Showdowns

Halloween H20 Vs. Halloween (2018)

The two big "Return of Laurie Strode" movies are considered the best sequels in the franchise, but which is better? We're breaking it down by Tomatometer, Audience Score, box office, storyline, and more.

by | October 31, 2020 | Comments

In one movie, a boozed-up and torn-down Laurie Strode must face the white-masked demon from her past and save her family; in the other, a boozed-up and… well, you get the gist. These two reboot/sequels, one released 20 years after the original Halloween and one released 40 years after, share a lot of the same DNA. But DNA is also the key difference: in Halloween H20: 20 Years Later, Laurie is related to Michael Myers; in 2018’s Halloween, that element of the plot has been slashed away and Laurie is simply the obsession, but not the sibling, of the Shape. Which movie did the whole reboot thing better? That’s what we’re deciding in the latest episode of Vs. Host and Rotten Tomatoes Contributing Editor Mark Ellis is pitting H20 and H40 against each other across four rounds – Box Office, Tomatometer and Audience Score, Storyline, and one wildcard round – to decide which sequel deserves the Halloween franchise silver medal. (Because gold, of course, goes to The Curse of Michael Myers, right?). As ever, if you don’t agree with our call, feel free to stalk us slowly and quietly in the comments.


Thumbnail image: © Dimension Films, © Universal Pictures


On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

Crunchyroll Wes Anderson game show Disney streaming service BBC America 93rd Oscars Stephen King toronto adaptation Ellie Kemper Writers Guild of America nature Interview Captain marvel Kids & Family elevated horror 4/20 DirecTV strong female leads Television Critics Association mockumentary comic book movie mission: impossible CMT rotten stand-up comedy Acorn TV Heroines true crime Marathons A24 USA emmy awards Sundance Now SXSW feel good japan PlayStation comic book movies Summer Western posters kaiju cancelled anime documentary Shudder 24 frames TBS Discovery Channel The Purge politics boxoffice marvel cinematic universe zombie cancelled TV series YouTube Creative Arts Emmys new star wars movies hist best Paramount Network 21st Century Fox Fantasy Hear Us Out quibi Legendary based on movie vampires FX on Hulu rt labs critics edition Disney Plus justice league prank mcc See It Skip It jamie lee curtis television Star Trek crime thriller reboot dreamworks Peacock witnail Awards American Society of Cinematographers worst movies kong Rom-Com Spring TV 2016 GoT Lifetime Christmas movies remakes animated TV Land Elton John History streaming movies festival CBS All Access mutant Comic-Con@Home 2021 video dark Emmy Nominations medical drama Epix target Film Festival AMC Plus comic doctor who action-comedy 71st Emmy Awards 007 NYCC X-Men scary movies MTV HBO Go TCA Awards screenings ghosts YouTube Premium Tomatazos Netflix Christmas movies Academy Awards TV One Extras halloween ID revenge asian-american BET Awards Opinion Pixar golden globes Logo Black Mirror Pride Month YouTube Red die hard south america social media dceu Pet Sematary Vudu sports rotten movies we love facebook spy thriller international child's play Amazon Studios movies TV renewals legend DGA 99% Reality zombies know your critic New York Comic Con dc singing competition indie olympics MCU Premiere Dates Martial Arts WarnerMedia A&E Super Bowl science fiction Superheroe popular Schedule IMDb TV ratings black comedy archives stoner Lifetime spider-verse godzilla thriller Bravo TLC toy story Rocketman japanese PBS CBS Walt Disney Pictures aapi classics spider-man green book Chernobyl cancelled TV shows Winter TV Turner E3 space Mary Tyler Moore Cosplay Pirates venice Food Network Arrowverse Turner Classic Movies Reality Competition Cannes Action binge Hulu marvel comics The Academy dogs Classic Film Brie Larson Mary Poppins Returns Starz Family period drama discovery psychological thriller batman directors FX VOD Ovation ABC Family diversity jurassic park boxing nfl Mudbound Marvel stop motion cancelled television universal monsters gangster MSNBC Disney Channel 72 Emmy Awards TV movies spain Sundance TV james bond casting TIFF Calendar Quiz Comic Book comedies video on demand Cartoon Network halloween tv TruTV GIFs Pop BAFTA Set visit Television Academy cults Holiday king arthur scary ESPN BBC One police drama teaser Video Games LGBTQ richard e. Grant Masterpiece HBO hispanic heritage month Warner Bros. Animation Sci-Fi Sony Pictures Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt joker twilight Baby Yoda Apple TV+ SDCC vs. Exclusive Video TCA young adult hidden camera dragons zero dark thirty royal family Music Esquire HBO Max Film book adaptation Certified Fresh Holidays sitcom Fox Searchlight cinemax Spectrum Originals black cartoon Lucasfilm FXX tv talk 20th Century Fox Syfy Election latino heist movie spinoff SundanceTV art house series political drama festivals documentaries Fall TV Apple TV Plus VICE adventure Apple debate Paramount crime robots Anna Paquin YA BBC technology Musicals fast and furious First Look TV genre TCA Winter 2020 films PaleyFest BET historical drama OWN blockbusters miniseries LGBT worst live action Amazon Star Wars new york Crackle The Arrangement canceled TV shows E! Women's History Month australia Disney+ Disney Plus satire cooking Winners serial killer 2019 Watching Series critic resources Marvel Studios franchise Amazon Prime Grammys crossover biography pirates of the caribbean Tubi RT21 DC streaming service composers Mystery spanish language wonder woman Lionsgate Ghostbusters USA Network Superheroes AMC book news Biopics Awards Tour Trailer Disney high school dexter superman Marvel Television romance El Rey blockbuster Musical San Diego Comic-Con 2015 Sneak Peek canceled 73rd Emmy Awards slasher OneApp basketball Adult Swim Rock ViacomCBS war Hallmark Toys foreign name the review ABC Signature criterion The CW reviews 2017 comic books transformers The Witch Black History Month FOX Comics on TV ABC NBA breaking bad comics Universal razzies Valentine's Day biopic mob kids Paramount Plus Pacific Islander talk show Box Office Image Comics Instagram Live game of thrones CW Seed Year in Review rom-coms suspense scene in color Alien Travel Channel 1990s aliens rt archives Sundance hispanic DC Universe Chilling Adventures of Sabrina 45 The Walt Disney Company Drama Thanksgiving Dark Horse Comics movie Broadway Amazon Prime Video football dramedy award winner crime drama The Walking Dead Polls and Games parents TNT Netflix Mindy Kaling Pop TV DC Comics Emmys trailers Best and Worst slashers 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards GLAAD critics docudrama anthology RT History rt labs IFC Films travel Song of Ice and Fire all-time obituary superhero Christmas nbcuniversal indiana jones 2021 supernatural Nat Geo Character Guide WGN concert renewed TV shows disaster telelvision Fox News adenture Rocky cats 2020 Endgame werewolf Avengers theme song sopranos blaxploitation APB Tumblr finale Trophy Talk Mary poppins screen actors guild Red Carpet sequel independent Nickelodeon First Reviews harry potter NBC Trivia lord of the rings Countdown new zealand Freeform Comedy Oscars king kong Showtime live event spanish sag awards Podcast docuseries Shondaland 90s romantic comedy italian streaming cars IFC fresh 2018 monster movies sequels chucky a nightmare on elm street National Geographic children's TV Hallmark Christmas movies scorecard Photos women comiccon french Tokyo Olympics laika Binge Guide natural history cops Tarantino Spike Country Teen ITV Infographic Funimation Universal Pictures deadpool Comedy Central psycho free movies Nominations unscripted CNN golden globe awards VH1 christmas movies TCA 2017 hollywood Neflix TCM President Horror versus saw Columbia Pictures what to watch Britbox