running considerably close to one another on the Tomatometer, that order also holds true when it comes to the opinions of critics.

But where in the series will Indy’s first outing in nineteen years fall? Below, we examine the critical response to Dr. Jones’ latest escapade, and compare and contrast the key differences of each spectacular Indiana Jones adventure. Check out more articles in our Indiana Jonesin’ countdown series here.

The Return of Dr. Jones…

more info…
Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull (2008)

Tomatometer: 80%

Plot: Nineteen years after he last graced screens, Indiana Jones is back. This time, he’s hunting for a mystical crystal skull in the Amazonian jungle — and reuniting with a lost love. Could the skull hold the key to extraterrestrial contact?

Villain: Irina Spalko (Cate Blanchett), a sword-wielding Russian agent specializing in psychic warfare

Sidekicks: Wartime buddy George ‘Mac’ McHale (Ray Winstone); former colleague Harold Oxley (John Hurt), out of touch with Indy for years and now missing in Peru; switchblade-wielding greaser Mutt Williams (Shia LaBeouf)

Love Interest: Mary Williams (Karen Allen) — nee Marion Ravenwood, Indy’s feisty love interest from Raiders of the Lost Ark

Indy IV may not entirely be the grand return that everyone had hoped for, but it’s still great to see a good old friend come around again.” — Peter Howell, Toronto Star


Indy’s First Three Adventures

more info…
Raiders of the Lost Ark (1981)
Tomatometer: 95%

Plot: In this smashing series opener, the Nazis are on their way to uncovering the fabled Ark of the Covenant, which holds the power to make their armies indestructible. Enter Indiana Jones — globe-trotting treasure hunter, ladies man, professor of archaeology, rogue extraordinaire — who, along with an old flame, traverses the earth to stop the Ark from falling into the wrong hands.

Villains: Rene Belloq (Paul Freeman), French archaeologist and professional nemesis of Indiana Jones; Major Toht (Ronald Lacey), Nazi interrogator who gets a medallion scorched into his hand and his face melted off; Colonel Dietrich (Wolf Kahler), cold Nazi commander of the Tanis outpost

Sidekicks: Marcus Brody (Denholm Elliott), museum curator; portly Egyptian excavator Sallah (John Rhys-Davies)

Love Interest: Marion Ravenwood (Karen Allen), feisty Nepalese barkeep and daughter of Indy’s former mentor, Abner Ravenwood

Raiders of the Lost Ark is an out-of-body experience, a movie of glorious imagination and breakneck speed that grabs you in the first shot, hurtles you through a series of incredible adventures, and deposits you back in reality two hours later — breathless, dizzy, wrung-out, and with a silly grin on your face.” — Roger Ebert


more info…
Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom (1984)
Tomatometer: 87%

Plot: In this prequel to Raiders, Indiana Jones finds himself fleeing Shanghai with a nightclub singer and an orphan, stumbling into an Indian palace where secret passages are lined with creepy crawlies, children are enslaved by an evil cult, and the menu features “chilled monkey brains.”

Villains: Chinese gangster Lao Che (Roy Chiao); Mola Ram (Amrish Puri), leader of the Thuggee cult, human sacrifice, brainwasher, and seeker of the Sankara Stones

Sidekicks: Short Round (Jonathan Ke Quan), eleven-year-old Shanghainese taxi driver

Love Interest: Willie Scott (Kate Capshaw), spoiled American showgirl

IF you’ve ever been a child or, barring that, if you’ve ever been around children, ages 7 to about 11, you may remember the sort of game in which each child attempts to come up with the vilest, most disgusting, most repulsive, most stomach-turning meal he can think of. It might consist of sheeps’ eyes in runny aspic, live cockroaches wrapped in spider webs, juicy worms a la king and bats’ brains with anchovies and chocolate sauce… This may well be the public’s reaction to Steven Spielberg’s exuberantly tasteless and entertaining Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom...” — Vincent Canby, New York Times


more info…
Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade (1989)
Tomatometer: 90%

Plot: Indy is sent to Venice to locate the Holy Grail — and his own missing father (Sean Connery), with whom he’s been estranged for years — where he must contend with an ancient brotherhood, a beautiful blonde double agent, and his old enemies, the Nazis.

Villains: Walter Donovan (Julian Glover), an American businessman and Nazi conspirator; Colonel Vogel (Michael Byrne), SS officer who gets caught with “no ticket”

Sidekicks: Dr. Henry Jones, Sr. (Sean Connery), Indy’s estranged father and lifelong Grail scholar

Love Interest: Elsa Schneider, Austrian art historian and femme fatale who seduces both Joneses

To say that Paramount’s Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade may be the best film ever made for 12-year-olds is not a backhanded compliment….The Harrison Ford-Sean Connery father-and-son team gives Last Crusade unexpected emotional depth, reminding us that real film magic is not in special effects.” — Joseph McBride, Variety


The Verdict:

While some critics peg Kingdom of the Crystal Skull somewhere above Temple of Doom, but below the mark of The Last Crusade, its adjusted Tomatometer score places Indiana Jones’ fourth onscreen outing after all three films in the original trilogy. Even so, Kingdom — like Raiders of the Lost Ark, Temple of Doom, and The Last Crusade all — has earned Certified Fresh status. Not too shabby for Indy’s first adventure in nearly two decades!

For more articles in our Indiana Jonesin’ series, click here.

Tag Cloud

Nat Geo Tubi Sundance Now ratings BBC FX Logo The Witch Awards Tour reboot fresh Tarantino black anthology PlayStation stand-up comedy book sequel binge BET Hulu legend APB unscripted richard e. Grant christmas movies 21st Century Fox Acorn TV Binge Guide spain Comic Book Polls and Games MSNBC Brie Larson Winter TV Elton John south america Cannes all-time Extras blockbusters Summer MCU police drama Rock Shondaland Adult Swim Columbia Pictures Spike Quiz Superheroe jamie lee curtis New York Comic Con Family Disney streaming service Black History Month facebook Baby Yoda Cartoon Network toy story Star Trek NBA target VOD Video Games based on movie worst movies teaser cops Toys Britbox Showtime Black Mirror Certified Fresh hist historical drama fast and furious Pixar medical drama indiana jones sitcom mission: impossible Red Carpet cults 2016 Television Academy Ellie Kemper Song of Ice and Fire Turner japan die hard razzies Winners Comedy news E! book adaptation Mary Tyler Moore Emmy Nominations spanish language spinoff The Purge Avengers criterion Tomatazos TruTV Film Festival dark PBS political drama video Premiere Dates Emmys Netflix Christmas movies spy thriller Disney+ Disney Plus Spring TV adventure blaxploitation WarnerMedia ESPN TIFF Funimation Marvel adaptation VH1 TLC The Academy superhero Disney Channel El Rey YouTube 2021 nfl YouTube Premium rotten Country Fantasy suspense revenge MTV Writers Guild of America Travel Channel latino italian FXX Trivia dragons SundanceTV heist movie 007 Amazon Studios TNT comic Amazon Prime Cosplay golden globes Pacific Islander Crackle casting RT History Valentine's Day marvel cinematic universe crime thriller Super Bowl Pirates Sundance GIFs CNN documentaries Schedule green book science fiction ABC Signature Action anime versus Grammys CMT dramedy Sneak Peek toronto kong Freeform TCM satire CBS All Access Martial Arts harry potter Hallmark robots SDCC Classic Film Star Wars Fall TV rt archives streaming movies Bravo universal monsters Lifetime japanese Interview talk show Set visit The Walking Dead Mystery Shudder trailers composers sag awards TCA period drama disaster Year in Review Tokyo Olympics DirecTV 2015 Podcast Lucasfilm jurassic park technology hispanic romantic comedy stoner Rocketman Stephen King films rotten movies we love X-Men Trophy Talk stop motion cooking Disney screen actors guild USA Network canceled TV shows TV Land know your critic Holidays 20th Century Fox independent new star wars movies Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt National Geographic Universal San Diego Comic-Con laika FX on Hulu ITV Mary poppins American Society of Cinematographers Thanksgiving franchise Legendary Character Guide Wes Anderson Pride Month Dark Horse Comics Paramount Plus Superheroes game show Tumblr children's TV diversity elevated horror concert tv talk 2017 miniseries prank Nickelodeon Horror Sundance TV Paramount Network Holiday 2018 Chernobyl Starz TV movies adenture dogs VICE nature transformers Mudbound cars slashers Apple TV+ live action Mary Poppins Returns Food Network screenings Election Lifetime Christmas movies Broadway theme song festival festivals spider-man classics Drama game of thrones CW Seed Rom-Com Pop TV name the review breaking bad Marvel Studios streaming The Arrangement nbcuniversal crime drama TV Comedy Central popular Western WGN HBO Max TV renewals canceled documentary boxoffice vampires zero dark thirty History deadpool Pet Sematary Film child's play DC streaming service batman Teen Biopics Apple AMC witnail kids romance Music Rocky cancelled television critics Best and Worst E3 4/20 2020 docuseries a nightmare on elm street singing competition Musicals 24 frames Hear Us Out comedies ABC Family twilight Nominations discovery DGA foreign See It Skip It saw true crime TCA Winter 2020 basketball Endgame 2019 remakes asian-american BAFTA golden globe awards A24 HBO Go Arrowverse Exclusive Video CBS Ghostbusters Countdown DC Universe Reality Competition aliens war supernatural mockumentary Paramount blockbuster Mindy Kaling series Masterpiece new york 90s Warner Bros. Captain marvel Watching Series olympics Spectrum Originals Heroines LGBT venice ID Fox Searchlight HBO Kids & Family politics OneApp finale doctor who movies best parents Television Critics Association lord of the rings 93rd Oscars sequels football Walt Disney Pictures hidden camera women Women's History Month BBC America obituary Alien cartoon high school international sports crossover australia werewolf Photos Marvel Television Animation hollywood Anna Paquin BET Awards comics Apple TV Plus Comic-Con@Home 2021 Awards king kong Ovation Netflix Image Comics Infographic Trailer NBC President Sony Pictures Disney Plus YA james bond worst Peacock LGBTQ thriller justice league godzilla Comics on TV USA natural history IFC Crunchyroll 99% crime spanish Christmas comiccon Fox News psychological thriller television award winner Esquire halloween tv Sci-Fi DC Comics GoT Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Oscars Musical emmy awards quibi kaiju video on demand Pop psycho Turner Classic Movies free movies social media Creative Arts Emmys Discovery Channel dceu renewed TV shows cinemax zombies Epix pirates of the caribbean TCA 2017 comic books TBS telelvision movie The Walt Disney Company 45 archives Syfy GLAAD Amazon Prime Video YouTube Red ghosts FOX The CW dc First Look reviews scene in color new zealand ABC directors serial killer OWN Reality Marathons PaleyFest what to watch strong female leads french space docudrama animated scorecard TCA Awards 71st Emmy Awards Calendar rom-coms Lionsgate travel indie Box Office 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards biography SXSW NYCC IFC Films joker Opinion cats halloween ViacomCBS A&E cancelled Hallmark Christmas movies superman First Reviews aapi BBC One cancelled TV shows RT21 chucky Academy Awards Vudu 72 Emmy Awards TV One Amazon 1990s cancelled TV series monster movies zombie boxing scary movies mutant